Showing posts with label finding of fact. Show all posts
Showing posts with label finding of fact. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 March 2026

Supreme court: What will be impact of Material vs. Normal Discrepancies on credibility of prosecution witnesses?

 In State of Rajasthan v. Smt. Kalki and Anr.   MANU/SC/0254/1981 : AIR 1981 SC 1390, while dealing with this issue, this Court observed as under:


In the depositions of witnesses there are always normal discrepancies, however honest and truthful they may be. These discrepancies are due to normal errors of observation, normal errors of memory due to lapse of time, due to mental disposition such as shock and horror at the time of the occurrence, and the like. Material discrepancies are those which are not normal, and not expected of a normal person. {Para 18}

19. The courts have to label the category to which a discrepancy belongs. While normal discrepancies do not corrode the credibility of a party's case, material discrepancies do so. (see: Syed Ibrahim v. State of A.P.   MANU/SC/8237/2006 : AIR 2006 SC 2908; and Arumugam v. State   MANU/SC/8108/2008 : AIR 2009 SC 331).


20. In Bihari Nath Goswami v. Shiv Kumar Singh and Ors.   MANU/SC/0158/2004 : (2004) 9 SCC 186, this Court examined the issue and held:


Exaggerations per se do not render the evidence brittle. But it can be one of the factors to test credibility of the prosecution version, when the entire evidence is put in a crucible for being tested on the touchstone of credibility.

21. While deciding such a case, the Court has to apply the aforesaid tests. Mere marginal variations in the statements cannot be dubbed as improvements as the same may be elaborations of the statement made by the witness earlier. The omissions which amount to contradictions in material particulars i.e. go to the root of the case/materially affect the trial or core of the prosecution's case, render the testimony of the witness liable to be discredited.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 891 of 2004

Decided On: 11.11.2010

Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta and Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P. Sathasivam and B.S. Chauhan, JJ.

Author: B.S. Chauhan, J.

Citation: 2010 INSC 770,2011 ALLMR 288 (SC),MANU/SC/0947/2010.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.


Print Page

Supreme Court: What are parameters for deciding appeal against acquittal?

 Appeal against Acquittal:


22. It is a well-established principle of law, consistently re-iterated and followed by this Court is that while dealing with a judgment of acquittal, an appellate court must consider the entire evidence on record, so as to arrive at a finding as to whether the views of the trial Court were perverse or otherwise unsustainable. Even though the appellate court is entitled to consider, whether in arriving at a finding of fact, the trial Court had placed the burden of proof incorrectly or failed to take into consideration any admissible evidence and/or had taken into consideration evidence brought on record contrary to law; the appellate court should not ordinarily set aside a judgment of acquittal in a case where two views are possible, though the view of the appellate court may be the more probable one. The trial court which has the benefit of watching the demeanour of the witnesses is the best judge of the credibility of the witnesses.


23. Every accused is presumed to be innocent unless his guilt is proved. The presumption of innocence is a human right. Subject to the statutory exceptions, the said principle forms the basis of criminal jurisprudence in India. The nature of the offence, its seriousness and gravity has to be taken into consideration.


The appellate court should bear in mind the presumption of innocence of the accused, and further, that the trial court's acquittal bolsters the presumption of his innocence. Interference with the decision of the Trial Court in a casual or cavalier manner where the other view is possible should be avoided, unless there are good reasons for such interference.


24. In exceptional cases where there are compelling circumstances, and the judgment under appeal is found to be perverse, the appellate court can interfere with the order of acquittal. The findings of fact recorded by a court can be held to be perverse if the findings have been arrived at by ignoring or excluding relevant material or by taking into consideration irrelevant/inadmissible material. A finding may also be said to be perverse if it is 'against the weight of evidence', or if the finding so outrageously defies logic as to suffer from the vice of irrationality. (See: Balak Ram and Anr. v. State of U.P.   MANU/SC/0410/1974 : AIR 1974 SC 2165; Shailendra Pratap and Anr. v. State of U.P.   MANU/SC/0007/2003 : AIR 2003 SC 1104; Budh Singh and Ors. v. State of U.P.   MANU/SC/8163/2006 : AIR 2006 SC 2500; S. Rama Krishna v. S. Rami Reddy (D) by his L.Rs. and Ors.   MANU/SC/7538/2008 : AIR 2008 SC 2066; Arulvelu and Anr. v. State   MANU/SC/1709/2009 : (2009) 10 SCC 206; Ram Singh alias Chhaju v. State of Himachal Pradesh   MANU/SC/0070/2010 : (2010) 2 SCC 445); and Babu v. State of Kerala   MANU/SC/0580/2010 : (2010) 9 SCC 189).

