Showing posts with label layout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label layout. Show all posts

Saturday, 2 April 2022

Decoding revenue Jargon for better appreciation of land Dispute(Real Estate)

A) Procedure for sanctioning of layout.

1) 10% open space is to be left for sanctioning of layout

2) tentative layout,

3) Approval

4) demarcated layout on spot

5) sanctioned layout.

6) revised layout if there is dispute.

This procedure is available under building byelaws

B) When city survey is done, Property card is issued.

Chalta sheet is maintained which shows which city survey is converted into which CTS No. in urban area. 

C) Gut no. is in respect of agricultural land .

Khasra patrak and pahni patrak are in respect of agricultural land 

Survey no is converted in to gut no in case of agricultural land.

Print Page

Whether Municipal Corporation can permit layout owners to use open spaces for further development?

 Once such layout is finalized, if the development takes place, the

layout virtually becomes unalterable. The plot in such layout are

sold and are developed by individuals. The land reserved for

road and open spaces are utilized for such purposes and none

else. In an ideal case, the plot owners would form a cooperative

society and using contributed funds they would keep spaces for

recreation, clean and tidy and usable for recreation. They may

develop garden or play ground on such lands. The building bylaws also contemplated that such plots would be handed over to the Municipal Corporation so that they would not only protect

them but would also develop them as play grounds or gardens.

It is not only the plot holders in the locality but even outsiders

who would come in this locality would be entitled to use the land

for its designated purpose such as; road and open spaces for

recreation. In other words, right of user of this open spaces and

roads accrued to public at large. No one can interfere in such

right. In view of this also, the attempt of the Municipal

Corporation to allow the layout owners to use open spaces for

further development was inappropriate and illegal. The

resolution of the Municipal Corporation for the reasons above,

cannot be said to be lawful. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD.

WRIT PETITION NO. 5044 OF 1999

 Vasantrao s/o Vinayakrao Deshmukh Vs Aurangabad Municipal Corporation

CORAM : A. V. NIRGUDE & V. L. ACHLIYA, JJ.

DATED : MARCH 5TH, 2015.

 (PER A. V. NIRGUDE, J.)

Print Page

Friday, 4 February 2022

Whether construction is permissible in open spaces left in approved building layout plans in residential zone?

     The development plan which is prepared by MHADA for entire area of more than 5,80,000 sq. yards, indicates broadly the usages in different zones. It is well known that such development plans are prepared by showing various zones such as residential, commercial, industrial etc. Merely because in such development plan prepared, in the area shown for residential purpose, authorities have not indicated the open spaces/garden, which were already left in the approved layout in such residential area, appellants cannot claim the benefit of making constructions in the plots which were left towards open space/garden. It is fairly well settled that the open spaces/garden left in an approved layout, cannot be allowed for the purpose of constructions. However, it is to be noticed that if one wants to utilize a big plot within the area of residential usage as indicated in the development plan, it is mandatory to sub-divide such big plots into smaller plots for utilizing them for the purpose of construction. When the layout is to be approved, certain percentage of area is required to be left towards roads, open plots, garden etc. The development Plan prepared by MHADA, cannot be confused with the layout which is approved confining to four big plots, on the application made by the appellants. It is not necessary for only the owner to apply for such layout. In any event, having applied for layout which was approved and after utilizing the 59 plots out of total of 61 plots, it is not open for the appellants to plead that it was not the obligation of the appellants to submit layout. In the layout sanctioned and obtained in the year 1967, the open spaces were rightly reserved as provided under Regulation 39 of 1967 DCR. Merely on such basis, the appellants cannot claim that the sub-plots which are covered by approved layout, left towards open spaces/garden, can also be used for constructions.  {Para 22}

