I have carefully perused the provisions of Sections 159 and 160 of the Evidence Act to consider the points urged by the Counsel.{PARA 6}
7. Section 159 of the Indian Evidence Act reads as under:
"A witness may, while under examination, refresh his memory by referring to any writing made by himself at the time of the transaction concerning which he is questioned, or so soon afterwards that the Court considers it likely that the transaction was at that time fresh in his memory.
The witness may also refer to any such writing made by any other person, and read by the witness within the time aforesaid, if when he read it he knew it to be correct".
A perusal of the above provision makes it clear that before permitting a witness to refresh his memory while under examination, one of the following two conditions must be satisfied.
1. The writing must have been made by him contemporaneously with the incident or transaction to which he testifies or soon afterwards when the facts were fresh in his memory;
2. Where the writing has been made by some one else within the aforesaid time it must have been read by the witness or read out in his presence within the aforesaid time and known to him to be correct i.e. he must have read it or it must have been read out in his presence when the facts were fresh in his memory and he had recognised the accuracy of the same.
8. Ordinarily, a witness deposes to facts from recollection of facts. But memory fades by efflux of time and therefore it becomes necessary sometimes that he should be allowed to assist his memory by looking into documents containing an account of them if there be any. This is known as refreshing memory. A reference to the written memoranda has the effect of reviving in the mind of the Witness recollection of facts known to him and recorded by him or recorded by someone else, but readout to him or in his presence, the accuracy of which had then been recognised by him.
9. Admittedly, the mahazar in this case had not been written by this witness P.W.6, nor was it written under his supervision. There was nothing in the case to show that it was read over in his presence and hearing and that the correctness of the same had been recognised by him, so that he is sure of the correctness of the facts stated therein. Therefore, conditions required under Section 159 of the Evidence Act to permit this witness to refresh his memory by referring to the contents of the mahazar had not been satisfied and the learned Sessions Judge was not right in permitting the witness to refresh his memory by referring to the mahazar in question.
10. Learned HCGP submits that in view of the provisions of Section 465(1) of Cr.P.C, this irregularity cannot be a ground to set aside the ruling of the Sessions Judge, since there is no failure of justice in the case. It cannot be said that the facts spoken to by the witness on the basis of a document not written by him or not read over by him contemporaneously at the time of writing the mahazar, would not cause prejudice to the case of the accused. Therefore, that portion of the deposition of PW-6, which was spoken to by him by referring to mahazar, requires to be excluded for the purpose of appreciation of evidence.
Karnataka High Court
Sridhar vs State Of Karnataka on 13 September, 2004
Citations: ILR 2004 KAR 4813, 2004 (7) KarLJ 518
Author: A Kabbin
Bench: A Kabbin
Print Page