Showing posts with label de-exhibition of documents. Show all posts
Showing posts with label de-exhibition of documents. Show all posts

Tuesday, 19 February 2019

Whether trial court can defer to decide prayer to de-exhibit document till final hearing of suit?

 In considered opinion of this Court, it is for the trial Court, which has an opportunity to go through the pleadings, frame issues and thereafter record the evidence of the witnesses, to know and decide whether the said document will be essential for adjudication of the issues framed by it. This document admittedly cannot be called as totally "irrelevant" or completely in-admissible, on any of the grounds, like insufficient stamp or otherwise. The document is relevant and ultimately what evidentiary value to be given to this document, will be considered by the trial Court, only at the time of final hearing, after having regard to the entire evidence on record, including the cross-examination of this witness to the fact that he does not understand the Sanskrit language, the fact that he is not the author of the said document, the document is in loose sheets and not signed by the witness. All these aspects will be considered by the trial Court at the time of final hearing, only after at this stage this document is admitted in evidence. At this stage, it cannot be said that the documents like these Granthas are, for the decision of this suit, totally irrelevant or inadmissible in evidence and therefore, the trial Court should not have admitted the same in evidence or the trial Court has committed an error in rejecting the objection raised by learned counsel for the Petitioners. This is too premature a stage to contend that this document be de-exhibited.

33. Once it is held that the document is essential and will be helpful to the trial Court also in arriving at its proper conclusion for proper adjudication of the case, then it follows that such document cannot be de-exhibited at this stage. However, again at the costs of repetition, this Court is reiterating that, so far as evidentiary value of this document, the trial Court will be considering the same at the proper stage after having regard to the entirety of the facts and evidence before it. Otherwise also, for its own adjudication, the trial Court would have to rely upon this Grantha as it ultimately pertains to the "Shastriya Bath" or what is called as a matter of religious beliefs, faiths and practices. Therefore, keeping in mind the larger picture also, it cannot be said that the trial Court has committed any irregularity or error, much less illegality, so as to warrant interference in the impugned order of the trial Court, in writ jurisdiction, the scope of which is very limited, only to ensure that the trial Court has acted within its jurisdiction. No jurisdictional error is pointed out in the impugned order passed by the trial Court. Therefore, so far as the Writ Petition No. 3258 of 2018 is concerned, it needs to be dismissed and, accordingly, stands dismissed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 3588 of 2018 and Writ Petition (ST.) No. 7520 of 2018

Decided On: 20.04.2018

Bipin Jaysukhlal Mehta Vs.  Jayantibhai Talakchand Shah and Ors.
Print Page

Whether it is permissible for court to exhibit religious scriptures (Granthas) ?

 Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondent No. 1/Plaintiffs has relied upon the judgment in the case of Sardar Dayalsing Charansing v. Tulsidas Tarachand, AIR (32) 1945 Sind 177, wherein in similar matter, while deciding the question relating to the practices and beliefs in Sikh religion, the documents, in the nature of religious scriptures (Granthas) were referred to in argument and in the authorities cited by the learned Advocates and it was held that the Court is entitled to refer to these documents under Section 57 of the Evidence Act, 1872, as these documents were found to be of assistance to the Court; in order to go in to the history and theological beliefs of that religion.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 3588 of 2018 and Writ Petition (ST.) No. 7520 of 2018

Decided On: 20.04.2018

Bipin Jaysukhlal Mehta Vs.  Jayantibhai Talakchand Shah and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dr. Shalini Phansalkar Joshi, J.

Citation: 2019(1) MHLJ 690
Print Page

Saturday, 9 February 2019

Whether bailiff report is public document?

 But, if the report of the bailiff was to be treated as a
public document, there was nothing for the respondent no.4 to
do, but to produce a certified copy of the same and then claim
that he had proved his stand. This would be contrary to the
requirement of Section 101 of the aforesaid Act, which reads as
follows:-
101. Burden of proof.—Whoever desires any
Court to give judgment as to any legal right or
liability dependent on the existence of facts
which he asserts, must prove that those facts
exist.
When a person is bound to prove the existence of
any fact, it is said that the burden of proof lies on
that person.
18. Thus, it becomes clear that the burden to prove

