Showing posts with label cheating. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cheating. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 April 2026

What is difference between cheating and criminal breach of trust?

 Cheating and criminal breach of trust differ mainly in the stage of dishonest intention: in cheating, the dishonest intention exists from the very beginning and the property is obtained by deception, while in criminal breach of trust, the property is initially received lawfully through entrustment and is dishonestly misappropriated later.

Print Page

Wednesday, 24 December 2025

The Illusion of Guilt: Why Receiving Money from a Cheater Doesn’t Make You a Cheat Under Section 420 IPC


 
Introduction

A common misconception in criminal law is that anyone who receives money in connection with a cheating transaction can be implicated as an accused under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code. However, recent judicial pronouncements clarify a crucial distinction: receiving part of illegally obtained funds does not automatically transform a victim into an offender. This article examines the essential ingredients of Section 420 IPC and demonstrates how courts distinguish between perpetrators and victims even where financial connections exist.

The Essential Ingredients of Section 420 IPC

Print Page

Thursday, 7 September 2023

Whether Use Of Deceased Brother's SIM Card amounts to An Offence of Criminal breach of trust and cheating?

Merely because the sim-card of real brother was used by the sister i.e. the present petitioner, that by itself will not constitute or amount to commission of the offence. The fact remains that to infer misuse of sim-card by the petitioner, there is no iota of evidence to infer such act. It is an admitted fact that the sim-card is duly received by the complainant from the petitioner before the date of lodging of the complaint. {Para 7}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.1871 OF 2022

Heena Afrin Huzaifa Shaikh Vs The State of Maharashtra & Anr. 

CORAM : NITIN W. SAMBRE & R. N. LADDHA, JJ.

DATE : 17th AUGUST, 2023

Print Page

Tuesday, 4 April 2023

Whether Advocate can be held guilty for cheating before Lok adalat through Whatsapp Video Call?


 The applicant is thus alleged of being a part of the entire episode of impersonating Mrs.Gidwani in the consent terms which were filed in S.C. Suit No. 3032/2019.Tilak Prima facie, it can be seen that the applicant filed his vakalatnama and represented the so-called Ms.Pushpa Gidwani for the first time on 9/3/2020, and he was having her mobile number and as per the direction of the Panel Members of the Lok Adalat on 12/12/2020 he made a phone call on the said number and one lady appeared at the other end, who had introduced herself as Pushpa Gidwani and she was known to the applicant as the defendant in the Suit. The applicant claim innocence by stating that as a lawyer, he was not expected to go into the detail Identification as once the client approached and introduced herself to be so and so, there is no reason to disbelieve and even the vakalatnama which was signed by her was given to him which he filed in the Court. {Para 6}


7 There is no reason to disbelieve the applicant, as a lawyer was satisfied that the vakalatnama given to him and chose to represent the defendant in the Suit and even signed the consent terms. However, the learned APP state that the applicant has refused to divert the phone number of Gidwani to whom he had made a video call. Mr.Nikam state that the applicant shall render his co-operation to the Investigating Officer.In the above circumstances, the custodial interrogation of the applicant is not necessary and he deserve protection by way of interim order.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO. 2174 of 2022

Date of Order: 18.08.2022

Rakesh Shrinath Dubey  Vs. The State Of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Bharati Dangre, J.

Citation: MANU/MHOR/121450/2022,2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 16.

Print Page

Saturday, 25 December 2021

Whether the court can convict the accused for an offence of cheating if there is no prosecution evidence that the lady maintained sexual relations under a false promise of marriage?

