Showing posts with label misappropriation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label misappropriation. Show all posts

Wednesday, 30 December 2015

Whether offence of criminal misappropriation of property is made out when property is not entrusted to accused?

Criminal - Illegal gratification - Sections 147 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 and Section 368 of Cochin Penal Code - Appellant and accused No. 2 were joint receivers of textile business - Appellant charged for receiving large sums of money by way of illegal gratification as motive and reward for allotting cloth bales produced in mills - Appellant charged for offence under Section 147 for accepting illegal gratification and for offence under Section 389 for criminal breach of trust and also for abetment and entering into conspiracy for commission of these offences - Appellant and his co-accused acquitted by Special Magistrate who made Order of acquittal in favour of them - On appeal High Court set aside Order of acquittal made in favour of appellant - Hence, present appeal - Appellant contended that High Court reversed Order of acquittal made by Trial Court without adverting to or displacing main grounds upon which decision of Trial Judge rested - Further contended that offence committed by appellant cannot constitute breach of trust though it may amount to taking of illegal gratification - Charge nowhere indicates that the offence consisted in wrongful use or disposal of these goods in violation or any direction of law and it was not stated also what these directions of law were - Held, appellant cannot be convicted for offence of breach of trust - Order of High court set aside - Appeal allowed
The learned Advocate-General appearing for the State Government saw the difficulty in the way of establishing that there was any entrustment with the accused in respect of the sum of Rs. 23,100 paid to him by P. W. 1. He tried to get round this difficulty by saying that it could be held on the facts of this case that the entrustment with the accused was in respect of the goods of the mills and the criminal breach of trust consisted in disposing of the goods contrary to the directions of the court and misappropriating the sale proceeds. It is not necessary to enter into the merits of this argument for the simple reason that this was not the charge upon which the accused was tried.
The subject of criminal breach of trust, as stated in the charge, was a sum of Rs. 23,100 and the definite allegation against the accused was that he and his co-receiver functioning as public servants neither remitted this amount to the credit of the company, nor brought it to the company's accounts, but dishonestly misappropriated the same with the intention of causing illegal loss to the company and illegal gain to themselves. No doubt the charge, which we have set out in the beginning, refers to the two accused having custody of the company's goods, but the charge nowhere indicates that the offence consisted in wrongful use or disposal of these goods in violation or any direction of law, and it was not stated also what these directions of law were.
Supreme Court of India
Chelloor Mankkal Narayan ... vs State Of Travancore-Cochin on 10 November, 1952

Bench: M. Patanjali Cji, B. K. Mukherjea, S. R. Das, V. Bose, G. Hassan
 Citation: AIR1953SC478, 1953()KLT173(SC),1954 CRLJ102 
Print Page

How to appreciate defence of accused in case of criminal misappropriation of property?