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 891 of 2004

Decided On: 11.11.2010

Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta and Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P. Sathasivam and B.S. Chauhan, JJ.

Author: B.S. Chauhan, J.

Citation: 2010 INSC 770,2011 ALLMR 288 (SC),MANU/SC/0947/2010.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.


Print Page

Supreme Court: Whether the court can rely on evidence of prosecution witness who has stated a fact before court for the first time without stating it at the time of his statement to police U/S 161 of CRPC?

 In case, the complainant in the FIR or the witness in his statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C., has not disclosed certain facts but meets the prosecution case first time before the court, such version lacks credence and is liable to be discarded. (Vide: State Represented by Inspector of Police, Tamil Nadu v. Sait @ Krishnakumar   MANU/SC/8143/2008 : (2008) 15 SCC 440). {Para 17}

30. So far as the stay of the deceased with her parents after coming from Kanpur to Kalyan at the guest house is concerned, admittedly at that time the relations between the parties were strained because of the suspicion that the deceased was having an illicit relationship with Kake. However, it has been admitted by Ramkishan (PW.8), father of the deceased, that subsequently the relations became normal and they were invited at the house of the appellants after the deceased tendered an apology to her mother-in- law. The said witness did not state in his statement before the police that when he went to see the appellants on 17.2.1985, they had asked him whether he had brought gold ornaments or had come empty handed or that he was told that the deceased would not be allowed to live there and they would make her condition even more miserable. Such an improvement was made while deposing in court and no explanation could be furnished by him as to why such vital facts were not stated by him at the time of recording his statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. This statement is to be discarded as it is not safe to hold the appellants guilty of the offences alleged against them on such an improved version.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 891 of 2004

Decided On: 11.11.2010

Sunil Kumar Sambhudayal Gupta and Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P. Sathasivam and B.S. Chauhan, JJ.

Author: B.S. Chauhan, J.

Citation: 2010 INSC 770,2011 ALLMR 288 (SC),MANU/SC/0947/2010

Print Page

Saturday, 14 April 2018

Whether plea of readiness and willingness is finding of fact?

So far as the plea relating to readiness and willingness is concerned, it was again rightly held by the High Court to which we concur that this being a finding of fact, it could not be disturbed in second appeal and was binding on the High Court. It was more so when the first Appellate Court had recorded its finding by appreciating the entire evidence on record. We, therefore, find no ground to disagree with this finding of the High Court.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 6069 of 2008

Decided On: 05.12.2017

Balwant Vithal Kadam Vs. Sunil Baburaoi Kadam

Print Page

Sunday, 4 September 2016

When finding of fact given by arbitrator can not be interfered by court U/S 34 of arbitration Act?

 A perusal of the award clearly indicates that the learned arbitrator has dealt with the provisions of the contract and has dealt with the submissions and pleadings of both the parties and has rendered a finding of fact. In my view, the said finding of fact rendered by the learned arbitrator is not perverse and thus cannot be interfered with by this Court under section 34 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996.
Bombay High Court
Oil And Natural Gas Corpoation Ltd vs International Certification ... on 28 April, 2016
Bench: R.D. Dhanuka
Citation:2016(4)MHLJ727
Print Page

Saturday, 14 May 2016

When appellate court should not interfere with finding of trial court?

