Showing posts with label attachment before judgment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label attachment before judgment. Show all posts

Monday, 27 April 2026

Explain provisions of Civil Procedure code regarding attachment before judgment

 Attachment before judgment is an extraordinary protective remedy under Order 38 Rules 5 to 13 CPC to stop the defendant from defeating the future decree by disposing of or removing property.

For a Judicial service interview, your 30-second answer should focus on object, conditions, procedure, and effect.

30-second answer

Print Page

Saturday, 7 September 2024

What are essential pre-requisite conditions the court should consider before passing the order of attachment before judgment?

14. Perusal of the law relevant for the purpose as contained in Rule 5 of Order 38 of the Code, is felt relevant. Therefore, the said provision is quoted hereinabove:--

"Attachment before Judgment

R. 5. Where defendant may be called upon to furnish security for production of property.-- (1) Where, at any stage of a suit, the Court is satisfied, by affidavit, or otherwise, that the defendant, with intent to obstruct or delay the execution of any decree that may be passed against him,--


(a) is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property; or


(b) is about to remove the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court,


the Court may direct the defendant, within a time to be fixed by it, either to furnish security, in such sum as may be specified in the order, to produce and place at the disposal of the Court, when required, the said property or the value of the same, or such portion thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the decree, or to appear and show cause why he should not furnish security.


(2) The plaintiff shall, unless the Court otherwise directs, specify the property required to be attached and the estimated value thereof.


(3) The Court may also in the order direct the conditional attachment of the whole or any portion of the property so specified.


(4) If an order of attachment is made without complying with the provisions of Sub-rule (1) of this rule, such attachment shall be void." {Para 14}

15. The said Rule 5 is under the heading Attachment before judgment. It appears from the said provision that Court was entitled to exercise the power for attachment before judgment only when the defendant with intent to obstruct or delay the execution of any decree that may be passed against him, is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court. It appears from the impugned order that the said aspects were not at all taken into consideration and no satisfaction in that respect was recorded by the trial Court as appears from the impugned order. Law in this regard as settled in the case of Premraj Mundra (supra) is relevant and in paragraph 10 of the said judgment, guiding principles have been noted as follows :--


"10. From a perusal of all the authorities, I think that the following guiding principles to be deduced :


(1) That an order under Order 38 Rules 5 & 6, can only be issued, if circumstances, exist as are stated therein.


(2) Whether such circumstances exist is a question of fact that must be proved to the satisfaction of the Court.


(3) That the Court would not be justified in issuing an order for attachment before judgment, or for security, merely because it thinks that no harm would be done thereby or that the defts. would not be prejudiced.


(4) That the affidavits in support of the contention of the applicant, must not be vague, & must be properly verified. Where it is affirmed true to knowledge or information or belief, it must be stated as to which portion is true to knowledge the source of information should be disclosed, and the grounds for belief should be stated.


(5) That a mere allegation that the deft. was selling off his properties is not sufficient. Particulars must be stated.


(6) There is no rule that transaction before suit cannot be taken into consideration, but the subject of attachment before judgment must be to prevent future transfer or alienation.


(7) Where only a small portion of the property belonging to the deft, is being disposed of, no inference can be drawn in the absence of other circumstances that the alienation is necessarily to defraud or delay the pltf.'s claim.


(8) That the mere fact of transfer is not enough, since nobody can be prevented from dealing with his properties simply because a suit has been filed; There must be additional circumstances to show that the transferrer is with an intention to delay or defeat the plft.'s claim. It is open to the Court to look to the conduct of the parties immediately before suit, and to examine the surrounding circumstances, and to draw an inference as to whether the deft, is about to dispose of the property, and if so, with what intention. The Court is entitled to consider the nature of the claim and the defence put forward.


(9) The fact that the deft, is in insolvent circumstances or in acute financial embarrassment is a relevant circumstance, but not by itself sufficient.


(10) That in the case of running businesses, the strictest caution is necessary and the mere fact that a business has been closed, or that its turnover had diminished, is not enough.