 In Maheshwar Tigga Vs. State of Jharkhand, (2020) 10

SCC 108 the question before the Hon’ble Supreme Court was

whether the prosecutrix had consented to the physical relationship

under any misconception of fact with regard to promise of marriage

or whether her consent was based on fraudulent misrepresentation of

marriage. The Apex Court has held that under Section 90 of IPC a consent given under a misconception of fact is no consent in the eye of the law. But the misconception of fact has to be in proximity of time to the occurrence and cannot be spread over a period of four years. The Apex Court has observed as under :-

“15. In Uday vs. State of Karnataka, (2003 4 SCC 46,

the Appellant and the prosecutrix resided in the same

neighbourhood. As they belonged to different castes,

a matrimonial relationship could not fructify even

while physical relations continued between them on

the understanding and assurance of marriage. This

Court observed as follows:

“21. It therefore appears that the consensus

of judicial opinion is in favour of the view

that the consent given by the prosecutrix to

sexual intercourse with a person with whom

she is deeply in love on a promise that he

would marry her on a later date, cannot be

said to be given under a misconception of

fact. A false promise is not a fact within the

meaning of the Code. We are inclined to

agree with this view, but we must add that

there is no straitjacket formula for

determining whether consent given by the

prosecutrix to sexual intercourse is voluntary,

or whether it is given under a misconception

of fact. In the ultimate analysis, the tests laid

down by the courts provide at best guidance

to the judicial mind while considering a

question of consent, but the court must, in

each case, consider the evidence before it

and the surrounding circumstances, before

reaching a conclusion, because each case has

its own peculiar facts which may have a

bearing on the question whether the consent

was voluntary, or was given under a

misconception of fact. It must also weigh the

evidence keeping in view the fact that the

burden is on the prosecution to prove each

and every ingredient of the offence, absence

of consent being one of them.” ”

“20. We have no hesitation in concluding that the

consent of the prosecutrix was but a conscious and

deliberated choice, as distinct from an involuntary

action or denial and which opportunity was available

to her, because of her deep-seated love for the

appellant leading her to willingly permit him liberties

with her body, which according to normal human

behaviour are permitted only to a person with whom

one is deeply in love. The observations in this regard

in Uday are considered relevant :-

“25…It usually happens in such cases, when two

young persons are madly in love, that they

promise to each other several times that come

what may, they will get married. As stated by

the prosecutrix the appellant also made such a

promise on more than one occasion. In such

circumstances the promise loses all significance,

particularly when they are overcome with

emotions and passion and find themselves in

situations and circumstances where they, in a

weak moment, succumb to the temptation of

having sexual relationship. This is what appears

to have happened in this case as well, and the

prosecutrix willingly consented to having sexual

intercourse with the appellant with whom she

was deeply in love, not because he promised to

marry her, but because she also desired it. In

these circumstances it would be very difficult to

impute to the appellant knowledge that the

prosecutrix had consented in consequence of a

misconception of fact arising from his promise.

In any event, it was not possible for the

appellant to know what was in the mind of the

prosecutrix when she consented, because there

were more reasons than one for her to

consent.”” {Para 8}

9. In the instant case, the evidence on record indicates that

the prosecutrix and the accused were known to each other. They had

indulged in sexual relationship for a period of over three years. The

evidence of PW1-prosecutrix does not indicate that she had sexual relationship with the accused under misconception of fact, with regard to the promise of marriage or that her consent was based on fraudulent misrepresentation of marriage. There is no evidence on record to indicate that since the inception accused did not intend to marry her. In the absence of evidence to prove that the prosecutrix had consented for physical relationship on a misconception of fact, as stipulated under Section 90 of IPC, the mere refusal to marry would not constitute offence under Section 417 of the IPC.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.119 OF 1999

Kashinath Narayan Gharat  Vs The State of Maharashtra 

CORAM : SMT. ANUJA PRABHUDESSAI, J.

DATED: 9th DECEMBER, 2021.

Print Page

Sunday, 7 March 2021

Whether the offence of cheating is made out if the prosecution fails to prove that accused has caused intentional deception by misrepresentation?

Before dealing with the submissions, qua the application of Section 417 of IPC to the facts of the case, let me advert to the evidence of the prosecutrix. In her testimony, she testified that she was living on construction site and be-friended with the accused, whereafter they fell in love with each other. Her evidence in no uncertain terms, let-out, that she presumed, appellant was not married and believing that he would marry her, she indulged into sexual relationship with him. Her evidence reads as under: {Para 11}

12. Thus, the evidence of the prosecutrix does not suggests that the appellant made false promise to marry her, soon after they be-friended. What appears from her evidence is, that prosecutrix consented for sexual relations, initially, for more than one time but when she learnt that he was married, she filed the report with police whereupon crime came to be registered.

