Showing posts with label precept. Show all posts
Showing posts with label precept. Show all posts

Wednesday, 8 April 2020

Whether application for sending precept to the collector for the partition of agricultural land is maintainable after 45 years of the passing of decree?

The present decree for partition of agricultural lands paying revenue to the Government, though was passed on 9-1-1947 and the said decree was affirmed in appeal on 2-1-1948 and it was directed in the said decree that the precept will be issued to the Collector on an application by the plaintiff and such application having been made on 15-2-1992 i.e. almost after 45 years of the passing of the decree, such an application for issuance of the precept to the Collector for partition of the lands, is neither barred by any period of limitation nor prohibited under any law. There being no law prohibiting the partition of the property assessed to payment of land revenue after a fixed period of limitation, the applicant could not have been deprived of his rights in having the partition decree dated 9-1-1947 effected through the Collector. Merely because the application for issuance of the precept has been made almost after 45 years of the passing of the decree for partition of the agricultural lands assessed to the payment of land revenue, such an application could not have been dismissed by Court below by applying the principle that law always helps those persons' who are vigilant about their rights and not those who have slept over their rights. No such principle of equity can be made applicable when law of Limitation does not bar making of such an application beyond any period. The Law of Limitation has to be read, as provided in the statute, and it does not spring from the common law of the country or principle of equity. As already observed above, the application filed by the applicant for issuance of precept to the Collector for effecting partition of the decree passed on 9-1-1947 relating to agricultural lands assessed to land revenue, being not an application for execution of a decree, was neither covered under Section 48 of the C.P.C. as was existing prior to 1-1-1964 nor Art. 182 of the Limitation Act, 1908 or any other article of the Limitation Act, 1908, or any of the provisions contained in the Limitation Act, 1963 and, therefore, the Court below committed serious error of law and jurisdiction in dismissing the application filed by the applicant on 15-2-1992 for issuance of the precept to the concerned Collector for effecting partition of the agricultural lands assessed to land revenue, mentioned in Schedule 'A' of the said decree.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT NAGPUR

Civil Revn. Appln. No. 1214 of 1992

Decided On: 17.04.1995

Ramrathibai Vs. Surajpal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M. Lodha, J.

Citations: AIR 1995 Bom 445, 1995 (4) BomCR 665, 1996 (2) MhLj 40
Print Page

Sunday, 3 June 2018

Notes on execution of decree- part 1


S 36.Provisions of this code relating to execution of decree are applicable to execution of orders.

S 37. Definition of court which passed a decree:-
a) Decree passed by appellate court,the court of first instance.
b) Court of first instance ceased to exist,the court having jurisdiction to try said suit.

S 38. Court by which decree may be executed:-
A decree may be executed either by the court which passed it,or by court to which it is sent for execution.

Read important judgments on execution of decree:
Click here

S 39. Transfer of decree:-
1) Court which passed a decree may on the application of decree holder sent it for execution to another court of competent jurisdiction-
a) if the person against whom decree is passed is residing or working within the jurisdiction of that court.
b) if such person has no property within the local limits of jurisdiction of the court which passed the decree sufficient to satisfy such decree and has property within the local limit of jurisdiction of such other court,or
c) if the decree directs the sale or delivery of immovable property situate outside the local limits of jurisdiction of the court which passed it,or
d) if the court which passed the decree considers for any other reason,which it shall record in writing, that the decree should be executed by such other court.
Print Page

Sunday, 13 May 2018

Basic concepts of CPC 4 -definitions

Commission

Commission refers to an authority which is appointed to exercise a power or direction issued by court,when for instance a witness is unable to attend court on account of his illness or other similar reasons, the court can order such a witness to be examined on commission.
Under S 75 of CPC, commission can be issued by court for several purposes, as for instance to examine witnesses, to make a local investigation, to adjust accounts, to make a partition and so on.

Letter of request/Rogatory letter

A letter of request or rogatory letter is a letter issued by a court of one country to a court in a foreign country requesting for some judicial assistance from Judiciary of that country. Such assistance may be in the form of request to serve a summons or to take evidence of specified person.
Print Page

Friday, 9 May 2014

Collector is duty bound to act upon precept of partition issued by court



In view of the limited grievance of the petitioner, I am inclined to allow the petition. The respondent No. 1-Collector, Beed, is directed to take necessary steps in furtherance of the precept received by him to effect partition as per the decree passed in Regular Civil Suit No. 44/1992 on 30-6-1995. The respondent No. 1-Collector, Beed, is further directed to take immediate steps as per the precept and hand over the possession of the property to the petitioner to which she is entitled, within a period of six months from today.


BOMBAY HIGH COURT

Sindhu W/o Machindra Jagtap Vs. Collector and Anr.

Court : Mumbai
Reported in : 2007(3)BomCR133; 2007(4)MhLj180
Judge : B.R. Gavai, J.

Decided On : Mar-14-2007
Acts : Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) , 1908 - Sections 54
Citation;2007(4)MHLJ 216 Bom
Print Page

Basic concept of precept under S 46 of CPC


 It appears that the decree holder as well as the objector Company are proceeding on the assumption that the order dated 18th December, 2010 passed by Himachal Pradesh High Court directing issuance of a precept amounted an attachment order. That, however, is not the correct position in law. A precept under Section 46 CPC is only a request of a Court passing the decree to another Court where the decree holder intends to initiate execution proceedings because of the judgment debtor having attachable properties within the jurisdiction of the Court to which decree is transferred under Order XXI Rule 6 CPC. Upon receipt of the precept the transferee Court has to attach the property in respect of which precept is received by it and even that attachment remains in force for a period of two months unless that attachment is extended by the Court which had passed the decree. This is provided in Section 46 CPC itself.


DELHI HIGH COURT

KARAM CHAND Vs. HARWINDER SINGH



Decided On : Sep-09-2013
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.K.BHASIN

Print Page

Friday, 24 August 2012

Object of issuance of precept as per s.46 of cpc for execution of decree

The object of a precept is to enable a decree-holder to obtain interim attachment where there is ground to apprehend that he may otherwise be deprived of the fruits of his decree. Section 46 expressly provides that, upon the application of the decree-holder, the Court, which passed the decree, may, whenever it thinks fit, issue a precept to any other Court, which would be competent to execute such decree, to attach any property belonging to the judgment-debtor and specified in the precept: and the Court, to which a precept is so sent, shall proceed to attach the property in the manner prescribed in regard to the attachment of property in execution of a decree, this provision plainly indicates that the Legislature did not intend that a Court should directly attach property beyond tile local limits, of its jurisdiction. It has been argued, in the second place, that, if the contention of the petitioners prevails, two separate orders would be required in respect of the same matter: that is, an order by the Court, which passed the decree, upon the judgment-debtor prohibiting him from recovering the debt, and an order by the Court, to which the decree has been transferred for execution, upon the debtor of the judgment-debtor prohibiting him from making payment thereof. This, in substance, was the argument which found favour with the learned Judges who decided the case of In re Hollick (1868) 2 B.L.R. 108 : 10 W.R. 447. I do not feel pressed by the weight of this contention. The course suggested does not lead to any serious inconvenience. On the other hand, if the prohibitory order is issued by the Court which made the decree, to a person beyond the local limits of its jurisdiction, the order may prove infructuous, if it is disobeyed, and the Court may find itself powerless to enforce it.
Calcutta High Court
Begg, Dunlop And Co. vs Jagannath Marwari on 28 June, 1911
Equivalent citations: (1912) ILR 39 Cal 104
Author: Mookerjee
Bench: Mookerjee, Carnduff
Print Page