(11) Where however the deft, starts disposing of his properties one by one, immediately upon getting a notice of the plft.'s claim, and/or where he had transferred the major portion of his properties shortly prior to the institution of the suit, and was in an embarrassed financial condition, these were grounds from which an inference could be legitimately drawn that the object of the deft. was to delay and defeat the plft.'s claim.


(12) Mere removal of properties outside jurisdiction, is not enough, but where the deft. with notice of the plft.'s. claim, suddenly begins removal of his properties outside the Jurisdiction of the appropriate Court, and without any other satisfactory reason, an adverse inference may be drawn against the deft. where the removal is to a foreign country, the Inference is greatly strengthened.


(13) The deft. in a suit is under no liability to take any special care in administering his affairs, simply because there is a claim pending against him. Here neglect, or suffering execution by other creditors, is not a sufficient reason for an order under Order 38 of the Code.


(14) The sale of properties at a gross undervalue, or benami transfers, are always good indications of an intention to defeat the plft.'s claim. The Court must however be very cautious about, the evidence on these points and not rely on vague allegations."

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA

R.M.A.T. No. 1388 of 2003

Decided On: 16.07.2003

R.B.M. Pati Joint Venture Vs. Bengal Builders

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

A. Chakrabarti and Sadhan Kumar Gupta, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2004 Calcutta 58,(2003) CALHN 569, MANU/WB/0220/2003.

Print Page

Tuesday, 2 January 2024

Whether S 10 of CPC relating to stay of suit bars the court to entertain subsequent suit and to pass interlocutory orders in that suit?

By virtue of Section 10 Code of Civil Procedure, a Court is prohibited from proceeding with trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit, of course, subject to other conditions mentioned therein. This Court has explained that the object of the prohibition contained in Section 10 Code of Civil Procedure is to prevent the Courts of concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously trying two parallel suits and to avoid inconsistent findings. However, this Rule of procedure is held not affecting the jurisdiction of the Court to entertain and deal with the latter suit and does not create a bar to the institution of the suit. The Courts have also consistently held that Section 10 Code of Civil Procedure does not create a bar to the passing of interlocutory orders including those of injunction. These principles are succinctly summarised by this Court in the case of Indian Bank v. Maharashtra State Cooperative Marketing Federation Ltd. MANU/SC/0350/1998 : (1998) 5 SCC 69. Therein, this Court was, of course, considering the applicability of bar Under Section 10 to summary suit Under Order XXXVII of Code of Civil Procedure but, while explaining the connotation of the expression "trial" in Section 10 Code of Civil Procedure, observed as under: {Para 17}


8. Therefore, the word "trial" in Section 10 will have to be interpreted and construed keeping in mind the object and nature of that provision and the prohibition to "proceed with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit". The object of the prohibition contained in Section 10 is to prevent the courts of concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously trying two parallel suits and also to avoid inconsistent findings on the matters in issue. The provision is in the nature of a Rule of procedure and does not affect the jurisdiction of the court to entertain and deal with the latter suit nor does it create any substantive right in the matters. It is not a bar to the institution of a suit. It has been construed by the courts as not a bar to the passing of interlocutory orders such as an order for consolidation of the latter suit with the earlier suit, or appointment of a receiver or an injunction or attachment before judgment. The course of action which the court has to follow according to Section 10 is not to proceed with the "trial" of the suit but that does not mean that it cannot deal with the subsequent suit any more or for any other purpose. In view of the object and nature of the provision and the fairly settled legal position with respect to passing of interlocutory orders it has to be stated that the word "trial" in Section 10 is not used in its widest sense.


18. The above principles of law, with necessary variations, when applied to the present case, lead to the position that even if final determination of the question of maintainability (in case the constitutional validity of the impugned provision is to be decided) may depend upon the decision of Larger Bench, the supplemental proceedings in the present suit, particularly those relating to the prayer of interim relief, cannot be put on hold.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Original Suit No. 1 of 2021

Decided On: 11.05.2023

State of Meghalaya Vs. Union of India (UOI) and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dinesh Maheshwari and P.V. Sanjay Kumar, JJ.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0559/2023.