13. Thus, on plain reading of the prosecutrix's evidence, it cannot be said that the appellant lured the prosecutrix to engage in sexual relations with him on false promise of marrying her.

14. In the context of the facts of the case and the evidence on record, question that falls for my consideration is whether conviction of the accused under Section 417 of the IPC is sustainable.

 Herein there was no ‘promise to marry’ nor intentional deception by misrepresentation or deceitfulness practised before establishing physical relationship with prosecutrix. In fact her evidence suggests that she presumed that he was not married and further assumed that he would marry her. Therefore, absence of ‘dishonest concealment of fact’, which is essential ingredient of offence, within the meaning of explanation, appended to Section 415 of IPC, conviction under Section 417 of IPC is not sustainable.

 In the High Court of Bombay

(Before Sandeep K. Shinde, J.)


Jagdish Raghunath Mankar Vs State of Maharashtra 

Criminal Appeal No. 354 of 1998

Decided on February 24, 2021

Citation: 2021 SCC OnLine Bom 269

Print Page

Friday, 25 October 2019

Whether prosecution for cheating can be quashed if civil suit and prosecution for dishonour of cheque is pending?

Mere filing of the suits for recovery of
the money and complaint filed under Section 138 of the N.I.
Act by itself is no ground to quash the proceedings in the
complaints filed by the appellant herein. When cheating and
criminal conspiracy are alleged against the accused, for
advancing a huge sum of Rs.9 crores, it is a matter which is
to be tried, but at the same time the High Court has entered
into the disputed area, at the stage of considering the
petitions filed under Section 482, Cr.P.C. It is fairly
well settled that power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is to be
exercised sparingly when the case is not made out for the

offences alleged on the reading of the complaint itself or
in cases where such complaint is filed by way of abuse of
the process. Whether any Schedules were appended to the
agreement or not, a finding is required to be recorded after
full fledged trial. Further, as the contract is for the
purpose of procuring the land, as such the same is of civil
nature, as held by the High Court, is also no ground for
quashing. Though the contract is of civil nature, if there
is an element of cheating and fraud it is always open for a
party in a contract, to prosecute the other side for the
offences alleged. Equally, mere filing of a suit or
complaint filed under Section 138 of the N.I. Act, 1881 by
itself is no ground to quash the proceedings. While
considering the petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C., we
are of the view that the High Court also committed an error
that there is a novation of the contract in view of the
subsequent agreement entered into on 08.11.2012. Whether
there is novation of contract or not and the effect of such
entering into the contract is a matter which is required to
be considered only after trial but not at the stage of
considering the application under Section 482, Cr.P.C.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS.1573-1575 OF 2019

Dr. Lakshman  Vs The State of Karnataka 

R. Subhash Reddy, J.
Dated:October 17, 2019.
Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2019

Whether court can reject application for compounding of offence in offence of cheating?

Even in this appeal, it is argued by learned Counsel for the Appellant that in view of the provision Under Section 320 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the offence Under Section 420 Indian Penal Code is compoundable with the permission of the court. It is further argued by learned Counsel, that while dismissing the application for compounding, High Court has dismissed the Criminal Revision also without considering the various grounds raised in the Revision Petition. It is further submitted that the alleged incident was of the year 1991-92, but the complaint was lodged belatedly on 05th of November 2004. Further it is submitted that Appellant is a senior citizen and the High Court has committed error in dismissing the Criminal Revision without considering the same on merits.

On the other hand, learned Counsel appearing for the State has submitted that, merely because an offence is compoundable Under Section 320 Code of Criminal Procedure, if the offence for which the Appellant is convicted has its adverse social impact on the society, it need not be compounded. It is further submitted that as much as Criminal Revision is also dismissed by the High Court, no case is made out in this appeal to interfere with the conviction recorded and sentence imposed on the Appellant.

