Showing posts with label refreshing of memory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label refreshing of memory. Show all posts

Friday, 11 September 2026

Bombay HC: Witness can not stealthily refresh his memory before entering the Court and deposing about the entire evidence giving minute details as if he was reeling them out from his memory.

 In the backdrop of the afore-said evidence, it will be useful to refer reported decision by the learned Single Judge of this Court (R.C. Chavan, J) reported in 2006(2) Mh.L.J. (Cri) 1210, Sharad s/o. Namdeorao Shirbhate vs. State of Maharashtra.


31. In para 10 of the said reported Judgment, the learned Single Judge found that Pundlik (PW-1) has admitted that the police had read over his statement to him and also told him to tender the evidence as per his statement. The learned Single Judge has observed thus : {Para 31}


"There would indeed be nothing wrong in the witness refreshing his memory, but that ought to be done before the Court and not outside the Court. In order to test the veracity of a witness, he would be required to recollect the incident out of his own memory and should be falter on some material aspect, he could be allowed to refresh his memory with reference to the contemporaneous records of the incident created by the police. It would not be permissible for such witness to stealthily refresh his memory before entering the Court and deposing about the entire evidence giving minute details as if he was reeling them out from his memory. Therefore, the objection to the reliability of evidence of PW-2 Prabhakar taken by learned Counsel for the appellant is valid."

(emphasis is supplied by us).

We approve the dictum of the learned Single Judge in that behalf.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Criminal Appeal No. 408 of 2012

Decided On: 31.10.2014

Suresh Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

B.R. Gavai and V.M. Deshpande, JJ.

Author: V.M. Deshpande, J.

Citation: 2015 ALL M R (Cri) 4243,MANU/MH/2012/2014.

Print Page

Wednesday, 24 August 2022

What are necessary Conditions for permitting a witness to refresh his memory?

  I have carefully perused the provisions of Sections 159 and 160 of the Evidence Act to consider the points urged by the Counsel.{PARA 6}

7. Section 159 of the Indian Evidence Act reads as under:

"A witness may, while under examination, refresh his memory by referring to any writing made by himself at the time of the transaction concerning which he is questioned, or so soon afterwards that the Court considers it likely that the transaction was at that time fresh in his memory.

The witness may also refer to any such writing made by any other person, and read by the witness within the time aforesaid, if when he read it he knew it to be correct".

A perusal of the above provision makes it clear that before permitting a witness to refresh his memory while under examination, one of the following two conditions must be satisfied.

1. The writing must have been made by him contemporaneously with the incident or transaction to which he testifies or soon afterwards when the facts were fresh in his memory;

2. Where the writing has been made by some one else within the aforesaid time it must have been read by the witness or read out in his presence within the aforesaid time and known to him to be correct i.e. he must have read it or it must have been read out in his presence when the facts were fresh in his memory and he had recognised the accuracy of the same.

8. Ordinarily, a witness deposes to facts from recollection of facts. But memory fades by efflux of time and therefore it becomes necessary sometimes that he should be allowed to assist his memory by looking into documents containing an account of them if there be any. This is known as refreshing memory. A reference to the written memoranda has the effect of reviving in the mind of the Witness recollection of facts known to him and recorded by him or recorded by someone else, but readout to him or in his presence, the accuracy of which had then been recognised by him.

9. Admittedly, the mahazar in this case had not been written by this witness P.W.6, nor was it written under his supervision. There was nothing in the case to show that it was read over in his presence and hearing and that the correctness of the same had been recognised by him, so that he is sure of the correctness of the facts stated therein. Therefore, conditions required under Section 159 of the Evidence Act to permit this witness to refresh his memory by referring to the contents of the mahazar had not been satisfied and the learned Sessions Judge was not right in permitting the witness to refresh his memory by referring to the mahazar in question.

10. Learned HCGP submits that in view of the provisions of Section 465(1) of Cr.P.C, this irregularity cannot be a ground to set aside the ruling of the Sessions Judge, since there is no failure of justice in the case. It cannot be said that the facts spoken to by the witness on the basis of a document not written by him or not read over by him contemporaneously at the time of writing the mahazar, would not cause prejudice to the case of the accused. Therefore, that portion of the deposition of PW-6, which was spoken to by him by referring to mahazar, requires to be excluded for the purpose of appreciation of evidence.