Print Page

Thursday, 30 November 2023

What is the basic concept and procedure for attachment before judgment as per provisions of Civil procedure Code?

 Attachment before judgment

O 38 R 5. Where defendant may be called upon to furnish security for production of property.—(1) Where at any stage of a suit, the Court is satisfied, by affidavit or otherwise, that the defendant, with intent to obstruct or delay the execution of any decree that may be passed against him,—

(a) is about to dispose of the whole or any part of his property, or

(b) is about to remove the whole or any part of his property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court,

the Court may direct the defendant, within a time to be fixed by it, either to furnish security, in such sum as may be specified in the order, to produce and place at the disposal of the Court, when required, the said property or the value of the same, or such portion thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the decree, or to appear and show cause why he should not furnish security.

(2) The plaintiff shall, unless the Court otherwise directs, specify the property required to be attached and the estimated value thereof.

(3) The Court may also in the order direct the conditional attachment of the whole or any portion of the property so specified.

[(4) If an order of attachment is made without complying with the provisions of sub-rule (1) of this rule, such attachment shall be void.]

Print Page

Sunday, 3 April 2022

What are parameters for exercise of power of attachment of property of defendant before Judgment?

  In so far as I.A. No.11829/2021 is concerned, the law with regard to the provisions of Order XXXVIII Rule 5 of the CPC has been settled by the Supreme Court judgment in Raman Tech. & Process Engg. Co. & Anr. Vs. Solanki Traders, (2008) 2 SCC 302, as below:-

“5. The power under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC is a drastic and extraordinary power. Such power should not be exercised mechanically or merely for the asking. It should be used sparingly and strictly in accordance with the Rule. The purpose of Order 38 Rule 5 is not to convert an unsecured debt into a secured debt. Any attempt by a plaintiff to utilise the provisions of Order 38 Rule 5 as a leverage for coercing the defendant to settle the suit claim should be discouraged. Instances are not wanting where bloated and doubtful claims are realised by unscrupulous plaintiffs by obtaining orders of attachment before judgment and forcing the defendants for out-of-court settlements under threat of attachment.

6. A defendant is not debarred from dealing with his property merely because a suit is filed or about to be filed against him. Shifting of business from one premises to another premises or removal of machinery to another premises by itself is not a ground for granting attachment before judgment. A plaintiff should show, prima facie, that his claim is bona fide and valid and also satisfy the court that the defendant is about to remove or dispose of the whole or part of his property, with the intention of obstructing or delaying the execution of any decree that may be passed against him, before power is exercised under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC. Courts should also keep in view the principles relating to grant of attachment before judgment. (See Premraj Mundra v. Md. Manech Gazi [AIR 1951 Cal 156] for a clear summary of the principles.)”

21. The Supreme Court has observed as aforesaid that the provisions of Order XXXVIII Rule 5 of the CPC have to be used sparingly and that the plaintiff has to satisfy the Court that the defendant is seeking to remove or dispose of whole or part of his property with the intention of obstructing or delaying the execution of the decree that may be passed against him.

22. In M/s. K. C. V. Airways Ltd. & Anr. Vs. Wg. Cor. R. K. Blaggana, AIR 1998 Delhi 70, a Division Bench of this Court held that the power of the Court under Order XXXVIII Rule 5 of the CPC is an extraordinary remedy. Reference in this regard may be made to paragraph 8 of the judgment:

“8. Needless to say, that R. 5 of O. XXXVIII, CPC is an extra ordinary remedy and if the ingredients for invoking it are lacking in the application and the affidavit filed in support thereto attachment before judgment order cannot be ordered claim for attachment before judgment on the averments has been mainly set out in paras 7 and 8 reproduced above of the application in question and a bare reading thereof reveals, that it was not pleaded therein that the appellants with intent to obstruct or delay the execution of the decree that may be passed against them (a) are about to dispose of the whole or any part of the property, or (b) are about to remove the whole or any part of the property from the local limits of the jurisdiction of this Court. Affidavit filed along with the application contains no statement except an assertion that the respondent has gone through the application and the facts stated therein are correct to the best of his knowledge and information received. That be so, on the basis of the averments as they stand made in the application and the affidavit in question the appellant could not have been legally asked to furnish security in the sum of Rs. 8,50 lacs.”