23. It is also to be noticed that the open spaces are required to be left for an approval of layout or for the purpose of creating lung space for the owners of other plots where constructions are permitted. It is not open to claim for construction in the two plots which are reserved for open spaces/garden spaces also. It is fairly well settled that in an approved layout, the open spaces which are left, are to be continued in that manner alone and no construction can be permitted in such open spaces. The Development Plan which was submitted in the year 1999, as per the 1991 DCR, will not divest the utility of certain plots which are reserved for open spaces in the approved layout. The appellants cannot plead that such a layout was only temporary and as a stop gap arrangement, the said two plots were shown as open spaces/garden and now they be permitted to use for construction.                                  Supreme Court

JUSTICE MOHAN M. SHANTANAGOUDAR JUSTICE R. SUBHASH REDDY

Anjuman E Shiate Ali & Anr. Vs. Gulmohar Area Societies Welfare Group & Ors. etc.

CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 6216-6217 OF 2019

17th April 2020

Citation: 2020 SCC OnLine SC 373,2021(1) ALL MR 367 (S.C.)

Author: R. SUBHASH REDDY, J.

Print Page

Wednesday, 15 December 2021

Whether Municipal Corporation can lease out open space vested in it in layout to third party?

 Considering the provisions applicable to the present matter, keeping in view observations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, we find that the Corporation does not have unfettered rights relating to open space. The Corporation has to use it for the purpose for which the space is left open. {Para 12}

13. In this regard, the petitioners have rightly pointed out the Circular issued by the Government of Maharashtra having Writ Petition No.4208/1998 No.TPB4396/114/C.No.89/96/NV.11, dated 10th June 1996. The Circular refers to misuse being done of such 10% open spaces handed over to public institutions. The Circular records that, to such open spaces, the first right is of the plot holders of the layout, because the plot holders have indirectly to the extent of their plots paid price to the owner of the plot even for the open space which was required to be left by the owner. It is stated that, even if from the open space 10% would be constructed for "Balak Mandir, Club Hall" etc., still such use should be made by the Corporation or jointly by the plot holders of the layout. The Circular requires forming of Co-operative Society/ Federation of plot holders of the lay-out. The proposal should be received from the Co-operative Society/ Federation of the plot holders and should be for common use. If Society/ Federation has not been formed, Registered Undertaking can be taken from plot holders to use the open space for the purposes specified. Such structure can be only for purposes of recreation. As per the directions issued by the State Government, the remaining space has to be left open permanently for the common use of the plot holders as a playground or garden or space for recreation. The Circular contains directions that it would be permissible for the Corporation to give such 10% open space to the Co-operative Society/ Federation of the plot holders on rent on such terms and Writ Petition No.4208/1998 conditions as mentioned in the Circular.

14. The above circular was issued on 10.6.1996, which was before the respondent Corporation passed resolution dated 30.3.1998 to give away the land to the respondent Club. There is no material to show that the Corporation made any efforts as were directed under the above Circular dated 10.6.1996.

15. This Court has, in the matter of "R.S. Pool Table & others Vs. The Aurangabad Municipal Corporation & ors."

(Writ Petition No.4335 of 2012), decided on 8th July 2014, held that, even where Corporation has to lease its land, it would be necessary to follow transparent procedure inviting tenders by issuing advertisement. In this matter, the Corporation cannot justify its action of simply receiving an application from a Club hardly two years old, managed by one of its Corporator and leasing out property, in violation of the Circular dated 10.6.1996, which had been recently issued at that time. In fact the Circular issued by State was specifically to curb leasing outs to such public institutions. Neither the Circular was resorted to nor any transparent procedure was followed for leasing out the land. In fact, as per direction Clause 'B' of the Circular, the only course open for the Corporation was to either lease out the open space to the Society/ Federation or develop the same itself.

Writ Petition No.4208/1998

16. For such reasons, the allocation of the open space made by the Corporation in favour of respondent No.3 and the impugned agreement dated 7.9.1998 is quashed and set aside.