Karnataka High Court
Sridhar vs State Of Karnataka on 13 September, 2004
Citations: ILR 2004 KAR 4813, 2004 (7) KarLJ 518
Author: A Kabbin
Bench: A Kabbin
Print Page

Sunday, 24 November 2019

Whether evidence given by witness becomes inadmissible if police has read over his statement recorded U/S 161 of CRPC before he enters witness box?

he Full Bench answered the questions in paragraph 27 of the judgment at p. 60 thus (at p. 45) of Cri LJ):

"(1) The evidence of such witness does not become inadmissible; its probative value has to be judged in the circumstances of each case. No hard and fast rule can be laid down that in all such cases the evidence of such witness will be of no value whatsoever.

(2) Reading over of the police statement to the witness before he enters the box does not amount to contravention of the prohibition contained in Section 162(1). But the fact of reading over of the statement may affect the probative value of the evidence of the witness.

(3) Reading over of such a statement to the witness before he enters the box does not amount to use of such statement contrary to Section 162(1)."

5. I am in respectful agreement with the views expressed by the Gujarat High Court in the Full Bench decision aforementioned. As observed therein the user contemplated in Section 162 of the Code is actual user in Court proceedings and not user dehors the Court proceedings. The Court proceedings begin when the Court starts hearing a case and end when the Court stops the proceedings and adjourns them to some other day. The section does not prevent user of a police statement outside the Court proceedings. That is manifested from the words "be used for any purpose, save as hereinafter provided, at any inquiry or trial in respect of any offence under investigation." The prohibition is only for using such statements in proceedings before Court. It was for that reason that the Privy Council in Zahiruddin's case (MANU/PR/0030/1947) (supra), held that evidence of the witness is inadmissible. In that case the evidence was rendered inadmissible for two reasons (1) he had previously given a signed statement to the police and (2) the statement was made use of by the witness while giving evidence to prompt his memory. The ratio of the decision of the Privy Council cannot therefore be extended to the present case. The result is that the testimonies of PWs. 1 and 3 do not become inadmissible for the reason that the police had read out the statement to them before they entered the witness box. There is thus no contravention of the prohibition contained in Section 162(1) of the Code. The reading of the statement to the witnesses does not therefore amount to use of such a statement contrary to the provision contained in Section 162(1) of the Code. Still the reading over of the statement may affect the probative value of the evidence of the witness which the Court has to judge in the circumstances of each case.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA

Cri. Appeal No. 462 of 1992

Decided On: 13.01.1995

 Ali  Vs.  State of Kerala

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K.P. Balanarayana Marar, J.


Print Page

Monday, 1 May 2017

Whether public prosecutor can be permitted to refresh memory of witness without declaring him hostile?

In light of the above referred legal position, when we consider the
deposition of complainant   Gurjibhai Isrambhai Nayak PW 8 recorded
vide Exh. 22, it is clear that the said witness, who is complainant, has
not supported the complaint. It is important to note that after recording
of paragraphs  Nos. 1 and 2 of the examination­in­chief, the learned
Additional Public Prosecutor had neither requested the Court to declare
the said witness as hostile one nor seek permission to cross­examine
the said witness. Instead of doing that, it appears from the evidence
which has been recorded vide paragraphs 3 and 4 of the examinationin­chief
that a leading question had been asked to refresh the memory
of the said complainant PW 8 and thereby a novel procedure has been
adopted   by   the   learned   Additional   Public   Prosecutor   which   was
permitted by the learned trial Judge which is against the provisions of
Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It is important to note that before recording
paragraph   Nos.   3   and   4   of   the   examination­in­chief   of   P.W.   No.8­
Gurjibhai Isrambhai Nayak at Exh. 25,  the learned trial Judge has not
put any note or remark to show as to for what reason learned Additional
Public Prosecutor was permitted to adopt said novel procedure. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL (AGAINST CONVICTION) NO. 964 of 2016


MAHESHBHAI RATILAL BHIL
V
STATE OF GUJARAT

CORAM:  MR.JUSTICE G.B.SHAH
Date : 11 /08/2016
Citation: 2017 CRLJ 459
Print Page

Sunday, 13 March 2016

How to appreciate Evidence of witness whose memory is refreshed as per S 159 and 160 of Evidence Act?

