In the case of (ING Vysya Bank Ltd. v. Modern India Ltd.), MANU/MH/0066/2008 : 2008 (2) Bom. C.R. 255 the learned single Judge of this Court considered an application in section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 for granting interim relief to a licensee against the licensor from terminating his license and taking over possession. In that case also the licensee claimed to be in possession of the licensed premises which was later renewable and consequently the right of extension/renewal of the license was claimed under the agreement. The respondent claimed that the application was essentially for specific performance of the agreement which relief could not be granted by the Court of Small Causes at Bombay under section 19(h) of the Act.
The Court considered that the substance and essence of the suit as required to be seen, to look to the kernel and not the chaff and to see the jural relationship between the parties upon the nature of the cause of action and the character of the reliefs. The Court also observed that in a suit relating to recovery of possession some of the reliefs may be structured around a claim for specific performance. If the theme and the foundation relate to recovery of possession such a relief could not be seen an isolation. Consequently the Civil Court's jurisdiction would have to be considered upon seeing the substance of the suit. The Court further observed that the basis to protect the possession against the dispossession in a preexisting relationship was important to consider and if that relationship was between the licensor and licensee (as also landlord and tenant or lessor and lessee) then the substance of the claim would be to protect the possession against recovery which would be a suit relating to possession. Hence it is observed in para 17 of the judgment that only a suit for specific performance simplicitor would not be covered. But if the suit was not for specific performance but essentially for continuation of the existing leasehold right it would be covered by the aforesaid legislation.
The Court noted that one of the reliefs was the execution of fresh leave and license agreement upon the declaration sought and not a bare relief of specific performance. Consequently it held that the Civil Court would be barred from trying such a suit.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Chamber Summons (L) No. 1075 of 2015 in Suit No. 1930 of 2002
Decided On: 26.06.2015
Manilal & Sons Bombay Forigings Ltd. Vs. Manilal & Sons
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.S. Dalvi, J.
Citation: 2016 Bom RC183.