Looking to the averments of the respondent No.3 that the petitioner No.1 was misusing the open space to park his vehicles etc., we record that it would be responsibility of the Municipal Corporation to ensure that the open space is kept open and for common use of the plot holders of the lay-out. The Corporation would be at liberty to take necessary steps as per the Circular referred and to ensure that open space is used strictly for the purpose for which it is left open under the bye-laws and shall take action against violation, if any.

Bombay High Court
Punjabrao Srihari Wadje And Anr vs Municipal Corpn. Aurangabad Thr. ... on 29 February, 2016
Print Page

Whether Municipal corporation can lease out out open space in layout without inviting tenders by issuing advertisement?

 This Court has, in the matter of "R.S. Pool Table & others Vs. The Aurangabad Municipal Corporation & ors."

(Writ Petition No.4335 of 2012), decided on 8th July 2014, held that, even where Corporation has to lease its land, it would be necessary to follow transparent procedure inviting tenders by issuing advertisement. In this matter, the Corporation cannot justify its action of simply receiving an application from a Club hardly two years old, managed by one of its Corporator and leasing out property, in violation of the Circular dated 10.6.1996, which had been recently issued at that time. In fact the Circular issued by State was specifically to curb leasing outs to such public institutions. Neither the Circular was resorted to nor any transparent procedure was followed for leasing out the land. In fact, as per direction Clause 'B' of the Circular, the only course open for the Corporation was to either lease out the open space to the Society/ Federation or develop the same itself.

Bombay High Court
Punjabrao Srihari Wadje And Anr vs Municipal Corpn. Aurangabad Thr. ... on 29 February, 2016
Print Page

Sunday, 16 August 2015

Whether Municipal corporation can put condition to transfer open space to it free of costs while sanctioning layout plan?

Property - consideration - Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 - whether municipal corporation of Delhi in absence of any provision of Act entitled to sanction plan for building activities with condition that open space for parks and schools be transferred to Corporation free of cost - Corporation by virtue of land specified as open space may get right as custodian of public interest to manage it in interest of society in general - right to manage as local body not same as claim transfer of property to itself - resolution of Committee to transfer land in colony for park and school was order of transfer without there being sanction for same in law - Corporation have right to manage land which was earmarked for school, park etc. - Corporation not have any right to change user of land which shall be beneficial enjoyment of residence of colony - open to Corporation to get land transferred in its favour after paying market price as prevalent on date when sanction to layout plan accorded.

Equivalent Citation: AIR1995SC430, JT1994(7)SC159, 1994(4)SCALE695, (1995)1SCC47, [1994]Supp5SCR180
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 319 of 1976
Decided On: 26.10.1994

Pt. Chet Ram Vashist  Vs.  Municipal Corporation of Delhi

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M. Sahai and N.P. Singh, JJ.


Print Page

Thursday, 11 September 2014

Whether municipal corporation has right to get open space transferred to it while sanctioning layout?

 But, the question is, does it entitle the
Corporation to claim that the land so specified should be transferred to
the authority free of cost. That is not made out from any provision in the
Act or on any principle of law. The Corporation by virtue of the land
specified as open space may get a right as a custodian of public interest to
manage it in the interest of the society in general. But the right to manage
as a local body is not the same thing as to claim transfer of the property to
itself. The effect of transfer of the property is that the transferor ceases to
be owner of it and the ownership stands transferred in the person in
whose favour it is transferred. The resolution of the Committee to transfer
land in the colony for parks and school was an order for transfer without
there being any sanction for the same in law. Thus, by a mere resolution
these lands could not be transferred and there has to be sanction for the
same in law.” (see para 6 on page 435).

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.3241 OF 2012
Shantaram Narayan Raut,

versus
The Additional Collector, Nashik.
 Citation: 2012(6)ALLMR527, 2013(2)BomCR341, 2012(6)MhLj790

CORAM : S.C.DHARMADHIKARI, J.
Date : 04th September, 2012.

Print Page

Monday, 8 September 2014

Whether municipal corporation can acquire ownership right in open space of layout which was given to it for management?


