Showing posts with label finding of criminal court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label finding of criminal court. Show all posts

Tuesday, 12 November 2019

Whether employer can remove employee from service even if he was released on probation of offenders Act?

 Yet another reason given by the High Court for interference with the order of discharge is that the criminal court released the Respondent on probation only to permit him to continue in service. The release under probation does not entitle an employee to claim a right to continue in service. In fact the employer is under an obligation to discontinue the services of an employee convicted of an offence involving moral turpitude.1 The observations made by a criminal court are not binding2 on the employer who has the liberty of dealing with his employees suitably.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 7011 of 2009

Decided On: 26.04.2019

 The State Bank of India  Vs.  P. Soupramaniane

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
L. Nageswara Rao and M.R. Shah, JJ.


Citation: AIR 2019 SC 2187

L. Nageswara Rao, J.
Print Page

Thursday, 20 July 2017

Whether civil court can rely on finding given by criminal court?

The case law on the subject is umpteen. As noticed, the proceedings are often referred to as, in the nature of, a summary proceeding, a quasi-civil proceeding, analogous to a civil proceeding, etc. All that is determined in the said proceeding is as to the prima facie entitlement for possession. Adjudication of title does not form the subject matter of enquiry therein, though incidentally title may also often go into the zone of consideration. However, the jurisdiction to decide on title ultimately vests with the Civil Court. Suffice to say that adjudication on title if any in a proceeding under Section 452 of the Cr.P.C., is always subject to the decision on the same by the Civil Court. The finding on title in a proceeding under Section 452 of the Cr.P.C. could not be made the basis for determination of title in the civil Court. The civil Court has to independently adjudicate on title.
23. The Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents-plaintiffs referred to the judgment of various High Courts and the Apex Court regarding the extent to which the judgment in a criminal case is relevant in a civil case. In Anil Behari v. Latika Dassi(AIR 1955 SC 566), though a person (named Charu) was convicted and sentenced for life in a Sessions trial, in a subsequent civil litigation the Apex Court held that the Civil Court has to independently decide on evidence if he was the murderer. The relevant portion of the judgment runs as under:
“The learned counsel for the contesting respondent suggested that it had not been found by the lower Appellate Court as a fact upon the evidence adduced in this case, that Girish was the nearest agnate of the testator or that Charu had murdered his adoptive father, though these matters had been assumed as facts. The Courts below have referred to good and reliable evidence in support of the finding that Girish was the nearest reversioner to the estate of the testator. If the will is a valid and genuine will, there is intestacy in respect of the interest created in favour of Charu, if he was the murderer of the testator. On this question the Courts below have assumed on the basis of the judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the High Court in the sessions trial that Charu was the murderer. Though that judgment is relevant only to show that there was such a trial resulting in the conviction and sentence of Charu to transportation for life, it is not evidence of the fact that Charu was the murderer. That question has to be decided on evidence.”
24. As noticed, the judgment of the Criminal Court was held to be relevant only to show that there was such a trial which ended up in conviction and sentence. If in a subsequent civil proceedings the very issue arises, the civil court has to independently consider the evidence and reach at its own conclusion. To sum up, independent on the finding under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C, the Court has to enter a finding on title, on its own.
In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam
(Before V. Chitambaresh and Sathish Ninan, JJ.)
Kerala State Cashew Development Corporation Limited, 
v.
M/s. Binod Cashew Corporation,
Decided on July 12, 2017.
Citation: 2017 SCC OnLine Ker 8389
Print Page

Tuesday, 11 October 2016

Whether vehicle seized in wild life protection Act can be confiscated without finding of criminal court?

The aforesaid determination brings me to the factual matrix
of the case in hand. The Authorized Forest Officer in exercise of
power under Section 39(1)(d) of the Act of 1972 has directed
confiscation of the vehicle in favour of the State Government but
the criminal case initiated for commission of offence against the
petitioners under Sections 9,44,51,25,26 (28) of the Act, 1972 is
pending consideration before the jurisdictional criminal court; and
at present there is no finding recorded by the criminal court that
the petitioners' vehicle has been used for committing offence. In
absence of such finding by the competent criminal court, the
provisions of Section 39(1)(d) of the Act, 1972 cannot be invoked
into. The order of the Specified Officer forfeiting the vehicle
without awaiting the decision of the competent criminal court
about use of offending vehicle in above-stated offence is without
jurisdiction and without authority of law in light of the decision
rendered by the Full Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in
the matter of Madhukar Rao (supra).
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
 Writ Petition (Cr.) No. 57 of 201 4

 Mohammad Shoaib, S/o Rafiq Mohammaad, V  The State of Chhattisgarh, 

Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal
DATED: 05 /0 4 /201 6
Print Page

Friday, 9 September 2016

Whether finding given by court in proceeding U/s 145 of CRPC is binding on civil court?

The   proceedings   under   Section   145   of   the   Criminal
Procedure Code are by way of stop gap or interim arrangement
till the competent  Civil Court is approached by  either of the
party for to decide the issue of possession of the suit one way or

the other   and   as such  decision  by   the  criminal Court  in  the
criminal proceedings is purely provisional or temporary in nature
until a decision is given from the competent Civil Court as to the
legal right to possession of the suit property.  As such criminal
proceedings, therefore, would no longer survive once the decree
for possession is passed by the competent Civil Court.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR
SECOND APPEAL NO.157 OF 2015

Balu @ Balasaheb Bapurao Khawal, Vs Subhash Pundlikrao Jadhav,

CORAM : A. P. BHANGALE, J. 
DATE : AUGUST 14, 2015
Citation: 2016(4) ALLMR 149
Print Page

Sunday, 10 April 2016

Whether findings of criminal court are binding over claim tribunal?

From the perusal of the award, it could been seen that during cross examination, RW1, has fully admitted that disciplinary proceedings have been taken against him, for his act of negligence and that he was under suspension for three months. While adverting to the evidence adduced, on behalf of both parties, the claims tribunal has considered the judgment, made in Zoological Park Vs. S.Kalyana Raman and others, reported in 2008 ACJ 133 wherein, the Court has held that the finding of the criminal court, is not binding on the claims tribunal.  Mere acquittal in the criminal case does not amount to absolving a person of his rash and negligent driving.  It is well known that the test to prove the guilt of an offence in the court of criminal jurisdiction is proof beyond all reasonable doubt,  whereas, in claim for compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, it is suffice that the claims tribunal adjudge, negligence on the principles of preponderance of probability. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF MADRAS
DATED:  23.06.2014
CORAM:
THE HON BLE MR. JUSTICE S. MANIKUMAR
C.M.A.No.1781 of 2014
and M.P.No.1 of 2014

The Managing Director,
... Appellant

Vs.

1.Santhi
Citation;2016(2) ALLMR(JOURNAL)40 Madras
Print Page

Thursday, 25 February 2016

When finding recorded by criminal court shall not be binding on civil court?

Indisputably, various documents including order-sheets in the earlier proceedings including execution case were filed to nullify the claim of the plaintiff regarding possession of the suit property but these documents have not been considered by the High Court. In our considered opinion the evidence and the finding recorded by the criminal courts in a criminal proceeding cannot be the conclusive proof of existence of any fact, particularly, the existence of agreement to grant a decree for specific performance without independent finding recorded by the Civil Court.
Supreme Court of India
K. Nanjappa (D) By Lrs vs R.A. Hameed @ Ameersab (D)By Lrs. & ... on 2 September, 2015

Bench: M.Y. Eqbal, C. Nagappan
REPORTABLE
Citation;(2016) 1 SCC 762
Print Page