The learned Special Court had disregarded the testimony of
PW-3 Srinivasan in the following terms:
“The evidence of PW-3 Srinivasan itself does not
inspire confidence since though he was a member
of the investigation team, he does not remember
anything else about the transaction of the
Plaintiffs except the circumstances under which
he has signed the letter of confirmation- Exh
D2-2.”
21. The learned senior counsel further contends that the
said finding of the learned special court ignores the
provision of Sections 159 & 160 of the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872 (hereinafter “the Evidence Act”). It is
contended that the Evidence Act recognizes that human
memory is fallible and after some time, it may become
totally blank about a transaction of long ago. Sections
159 and 160 of the Evidence Act are quoted hereunder:
“159. Refreshing memory: A witness may, while
under examination, refresh his memory by referring
to any writing made by himself at the time of the
transaction concerning which he is questioned, or
so soon afterwards that the Court considers it
likely that the transaction was at that time fresh
in his memory. The witness may also refer to any
such writing made by any other person, and read by
the witness within the time aforesaid, if when he
read it he knew it to be correct.”

“160. Testimony to facts stated in document
mentioned in Section 159- A witness may also
testify to facts mentioned in any such document as
is mentioned in section 159, although he has no
specific recollection of the facts themselves, if
he is sure that the facts were correctly recorded
in the document.”

22. It is further contended by Mr. Ram Jethmalani, the
learned senior counsel on behalf of the appellant, that
Mr. Srinivasan, PW-3, was called to depose in the year
2009 for a transaction that took place in November 1992.
Thus, it would be perfectly reasonable for him to claim
that he remembers practically nothing unless reminded by
the contemporaneous document of 1992 of which, he had once
before been reminded in 1996. The learned senior counsel
further contends that no suggestion was put to him at the
time of his cross examination regarding any bribery or
inducement on behalf of the CMF. No suggestion was also
put to him that the letter dated 11.03.1996 was not
written by him. It was further not suggested to him that
no such meeting happened on 07.11.1992.
23. The learned senior counsel for the appellant further
contends that the respondent CMF in their Written
Statement before the Special Court never denied the
happening of the meeting on 07.11.1992. Para 12 of the
Written Statement reads thus:-
“……this Defendant denies that S.R Ramaraj stated
to CBI on 07.11.1992 or at any time that
Defendant No.2 had a dummy transaction with the
Fund or that the details of the said alleged
transactions came to light only during the
proceedings in Misc. Petition No. 81 of 1995.”
24. The learned senior counsel further contends that
because even the respondent CMF never denied the happening
of the meeting on 07.11.1992, the learned Special Court
erred in coming to the said conclusion, which is contrary
to the pleading and evidence on record.
25. We agree with the contention advanced by the learned
senior counsel on behalf of the appellant, Mr. Ram
Jethmalani with regard to the meeting on the above date.
26. There needs to be specific denial by a witness as to
the suggestion regarding the happening of a meeting for
the Special Court to arrive at the conclusion that the
meeting did not take place. Order VIII Rule 5 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 deals with this aspect, which is
reproduced hereunder:
“Order VIII Rule 5 - Specific denial:
(1) Every allegation of fact in the plaint, if
not denied specifically or by necessary
implication, or stated to be not admitted in the
pleading of the defendant, shall be taken to be
admitted except as against a person under
disability………”
It is a settled position of law that if an allegation
made in the plaint is not specifically denied in the
written statement, it is treated as admitted, as was also
held by this Court in the case of Balraj Taneja v. Sunil
Madan
REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
 CIVIL APPEAL NOS.9540-9541 OF 2010
STANDARD CHARTERED BANK …
Vs.
ANDHRA BANK FINANCIAL SERVICES LTD & ORS. ……
Citation;(2016)1 SCC 207

V. GOPALA GOWDA, J.

Print Page

Tuesday, 23 February 2016

How to appreciate evidence of witness whose memory is refreshed?

 Referring back to the evidence of P.W.3 Vishnu, the independent
panch witness, learned Counsel for the accused submitted that evidence of
complainant Khannubhai on the point of demand and acceptance of bribe on
28­12­1993 do not find trustworthy corroboration from this witness and by
referring to his admission given in the fag end of his cross­examination that
the officers of Ante Corruption Bureau Officers asked him to prepare notes to
give evidence in the Court and that accordingly he had prepared the notes as