clearly was on the respondent no.4 in the facts of the present
case. Only the contents of the summons issued by the Court,
consisting of name of the Court, name of the parties, seal of
the Court and the returnable date stated in the summons could
be said to be a public document. The report written by the
bailiff on the reverse of the said document could certainly not
be said to be a public document under Section 74 of the said
Act. Yet, the trial Court passed the order dated 26.08.2015
allowing the production of the documents, including the bailiff
report, by the respondent no.4 and passed the impugned order
dated 26.08.2015 below Exh.40 holding the said documents to
be directly admissible in evidence as public documents and
marking them as exhibits. The trial Court also erred in passing
the impugned order dated 21.07.2016 below Exh.44 rejecting
the application of the petitioner for de-exhibiting the said
documents including the bailiff report. It is also surprising that
the trial Court did not even call for the say/response of the
petitioner while passing the order, whereby production of the
documents was allowed and while passing impugned order
dated 26.08.2015, whereby the documents including the said
bailiff report, were treated as public documents and accepted.
This was clearly erroneous, thereby rendering the impugned
orders unsustainable and liable to be quashed and set aside.

19. In the light of the above, the present writ petition is
allowed and the impugned orders are quashed and set aside.
The application Exh.44 is allowed. It is held that the bailiff
report sought to be placed on record and exhibited as public
document cannot be treated as a public document and that it
will have to be proved by respondent no.4 in accordance with
law.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
Writ Petition No. 79 of 2017

Sushilkumar Mandanlal Ganediwal, Vs  Vijaykumar Mandanlal Ganediwal,


CORAM : MANISH PITALE, J.

DATED: JANUARY 31,2019
Citation: 2019(3) MHLJ 721,AIR 2019 BOM 201
Print Page

Sunday, 4 November 2018

Whether previous evidence will be wiped off if exparte decree is set aside?

 The question involved in the present case is whether in the facts and circumstances of this case, the evidence led by the plaintiff and recorded prior to setting aside the ex parte decree gets wiped out completely and the Court is required to re-record the evidence?

5. The Full Bench decision of Gujarat High Court in the case of Shah Bharatkumar Premchand v. M/s. Motilal and Bharulal, reported in AIR 1980 Gujarat 51, takes into consideration the conflicting views taken by the different High Courts on the question. The Full Bench agrees with the view taken by Madras High Court that the evidence recorded before setting aside the ex parte decree does not become non est and when the ex parte decree is set aside, all that the other side can insist upon is the right to cross-examine the witness if he so desires. The Full Bench further makes the distinction and states that it is one thing to say that the proceedings would not bind the defendant and it is another to say that the proceedings must be treated as non-existed. The Full Bench accepts the proposition that nothing done during his absence can bind him. Therefore, if the Court has admitted a document which is not admissible in evidence, the defendant can insist on the document being de-exhibited. It gives an instance that if an order is passed in his absence that the document is properly stamped or does not require registration, that does not bind him and he can challenge such a decision notwithstanding the previous order.

6. The Trial Court has relied upon the aforesaid view taken by the Full Bench of Gujarat High Court and accordingly, the documents are sent for impounding. I am not expressing any view on the correctness or otherwise of the decision of the Full Bench of Gujarat High Court, which has taken a view in deviation of one taken by Andhra Pradesh, Allahabad and Calcutta High Courts. The distinguishing feature is that in the decision of the Full Bench of Gujarat High Court, it was not a case where permission to file written statement was granted while setting aside the ex parte decree. In my view, where an order setting aside the ex parte decree with permission to file written statement attains the finality, it has the effect of wiping out the entire evidence recorded prior to setting aside the ex parte decree and the Court will have to re-record such evidence. The evidence of the witnesses of the plaintiff recorded earlier can be used to confront it to the said witnesses, as is permissible under Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, being the previous statement of the witnesses.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 2177 of 2016

Decided On: 03.04.2018

 Chandraprakash Dayaramji Lanjewar Vs.  Ratnakala Wamanrao Khatkhede and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Deshpande, J.

Citation: 2018(5) MHLJ 57
Print Page

Sunday, 17 December 2017

Whether documents once exhibited can be de-exhibited?

I have also perused the material on record. It is
settled position in law that once the documents are marked
as Exhibits, they cannot be de­exhibited.  At the same time,
while deciding the suit finally, the learned trial Judge will
decide the same uninfluenced by the observations made in
the order dated 27.3.2012 in relation to Exhibits­21 to 23
and 25 to 27.  Subject to this clarification, no case is made
out   for   invocation   of   powers   under   Article   227   of   the

Constitution   of   India.   Petition   fails   and   the   same   is
dismissed. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Writ Petition NO. 8569 OF 2016
Sultan Suleman Qureshi  V Mrs. Anisa Rafiq Charolia 
And Ors  .

  CORAM :   R. G. KETKAR, J.
  DATE     :  18th August, 2016

Print Page