10. Having heard the learned Counsel on both sides we have perused the impugned judgment and also other material placed on record. It was the case of the prosecution that in the beneficial scheme introduced for poor persons under residential scheme an amount of Rs. 9800/- was sanctioned during the year 1991-92 to the complainant. It is the specific case of the complainant that though she was to be paid entire Rs. 9800/-, but Appellant misled her and procured her signature and made payment of only Rs. 4000/- and he has utilised rest of the amount for himself for his personal benefit and gain. Merely because an offence is compoundable Under Section 320 Code of Criminal Procedure still discretion can be exercised by the court having regard to nature of offence, as such it is rightly held in the impugned judgment that as the offence for which Appellant was convicted and sentenced, it will have its own effect on the society at large. In view of the reasons recorded in the impugned order rejecting the application for compounding, it cannot be said that the High Court has committed any error in not accepting the application filed for compounding the offence.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 465 of 2019

Decided On: 11.03.2019

 Bhagyan Das Vs.  The State of Uttarakhand and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R. Banumathi and R. Subhash Reddy, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2019 SC 2032: 2019 (2) Crimes 27 : 2019 (2) KLJ 190 : 2019 (2) RCR (Criminal) 551 : (2019) 4 SCC 354
Print Page

Saturday, 13 April 2019

Whether failure to pay Mobile postpaid user charges amounts to offence of cheating U/S 420 of IPC?

 The prosecution case as against the petitioner as per Annexure 1 report is that, he, after having obtained a mobile postpaid connection in his name, failed to discharge his liability for user charges for a period of 5 months from 21.7.2006 to 21.11.2006. The allegation is that the petitioner incurred a gross monetary liability of ` 97,678.5/- for the period and after making a part payment of ` 10,580/-, he kept the balance in arrears. The default on the part of the petitioner, according to the prosecution, amounts to an offence of cheating punishable under Section 420 of IPC.

3. The petitioner's case is that the transaction in question is based on an agreement between the parties and therefore the alleged liability under the transaction is purely of civil nature. In as much as what is made out is only a civil liability out of the transaction in question, the petitioner seeks the consequential criminal proceedings in C.C. No. 1518/2008 pursuant to the Annexure 1 final report, to be quashed.

5. On marshaling the materials on record, I find that the transaction involved as between the parties is one arising out of a civil dispute. The purported liability of the petitioner seems to have arisen from breach of promise or agreement other than a breach followed by any dishonest intention to cheat the de facto complainant. Mere breach of trust or agreement will not by itself amount to a criminal offence under Section 420 IPC. In order to make out an offence under Section 420, the prosecution has to show that the dishonest intention to cheat existed at the time when the alleged promise in question was made. That legal proposition does not match the materials on record as well as the allegations made out through the Annexure 1 report. Consequently being satisfied that what is involved in the present case is one of civil dispute between parties, I hold that this seems to be a fit case where the criminal proceedings pending before the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate Court, Ernakulam requires to be quashed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

Crl. M.C. No. 1813 of 2014

Decided On: 08.03.2019

Abdul Hakkem P.V. Vs.  State of Kerala and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
T.V. Anil Kumar, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 3 March 2019

Whether Advocate can prosecute litigant for cheating if they fail to pay his fees?

Conspectus to facts/case needs revaluation. The accused-applicants, already harassed couple, with trust deficit, difference of opinion in matrimonial life, though well educated, approached the complainant for legal advise. This contact was with a hope of proper advise. Naturally, to a person professing a noble profession. The complainant, as Advocate, after hearing the parties handed draft petition for mutual divorce. There is no controversy to this aspect. The fact remains, if the couple has thereafter decided not to prosecute their controversies or discord and to have a happy married life, can it be said to be dishonest intention to approach the complainant for his legal advise. The answer is, there could not be of dishonest intention at initial stage. It is absurd to think, for a couple, to hatch a conspiracy, will approach an advocate making a show of difference in their marital life and ensure the Advocate to part with his valuable knowledge which is his property to deliver by way of a divorce petition. Basic requirement for invoking criminal prosecution is, such intention must be shown to exist at the time of making of inducement. Mere failure to keep promise subsequently, will not lead to cheating. There is no element by the accused-applicant to induce the complainant by any representation to draft petition and thereafter back out.