per say of Ante Corruption Bureau Officer and further admitting that he had
gone through all such notes before giving evidence, learned Counsel for the
accused submitted that since said witness was not stating the facts from his
memory,   his   entire   evidence   would   be   inadequate   to   provide   any
corroboration   to   the   evidence   of   complainant.     As   against   this,   learned
Additional Public Prosecutor has submitted that since the incident was more
than ten years old, there was nothing wrong in the witness refreshing his
memory before deposing about the incident giving minute details.   In that
view of the mater, I find that there would  be nothing wrong in the witness
refreshing his memory, but that ought not to be done before the Court or
outside   the   Court.     In  order  to   test  veracity  of  a   witness,   he   would  be
required to recollect the incident out of his memory and should he falter on
some material aspect, in that case, he could be allowed to refresh his memory
with regard to the contemporaneous records of the incident created by the
police and it would not be permissible for such a witness to stealthily refresh
his   memory   before   entering   the   Court   and   deposing   about   the   entire
evidence giving minute details.   Under these circumstances, I find much
substance in the submissions advanced on behalf of the accused.  
24. In   the   light   of   above   submissions,   I   find   it   necessary   to
reproduce sub­section (1) of Section 162 of the Criminal Procedure Code,
1898, which lays down as follows.  

“No statement made by any person to a police officer in the
course of an investigation under this Chapter, shall, if reduced
to writing, be signed by the person making it; nor shall any
such statement or any record thereof, whether in a police diary
or otherwise, or any part of such statement or record, be used
for any purpose, save as hereinafter provided at any inquiry or
trial in respect of any offence under investigation at the time
when such statement was made :
Provided that when any witness is called for the prosecution in
such inquiry or trial whose statement has been reduced into
writing as aforesaid, any part of his statement, if duly proved,
may be used by the accused, and with the permission of the
Court, by the prosecution to contradict such witness in the
manner provided by S. 145 of the Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of
1872); and when any part of such statement is so used, any
part thereof may also be used in the re­examination of such
witness, but for the purpose only of explaining any matter
referred to in his cross­examination.”
In the backdrop of above provisions, I further find it useful to
refer to the decision in the case of Zahiruddin v. Emperior reported in AIR
1947 PC 75, wherein with regard to use of the statement for refreshing
memory, their Lordships observed as follows :­  
“The use by a witness while he is giving evidence, of a statement
made by him to the police raises different considerations.   The
categorical prohibition of such use would be merely disregarded
if reliance were to be placed on the evidence of a witness who
had made material use of the statement when he was giving
evidence   at   the   trial.     When,   therefore,   the   Magistrate   or
Presiding Judge discovers that a witness has made material use
of such a statement it is his duty under the Section to disregard
the evidence of that witness as inadmissible.”
25. In the light of above, very little value needs to be attached to

the   evidence   of   P.W.3   Vishnu   because   he   appears   to   have   deposed   the
particular incident not by recollecting the evidence of that incident but what
has been read out by him from the police statement, short time before he
deposed.   Under these circumstances, in the first place, entire evidence of
this witness becomes inadmissible and even if it be held that it is admissible
evidence,   no   value   whatsoever   can   be   attached   to   his   evidence,   which
evidence even otherwise as already stated aforesaid does not appear to be
convincing and is contrary to the evidence of complainant on the material
aspect of demand and acceptance.  
  IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.149 OF 1999
Rustam s/o Ukarda Jadhav,

        V
State of Maharashtra, 
  CORAM : P.N. DESHMUKH, J.
   DATED  : 8th  OCTOBER, 2014.
Citation;2016 ALLMR(CRI)248
Print Page

Tuesday, 24 December 2013

Whether document though inadmissible in evidence can be used by witness to refresh his memory by referring to it?

The Privy Council in the decision reported in Jewan Lal Daga v. Nilmani, AIR 1928 PC 80 had occasion to consider whether the account books produced at the late stage, not admitted in evidence, could be allowed to be perused by the party to refresh his memory at the time of evidence and held in the affirmative. Such a decision was rendered on the ground that refusal to permit a man to refresh his memory by proper relevant contemporaneous documents might lead to grave injustice. In Abdulla v. Emperor, AIR 1933 Lahore 716 (FB), a Full Bench considered the question whether a Magistrate while giving oral evidence can refresh his memory by looking into the written memorandum prepared by him which is inadmissible in evidence as the same was not recorded under Section 164, Cr. P.C. The Court held that the oral evidence of the Magistrate is admissible, but his memorandum is not admissible though he can refresh his memory under Section 159 of the Evidence Act when underexaminadon, by referring to the memorandum. In the decision reported in Mohammad Salabat v. Emperor, AIR 1937 Lahore 475, it was held that a witness who is to be examined on the side of the prosecution can refer to the documents which he had prepared under Section 159 of the Evidence Act and state in Court everything which is material. The Supreme Court in the decision reported in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Cheemalapati Ganeswara Rad, (1964) 3 SCR 297 : (AIR 1963 SC 1850), held that where a witness has to depose to a large number of transactions and those transactions are referred to or mentioned either in the account books or in other documents, there is nothing wrong in allowing the witness to refer to the account books and the documents while questions are put to him. Such a course is specifically permitted under Sections 159 and 160 of the Evidence Act. In Choudhari Ramprasad v. Nathuram, AIR 1923 Nagpur 32, the Nagpur High Court considered the question whether a copy of an unstamped Receipt though inadmissible in evidence, can be used by a witness to refresh his memory by referring to it and held that such a course is permissible.
15. These decisions come to my aid to hold that the course adopted by the Court below is not justifiable and the Court below was incorrect in not permitting the Commissioner to testify any matters mentioned in his report. So, the impugned order is set aside.