The finding of the High Court that such condition did not amount. to transfer of ownership but it was only a transfer of the right of management cannot be accepted. The two rights, namely, of ownership and of management, are distinct and different rights. Once a vacant site is transferred in favour of another free of cost then the person transferring it ceases to be owner of it. Whereas in transfer of right of management the ownership continues with the person to whom the property belongs and the local authority only gets rights to manage it. But the conditions imposed by the Standing Committee clearly meant to transfer the ownership in favour of the Corporation. The Corporation as custodian of civil amenities and services may claim and that would be proper as well, to permit the Corporation to regulate, manage, supervise and look after such amenities but whether such a provision can entitle a Corporation to claim that such property should be transferred to it free of cost appears to be fraught with insurmountable difficulties. The law does not appear to be in favour of the Corporation. Public purpose is, no doubt, a very important consideration and private interest has to be sacrificed for the welfare of the society. But when the appellant was willing to reserve the two plots for park and school then he was not acting against public interest. This cannot be stretched to create a right and title in favour of a local body which utmost may be entitled to manage and supervise only.

Supreme Court of India
Pt.Chet Ram Vashist vs Municipal Corporation Of Delhi on 26 October, 1994
Equivalent citations: 1995 AIR 430, 1995 SCC (1) 47
JT 1994 (7) 159 1994 SCALE (4)695
Print Page

Whether municipal corporation can direct land owner to surrender open space to it while sanctioning layout?


None of its provisions entitled the Corporation to claim any right or interest in the property of the owner. Sub-section (3) empowers the Standing Committee to accord sanction to the layout plan on such conditions as it may think fit. The expression, 'such conditions' has to be understood so as to advance the objective of the provision and the purpose for which it has been enacted. The Corporation has been given the right to examine that the layout plan is not contrary to any provision of the Act or the rules framed by it. For instance a person submitting a layout plan may be required to leave certain open space or he may be required that the length and width of the rooms shall not be less than a particular measurement or that a coloniser shall have to provide amenities and facilities to those who shall purchase land or building in its colony. But the power cannot be construed to mean that the Corporation in the exercise of placing restrictions or imposing conditions before sanctioning a layout plan can also claim that it shall be sanctioned only if the owner surrenders a portion of the land and transfers it in favour of the Corporation free of cost. That would be contrary to the language used in the section and violative of civil rights which vests in every owner to hold
his land and transfer it in accordance with law. The resolution passed by the Corporation directing the appellant to transfer the space reserved for tubewells, school and park in its favour free of cost was depriving the owner of his property and vesting it in the Corporation against law. 

Supreme Court of India
Pt.Chet Ram Vashist vs Municipal Corporation Of Delhi on 26 October, 1994
Equivalent citations: 1995 AIR 430, 1995 SCC (1) 47,JT 1994 (7) 159 1994 SCALE (4)695
Print Page

Sunday, 7 September 2014

Whether ownership in open space is automatically transferred to Municipal Council on passing of lay out?

The open space is meant to act as lungs in the city and is for the use of all the plot holders in the lay out. Unless the 10% of the total lands is provided as an open space, the lay out is not sanctioned and without the lay out, no construction can be made. The title in the open space is not transferred from the petitioner to the Municipal Council merely on passing of the lay out. When, however, the petitioner transfers the plots in the lay out, the purchasers of the plots get a right to use in common with the original owner so long as he retains on or more plots -- the open space, because the plots in the lay out became buildable only on sanctioning of the layout. We are unable to agree with the contention of Shri Joshi that the ownership in the said open space is automatically transferred to the Municipal Council on passing of the lay out.


Bombay High Court

Vrajlal Jinabhai Patel, Since ... vs State Of Maharashtra And Ors. on 29 August, 2002

Bench: B Marlapalle, D Karnik
Citation;2003(3)MHLJ215,Bom,2003(4)ALLMR299, 2003(105(1))BOMLR223,
Print Page