11. Even if as the complainant says, his case squarely comes within the parameters of Section 415 of I.P.C. the above referred factual situation illustrates the scenario, wishfully was developed by the complainant to achieve his agenda for recovering his professional fees. He knew, being well versed in the field, how to squeeze a litigant, not familiar to court system. Resultantly, gullible litigant has faced the brunt. Reading of the complaint petition as a whole, the basic ingredients for infraction of Section 420 or 415 or 120B of I.P.C. are miserably lacking. Not acting on legal advice and not paying fees could be stretched to a civil wrong, without clamour of criminality. Both the courts were expected to look into the legal position, peculiar facts relating to recovery of fees and then to have adverted for appropriate order in legal frame. There should not be poverty of thoughts. I quite see this litigation has proved a windfall for the couple to unite and contest. However, that will not primarily mean that the couple prognosticate conspiracy. It may be their personal mutual satisfaction, which made the couple not to further prosecute and accelerate the divorce proceeding. It will not amount to an deception, a withdrawal from solemn undertaking or disowning rights. There was no inherent propensity to commit offence. Criminal writ petition is allowed. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Writ Petition No. 685 of 2013

Decided On: 26.07.2013

 Dnyananda Sameer Nilekar Vs. State of Maharashtra 

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K.U. Chandiwal, J.

Citation;2013 ALL M R (Cri)3522
Print Page

Sunday, 26 August 2018

Notes on criminal misappropriation of property,criminal breach of trust and cheating

Criminal misappropriation of property( S 403 of IPC) 
A person commits criminal misappropriation if he
1) dishonestly misappropriates or converts to his own use,
2) any movable property.
  The offence of criminal misappropriation takes place where the initial possession is innocent,but the retention thereof becomes wrongful and fraudulent by a subsequent change of intention or from knowledge of some new fact not previously known to the party.
Criminal breach of trust( S 405 of IPC)
Print Page

Saturday, 2 September 2017

When prosecution for cheating is liable to be quashed?

Even if all the allegations in the complaint taken at
the face value are true, in our view, the basic essential
ingredients of dishonest misappropriation and cheating
are missing. Criminal proceedings are not a short cut
for other remedies. Since no case of criminal breach of
trust or dishonest intention of inducement is made out
and the essential ingredients of Sections 405/420
Indian Penal Code are missing, the prosecution of the
Appellants Under Sections 406/120B Indian Penal
Code, is liable to be quashed.”
12. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and
perusing the record of the case as well as precedent laws cited at
Bar, this Court is of the opinion that the sum and substance of the
FIR was that at the time of agreement with the respondent No.2,
the property in question was already promised to be transferred to
one Chhoga Ram vide agreement dated 25.07.2012. It is an
admitted position which is also reflected in the case diary that
Chhoga Ram has during investigation deposed before the
investigating authority and stated that though he had entered into
an agreement on 25.07.2012 but after a compromise, he has
abandoned the agreement and vide compromise between the
parties on 25.04.2013, he has agreed to the proposition of the
petitioner that the agreement in question shall no more have any
impact upon the title of the petitioner. Thus, very basis of the FIR
is not found to be correct in the investigation and the investigating
authority has categorically pointed out that Chhoga Ram was not
having any claim over the property in question after 25.04.2013
whereas the agreement between the petitioner and respondent
No.2 had happened only on 08.09.2013 and at the very inception,
the petitioner was neither deceiving the respondent No.2 nor
inducing him by any of his act which would amount to an offence
as defined under Section 415 IPC.
13. Since, the offence under Section 415 IPC itself was not
made out, there is no question of offence under Section 420 IPC
being made out, as the basic ingredients of the alleged offence is
cheating and dishonest inducement, at the inception, for delivery
of property. Thus, even in the constrained jurisdiction under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. after seeing the precedent laws and observing
the facts, on the face of it, this Court finds that no offence is made
out.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT
JODHPUR
S.B. Criminal Misc(Pet.) No. 3723 / 2016
Jugal Kishore V The State of Rajasthan

HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE PUSHPENDRA SINGH BHATI
Order
24/08/2017
Print Page

Monday, 1 May 2017

When accused can be held guilty for cheating and forgery?

