Showing posts with label official capacity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label official capacity. Show all posts

Friday, 29 June 2018

Whether Chief minister can sue for defamation in official capacity if defamatory statement has no connection with his official duty?

 If the allegedly defamatory statements, already extracted, in respect of which sanction has been accorded to the Public Prosecutor to file the complaint against the Appellant Under Section 199 (2) Code of Criminal Procedure by the order dated 24th June, 2014 are to be carefully looked into, according to us, none of the said statements, even if admitted to have been made by the Appellant, can be said to have any reasonable connection with the discharge of public duties by or the office of the Hon'ble Chief Minister. The appointment of persons from the area/place to which the wife of the Hon'ble Chief Minister belongs and the making of phone calls by the relatives of the Hon'ble Chief Minister have no reasonable nexus with the discharge of public duties by or the office of the Hon'ble Chief Minister. Such statements may be defamatory but then in the absence of a nexus between the same and the discIt is the remedy saved by the provisions of If the allegedly defamatory statements, already extracted, in respect of which sanction has been accorded to the Public Prosecutor to file the complaint against the Appellant Under Section 199 (2) Code of Criminal Procedure by the order dated 24th June, 2014 are to be carefully looked into, according to us, none of the said statements, even if admitted to have been made by the Appellant, can be said to have any reasonable connection with the discharge of public duties by or the office of the Hon'ble Chief Minister. The appointment of persons from the area/place to which the wife of the Hon'ble Chief Minister belongs and the making of phone calls by the relatives of the Hon'ble Chief Minister have no reasonable nexus with the discharge of public duties by or the office of the Hon'ble Chief Minister. Such statements may be defamatory but then in the absence of a nexus between the same and the discharge of public duties of the office, the remedy Under Section 199(2) and 199(4) Code of Criminal Procedure will not be available. Charge of public duties of the office, the remedy Under Section 199(2) and 199(4) Code of Criminal Procedure will not be available. 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 547 of 2018 

Decided On: 13.04.2018

K.K. Mishra Vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ranjan Gogoi and R. Banumathi and Mohan M. Shantanagoudar, JJ.

Print Page

Sunday, 19 March 2017

Whether court should grant damages against public officer for any acts done by him in official capacity?

On bare perusal of the Judgment of the learned Judge, I find that the
learned Judge has lost sight of the said provisions to erroneously come to the
conclusion that the Plaintiff was entitled for compensation for granting
electrical connection to said Gokuldas in terms of the said Act. In any event,
any acts done in good faith in official capacity in furtherance of the duties
cannot be a ground to award damages to the plaintiff when admittedly no
pecuniary loss has been established nor pleaded by the plaintiff. Learned
Judge has failed to consider the well settled principles of law while awarding
damages as, admittedly, no pecuniary loss has been established by the
plaintiff. Apart from that, the directions issued by the defendant no. 1 and 4
are in exercise of power conferred under the Public Health Act. The issue of
title or other rights to get said electricity connection are matters to be
adjudicated in the proper forum. Merely because such electricity connection
has been granted for domestic purpose would not by itself affect the rights, if
any, of the plaintiff to get their claim adjudicated as against the said
Gokuldas in accordance with law. Considering that the learned Judge failed
to consider the well settled principles of law whilst passing the impugned
order, I find that the impugned order passed by the learned Judge cannot be
sustained and deserves to be quashed and set aside. The points for
determination are answered accordingly.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA
FIRST APPEAL No. 62 OF 2007
Shri Shivaji B. Dessai,

 V
Shri Vithoba Babuso Adel,


 CORAM:- F.M. REIS, J

 Dated : 02.12.2016
Citation: 2017(2) MHLJ 382
Print Page

Sunday, 27 December 2015

Whether public servant can compound the case if assault is committed on him while he was acting in official capacity?

In my considered view, FIR in question cannot be quashed
on the basis of compromise. Nature of allegations show that petitioners
assaulted the complainant, who was posted as Head Constable in the
police station itself and had torn his uniform when he was conducting
investigation on the direction of the Station House Officer pursuant to a
complaint lodged against them. They also threatened to kill the
investigating officer as well as complainant. Instant dispute is not
personal in nature. Petitioners committed an offence against the State.
There can be no question of compromise between accused and officials of
the State. For this reason, FIR was lodged by the Head Constable and the
investigating agency registered a case. It is inexplicable how Head
Constable entered into a compromise on behalf of the State. There is
nothing on record to show that he was authorised by the police
department to enter into a compromise with the petitioners. Even
otherwise, such a compromise would be of no avail in view of nature of
allegations. The Head Constable while making complaint to the police
was merely acting on behalf of the police department. He would, thus,
have no authority to enter into compromise with the accused thereafter.
In my considered view after public servant lodges an FIR regarding the
assault raised upon him while he was performing his official duty, he
loses the locus standi to enter into compromise with the accused.
Judgment in Kulwinder Singh's case (supra) is not attracted to cases of
this nature. Under the circumstances, there is no ground for quashing of
FIR. The petition is hereby dismissed.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH.
CRM-M-37551-2015 (O&M)
Date of decision: December 23, 2015
Amrik Singh and others V
State of Punjab & another 
CORAM: MR. JUSTICE RAJAN GUPTA

Print Page