Showing posts with label consent order. Show all posts
Showing posts with label consent order. Show all posts

Friday, 19 April 2019

Whether breach of undertaking given in consent decree amounts to contempt of court?

Mr. Nedumpara, learned Counsel for the Respondents, argues that the order passed by this court on 27 September 2012 is a consent order. Learned Counsel submits that a consent order merely records an agreement between the parties. Learned Counsel submits that merely because in its body, the word 'undertaking' is included, the order does not undergo any change; it is still a consent order passed on a compromise between the parties. Learned Counsel submits that no contempt can be alleged of any such order; such order can only be executed by the court. This controversy has finally been laid to rest by the Supreme Court in case of Rama Narang Vs. Ramesh Narang MANU/SC/1960/2006 : (2006) 11 Supreme Court Cases 114. The definition of civil contempt under Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, as noted by the court in that case, provides for two categories of cases, first, any willful disobedience to a process of court, and second, any breach of an undertaking given to a court. The Supreme Court held that the word 'any' indicated the wide nature of the power. No distinction could be statutorily drawn in this behalf between an order passed after adjudication and an order passed by consent. Any wilful violation of any order or decree would be tantamount to contempt. A compromise decree or order is as much a decree or order as a decree or order passed on adjudication, and not merely an agreement between the parties; in passing a decree by consent, the court adds its mandate to the consent so that the consent decree may be said to be composed of both command and contract. A consent decree, in other words, is a contract with the imprimatur of the court added to it. By passing a decree in terms of consent terms, the court authorises and approves the course of action consented to. Just as an order or decree passed on adjudication is executable under the Code of Civil Procedure, even a consent order or decree is of course executable, but merely because of that, it does not take away the jurisdiction of the court to deal with its violation or breach under the Contempt of Courts Act, provided the court is satisfied that the violation or breach complained of is such as would warrant a punishment under Section 13 of that Act. The present consent order is no different. Besides, the breach alleged in the present case is not merely of the consent order, but of an express undertaking given to the court and which was recorded and accepted by it in the consent order. A willful breach of an undertaking given to a court clearly and unequivocally attracts its contempt jurisdiction.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Contempt Petition No. 29 of 2016 in Suit No. 2503 of 2012

Decided On: 31.10.2018

 Swaranjeet Singh  Vs.  Melco Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.C. Gupte, J.

Citation: 2019(2) MHLJ 277
Print Page

Sunday, 3 September 2017

Whether principle of res judicata is applicable to consent order?

As far as the plea of res judicata is concerned, the fundamental principle requisite to its applicability is that the matter must have been heard and finally decided. This means that the matter must have been heard and decided by a competent court in the earlier proceedings. When a consent order is passed and the case is disposed of on the basis of consent, it cannot attract the principle of res judicata as such.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL

Special Appeal No. 14 of 2015

Decided On: 12.05.2017

Rajesh Goyal and Ors.Vs. State of Uttarakhand and Ors.
Print Page

Sunday, 11 October 2015

Whether accused can be discharged in prevention of food adulteration Act on the ground that consent order did not mention type of adulteration?

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Cri. Revision Appln. No. 271 of 1992
Decided On: 02.12.1999
Appellants: State of Maharashtra 
Vs.
Respondent: Arunkumar Hirji Shah and another
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Smt. Ranjana Prakash Desai, J.

Food Adulteration - Discharge - Legality of - Section 11(1)(c)(i) of Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954; Rules 15 and 16 of Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955; Section 114 of Evidence Act 1872 - In present Application State had challenged order passed by Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, discharging Respondents original Accused nos. 1 and 2 of alleged - Whether impugned order was perverse and liable to be set aside - Held, it was improper for Magistrate at present stage to come to a conclusion that bags were not clean on basis of solitary statement made by Food Inspector in cross-examination that he had not personally cleaned bags - Prosecution ought to be given chance to lead evidence on this point - Food Inspector had stated that panchnama was drawn - It was always open for prosecution to prove panchnama by examining witnesses - Present case was covered by judgment in case of State of Maharashtra vs. Shri Arjunbhai Hargovindbhai Rathod - Food inspector stated that after filling chilli powder in three polythene bags he sealed mouth of bags by means of wax candle - Therefore, prima facie, Magistrate was not right when he said that mouth of bags were not sealed, hence, Food Inspector had committed breach of Rules 15 and 16 of Rules - A conclusion that there was breach of Rule 14 to 16, if it was possible to be arrived at, could have been arrived at in facts of present case only after trial - It was not as if Local Health Authority was not informed on same day - Therefore, whether there was a breach of Section 11(1) (c)(i) of Act, could not be conclusively decided at present stage - Validity of consent was a mixed question of law and fact and prosecution could always adduce evidence to prove validity of consent - It being merely an administrative function and not a judicial function, its purpose was to see whether prima facie material existed to put up Accused for trial - In considering validity of a consent order, presumption under Section 114 of Evidence Act would have to be kept in mind - Official acts must be presumed to have been regularly performed - Merely because consent order did not mention type of adulteration it could not be held to be bad in all cases - It would depend on facts and circumstances of each case - In facts and circumstances of present case, prima facie, it could not be said that consent order was bad in law - Framing of a charge against a person was a serious matter - A Court of law had, therefore, to take utmost care while framing a charge - It had to consider judicially whether material warranted framing of charge - Supreme Court in case of State of Maharashtra vs. Somnath Thapa and others observed, that if on material on record, a Court would come to conclusion that commission of offence was a probable consequence, a case of framing of charge existed - In present case, report of Public Analyst and evidence of Food Inspector was good enough material to make out prima facie case against Accused for purpose of putting him up for trial - Alleged breaches of mandatory provisions, faulty consent order could be examined better at stage of trial - Order discharging Accused was, therefore, erroneous - Impugned order passed by Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, was set aside - Case was remanded to trial Court for disposal according to law - Application disposed of
Equivalent Citation: 2000(3)MhLj16
Print Page

Friday, 2 October 2015

Whether judgments rendered on the basis of consent are precedent?

It is axiomatic that when a direction or order is made by consent of the parties, the Court does not adjudicate upon the rights of the parties nor lay down any principle. Quotability as 'law' applies to the principle of a case, its ratio decidendi. The only thing in a Judge'sdecision binding as an authority upon a subsequent Judge is the principle upon which the case was decided. Statements which are not part of the ratio decidendi are distinguished as obiter dicta and are not authoritative. The task of finding the principle is fraught with difficulty because without an investigation into the facts, as in the present case, it could not be assumed whether a similar direction must or ought to be made as a measure of social justice. That being so, the direction made by this Court in Jamna Das' case could not be treated to be a precedent. The High Court failed to realise that the direction in Jamna Das'case was made not only with the consent of the parties but there was an interplay of various factors and the Court was moved by compassion to evolve a situation to mitigate hardship which PG NO 938 was acceptable by all the parties concerned. The Court no doubt made incidental observation to the Directive Principles of State Policy enshrined in Art. 38(2) of the Constitution and said:
Supreme Court of India
Municipal Corporation Of Delhi vs Gurnam Kaur on 12 September, 1988
Equivalent citations: 1989 AIR 38, 1988 SCR Supl. (2) 929
(1989) 1 SCC101
Bench: Sen, A.P. (J)
Print Page