 In the present case, it is an undisputed fact that
the petitioner happened to be a suspended employee of the

Punjab National Bank and the factum of his having
approached PW-1 for purchase of electronics goods on
11.09.1998 and having presented forged demand draft to
him in lieu of the payment of said electronics goods has been
duly proved on record by the prosecution.
 Dr. B.A. Vaid, handwriting expert, entered the
witness box as PW-6 and he deposed on the basis of material

on record which included the admitted handwriting of the
petitioner/accused as well as his handwriting which were
obtained during the course of investigation that these
handwritings and those found on the forged demand draft
were of one and the same person i.e. accused/petitioner.
19. In my considered view, from the material which
was produced on record by the prosecution, all the
incriminating factors were pointing towards the guilt of the
accused. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr. Revision No. 39 of 2010

 Date of decision: 26.08.2016

Sunil Bhaseen V State of Himachal Pradesh 
Coram :
 Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge.
Citation: 2017 CRLJ322
Print Page

Sunday, 30 April 2017

When offence of cheating is made out against sanyasi?

In case of Sri Bhagwan Samardha Vrs. State of
A.P. and others reported in (1999) 5 Supreme Court Cases
740, it is held as follows:-25
“8. If somebody offers his prayers to God for
healing the sick, there cannot normally be any
element of fraud. But if he represents to another
that he has divine powers and either directly or
indirectly makes that other person believe that
he has such divine powers, it is inducement
referred to in Section 415 IPC. Anybody who
responds to such inducement pursuant to it and
gives the inducer money or any other article and
does not get the desired result is a victim of the
fraudulent representation. The Court can in such
a situation presume that the offence of cheating
falling within the ambit of Section 420 IPC has
been committed. It is for the accused, in such a
situation to rebut the presumption.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
BLAPL NO. 7367 of 2015

Surendranath Mishra V State of Odisha 

P R E S E N T:-
 MR. JUSTICE S.K. SAHOO
 Date of order: 25.05.2016

Citation: 2017 CRLJ30

Print Page

Friday, 14 April 2017

Whether offence of cheating is made out if cheque is issued after closure of bank Account?

 There is apparent distinction between a situation wherein a person after issuing a cheque to another, closes that account, and a situation wherein a person after closing the account with the bank, manages to issue a cheque to another from that account he had already closed. In the former, apart from the fact that it may invite another offence, it would certainly be an offence under Section 138 of the N.I. Act.
15. The latter situation deals with two totally different situations. Firstly, the account is being closed by the bank on the demand of the account holder himself and thereafter the account holder manages to issue a cheque to another from that account he had already closed. Secondly, the bank on its own volition closes the account by itself, without the knowledge and consent of the account holder; say for example, by treating the account as a non-performing account, and without the knowledge that the account was closed by the bank, the account holder issues a cheque to another from that account. In the case covered by firstly as aforesaid, it would be the offence of cheating, since the cheque was intentionally issued to the payee to cheat him with the knowledge that there was no live account. In that case, it would not be an offence under Section 138 of the N.I. Act, since there was no live account at the time when the cheque is issued. In the case covered by secondly as aforesaid, it would not be an offence of cheating, since the cheque was issued bonafide by believing that the account remained alive; whereas, the dishonour of that cheque would invite an offence under Section 138 of the N.I. Act.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
Crl. Appeal No. 141 of 2009
Decided On: 05.07.2016

 V. Muralidharan Vs.  V.A. Kumaran and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

B. Kemal Pasha, J.

Citation: 2017 CRLJ(NOC)69 Ker
Print Page

Saturday, 23 April 2016

Whether failure to follow rules and regulation amounts to offence of cheating or criminal breach of trust?

