Showing posts with label multiple cause of action. Show all posts
Showing posts with label multiple cause of action. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 January 2018

How to ascertain limitation in case of multiple cause of action?

While enacting Article 58 of the 1963 Act, the legislature has designedly made a departure from the language of Article 120 of the 1908 Act. The word 'first' has been used between the words `sue' and `accrued'. This would mean that if a suit is based on multiple causes of action, the period of limitation will begin to run from the date when the right to sue first accrues. To put it differently, successive violation of the right will not give rise to fresh cause and the suit will be liable to be dismissed if it is beyond the period of limitation counted from the day when the right to sue first accrued.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 7773 of 2011 (Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 22126 of 2009)

Decided On: 09.09.2011

Khatri Hotels Private Limited and Anr. Vs. Union of India (UOI) and Anr.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
G.S. Singhvi and H.L. Dattu, JJ.

Citation: (2011) 9 SCC 126
Print Page

Wednesday, 30 November 2016

How to ascertain period of limitation if suit is based on multiple cause of action?

 In Khatri Hotels (P) Ltd. v Union of India (2011

(9) SCC 126) the Apex Court held that, while enacting Article 58

of the Limitation Act, 1963, the legislature has designedly made a

departure from the language of Article 120 of the Limitation Act,

1908. The word 'first' has been used between the words 'sue' and

'accrue'. This would mean that, if the suit is based on multiple

cause of action, the period of limitation will begin to run from the

date when the right to sue first accrues. To put it differently,

successive violation of right will not give rise to fresh cause and

the suit will be liable to be dismissed if it is beyond the period of

limitation counted from the date when the right to sue first

accrued.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALAAT ERNAKULAM

                                               PRESENT:

                 MR.JUSTICE P.R.RAMACHANDRA MENON
                                                      &
                     MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN

                4TH DAYOF NOVEMBER 2016

                                          RFA.No. 140 of 2010
                                          

                     K.K.GOVINDAN 
Vs

                     K.G.PREMSANKAR, I
Print Page

Saturday, 10 September 2016

Whether subsequent suit based on different cause of action will be barred by O 2 R 2 of CPC?

A bare perusal of the above provisions would indicate that if a plaintiff is entitled to several reliefs against the defendant in respect of the same cause of action, he cannot split up the claim so as to omit one part of the claim and sue for the other. If the cause of action is the same, the plaintiff has to place all his claims before the court in one suit as Order 2 Rule 2 is based on the cardinal principle that the defendant should not be vexed twice for the same cause.
In Palaniappa Chettiar v. Alagan Chettiar & Ors., A.I.R. 1931 P.C.228, it was laid down that the plaintiff cannot be permitted to draw the defendant to court twice for the same cause by splitting up the claim and suing, in the first instance, in respect of a part of claim only.
What the rule, therefore, requires is the unity of all claims based on the same cause of action in one suit. It does not contemplate unity of distinct and separate causes of action. If, therefore, the subsequent suit is based on a different cause of action, the rule will not operate as a bar. [See Arun Lal Gupta & Ors. v. Mriganka Mohan Sur & Ors. : A.I.R.1975 S.C.207; State of Madhya Pradesh v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. : A.I.R. 1977 S.C.1466; Kewal Singh v. Mt.Lajwanti : A.I.R. 1980 S.C. 161].
In Sidramappa v. Rajashetty & Ors. : A.I.R. 1970 S.C.1059, it was laid down that if the cause of action on the basis of which the previous suit was brought, does not form the foundation of the subsequent suit and in the earlier suit the plaintiff could not have claimed the relief which he sought in the subsequent suit, the latter namely, the subsequent suit, will not be barred by the rule contained in Order II Rule 2, CPC. In Gurbux Singh v. Bhura Lal (A.I.R. 1964 S.C.1810), it was observed:
"In order that a plea of a bar under 0.2 R.2(3). Civil Procedure Code should succeed the defendant who raises the plea must make out (i) that the second suit was in respect of the same cause of action as that on which the previous suit was based; (2) that in respect of that cause of action the plaintiff was entitled to more than one relief; (3) that being thus entitled to more than one relief the plaintiff, without leave obtained from the Court, omitted to sue for the relief for which the second suit had been filed. From this analysis, it would be seen that the defendant would have to establish primarily and to start with, the precise cause of action upon which the previous suit was filed, for unless there is identity between the cause of action on which the earlier suit was filed and that on which the claim in the later suit is based there would be no scope for the application of the bar."
In view of the above, what is to be seen in the instant case is whether the cause of action on the basis of which the previous suit was filed, is identical to the cause of action on which the subsequent suit giving rise to the present appeal, was filed. If the identity of causes of action is established, the rule would immediately become applicable and it will have to be held that since the relief claimed in the subsequent suit was omitted to be claimed in the earlier suit, without the leave of the court in which the previous suit was originally filed, the subsequent suit for possession is liable to be dismissed as the appellants, being the defendants in both the suits, cannot be vaxed twice by two separate suits in respect of the same cause of action.

