Showing posts with label residential use. Show all posts
Showing posts with label residential use. Show all posts

Friday, 22 August 2025

Whether landlord is bound to deduct TDS on rental income of Rs 40,000/ per month given for household use in india?

 No, the landlord is not bound to deduct TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) on rental income of ₹40,000 per month given for household (residential) use in India.

According to Section 194IB of the Income Tax Act, TDS is only required to be deducted by the tenant if the monthly rent paid exceeds ₹50,000. The obligation for TDS deduction does not apply for rent payments below this threshold, whether the use is residential or commercial.

So, for a monthly rent of ₹40,000, there is no requirement for the landlord or the tenant to deduct TDS under current Indian tax laws.

Print Page

Friday, 4 February 2022

Whether construction is permissible in open spaces left in approved building layout plans in residential zone?

     The development plan which is prepared by MHADA for entire area of more than 5,80,000 sq. yards, indicates broadly the usages in different zones. It is well known that such development plans are prepared by showing various zones such as residential, commercial, industrial etc. Merely because in such development plan prepared, in the area shown for residential purpose, authorities have not indicated the open spaces/garden, which were already left in the approved layout in such residential area, appellants cannot claim the benefit of making constructions in the plots which were left towards open space/garden. It is fairly well settled that the open spaces/garden left in an approved layout, cannot be allowed for the purpose of constructions. However, it is to be noticed that if one wants to utilize a big plot within the area of residential usage as indicated in the development plan, it is mandatory to sub-divide such big plots into smaller plots for utilizing them for the purpose of construction. When the layout is to be approved, certain percentage of area is required to be left towards roads, open plots, garden etc. The development Plan prepared by MHADA, cannot be confused with the layout which is approved confining to four big plots, on the application made by the appellants. It is not necessary for only the owner to apply for such layout. In any event, having applied for layout which was approved and after utilizing the 59 plots out of total of 61 plots, it is not open for the appellants to plead that it was not the obligation of the appellants to submit layout. In the layout sanctioned and obtained in the year 1967, the open spaces were rightly reserved as provided under Regulation 39 of 1967 DCR. Merely on such basis, the appellants cannot claim that the sub-plots which are covered by approved layout, left towards open spaces/garden, can also be used for constructions.  {Para 22}

23. It is also to be noticed that the open spaces are required to be left for an approval of layout or for the purpose of creating lung space for the owners of other plots where constructions are permitted. It is not open to claim for construction in the two plots which are reserved for open spaces/garden spaces also. It is fairly well settled that in an approved layout, the open spaces which are left, are to be continued in that manner alone and no construction can be permitted in such open spaces. The Development Plan which was submitted in the year 1999, as per the 1991 DCR, will not divest the utility of certain plots which are reserved for open spaces in the approved layout. The appellants cannot plead that such a layout was only temporary and as a stop gap arrangement, the said two plots were shown as open spaces/garden and now they be permitted to use for construction.                                  Supreme Court

JUSTICE MOHAN M. SHANTANAGOUDAR JUSTICE R. SUBHASH REDDY

Anjuman E Shiate Ali & Anr. Vs. Gulmohar Area Societies Welfare Group & Ors. etc.

CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 6216-6217 OF 2019

17th April 2020

Citation: 2020 SCC OnLine SC 373,2021(1) ALL MR 367 (S.C.)

Author: R. SUBHASH REDDY, J.

Print Page

Saturday, 16 October 2021

Can the court hold that rented property was used for composite purposes if the professional uses part of it for his professional work?

  In the present case, the Respondent being Chartered Accountant, was using one room for consultation. His clients used to visit the premises for consultation. Therefore, mere usage of the premises of the Chartered Accountant for carrying out his profession though admittedly dominant purpose and use of the premises is for residence, that itself cannot be sufficient to hold that the premises was let out for composite purposes. It no way change or alter the purpose of letting out. The landlady may or may not take objection to such composite usage. In Sakharam Narayan Kherdekar Vs. City of Nagpur Corporation and Ors. AIR, 1964 Bombay, 200, this Court while considering the advocate's profession held that it is not a commercial activity in the premises, and therefore, registration is not necessary under the Bombay Shops and Establishments Act. In the present case also, there is nothing to show that the premises or portion of the premises was registered for any commercial activities.{Para 4}

5. In Narayan Dattatraya Umbarkar Vs. Late Shri Shankar Hirji Pandya (deceased by his legal heir), 1993 Bom.R.C. ig 324, while dealing with the said provision held that mere user of part of premises for profession would not account to change of user.

Therefore, the professional like Doctor advocate, Chartered Accountant if use their premises for professional purpose and dominantly for residential purpose, the so called agreement cannot be said to be for composite purpose of residential and non-residential. It is observed by this Court in Bhavarlal Sukhlal Soni by L.Rs. Vs. Lakshminarayan Deo Public Trust, 1994 Mh.L.J. 843, that Section 13(1)(l) provision applies only to premises taken on lease for residential use and not to premises taken for commercial use. However, in the present case, there is clear finding given by the Court below that tenant use to have office in the suit premises in connection with the income tax. There are witnesses to support the same also. But having once found that it is permissible for such tenant to use the premises for professional purposes, and such use in no way amounts to change of user of the suit premises, this finding according to me supports the case of the landlady that the premises was let out and used through out for the residential purpose and it was never objected as it no way amounts to creation of composite tenancy. Once, it is clear that the tenant has used this entire premises dominantly for residential purpose and the use of portion of the premises for professional purpose, is not amount to change of user and therefore, the tenancy through out as created is of residential purpose only.

Bombay High Court
Sumatibai Anandrao Rajurkar vs Shri Punamchand P. Lohade on 2 December, 2008
Print Page