 The Appellate Court may not interfere with the finding of the trial court unless the finding recorded by the trial court is erroneous or the trial court ignored the evidence on record. The High Court reversed the decree passed by the trial court without discussing oral and documentary evidence and several grounds raised before the trial court. The High Court veered away from the main issue and went on to elaborate on the law of arbitration and the mode of setting aside the arbitral award under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act, which in our view, was not warranted. Without considering the oral and documentary evidence, the High Court erred in interfering with the factual findings recorded by the trial court and the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside.
Supreme Court of India
Venkatesh Constrn.Co vs Karnataka Vidyut Karkhane ... on 20 January, 2016

Bench: T.S. Thakur, A.K. Sikri, R. Banumathi
REPORTABLE
 CIVIL APPEAL NOS.       461-462  OF  2016
 (Arising out of SLP (C) Nos.29680-29681 of 2010)

Citation;(2016)4 SCC119
Print Page

Saturday, 9 April 2016

Whether finding of fact can be interfered in second appeal?

Whether the
property was joint Hindu family property or it was self
acquired property of defendant No.1 is a question of fact
and the fact finding Court has given finding against the
appellants. In second appeal it is not possible to interfere
in this finding and it needs to be held all these properties
are the joint Hindu family properties.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
Second Appeal No. 1132 of 2004
 Rajaram Mahadu Dahatonde

Versus
 Babu Mahadu Dahatonde,

 CORAM: T.V. NALAWADE, J.

 DATE : 29th OCTOBER 2015
Citation;2016(2)ALLMR 326

Print Page

Sunday, 21 February 2016

Whether wrong finding of fact will constitute question of law?

Be that as it may, the question whether there is a
structural alteration in a tenanted premises is not a fact limited
to the personal knowledge of the owner. It can be proved by
any admissible and reliable evidence. That burden has been
successfully discharged by the plaintiff by examining PWs-1
and 2. The defendants could not shake that evidence. In fact,
that fact is proved partially from the evidence of the
defendants themselves, as an admitted fact. Hence, only the
trial court came to the definite finding on structural alteration.
That finding has been endorsed by the first appellate court on
re-appreciation of the evidence, and therefore, the High Court
in second appeal was not justified in upsetting the finding
which is a pure question of fact. We have no hesitation to note
that both the questions of law framed by the High Court are not
substantial questions of law. Even if the finding of fact is wrong,
that by itself will not constitute a question of law. The wrong
finding should stem out on a complete misreading of evidence
or it should be based only on conjectures and surmises. Safest
approach on perversity is the classic approach on the

reasonable man’s inference on the facts. To him, if the
conclusion on the facts in evidence made by the court below is
possible, there is no perversity. If not, the finding is perverse.
Inadequacy of evidence or a different reading of evidence is not
perversity.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 231 OF 2015
DAMODAR LAL 
V
SOHAN DEVI AND OTHERS .
KURIAN, J.:
Citation;AIR2016 SC 262
Print Page

Sunday, 31 May 2015

Whether finding made on adverse inference is binding on parties?

It is no doubt true that much of the finding recorded by the Industrial Court on the issue was because of the adverse inference drawn by the learned Judge against the First Respondent for failure to place on record the material documents, which would have clinched the issue. Nonetheless, a finding made even on adverse inference is also a finding of fact binding on the parties. 

Bombay High Court

Baburao P. Tawade & Ors. vs Hes Ltd. Bombay & Ors. on 3 April, 1995
Equivalent citations: (1997) IIILLJ 265 Bom,1995(2)MHLJ595

Bench: B Srikrishna

Print Page

Saturday, 30 March 2013

When finding of fact may give rise to a substantial question of law?


It is trite law that a finding of fact may give rise to
a substantial question of law, inter-alia, in the event the findings are based on no evidence and/or while arriving at the said finding, relevant admissible evidence has not been taken into consideration or inadmissible evidence has been taken into consideration or legal principles have not been applied in appreciating the evidence, or when the evidence has been misread.
 This Court culled out three principles for determining whether a question of law raised in a case is substantial. One of the principles so summarised, is : The general rule is that High Court will not interfere with the concurrent findings of the courts below. But it is not an absolute rule. Some of the well-recognized exceptions are where (i) the courts below have ignored material evidence or acted on no evidence; (ii) the courts have drawn wrong inferences from proved facts by applying the law erroneously; or (iii) the courts have wrongly cast the burden of proof. 

Supreme Court of India
Chandna Impex P.Ltd. vs Commr.Of Customs on 6 July, 2011
Print Page