Showing posts with label presumption of future continuance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label presumption of future continuance. Show all posts

Sunday, 20 November 2016

What is presumption of continuity of possession of property?


The issue that then arises is as to what is the consequence of the minor dying in such situation -- does the factum of the actual or notional possession of the estate of the legal guardian evaporate in the thin air with the fast breath of the minor? I do not think so. No such fiction can be exercised. There is a settled general rule that if a person is specifically found in possession of an estate at a prior date, there is a presumption of continuity of such possession till the contrary is established. This general rule of law is too well settled to admit of any doubt. Yet, within this jurisdiction, if a precedent was needed, it is first available in the authoritative decision of the Full Bench of this Court in Shiva Prasad Singh v. Hira Singh MANU/BH/0148/1921, and again reiterated in Ghoghar Raut v. Jagannath Prasad Singh MANU/BH/0178/1947, in the following terms : --
"The decision can only be based on the general rule of evidence in favour of presuming the continuity of things shown to exist at a prior date. It is certainly a plausible argument that if the plaintiff has shown that he was in possession in 1896, he must be presumed to have continued in possession, unless and until his dispossession is proved by the defendants. But the presumption in question is a general presumption. It would equally apply, no matter what the evidence on which the plaintiff relied to prove his possession in 1896."
15. It is somewhat plain on both authority and general principle that with regard to a legal guardian in possession of the estate of the minor, there would be a presumption of the continuity of possession after the death of the minor till it has been shown otherwise that he was dispossessed thereof.
Citation : AIR 1987 Pat 239
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA
FULL BENCH
Letters Patent Appeal No. 42 of 1982
Decided On: 29.09.1986
Sudama Devi and Ors.
Vs.
Jogendra Choudhary and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.S. Sandhawalia , C.J., L.M. Sharma and S. Ali Ahmad , JJ.
Print Page

What is presumption of future continuance?

 The survey records of 1892, 1895, 1904 and 1909 disclose that the ancestors of the plaintiffs held some of the frontier plots of Dubha Mal. The High Court was, therefore, asked to draw the inference that their ancestors held those plots during 1845 to 1863 when the Taufir lands accreted. The question is whether such an inference should be drawn. Now, if a thing or a state of things is shown to exist, an inference of its continuity within a reasonably proximate time both forwards and backwards may sometimes be drawn. The presumption of future continuance is noticed hi Illustration (d) to s. 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. In appropriate cases, an inference of the continuity of a thing or state of things backwards may be drawn under this section, though on this point the section does not give a separate illustration. The rule that the presumption of continuance may operate retrospectively has been recognised both in India, see Anangamanjari Chowdh-rani v. Tripura Soondari Chowdhrani MANU/PR/0033/1887 and England, see Bristow v. Cormican (1878) L.R. 3 A.C. 64 Deo v.Young (1845) 8 Q.B. 63115 E.R. 798 The broad observation in Manmatha Nath Haldar v. Girish Chandra Roy(1934) 38 C.W.N. 763 and Hemendra Nath Roy Chowdhury v. Jnanendra Prasanna Bhaduri (1935) 40 C.W.N. 115 that there is no rule of evidence by which one can presume the continuity of things backwards cannot be supported. The presumption of continuity weakens with the passage of time. How far the presumption may be drawn both backwards and forwards depends upon the nature of the thing and the surrounding circumstances. 
 Citation : AIR 1966 SC 605
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 435 to 437 of 1959
Decided On: 08.09.1965
Ambika Prasad Thakur and Ors.
Vs.
Maharaj Kumar Kamal Singh and Ors.
Coram:
J.R. Mudholkar, K. Subba Rao and R.S. Bachawat, JJ.


Print Page