He will now proceed to consider the final report submitted by the Police (C.I.D.). I should, however, like to observe for the benefit of the learned Magistrate that he will bear in mind that mere failure to follow rules and regulations is neither cheating nor breach of trust. He will also bear in mind while applying himself to the case diary with all thoroughness whether there is any material to show that the Railways have suffered. In order to constitute offence of cheating causation of damage or harm to a person in body, mind, reputation or property is essential. The learned Magistrate will direct his attention to this aspect of the matter. Loss to the Railways cannot be presumed merely from the fact of irregular booking. The learned Magistrate will consider the effect of issuing of despatch advice and forwarding notes by Tisco at the time of despatch of goods. The learned Magistrate will also bear in mind that mere failure to pay does not amount to cheating for, mere breach of contract is not cheating. The attention of the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate is particularly drawn to the cases of Harkrishna Mahatab v. Emperor MANU/BH/0295/1929 : AIR1930Pat209 , Major Robert Stuart Wauchope v. Emperor MANU/WB/0123/1933 : AIR1933Cal800 and the State of Kerala v. A. Prasad Pillai and Anr. MANU/SC/0263/1972 : 1972CriLJ1243 . To my mind that Railway as an organisation profited rather than lost by the unusual procedure adopted in relation to Tisco. The learned. Magistrate will also consider whether the whole case diary reveals any material indicating that any public servant had enriched himself either by bribery or by breach or by breach of faith. After going through the case diary thoroughly the learned Magistrate will decide dehors the recommendation of Superintendent of Railway Police, respondent No. 7 and C.I.D. whether any offence had been committed and if so which accused should be put on trial.
Equivalent Citation: AIR1980SC326, 1980CriLJ98, (1980)1SCC554, (1980)SCC(Cri)272, [1980]2SCR16
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal Nos. 301 and 300 of 1979
Decided On: 13.11.1979

State of Bihar and Anr. Vs. J.A.C. Saldanha and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

D.A. Desai, O. Chinnappa Reddy and R.S. Sarkaria, JJ.
Print Page

Wednesday, 3 February 2016

What is Distinction between offence of cheating and breach of contract?

It is to be seen that whether
the averments in the complaint make out a case to constitute an
offence of cheating. The essential ingredients to attract Section
420 IPC are: (i) cheating; (ii) dishonest inducement to deliver
property or to make, alter or destroy any valuable security or
anything which is sealed or signed or is capable of being
converted into a valuable security and (iii) mens rea of the
accused at the time of making the inducement. The making of a
false representation is one of the essential ingredients to
constitute the offence of cheating under Section 420 IPC. In order
to bring a case for the offence of cheating, it is not merely
sufficient to prove that a false representation had been made, but,
it is further necessary to prove that the representation was false
to the knowledge of the accused and was made in order to deceive
the complainant.
Distinction between mere breach of contract and the
cheating would depend upon the intention of the accused at the
time of alleged inducement. If it is established that the intention
of the accused was dishonest at the very time when he made a

promise and entered into a transaction with the complainant to
part with his property or money, then the liability is criminal and
the accused is guilty of the offence of cheating. On the other
hand, if all that is established that a representation made by the
accused has subsequently not been kept, criminal liability cannot
be foisted on the accused and the only right which the
complainant acquires is the remedy for breach of contract in a
civil court. Mere breach of contract cannot give rise to criminal
prosecution for cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention
is shown at the beginning of the transaction. In S.W. Palanitkar &
Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Anr. (2002) 1 SCC 241, this Court held as
under:
“21 ……In order to constitute an offence of cheating, the
intention to deceive should be in existence at the time when
the inducement was made. It is necessary to show that a
person had fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of
making the promise, to say that he committed an act of
cheating. A mere failure to keep up promise subsequently
cannot be presumed as an act leading to cheating.”
The above view in Palanitkar’s case was referred to and followed in
Rashmi Jain vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. (2014) 13 SCC 553.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 2128 OF 2011
INTERNATIONAL ADVANCED RESEARCH
CENTRE FOR POWDER METALLURGY
AND NEW MATERIALS (ARCI) & ORS.
V
NIMRA CERGLASS TECHNICS (P) LTD.
& ANR.
Citation;2015ALLMR(Cri)4101,2015(4)Crimes86(SC), 
 R. BANUMATHI, J.
Print Page

Saturday, 26 December 2015

Whether sale of truck by accused before repayment of loan amounts to offence U/S 420 of IPC?