23. Furthermore, the application filed on behalf of the plaintiff is bereft of any details as to how relief under Order XXXVIII Rule 5 of the CPC can be granted in her favour as there are no material particulars pleaded in this regard. Such power cannot not be exercised by this Court mechanically or merely for the asking of the plaintiff.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

CS(OS) 437/2021

VANDANA VERMA Vs ROOP SINGH & ORS.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL

 Date of decision: 24th March, 2022.

Print Page

Thursday, 28 April 2016

Whether Advocate can get order of attachment before judgment for recovery of professional fees?

 I find from application Exhibit5
and the order impugned that
besides the averments and submission of statistical data below paragraph
11 in the suit, there was no shred of evidence in the form of documents
before the Trial Court which could have convinced it to grant the said
application. There was no material before the Trial Court to prima facie
conclude that the Respondent was liable to pay the amount as claimed by
the Petitioner. It cannot be overlooked that the Respondent is an
agriculturist and the amount at issue is compensation that is to be paid to
him on account of acquisition of his land.

23 The Apex Court, in the matter of Raman Tech and Process
Engineering v/s Solanki Traders (supra), has concluded that the object of
Order 38 Rule 5 is to prevent any Defendant from defeating the
realization of the decree that may ultimately be passed in favour of the
Plaintiff by attempting to dispose of or alienate his property or remove the
movables. Paragraphs 4 and 5 of the said judgment read as under:“
4. The object of supplemental proceedings
(applications for arrest or attachment before
judgment, grant of temporary injunctions and
appointment of receivers) is to prevent the ends of
justice being defeated. The object of order 38 rule 5
CPC in particular, is to prevent any defendant from
defeating the realization of the decree that may
ultimately be passed in favour of the plaintiff, either
by attempting to dispose of, or remove from the
jurisdiction of the court, his movables. The Scheme
of Order 38 and the use of the words `to obstruct or
delay the execution of any decree that may be
passed against him' in Rule 5 make it clear that
before exercising the power under the said Rule, the
court should be satisfied that there is a reasonable
chance of a decree being passed in the suit against
the defendant. This would mean that the court
should be satisfied the plaintiff has a prima facie
case. If the averments in the plaint and the
documents produced in support of it, do not satisfy
the court about the existence of a prima facie case,
the court will not go to the next stage of examining
whether the interest of the plaintiff should be
protected by exercising power under Order 38 Rule
5CPC. It is wellsettled
that merely having a just or
valid claim or a prima facie case, will not entitle the
plaintiff to an order of attachment before judgment,
unless he also establishes that the defendant is
attempting to remove or dispose of his assets with

the intention of defeating the decree that may be
passed. Equally well settled is the position that even
where the defendant is removing or disposing his
assets, an attachment before judgment will not be
issued, if the plaintiff is not able to satisfy that he
has a prima facie case.
5. The power under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC is drastic and
extraordinary power. Such power should not be
exercised mechanically or merely for the asking. It
should be used sparingly and strictly in accordance
with the Rule. The purpose of Order 38 Rule 5 is not
to convert an unsecured debt into a secured debt.
Any attempt by a plaintiff to utilize the provisions of
Order 38 Rule 5 as a leverage for coercing the
defendant to settle the suit claim should be
discouraged. Instances are not wanting where
bloated and doubtful claims are realised by
unscrupulous plaintiffs by obtaining orders of
attachment before judgment and forcing the
defendants for out of court settlement, under threat
of attachment.”
(emphasis is mine)
24 It, therefore, has to be borne in mind that Order 38 Rule 5 is
not to be exercised mechanically and casually. It is that power which has
to be exercised sparingly and so to say in the rarest of rare case where the
intended object of the Defendant is prima facie visible in frustrating the
claim of the Plaintiff. In the instant case, besides the admission of the Respondent that an amount of Rs.15,000/is to be paid by way of
professional fees, the details put forth by the Petitioner/ Plaintiff below paragraph 11 in the suit, prima facie appear to be a mere statistical data, unsupported and unsubstantiated by any document.

