The major question arising for consideration is whether the findings entered into by the Rent Control Appellate Authority that the denial of title was bona fide is legal and proper and is supported by evidence and law. The other question as to whether landlords established the grounds of eviction could arise only if the first question is answered in favour of the revision petitioner.
18. The authorities under the Act are not supposed to decide the title in dispute between the parties since law does not extend its jurisdiction to adjudging the title of parties to the alleged tenanted premises. Such a function to decide title is exclusively confined by law to civil courts. The authority of the functionaries under the Act is only to ascertain whether denial of title in the proceedings is bona fide or not. If the finding entered as required by 2nd proviso to Section 11(1) of the Act accepts denial as a bona fide contention, the eviction of the occupant then could be pursued only in a civil court. Pursuit of eviction proceedings in the Rent Control Court after the finding under the 2nd proviso to Section 11(1) of the Act could be justified only if the said finding ended up in holding that the denial was without bona fides. In testing the bona fides of the contention denying title, the function of the authorities under the Act is only to check up whether such a plea was raised in good faith and with honesty and proceed accordingly. In that process, we however, do not think, it is necessary for the Rent Control Court to make sure that the plea denying title is one which should essentially be upheld by the civil court in the proceedings instituted before it.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
R.C. Rev. No. 234 of 2015
Decided On: 04.06.2019
Baby Vs. Babu P. Pappachan and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A. Hariprasad and T.V. Anilkumar, JJ.