There is no dispute that approximately 1,30,000 yards out of the cloth -entrusted to the company by the Textile Commissioner for dyeing has not been returned. By its letter dated December 4, 1950, the company admitted liability to deliver 1,29,748 yards of cloth, but this cloth has not been returned to the Textile Commissioner in spite of repeated demands. That the appellants, as directors of the company had dominion over that cloth was not questioned in, the trial court. The plea that there were other Directors of the company besides the appellants who had dominion over the cloth has been negatived by the High Court and in our judgment rightly. Direct evidence to establish misappropriation of the cloth over which the appellants had dominion is undoubtedly lacking, but to establish a charge of criminal breach of trust, the prosecution is not obliged to prove the precise mode of conversion, misappropriation or misapplication by the accused of the property entrusted to him or over which he has dominion. The principal ingredient of the offence being dishonest misappropriation or conversion which may not ordinarily be a matter of direct proof, entrustment of property and failure in breach of an obligation to account for the property entrusted, if proved, may in the light of other circumstances, justifiably lead to
-an inference of dishonest misappropriation or conversion. Conviction of a person for the offence of criminal breach of trust may not, in all cases, be founded merely on his failure to account for the property entrusted to him, or over which he has dominion, even when a duty to account is imposed upon him, but where he is unable to account or renders an explanation for his failure to account which is untrue, an inference of misappropriation with dishonest intent may readily be made.
In this case, on a search of the factory on December 29, 1952, the cloth remaining to be delivered by the company was not found. At the trial, the appellants sought to explain the disappearance of the cloth from the factory premises where it was stored, on the plea that it was old and was eaten up by white-ants and moths, and had been thrown away as rubbish. This plea of the appellants was not accepted by the High Court and we think rightly. No information was given at any time to the Textile Commissioner after December 4, 1950, that the cloth had been eaten up by white-ants and moths, and was therefore thrown away or otherwise destroyed. Nor was any evidence led in support of the plea by the appellants.
In this court, counsel for the first appellant contended that failure to return the cloth may give rise to a civil liability to make good the loss occasioned thereby, but in the circumstances of the case, the first appellant cannot be found guilty of the offence of criminal breach of trust. Counsel submitted that the first appellant had left Bombay in 1950 and had settled down in Ahmedabad and was attending to a factory in that town, that thereafter the first appellant was involved in insolvency proceedings and was unable to attend to the affairs of the company in Bombay, and if, on account of the pre-occupation of the first appellant at Ahmedabad, he was unable to visit Bombay and the goods were lost, no criminal misappropriation can be attributed to him. But the case pleaded by the appellant negatives this submission. The first appellant in his statement before the trial court admitted that he often went to Bombay even after he had migrated to Ahmedabad and-that he visited the mill premises and got the same opened by the Gurkha watchman and he found that the heap of cloth lying in the mill was getting smaller every time he visited the mill and on inquiry, he was told by the watchman that every day one basketful of sweepings was thrown away. He also stated that he was shown several places in the compound of the factory where pits had been filled up with these sweepings, and that he found a small heap lying by the side of the " Tulsipipe gutter" and also in the warehouses in the mill premises. It is clear from this statement and other evidence on the record that even after he migrated to Ahmedabad, the first appellant was frequently visiting the factory at Bombay. The evidence also discloses that meetings of Directors were held from time to time, but the minutes of the Directors' meetings have not been produced. The books of account-of the company evidencing disbursements to the Directors of remuneration for attending the meetings and the expenses for the alleged collection and throwing away of the sweepings have not been produced. It is admitted by the first appellant that the letter dated November 27, 1952, was written by the second appellant under his instructions. In his statement at the trial, the first appellant stated that he was informed of the letter dated November 26, 1952, from the Textile Commissioner and that hecould not attend the office of that officer because he was busy attending to the insolvency proceedings and that he deputed the second appellant to attend the office and to explain and discuss the position. Be then stated, "We had informed the Commissioner that the company was prepared to pay for the cloth remaining after deducting the amount claimed as damages". The letter dated November 27, 1952, was evidently written under the direction of the first appellant and by that letter, liability to pay for the cloth after certain adjustments for losses alleged to be suffered by the company in carrying out the contract was admitted. By the letter dated December 4, 1950, liability to deliver the cloth was admitted and by the letter dated November 27, 1952, liability to pay compensation for the loss occasioned to the Government was affirmed. The appellants who were liable to account for the cloth over which they had dominion have failed to do so, and they have rendered a false explanation for their failure to account. The High Court was of the opinion that this false defence viewed in the light of failure to produce the books of account, the stock register and the complete absence of reference in the correspondence with the Textile Commissioner about the cause of disappearance established misappropriation with criminal intent.
Supreme Court of India
Jaikrishnadas Manohardasdesai ... vs The State Of Bombay on 16 March, 1960
Equivalent citations: 1960 AIR 833, 1960 SCR (3) 329,1960 CRLJ 1250

Bench: Gajendragadkar, P.B.
    
Print Page

Whether property obtained by misappropriation amounts to stolen property?

Stolen property as used in this section has been defined in section Section 410 :
"410. Stolen Property.--Property, the possession whereof has been transferred by theft, or by extortion, or by robbery, and property which has been criminally misappropriated or in respect of which criminal breach of trust has been committed, is designed as "stolen property", whether the transfer has been made, or the misappropriation or breach of trust has been committed, within or without India. But, if such property subsequently comes into the possession of a person legally entitled to the possession thereof, it then ceases to be stolen property."
Section 410 accordingly defines stolen property. A property is stolen for the purpose of this section when its possession is transferred by theft, extortion, robbery, dacoity or criminal breach of trust or which was obtained under misappropriation committed whether in India or outside.
An extended meaning is given to the words `stolen property' which are used in the four subsequent sections. Not only things which have been stolen, extorted or robbed but also things which have been obtained by  criminal misappropriation or criminal breach of trust are within the meaning assigned to these words.
Criminal - Stolen Property - Section 411 of Indian Penal Code - Not only things which have been stolen, extorted or robbed but also things which have been obtained by criminal misappropriation or criminal breach of trust are within the meaning of stolen property.
Supreme Court of India
Mir Nagvi Askari vs C.B.I on 7 August, 2009

Bench: S.B. Sinha, Cyriac Joseph
Citation: AIR2010SC528, (2009)15SCC643, 
Print Page

Tuesday, 22 December 2015

When sanction for prosecution is not required for prosecution of public servant?

The alleged indulgence of the officers in cheating,
fabrication of records or misappropriation cannot be said to be
in discharge of their official duty. Their official duty is not to
fabricate records or permit evasion of payment of duty and
cause loss to the Revenue. Unfortunately, the High Court
missed these crucial aspects. The learned Magistrate has
correctly taken the view that if at all the said view of sanction is
to be considered, it could be done at the stage of trial only.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 129 OF 2013
Inspector of Police and another … Appellant (s)
Versus
Battenapatla Venkata Ratnam and another ... Respondent (s)
Citation; 2015 (4) crimes 267 SC
Print Page