Showing posts with label extension of lease. Show all posts
Showing posts with label extension of lease. Show all posts

Saturday, 23 February 2019

Whether suit for specific performance of contract is tenable before small causes court?

In the case of (ING Vysya Bank Ltd. v. Modern India Ltd.), MANU/MH/0066/2008 : 2008 (2) Bom. C.R. 255 the learned single Judge of this Court considered an application in section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 for granting interim relief to a licensee against the licensor from terminating his license and taking over possession. In that case also the licensee claimed to be in possession of the licensed premises which was later renewable and consequently the right of extension/renewal of the license was claimed under the agreement. The respondent claimed that the application was essentially for specific performance of the agreement which relief could not be granted by the Court of Small Causes at Bombay under section 19(h) of the Act.

The Court considered that the substance and essence of the suit as required to be seen, to look to the kernel and not the chaff and to see the jural relationship between the parties upon the nature of the cause of action and the character of the reliefs. The Court also observed that in a suit relating to recovery of possession some of the reliefs may be structured around a claim for specific performance. If the theme and the foundation relate to recovery of possession such a relief could not be seen an isolation. Consequently the Civil Court's jurisdiction would have to be considered upon seeing the substance of the suit. The Court further observed that the basis to protect the possession against the dispossession in a preexisting relationship was important to consider and if that relationship was between the licensor and licensee (as also landlord and tenant or lessor and lessee) then the substance of the claim would be to protect the possession against recovery which would be a suit relating to possession. Hence it is observed in para 17 of the judgment that only a suit for specific performance simplicitor would not be covered. But if the suit was not for specific performance but essentially for continuation of the existing leasehold right it would be covered by the aforesaid legislation.

The Court noted that one of the reliefs was the execution of fresh leave and license agreement upon the declaration sought and not a bare relief of specific performance. Consequently it held that the Civil Court would be barred from trying such a suit.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Chamber Summons (L) No. 1075 of 2015 in Suit No. 1930 of 2002

Decided On: 26.06.2015

 Manilal & Sons Bombay Forigings Ltd. Vs. Manilal & Sons

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.S. Dalvi, J.
Citation: 2016 Bom RC183.
Print Page

Saturday, 15 July 2017

What is distinction between renewal of lease and extension of lease?

 This review petition has been filed mainly on the ground that the judgments referred by learned counsel for the respondent skipped attention of the Court and could not be considered in the right perspective. It has also been averred that clause (n) of the lease deed executed between the erstwhile lessor Bhanwar Lal and IOCL had not been properly interpreted. In Clause (n) of the said lease deed, though term "renewal" has been employed but looking to the terms and conditions mentioned thereunder, it amounts to "extension", which is an unilateral act of one party for which the consent of another is not required.
 This Court while passing the judgment under review, has taken help of various pronouncements rendered by Hon'ble Supreme Court, besides the judgments referred by learned counsel for the respondent IOCL. The judgment of Calcutta High Court in case of Ansuman Mullick Vs. Mallika Investment Co.(P) Ltd. & Ors., reported in AIR 2004 Calcutta p.316 has also been discussed wherein the distinction between the "renewal" and "extension" of the lease deed has been dealt with. Similarly, the case of Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. Vs. V. Ashvinraj, reported in 1997 (1) All India Rent Control Journal p.408 has also been considered on the point of renewal of lease. This Court has been benefitted by these judgments while coming to the conclusion in the matter in hand.
14. Clause (n) of the lease deed has also been critically examined while reproducing the same in the said judgment. Taking note of the fact that in this Clause, everywhere the term "renewal" has been used and not "extension", it has been inferred that by the said lease deed, only "renewal" of the lease deed was contemplated and not the "extension" thereof. It is, thus, clear that the distinction between the concept of "renewal" and "extension" has been clearly considered by the Court while passing the judgment dated 1.3.2016 and the plea raised by learned counsel for the respondent IOCL has been rejected.
Rajasthan High Court - Jodhpur
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd vs Navratan Singh on 6 October, 2016
Citation:AIR 2017(NOC)392 Raj
Print Page

Friday, 22 July 2016

What is distinction between extension of lease and renewal of lease?


  In this context, the cardinal distinction between the terms

"extension" and "renewal" must be remembered.                Normally the term

'extend' means to enlarge, lengthen, prolong, etc.           Settled law is that


renewal of a lease denotes the creation of a new lease for all practical


purposes. Supreme Court in Provash Chandra Dalui's case (supra) re-

stated the principles thus:

                    "It is pertinent to note that the word used is

              'extension' and not 'renewal'. To extend means to

              enlarge, expand, lengthen, prolong, to carry out

              further than its original limit. Extension, according to

              Black's Law Dictionary, means enlargement of the

              main body; addition of something smaller than that

              to which it is attached; to lengthen or prolong. Thus

              extension ordinarily implies the continued existence

              of something to be extended. The distinction



              between 'extension and 'renewal' is chiefly that in


              the case of renewal, a new lease is required, while


              in the case of extension the same lease continues


              in force during additional period by the performance


              of the stipulated act. In other words, the word

              'extension' when used in its proper and usual sense

              in connection with a lease means a prolongation of

              the lease........"
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALAAT ERNAKULAM

                                                         PRESENT:
 MR. JUSTICE A.HARIPRASAD

                WEDNESDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2015
                                                RSA.No. 282 of 2015 ()
                                                  

       M/S. INDIRA MOTOR SERVICE
          Vs

        PANAKKAT NAZARUDDIN
        
Print Page

Sunday, 16 February 2014

What is difference between extension of lease and renewal of lease?

A lease deed does not automatically get renewed by merely incorporating a clause for renewal

In numerous cases, parties execute a lease deed for a fixed term containing a clause for renewal of the lease for a further fixed term. However, many individuals erroneously believe that by merely incorporating a clause for renewal of lease under the original lease deed, the lease would automatically get renewed for an additional period upon expiry of the initial lease term. To avoid litigation and uncertainty over rights and entitlements of the parties over leased premises, it is important for both lessors and lessees to be aware of the difference between an extension and renewal of lease. 

Print Page