Learned counsel for the appellant has placed
reliance on the judgment of this Court dated
30.07.2019 in Criminal Appeal No.1160 of 2019 (G.J.
was considering provisions of Section 143A of the
N.I. Act which was inserted by the same Amendment Act
20 of 2018 by which Section 148 of the N.I. Act has
been inserted. This Court took the view that Section
143A is prospective in nature and confined to cases
where offences were committed after the introduction
of Section 143A i.e. after 01.09.2018. In paragraph
22 of the judgment following has been held:
“22. In our view, the applicability of
Section 143A of the Act must, therefore, be
held to be prospective in nature and
confined to cases where offences were
committed after the introduction of Section
143A, in order to force an accused to pay
such interim compensation.”
15. The judgment of this Court which was delivered in
the case of the present appellants i.e. Criminal
Appeal Nos.917-944 of 2019 (Surinder Singh Deswal @
Col. S.S. Deswal and others vs. Virender Gandhi) (in
which one of us M.R.Shah, J was also a member) was
also cited before the Bench deciding the case of G.J.
Raja. This Court in its judgment dated 29.05.2019 has
rejected the submission of the appellants that
Section 148 of N.I. Act shall not be made applicable
retrospectively. This Court held that considering the
Statement of Objects and Reasons of the amendment in
Section 148 of the N.I. Act, on purposive
interpretation of Section 148 of the N.I. Act as
amended, shall be applicable in respect of the
appeals against the order of conviction and sentence
for the offence under Section 138 of the N.I. Act,
even in a case where the criminal complaints for the
offence under Section 138 of the N.I. Act were filed
prior to amendment Act No.20/2018 i.e. prior to
01.09.2018.
16. The Bench deciding G.J. Raja’s case has noticed
the judgment of this Court in the appellants’ case
i.e. Surinder Singh Deswal’s case and has opined that
the decision of this Court in Surinder Singh Deswal’s
case was on Section 148 of the N.I. Act which is a
stage after conviction of the accused and
distinguishable from the stage in which the interim
compensation was awarded under Section 143A of the
N.I.Act. When the Bench deciding G.J. Raja’s
case(supra) itself has considered and distinguished
the judgment of this Court in appellants’ own case
i.e. Surinder Singh Deswal’s, reliance by the learned
counsel for the appellants on the judgment of this
Court in G.J. Raja’s case is misplaced. It is useful
to refer to paragraph 23 of the judgment in G.J.
Raja’s case which is to the following effect:
“23. We must, however, advert to a
SCALE 445 where Section 148 of the Act
which was also introduced by the same
Amendment Act 20 of 2018 from 01.09.2018
was held by this Court to be retrospective
in operation. As against Section 143A of
the Act which applies at the trial stage
that is even before the pronouncement of
guilt or order of conviction, Section 148
of the Act applies at the appellate stage
where the Accused is already found guilty
of the offence Under Section 138 of the
Act. It may be stated that there is no
provision in Section 148 of the Act which
is similar to Sub-Section (5) of Section
143A of the Act. However, as a matter of
fact, no such provision akin to Sub-section
(5) of Section 143A was required as
Sections 421 and 357 of the Code, which
apply post-conviction, are adequate to take
care of such requirements. In that sense
said Section 148 depends upon the existing
machinery and principles already in
existence and does not create any fresh
disability of the nature similar to that
created by Section 143A of the Act.
Therefore, the decision of this Court in
Surinder Singh Deswal (2007) 13 SCC 492
stands on a different footing.”
In view of the above, the judgment of this Court in
the case of G.J. Raja does not help the appellants.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS.1936-1963 OF 2019
SURINDER SINGH DESWAL @ COL. S.S. DESWAL Vs VIRENDER GANDHI & ANR.
ASHOK BHUSHAN, J.
Dated:January 08, 2020.