25 In the light of the above, I do not find that the impugned
order could be termed as being perverse or erroneous so as to cause an
interference.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.9591 OF 2015

Annarao s/o Govindrao Patil, V Dnyanobas/o Vithal Bade,

CORAM: RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J.
DATE :22ndSeptember, 2015
Citation;2016(2) ALLMR110
Print Page

Monday, 1 June 2015

Whether surety who is defendant can obtain attachment before judgment and Injunction against principal debtor to protect his own interest?

In view of the aforesaid observations, and especially in view of the provisions of Order 38, Rule 5 read with sections 94(b) & (e) and 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in order to protect the interest of the surety and in view of the peculiar circumstances of the facts in the present matter, I am of the opinion that the present applicant, who is the surety, is entitled to apply under Order 38, Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure for attachment of the property of the principal debtor, i.e., the present non-applicant No. 1 before judgment, or even he can apply under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 read with sections 94 and 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, to protect his interest and in the ends of justice.
Bombay High Court
Jugalkishore Rampratapji Rathi vs Brijmohan S/O Rampratapji Rathi ... on 10 November, 1992
Equivalent citations: 1994 (2) BomCR 537

Bench: S Mutalik


Print Page

Sunday, 10 November 2013

Under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC, Court can attach debts due to defendant from third party.


The above noticed provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 60 read with the provisions of Rule 7 and 8 of Order 38 CPC clearly shows that even the debts due to the defendants/judgment-debtor from third party falls within the purview of Order 38 Rule 5 CPC and therefore such a debt could be attached under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC. Unfortunately, the provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 60, Rule 7 and 8 of Order 38 CPC were not brought to the notice of the learned Judge in J.Balakrishna's case (supra 1). Therefore, with great respect, we are not persuaded to accept the opinion of the learned Judge as correct law.
The further opinion of the learned Judge in J.Balakrishna's case (supra 1) that the attachment before judgment could be ordered only against the defendant and cannot be ordered against the third party, in my considered opinion, does not seem to be correct proposition of law.
Order 38 Rule 7 CPC provides that the attachment under Order 38 Rule 5 shall be made in the manner provided in the attachment of property in execution decree. It is trite, the attachment envisaged under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC is an attachment before judgment. The restriction found by the learned single Judge that under Order 38 Rule 5, only the properties of the defendant can be attached and not the properties in the hands of garnishee has no statutory support nor the support of any precedent. In Alwar Aiyangar's case (supra 2), the question as to whether a Court attaching a debt either before judgment or in execution can enquire into the truth or the existence of the debt arose. Curgenven,J, speaking for the Madras High Court was pleased to observe : "The attachment in the present instance was made before judgment on an application filed on the same day as the plaint. But I cannot find that it makes any difference whether such an attachment was made before judgment or in execution of the decree, and it appears to me that Rr.7 and 8, O.38, Civil P.C., show that the Court has the same powers in the one case as the other."
The above observation of Curgenven,J also supports our view in a way. Therefore, we hold that in exercise of the power, under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC, the Court can attach the debts due to the defendant from a third party. The attachment of debts due to the defendant from third party could be attached before judgment under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC. In that view of the matter, we hold that the opinion of the learned single Judge in J.Balakrishna's case (supra 1) is not good law and it is accordingly overruled.

Andhra High Court
Surender Singh Bajaj vs M/S.Kitty Steels Limited And ... on 22 April, 2002

Print Page

Whether order of attachment before judgment would be operative even after the decree is passed?

