Showing posts with label oral argument. Show all posts
Showing posts with label oral argument. Show all posts

Thursday, 1 August 2024

Delhi HC: Provisions of Case Management hearing Under the Commercial courts Act empowers the court to set time limit for addressing oral arguments by the parties

The counsel for the plaintiff states that a direction is sought for limiting the time for addressing oral arguments. {Para 4}

Rule 2 inter alia includes fixing the date on which oral arguments are to be heard by the Court and setting time limits for the parties and their advocates to address oral arguments.{Para 8}.

12. The counsel for the defendant of course controverts but is unable to. However, on enquiry as to how much time the defendant will take to address arguments, refuses to commit.

13. The application is disposed of, binding the plaintiff to the aforesaid time limits and clarifying, that after the opening arguments of the counsel for the plaintiff, the Court shall, if need be, limit the time for addressing oral arguments on behalf of the defendant.

 In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi

(Before Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.)


Roland Corporation Vs  Sandeep Jain

CS (COMM) 565/2018, 

Decided on January 15, 2019

Citation:
2019 SCC OnLine Del 6557 : (2019) 196 AIC 723
Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2024

Madras HC: Commercial court can dispense with written argument and hear oral argument in cases where Ex-parte evidence was recorded

 A perusal of the above would reveal that there is a departure made from the usual procedure, particularly in that part of CPC, which remains untouched by said Act. That departure is, written arguments are to be filed before oral arguments are advanced. A perusal of amended CPC as amended by said Act would reveal that written arguments supra has to be filed in accordance with Order XVIII Rule 2 Sub Rules (3A) to (3F). This takes us to the question as to in a given case like this, where there is no contest, where ex parte evidence has been recorded, whether the Court i.e., Commercial Division can hear oral submissions and dispose of the suit before filing of written arguments. {Para 25}

27. A perusal of the same reveals that in case of transferred suits, this Commercial Division can prescribe new time lines and can also issue further directions as may be necessary for speedy and efficacious disposal of suit. In the instant case, in the light of the sole defendant remaining ex parte and in the light of ex parte evidence being recorded, I am of the view that no reasonable purpose will be served by directing the plaintiff to file written arguments, more so, in accordance with Order XVIII Rule 2 Sub Rules (3A) to (3F). It will serve the interest of efficacious disposal, if the written arguments step is skipped and oral arguments are heard. Therefore, I have skipped written arguments and I have heard oral arguments today, after recording of ex parte evidence in the instant suit. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

C.S. No. 28 of 2015, A. No. 208 of 2015, O.A. Nos. 41 and 42 of 2015

Decided On: 26.09.2018

Tablets (India) Ltd. Vs. D.R. Johns Lab Pharma Pvt. Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

M. Sundar, J.

Citation: 2018(8) MLJ 70, MANU/TN/5765/2018.

Print Page

Sunday, 24 November 2019

Supreme Court: Private Counsel Engaged By Victim To Assist Public Prosecutor Cannot Make Oral Argument/Cross Examine Witnesses

We find that a victim's counsel should ordinarily not be given the right to make oral arguments or examine and cross-examine witnesses. As stated in Section 301(2), the private party's pleader is subject to the directions of the Public Prosecutor. In our considered opinion, the same principle should apply to the victim's counsel under the proviso to Section 24(8), as it adequately ensures that the interests of the victim are represented. If the victim's counsel feels that a certain aspect has gone unaddressed in the examination of the witnesses or the arguments advanced by the Public Prosecutor, he may route any questions or points through the Public Prosecutor himself. This would not only preserve the paramount position of the Public Prosecutor under the scheme of the Code of Criminal Procedure, but also ensure that there is no inconsistency between the case advanced by the Public Prosecutor and the victim's counsel.

12.5. However, even if there is a situation where the Public Prosecutor fails to highlight some issue of importance despite it having been suggested by the victim's counsel, the victim's counsel may still not be given the unbridled mantle of making oral arguments or examining witnesses. This is because in such cases, he still has a recourse by channelling his questions or arguments through the Judge first. For instance, if the victim's counsel finds that the Public Prosecutor has not examined a witness properly and not incorporated his suggestions either, he may bring certain questions to the notice of the Court. If the Judge finds merit in them, he may take action accordingly by invoking his powers Under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or Section 165 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. In this regard, we agree with the observations made by the Tripura High Court in Smt. Uma Saha v. State of Tripura (supra) that the victim's counsel has a limited right of assisting the prosecution, which may extend to suggesting questions to the Court or the prosecution, but not putting them by himself.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1727 of 2019 

Decided On: 20.11.2019

 Rekha Murarka  Vs.  The State of West Bengal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Mohan M. Shantanagoudar and Deepak Gupta, JJ.

Citation: (2020) 2 SCC474,AIR 2020 SC 100

Print Page