Showing posts with label contractual obligation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label contractual obligation. Show all posts

Thursday, 6 May 2021

Whether the government can waive non-essential term in the tender if there is substantial compliance with tender terms?

 In Jal Mahal Resorts (P) Ltd. v. K.P. Sharma (2014) 8 SCC 804, the Supreme Court has quoted with approval B.S.N. Joshi & Sons Ltd. It has held that when there is substantial compliance with the terms of tender, the Government is entitled to waive any non-essential term in the tender for the bona fide reasons and in public interest. To conclude, the Court has held that if there were no mala fides in the decision-making process, literal compliance cannot be insisted upon. {Para 51}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

WRIT PETITION NOS.1114 of 2016 & 718 of 2018

Dr. R. Venkatesh  V/s  State of Goa,


Coram:- DAMA SESHADRI NAIDU &

NUTAN D. SARDESSAI, JJ.

Date:- 5th MARCH 2020

ORAL JUDGMENT: (Per Dama Seshadri Naidu, J.)

Citation: 2021(1) MHLJ 105

Print Page

Monday, 12 June 2017

How difference between sale and agreement of sale will affect contractual obligation?

The undisputed factual position is that the appellantbank
has not released the mortgage. The possession of the
mortgaged property has not been delivered to the first
respondent so far. The three year lock in period expired on
01.03.2015. The creation of third party interest or
arrangement by way of agreement for sale within the three year
period is different from sale. Admittedly, sale has not been
made within the period of three years of settlement. The
scheme has not provided for any other restriction of
involvement of third party interest for settlement of the

dues. The only restriction is on sale of the property within
three years of the settlement. That admittedly having not been
done, the appellant cannot rest any claim under law for the
share of the increase in fair market value by way of
recompense. There is nothing to be recompensed since the bank
has not suffered or lost anything.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3197 OF 2016

PUNJAB & SIND BANK
V
PUNJAB BREEDERS LTD. & ANOTHER.
Citation:(2016) 13 SCC 283
Print Page

Sunday, 9 October 2016

Whether Writ petition are maintainable to avoid contractual obligation?

Writ petition was not maintainable to
avoid contractual obligation. Occurrence of
commercial difficulty, inconvenience or hardship in
performance of the conditions agreed to in the
contract can provide no justification in not
complying with the terms of contract which the
parties had accepted with open eyes. It cannot
ever be that a licensee can work out the licence if
he finds it profitable to do so: and he can
challenge the conditions under which he agreed to
take the licence, if he finds it commercially
inexpedient to conduct his business.
70.6. Ordinarily, where a breach of contract is
complained of, the party complaining of such
breach may sue for specific performance of the
contract, if contract is capable of being specifically
performed. Otherwise, the party may sue for
damages.”
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 9821 OF 2016
(Arising out of S.L.P.(C) No. 7874 of 2016)
GUJARAT MARITIME BOARD 
V
L&T INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT
PROJECTS LTD. AND ANOTHER 
Dated:September 28, 2016. 
Print Page

Thursday, 30 July 2015

Whether a party can avoid contractual obligation on ground of violation of fundamental right?

It is a fundamental principle of general application
that if  a person  of his  own accord, accepts a contract on
certain terms  and works  out the  contract,  he  cannot  be
allowed to  adhere to  and abide by some of the terms of the
contract which proved advantageous to him and repudiate the
other  terms   of  the  same  contract   which   might   be
disadvantageous to  him. The  maxim,  is  qui  approbat  non
reprobat. A  party to  an instrument  or transaction  cannot
take advantage of one part of a document or transaction and
reject the rest. [441E-H]
     Verschures  Creameries   Ltd.  v. Hull  &  Netherlands
Steamship Co.  [1921] 2  K  B.608  and Douglas  Menzies  v.
Umphelby [1908] A.C. 224 at p. 232 referred to.
     In the  instant case  the petitioners  had by  offering
highest bids  at public auctions or by Tenders, accepted and
worked out  the contracts  in the past but are now resisting
the demands  or other  action, arising out of the impugned
condition 13  on the ground that this condition is violative
of Article 19(1)(g) and 14 of the Constitution. The impugned
conditions though  bearing a  statutory  complexion,  retain
their basic contractual character. Though a person cannot be
debarred from enforcing his fundamental rights on the ground
of estoppel or waiver, the principle which prohibits a party
to a  transaction from approbating a part of its conditions
and reprobating  the rest, is different from the doctrine of
estoppel or waiver.
Supreme Court of India
New Bihar Biri Leaves Co. & Ors vs State Of Bihar & Ors on 6 January, 1981
Equivalent citations: 1981 AIR 679, 1981 SCR (2) 417
Bench: Sarkaria, Ranjit Singh
         Read full judgment here;click here

Print Page