Showing posts with label intimation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intimation. Show all posts

Monday, 1 January 2018

Whether date of birth recorded on intimation received from hospital can be corrected?

Even Thomas Jacob (supra) declared that a correction could be made only when there is a error discernible in the recording of the date of birth and there should be cogent material available for the Registrar to be satisfied as to the error having occurred. Only then could the correction be effected. It is also pertinent that there, the correction sought was to an earlier date, than that recorded in the Register. The correction to a later date cannot be permitted, since there could be no presumption that the birth was intimated, in anticipation. This is more so since the Register is said to be maintained with pages numbered serially and the births registered, being entered in the Register chronologically, on the consecutive dates; which dispel any allegation of an error having been committed by the Registrar as to the date recorded.
12. This Court cannot issue a direction in the teeth of the registration of birth having been recorded as 14.01.1987; that too on intimation from the Hospital. The mere fact of a wrong declaration having been made in the later life of the child cannot result in upsetting the factual aspects. In that event, the remedy available is to seek correction of the subsequent declarations made. In such circumstances the prayer of the petitioner  cannot be considered.
Kerala High Court
Abdul Rahiman vs The Registrar Of Birth And Death


      Coram: K. VINOD CHANDRAN, J.
      
           W.P(C). No.21486 of 2016-I
      
    Dated this the 11th day of August, 2016
Print Page

Sunday, 26 November 2017

Whether insurance claim for theft can be refused if there is delay in intimation of theft?

It is common knowledge that a person who lost his vehicle may not straightaway go to the Insurance Company to claim compensation. At first, he will make efforts to trace the vehicle. It is true that the owner has to intimate the insurer immediately after the theft of the vehicle. However, this condition should not bar settlement of genuine claims particularly when the delay in intimation or submission of documents is due to unavoidable circumstances.
The decision of the insurer to reject the claim has to be based on valid grounds. Rejection of the claims on purely technical grounds in a mechanical manner will result in loss of confidence of policy-holders in the insurance industry. If the reason for delay in making a claim is satisfactorily explained, such a claim cannot be rejected on the ground of delay.
It is also necessary to state here that it would not be fair and reasonable to reject genuine claims which had already been verified and found to be correct by the Investigator. The condition regarding the delay shall not be a shelter to repudiate the insurance claims 8 which have been otherwise proved to be genuine. It needs no emphasis that the Consumer Protection Act aims at providing better protection of the interest of consumers. It is a beneficial legislation that deserves liberal construction. This laudable object should not be forgotten while considering the claims made under the Act.
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Om Prakash Vs. Reliance General Insurance and ANR.
[Civil Appeal No. 15611 of 2017 arising out of SLP (C) No.742 of 2015]
S.ABDUL NAZEER, J.
Dated:October 4, 2017.
Citation:(2017) 9 SCC 724
Print Page

Sunday, 19 March 2017

Whether insurance company can repudiate insurance claim for theft of vehicle if theft is not promptly intimated?

 We have considered the rival contention and perused the record. On perusal of complaint we find that it is the case of the complainant that he reported the theft of subject vehicle to the concerned Police Station on the same day and gave oral information of theft to the petitioner insurance company. It is not the case of the complainant that he gave immediate intimation of theft of vehicle in writing to the insurance company. Thus, the question is whether the Fora below were justified in allowing in the consumer complaint ignoring condition no. 1 of the insurance contract, which reads as under:
“1. Notice shall be given in writing to the company immediately upon the occurrence of any accidental loss or damage in the event of any claim and thereafter the insured shall give all such information and assistance as the company shall require. Every letter claim writ summons and/or process or copy thereof shall be forwarded to the company immediately on receipt by the insured. Notice shall also be given in writing to the company immediately the insured shall have knowledge of any impending prosecution, inquest or fatal inquiry in respect of any occurrence which may give rise to a claim under this policy. In case of theft or criminal act which may be the subject of a claim under this policy the insured shall give immediate notice to the police and co-operate with the company in securing the conviction of the offender.”
 8. Similar issue came up before the Coordinate Bench of this Commission in the mater of Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jai Prakash, Revision Petition No. 2479 of 2015 decided on 11.01.2016. In the said matter, the Coordinate Bench of this Commission took the view that on account of failure of the complainant to perform his contractual obligation to intimate the theft of vehicle to the insurer, repudiation of contract was justified. Similar view was taken by Bench No. 4 of this Commission in Revision Petition No. 2391 of 2015 titled Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. v.Harbhajan Khaira.
 9. We do not find any reason to differ with the aforesaid view taken by Coordinate Benches. Accordingly, we hold that Fora below have committed a grave irregularity by passing the impugned order in utter disregard of law laid down by the Supreme Court of Parvesh Chander Chadha (supra). Thus, we have no hesitation in holding that as the insured has failed to fulfil his obligation to intimate the theft of vehicle to the insurer in writing immediately after the theft, insurance company was justified in repudiating the insurance claim.
National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi
(Before Ajit Bharihoke, Presiding Member and S.M. Kantikar, Member)

Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd.
V
Arun Kumar Singh & anr.
Revision Petition No. 1054 of 2016
Decided on January 3, 2017
Citation:2017 SCC OnLine NCDRC 1
Print Page

Sunday, 22 September 2013

Tenant can not repair rented property without knowledge and consent of landlord

Following the decision of the Supreme Court above, it has to be held that no notice under Section 106 need to be issued to the tenant before filing the petition for eviction and that is not a pre-requisite one. Even if the tenant carries out the repairs, it should be with knowledge and consent of the landlord for which Section 22 of the Act contemplates issue of notice to the tenant by the landlord as to making of necessary repairs of the building. In the absence of such notice, the tenant cannot carry out any repair and come forward to say that the rent could be adjusted in the case of repair.
Madras high court
K.A.Jaganathan vs S.Shanju on 9 December, 2009

Print Page