Supreme Court of India

Deva Ram And Another vs Ishwar Chand And Another on 16 October, 1995
Equivalent citations: 1996 AIR 378, 1995 SCC (6) 733

BENCH:
AHMAD SAGHIR S. (J)
KULDIP SINGH (J)

Print Page

Tuesday, 5 April 2016

When plaintiff can join multiple cause of action in one suit?

 Hence it is seen that there are two causes of action upon
which the plaintiff has sued.  They are in respect of the same property
and against the same party.   The plaintiff can join those causes of
action to sue.  The plaintiff could sue in respect of the initial cause of
action consequent upon the leave granted.  The plaintiff could file any
other suit on any other cause of action within the period of limitation.
Hence the  plaintiff  could sue on the second cause of action  even
without the leave.  That is the inherent right of the plaintiff to sue in
civil court. That right is not barred.
 Consequently   the   first   right   which   would   otherwise   be
barred is saved by the leave granted upon the defect of jurisdiction.
The second right is not barred at all.  
The chronology of the events and dates and the averments
in plaint, therefore, do not show that the suit is barred by the Law of
Limitation and the plaint, therefore, cannot be rejected on the ground
that the suit is barred by the Law of Limitation under Order 7 Rule
11(d) of the CPC.  Hence prayer 'c' of the Notice of Motion is rejected.
18. It is also contended that this suit is filed upon the leave
granted in Suit No.1251 of 2007. This suit, however, extends further.
Leave has been granted obviously to sue on the same cause of action.
The cause of action in that suit was unauthorized construction and
encroachment outside the premises of defendant Nos.1 and 2 as also
the other occupants / tenants.   This suit is filed on that cause of
action.
It is not contended that these two causes of action, one

initially for which the leave was obtained and the other which accrued
later upon a further act of defendant Nos.1 and 2 would constitute
misjoinder  of the causes of action.   Indeed it does not appear to
constitute any misjoinder.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY 
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
NOTICE OF MOTION NO.170 OF 2012
ALONGWITH
Parwan Constructions Pvt. Ltd.
Vs.
Ranjitsingh Linga & Ors. 

       CORAM :   MRS. ROSHAN DALVI, J.
           DATE     :   23rdMarch, 2015.
Citation; 2016(1) ALLMR252
Print Page

Sunday, 13 April 2014

Procedure to be followed by court if there is multiple cause of action


In the present case, the state of pleadings in the suit being what it is, the
court cannot agree with the defendant‟s contention that the action is time barred.
May be, in regard to some claims, the suit could be time barred; however, the
court cannot, at this pre-trial stage, undertake a detailed scrutiny. Another cardinal
rule which guides courts is that the plaint cannot be rejected in part, if it contains
multiple causes of action. Assuming that claims to some causes might be barred,
the existence of others which may be established at the trial stage should impel
the court to tread softly. For these reasons, the plea of limitation cannot be
accepted.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

Pronounced on : 23.10.2008

ANIL RAI  Vs  VINAY RAI

CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT

S.RAVINDRA BHAT, J.

Print Page