PENAL CODE - Section 420--Cheating--Complainant--advancing Rs. 20,000/- on execution of pronote for purchasing truck-Orally agreed not to sell truck till loan is repaid-Accused selling truck before repayment-Held, complainant was not defrauded to part with Rs. 20,000/-It is a case of breach of agreement and civil liability is incurred-Charge of cheating is quashed.
On 13th June, 1980, the petitioner obtained a loan of Rs. 20,000/- from the complainant and executed a pronote in favour of the complainant and at the time of the execution of the said pro-note, it was orally agreed that so long as the petitioner did not repay the aforesaid amount of loan, the petitioner would not take his share of the income from the truck and it was also agreed that so long as the petitioner did not repay the amount of the pronote, he would not be entitled to sell the truck and that the aforesaid agreement was also re-evolved on the back of the pronote.
The allegations contained in the complaint, do not make out the case that at the time when the complainant advanced the sum of Rs. 20,000/- to the petitioner, the petitioner had deceived the complainant by fraudulently including the complainant to advance the loan of Rs. 20,000/- to the petitioner & that but for the aforesaid inducement, the petitioner would not have paid the sum of Rs. 20,000/- to the complainant.
The petitioner in selling the truck before repaying the amount of the loan of Rs. 20,000/-, has committed breach of the agreement, which is said to have been entered into between the complainant and the petitioner on 13th June, 1980 when the complainant advanced the loan of Rs. 20,000/-to the petitioner. The aforesaid alleged breach of the agreement may give rise to civil liability but it would not give rise to any criminal liability.
Petition Allowed

Equivalent Citation: 1982WLN(UC)195
IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN
S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 123/82
Decided On: 30.07.1982

Kayhaiya Lal Vs.  The State of Rajasthan

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.C. Agrawal, J.

Equivalent Citation: 1982WLN(UC)195


Print Page

Tuesday, 22 December 2015

When sanction for prosecution is not required for prosecution of public servant?

The alleged indulgence of the officers in cheating,
fabrication of records or misappropriation cannot be said to be
in discharge of their official duty. Their official duty is not to
fabricate records or permit evasion of payment of duty and
cause loss to the Revenue. Unfortunately, the High Court
missed these crucial aspects. The learned Magistrate has
correctly taken the view that if at all the said view of sanction is
to be considered, it could be done at the stage of trial only.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 129 OF 2013
Inspector of Police and another … Appellant (s)
Versus
Battenapatla Venkata Ratnam and another ... Respondent (s)
Citation; 2015 (4) crimes 267 SC
Print Page

Saturday, 19 December 2015

Whether offence of cheating is made out if there is no allegation of dishonesty or cheating?

 After giving a plain reading to the complaint and taking it at its face value, one cannot come to any other conclusion other then the following. The entire complaint taken on the whole is indicative of a dispute between the parties which is purely of a civil nature. No where in the said complaint, it has been stated that the petitioners herein had acted dishonestly or had the intention of cheating the 2nd respondent/complainant. The whole of the complaint only speaks about the business transaction of giving raw coffee by the petitioners and delivery of cured coffee by the 2nd respondent and there being some violation of certain conditions of the agreement entered into between the parties and causing loss to the complainant. As such it cannot be said from the reading of the said complaint without either adding or subtracting anything to the complaint that the said complaint disclosed the necessary ingredients of the offences alleged therein.
Karnataka High Court
Lmj International Limited, (A ... vs State Of Karnataka And Shylaja ... on 6 July, 2007
Equivalent citations: 2007 CriLJ 4437
Bench: V Jagannathan
Print Page