Showing posts with label private counsel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label private counsel. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 November 2019

Supreme Court: Private Counsel Engaged By Victim To Assist Public Prosecutor Cannot Make Oral Argument/Cross Examine Witnesses

We find that a victim's counsel should ordinarily not be given the right to make oral arguments or examine and cross-examine witnesses. As stated in Section 301(2), the private party's pleader is subject to the directions of the Public Prosecutor. In our considered opinion, the same principle should apply to the victim's counsel under the proviso to Section 24(8), as it adequately ensures that the interests of the victim are represented. If the victim's counsel feels that a certain aspect has gone unaddressed in the examination of the witnesses or the arguments advanced by the Public Prosecutor, he may route any questions or points through the Public Prosecutor himself. This would not only preserve the paramount position of the Public Prosecutor under the scheme of the Code of Criminal Procedure, but also ensure that there is no inconsistency between the case advanced by the Public Prosecutor and the victim's counsel.

12.5. However, even if there is a situation where the Public Prosecutor fails to highlight some issue of importance despite it having been suggested by the victim's counsel, the victim's counsel may still not be given the unbridled mantle of making oral arguments or examining witnesses. This is because in such cases, he still has a recourse by channelling his questions or arguments through the Judge first. For instance, if the victim's counsel finds that the Public Prosecutor has not examined a witness properly and not incorporated his suggestions either, he may bring certain questions to the notice of the Court. If the Judge finds merit in them, he may take action accordingly by invoking his powers Under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or Section 165 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. In this regard, we agree with the observations made by the Tripura High Court in Smt. Uma Saha v. State of Tripura (supra) that the victim's counsel has a limited right of assisting the prosecution, which may extend to suggesting questions to the Court or the prosecution, but not putting them by himself.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1727 of 2019 

Decided On: 20.11.2019

 Rekha Murarka  Vs.  The State of West Bengal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Mohan M. Shantanagoudar and Deepak Gupta, JJ.

Citation: (2020) 2 SCC474,AIR 2020 SC 100

Print Page

Wednesday, 23 May 2018

Whether Independent Prosecution By De Facto Complainant is Permissible In Sessions Case?

Learned counsel appearing for both the parties in
the matter submit that the impugned order cannot be
sustained in view of the scheme provided in the proviso to
Section 24(8) of the Cr.PC and in light of the decision
of this Court in Shiv Kumar v. Hukam Chand & Anr. [(1999)
7 SCC 467] and Dhariwal Industries Ltd. vs. Kishore
Wadhwani & Ors. [(2016) 10 SCC 378].
The impugned judgment is accordingly set aside in
light of the aforementioned decisions.

 S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A
 RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No(s).2240/2018

THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF
HYDERABAD FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AND THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH PETITIONER(S)
 VERSUS
MAHABUNISA BEGUM & ORS. RESPONDENT(S)
Date : 14-05-2018 This petition was called on for hearing today.
CORAM :
 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE J. CHELAMESWAR
 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KISHAN KAUL


Print Page

Wednesday, 6 July 2016

Whether private counsel can be permitted to conduct trial in session court?

“13. From the scheme of the Code the legislative
intention is manifestly clear that prosecution in a
Sessions Court cannot be conducted by anyone
other than the Public Prosecutor. The legislature
reminds the State that the policy must strictly
conform to fairness in the trial of an accused in a
Sessions Court. A Public Prosecutor is not
expected to show a thirst to reach the case in the
conviction of the accused somehow or the other
irrespective of the true facts involved in the case.
The expected attitude of the Public Prosecutor
while conducting prosecution must be couched in
fairness not only to the court and to the
investigating agencies but to the accused as well.
If an accused is entitled to any legitimate benefit
during trial the Public Prosecutor should not
scuttle/conceal it. On the contrary, it is the duty
of the Public Prosecutor to winch it to the fore
and make it available to the accused. Even if the
defence counsel overlooked it, the Public
Prosecutor has the added responsibility to bring
it to the notice of the court if it comes to his
knowledge. A private counsel, if allowed a free
hand to conduct prosecution would focus on
bringing the case to conviction even if it is not a
fit case to be so convicted. That is the reason why
Parliament applied a bridle on him and subjected
his role strictly to the instructions given by the
Public Prosecutor.
14. It is not merely an overall supervision which
the Public Prosecutor is expected to perform in
such cases when a privately engaged counsel is
permitted to act on his behalf. The role which a
private counsel in such a situation can play is,
perhaps, comparable with that of a junior
advocate conducting the case of his senior in a
court. The private counsel is to act on behalf of
the Public Prosecutor albeit the fact that he is
engaged in the case by a private party. If the role
of the Public Prosecutor is allowed to shrink to a
mere supervisory role the trial would become a
combat between the private party and the
accused which would render the legislative
mandate in Section 225 of the Code a dead
letter.”
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.131 of 2016

