Our attention is invited to disclosure statement under section 27 of the Evidence Act made by accused No. 1 to show that he has pointed out what transpired in the night of 1/10/2008. He has pointed out that on 1/10/2010 in the night deceased Baban gave abuses to his sister Guddu and hence he and accused No. 2 tried to pacify him and asked him not to indulge in such abuses. He was not in mood to listen and altercation ensued. Therefore he with wooden stick and accused No. 2 with iron rod bet Baban on legs, hands and head.
Our attention is drawn to judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court reported at Murli @ Denny vs. State of Rajasthan, MANU/SC/0136/1994 : 1995 Supp (1) Supreme Court Cases 39 to submit that such disclosure under section 27 of the Evidence Act can be pressed into service by accused in defence. Similar view is taken by Division Bench of the Court in the case of Madhavgir s/o Gururatangir, MANU/MH/1601/2003 : 2005(1) Mh. L. J. 161 is also relied upon.
In this backdrop when cross examination of PW-1-Nanda is seen, there is no attempt to bring on record any such abuses. Perusal of questions put to accused No. 1 is question Nos. 3, 4 and to accused No. 2 is question Nos. 3 and 4 in section 313 examination shows that they are denying the entire incident. While answering question No. 27 they could have taken defence of abuses to sister by deceased, but there is no such effort. Both of them have stated that they are falsely involved in the matter. Thus, as a matter of fact, defence of abuse in name of sister of accused No. 1 by deceased Baban was never raised and has not been established.
23. Stray sentences appearing in disclosure memorandum Exhibit 17 therefore cannot be allowed to be utilized to build such defence in present facts.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Criminal Appeal No. 656 of 2012,
Decided On: 02.12.2019
Atikul Habibul Rehman Shaikh Vs. The State of Maharashtra
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.P. Dharmadhikari and Sandeep K. Shinde, JJ.