An order to furnish security to produce any property belonging to a defendant and to place the same at the disposal of the Court or order the attachment of any property as also grant of a temporary injunction or appointment of a receiver are supplemental in nature. The effect of such order may be felt even after decree is passed. An order of attachment passed under Order 38 of the Code of Civil Procedure would be operative even after the decree is passed. Such an order of attachment passed under Order 38 can be taken benefit of by the decree holder even after a decree is passed. An order of temporary injunction passed in a suit either may merge with a decree of permanent injunction or may have an effect even if a decree is passed, as, for example, for the purpose of determination as regard the status of the parties violating the order of injunction or the right of a transferee whom have purchased the property in disobedience of the order of injunction. The orders passed in supplemental proceedings may have to be treated distinctly as opposed to an order which is ancillary in nature or which has been passed in the incidental proceedings.

Supreme Court of India
Vareed Jacob vs Sosamma Geevarghese & Ors on 21 April, 2004
Bench: S.B. Sinha.
Print Page

Tuesday, 5 November 2013

Why court should pass order for attachment of property before judgment?


The object behind the order levying an attachment before judgment is to give an assurance to the plaintiff that his decree, if made, would be satisfied. Where an attachment has been made, any private transfer or delivery of the property attached would be void as against all claims enforceable under the attachment. What is claimed enforceable is claim for which the decree is made. A dismissal of the suit may terminate the attachment and would not be revived even if the suit is restored As a corollary, if attachment before judgment is obtained in a suit which ends in a decree but if in appeal the decree is set aside, the attachment of necessity must fall. It at an intermediate stage pursuant to the decree of the trial Court the attached property is sold at a Court auction and where an appeal is preferred, an attempt should be made to obtain stay of the execution of the decree of the trial court. If the execution proceeds and the property is

sold at a court auction before the appeal is disposed of, the equity in favour of a person as a auction purchaser may come into existence. In such a case if the auction purchaser is an outsider and if the execution of the decree was not stayed, the auction purchaser would be protected even if the decree in execution of which the auction sale had been held is set aside because the equity in favour of the stranger should be protected. 1

Supreme Court of India
Sardar Govindrao Mahadik & Anr vs Devi Sahai & Ors on 15 December, 1981
Equivalent citations: 1982 AIR 989, 1982 SCR (2) 186
Bench: Desai, D.A.

Print Page

Friday, 24 August 2012

Object of issuance of precept as per s.46 of cpc for execution of decree

The object of a precept is to enable a decree-holder to obtain interim attachment where there is ground to apprehend that he may otherwise be deprived of the fruits of his decree. Section 46 expressly provides that, upon the application of the decree-holder, the Court, which passed the decree, may, whenever it thinks fit, issue a precept to any other Court, which would be competent to execute such decree, to attach any property belonging to the judgment-debtor and specified in the precept: and the Court, to which a precept is so sent, shall proceed to attach the property in the manner prescribed in regard to the attachment of property in execution of a decree, this provision plainly indicates that the Legislature did not intend that a Court should directly attach property beyond tile local limits, of its jurisdiction. It has been argued, in the second place, that, if the contention of the petitioners prevails, two separate orders would be required in respect of the same matter: that is, an order by the Court, which passed the decree, upon the judgment-debtor prohibiting him from recovering the debt, and an order by the Court, to which the decree has been transferred for execution, upon the debtor of the judgment-debtor prohibiting him from making payment thereof. This, in substance, was the argument which found favour with the learned Judges who decided the case of In re Hollick (1868) 2 B.L.R. 108 : 10 W.R. 447. I do not feel pressed by the weight of this contention. The course suggested does not lead to any serious inconvenience. On the other hand, if the prohibitory order is issued by the Court which made the decree, to a person beyond the local limits of its jurisdiction, the order may prove infructuous, if it is disobeyed, and the Court may find itself powerless to enforce it.
Calcutta High Court
Begg, Dunlop And Co. vs Jagannath Marwari on 28 June, 1911
Equivalent citations: (1912) ILR 39 Cal 104
Author: Mookerjee
Bench: Mookerjee, Carnduff
Print Page