Showing posts with label estate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label estate. Show all posts

Tuesday, 15 September 2020

Bombay HC: Wife can claim maintenance from her father in law after the death of her husband from estate inherited by him

 At the outset, it is required to be submitted that the plain
reading of Section 19 of the Act contemplates that the respondents
have every right to claim the maintenance after the death of husband
from the estate inherited by her father-in-law i.e. the present petitioner.
That proviso to Sub-Section (1) of Section 19 contemplates that the
respondent has to demonstrate that she on her is unable to maintain
herself. It is in this eventuality she can claim maintenance from the
estate of her husband, still fact remains that the said burden can be
discharged by respondent no.1 at an appropriate stage. The object with
which the provision is made in the statute book for grant of interim
maintenance cannot be ignored.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION (ST.) NO.4054 OF 2020

Sardool Singh Sucha Singh Matharoo Vs.  Harneet Kaur widow of Bhupinder Singh Matharoo & Anr. 

Coram : NITIN W. SAMBRE, J.
Date : 7th September, 2020
Print Page

Sunday, 23 April 2017

Whether claim of first wife can be rejected if her husband has suppressed marriage with her from court?

In   the   present   case,     Indubai   had   filed   criminal   case   for
maintenance under section 125 of Cr. P.C.  In the written statement,
Jaydeo has admitted his marriage with Indubai and he did not state
anything about his marriage with Draupada.  On the basis of evidence
tendered in the said case, the learned Magistrate held that fact of
marriage between Draupada and Jaydeo is proved and held that she
was entitled to maintenance and awarded the same.  Thus, under that
order, Jaydeo was paying maintenance to her during his life time.
The learned Judge of the trial Court has erred in accepting the finding
of the learned Magistrate as a final word while  determining the issue
of valid marriage of Indubai and Draupada with Jaydeo.  Draupada
has four children out of this wedlock.  The trial under section 125 of
Cr. P.C. conducted before the learned Magistrate was in absence of
Draupada.   The suppression of the fact of first marriage by Jaydeo
was obvious because he was in Government service and if he would
have   stated   about   the   first   marriage,   then   he   would   have   been
charged   for   misconduct   under   Rule   26   of   the   Maharashtra   Civil
Services (Conduct) Rules and that might have been affected adversely
on his service.  Thus, silence of Jaydeo about his first marriage with
Draupada in the written statement cannot be given any weightage
and a circumstance against Draupada.  His efforts to hide the fact of
first marriage from Court was successful and therefore, Indubai was
declared to be entitled to receive maintenance and which she was
receiving during his lifetime.   The learned Judicial Magistrate First
Class in that maintenance application gave the correct finding on the
basis of the evidence available to him.   Draupada was never before
him to plead her case.  Under such circumstances, if one wife does not
come before the Court to plead her case and the fact of two marriages
are   never   brought   before   the   Court,   then   the   finding   given   and
judgment passed in respect of validity of one marriage is always a
subject of challenge before the Civil Court and in that event, the Civil
Court has to consider the evidence independently of both the parties
and is required to give its verdict. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.577 OF 2015

Draupada @ Draupadi Jaydeo Pawar vs. Indubai d/o. Kashinath Shivram Chavan
CORAM : MRS.MRIDULA BHATKAR, J.
 Dated  : 10th FEBRUARY, 2016
Citation: 2017(1) ALLMR197

Print Page