Kerala High Court
V.P. Padmanabhan Nair And Ors. vs Grasim Industries, Mavoor And ... on 22 May, 1997
Equivalent citations: AIR 1997 Ker 356
Print Page

Sunday, 31 March 2013

Whether magistrate recording dying declaration should depose about contents of dying declaration?


In our opinion, the recorder of "a statement/dying declaration" does not offer himself for cross examination as if he is the deceased. He is only supposed to bring the statement of the deceased on record and prove the contents thereof. As a matter of fact, the dying declaration can be proved even if its recorder is not available, being dead or who cannot be 
found or, for any reason whose attendance cannot be procured. Any other person such as a Doctor / Nurse, if states, that he/she was present when the deceased made such statement, in our opinion, may be sufficient to admit the dying declaration. In that eventuality, if such witness deposes before the Court that he was present when the statement was recorded by a Magistrate, he heard the deceased making such statement, saw the Magistrate recording it, taking the signature / thumb impression of its maker, and also putting his signature thereon etc. may be sufficient to prove the contents of such statement. Whether to form conviction on the basis thereof, however, would be a matter of appreciation of evidence. It is common knowledge that Magistrates /Executive Magistrates who are always willing and make themselves available to record dying declarations are often called by Police. In some cases, we find that a particular Magistrate records 10/15 dying declarations in a week or 20/25 in a month. In such a situation, it would be humanly impossible for any Magistrate to remember contents of the statements recorded by him and to reproduce while deposing before the Court. It is true that Magistrate while under examination can refresh his memory as provided for under Section 159 of the Evidence Act. That being so, in our opinion,
expecting the Magistrate, after referring to the statement recorded by him, to repeat and/or reproduce contents thereof, would be too technical and would create violence to logic. In criminal trials, while dealing with such evidence Courts have to be rational and realistic and need not take dogmatic and hyper technical approach. The Courts cannot ignore or turn its mind/attention away from the truth of the cause, in disregard to its duty to prevent miscarriage of justice.

Bombay High Court
Ramesh S/O Gyanoba Kamble vs The State Of Maharashtra on 12 August, 2011
Bench: D.B.Bhosale, S.B. Deshmukh, Shrihari P. Davare

Print Page

Monday, 15 October 2012

Whether Investigating officer can read case papers while giving evidence in court?

 Trial court cannot overlook the reality that an investigating officer comes to the court for giving evidence after conducting investigation in many other cases also in the meanwhile. Evidence giving process should not bog down to memory tests of witnesses. An investigating officer must answer the questions in court, as far as possible, only with reference to what he had recorded during investigation. Such records are the contemporaneous entries made by him and hence for refreshing his memory it is always advisable that he looks into those records before answering any question.

23. Section 159 of the Evidence Act is couched in a language recognising the aforesaid necessity. The section reads thus:
159. Refreshing memory :- A witness may, while under examination, refresh his memory by referring to any writing made by himself at the time of the transaction concerning which he is questioned, or so soon afterwards that the Court considers it likely that the transaction was at that time fresh in his memory.
The witness may also refer to any such writing made by any other person, and read by the witness within the time aforesaid, if when he read it he knew it to be correct.
The objection of the defence counsel when investigating officer wanted to reply by referring to the records of investigation is, therefore, untenable and unjustified. The trial court should repel such objections.

Supreme Court of India
State Of Karnataka vs K. Yarappa Reddy on 5 October, 1999
Equivalent citations: AIR 2000 SC 185, 2000 CriLJ 400, 1999 (3) Crimes 171 SC
Print Page