Coming to the question whether execution of sale deed in favour of plaintiff has
been proved, the High Court has held that the sale deed has not been proved for want of
examination of Buchamma. The High Court has ignored the pleadings of the parties and
the evidence on the question of execution of sale deed which establishes that sale deed
been proved, the High Court has held that the sale deed has not been proved for want of
examination of Buchamma. The High Court has ignored the pleadings of the parties and
the evidence on the question of execution of sale deed which establishes that sale deed
had been executed by Buchamma in favour of the plaintiff. In the written statement
filed on behalf of the defendants, the sale deed was denied for want of knowledge. A
perusal of same indicates that the authority of Buchamma to execute the sale deed in
favour of the plaintiff was put into question. Defendant no. 3 Sarojana in her deposition
in court did not deny the fact that sale deed was executed by Buchamma in favour of the
plaintiff. She has stated that she was not aware whether Buchamma has executed anysale deed in favour of the plaintiff. She only asserted that she was the adopted daughter
of Yashoda.
15. It is settled law that denial for want of knowledge is no denial at all. The
execution of the sale deed was not specifically denied in the written statement. Once the
execution of the sale deed was not disputed it was not necessary to examine Buchamma
to prove it. The provisions contained in Order 8 Rule 5 require pleadings to be
answered specifically in written statement. This Court in Jahuri Sah & Ors. v. Dwarika
Prasad Jhunjhunwala AIR 1967 SC 109 has laid down that if a defendant has no
knowledge of a fact pleaded by the plaintiff is not tantamount to a denial of existence offact, not even an implied denial. Same decision has been followed by Madhya Pradesh
High Court in Dhanbai D/o Late Shri Cowash v. State of M.P. & Ors. 1978 MPLJ 717.
The High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Samrathmal & Anr. v. Union of India, Ministry of
Railway & Ors. AIR 1959 MP 305 relying on P.L.N.K.L. Chettyar Firm v. Ko Lu Doke
filed on behalf of the defendants, the sale deed was denied for want of knowledge. A
perusal of same indicates that the authority of Buchamma to execute the sale deed in
favour of the plaintiff was put into question. Defendant no. 3 Sarojana in her deposition
in court did not deny the fact that sale deed was executed by Buchamma in favour of the
plaintiff. She has stated that she was not aware whether Buchamma has executed anysale deed in favour of the plaintiff. She only asserted that she was the adopted daughter
of Yashoda.
15. It is settled law that denial for want of knowledge is no denial at all. The
execution of the sale deed was not specifically denied in the written statement. Once the
execution of the sale deed was not disputed it was not necessary to examine Buchamma
to prove it. The provisions contained in Order 8 Rule 5 require pleadings to be
answered specifically in written statement. This Court in Jahuri Sah & Ors. v. Dwarika
Prasad Jhunjhunwala AIR 1967 SC 109 has laid down that if a defendant has no
knowledge of a fact pleaded by the plaintiff is not tantamount to a denial of existence offact, not even an implied denial. Same decision has been followed by Madhya Pradesh
High Court in Dhanbai D/o Late Shri Cowash v. State of M.P. & Ors. 1978 MPLJ 717.
The High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Samrathmal & Anr. v. Union of India, Ministry of
Railway & Ors. AIR 1959 MP 305 relying on P.L.N.K.L. Chettyar Firm v. Ko Lu Doke
AIR 1934 Rang 278 and Lakhmi Chand v. Ram Lal AIR 1931 All. 423, had also opined
that if the defendant did not know of a fact, denial of the knowledge of a particular fact
that if the defendant did not know of a fact, denial of the knowledge of a particular fact
is not a denial of the fact and has not even the effect of putting the fact in issue.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4816 OF 2016
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4816 OF 2016
Muddasani Venkata Narsaiah V Muddasani Sarojana
Citation:(2016) 12 SCC 288
Citation:(2016) 12 SCC 288