Anant Prakash Sinha @ Anant Sinha Vs State of Haryana 

Citation:(2016) 6 SCC105
Dipak Misra, J.
Dated:March, 4, 2016

Print Page

Saturday, 31 October 2015

When magistrate can permit private counsel to assist Public Prosecutor in conduct of prosecution as per S 302 of crpc?

Under Section 301, a Pleader en-gaged by a private person can assist the Public Prosecutor or the Assistant Pub-lie Prosecutor as the case may be in the conduct of the prosecution while under Section 302 the Magistrate may permit the prosecution itself to be conducted by any person or by a pleader instructed by him. The distinction is when permission under Section 302 is given the Public Prosecutor or the Assistant Public Prosecutor as the case may be disappears from the scene and the pleader engaged by the person who will invariably be the de facto complainant will be in full charge of the prosecution. The question is even if the Magistrate has got the discretion to grant the permission is it to be granted as a matter of course? There is an ocean of difference between assisting the Public Prosecutor under Section 301 and conducting the prosecution on the basis of a permission granted under Section 302. Public Prosecutors are really ministers of justice whose job is none other than assisting the State in the administration of justice. They are not representatives of any party. Their job is to assist the court by placing before the court all relevant aspects of the case. They are not there to see the innocents go to the gallows. They are also not there to see the culprits escape a conviction. But the Pleader engaged by a private person who is a de facto complainant cannot be (expected to be so impartial. Not only that it will be his endeavour to get a conviction even if a conviction may not be possible. So the real assistance that a Public Prosecutor is expected to render will not be there if a pleader engaged by a private person is allowed to take the role of a public prosecutor by granting permission under Section 302 of the Code. This does not mean that permission cannot at all be granted under Section 302. Under very exceptional circumstances permission can be granted under Section 302. Otherwise, there is no reason why the provision is there in the Code. But that is to be done only in cases where the circumstances are such that a denial of permission under Section 302 will stand in the way of meeting out, justice in the case. A mere apprehension of a party that the Public Prosecutor will not be serious in conducting the prosecution simply because a conviction or an acquittal in the case will affect another case pending will not by itself be enough. At the same time, if the apprehension of the party is going to materialise the court can pending the trial, grant permission under Section 302 even if a request for permission was rejected at the outset.

Equivalent Citation: 1984CriLJ499, 1984KLJ92
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
Decided On: 04.01.1984
Appellants: Babu
Vs.
Respondent: State of Kerala
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K.K. Narendran and M. Fathima Beevi, JJ.
Print Page

Friday, 14 February 2014

Whether private counsel can be permitted to conduct trial in Session cases?

As we are in complete agreement with the observation of a Division Bench of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Medichetty Ramakistiah & ors. v. The State of Andhra Pradesh (AIR 1959 A.P. 659) we deem it fit to extract the said observation: A prosecution, to use a familiar phrase, ought not to be a persecution. The principle that the Public Prosecutor should be scrupulously fair to the accused and present his case with detachment and without evincing any anxiety to secure a conviction, is based upon high policy and as such courts should be astute to suffer no inroad upon its integrity. Otherwise there will be no guarantee that the trial will be as fair to the accused as a criminal trial ought to be. The State and the Public Prosecutor acting for it are only supposed to be putting all the facts of the case before the Court to obtain its decision thereon and not to obtain a conviction by any means fair or foul. Therefore, it is right and proper that courts should be zealous to see that the prosecution of an offender is not handed over completely to a professional gentleman instructed by a private party.1

Supreme Court of India
Shiv Kumar vs Hukam Chand And Anr on 30 August, 1999
Bench: S.P.Kurdukar, K.T.Thomas, N Hegde
Citation: 1999 (7) SCC 467
Print Page