Showing posts with label dying declaration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dying declaration. Show all posts

Saturday, 25 April 2026

How session judge should appreciate multiple dying declaration?

 You can explain it in interview as a simple filtering process: first see whether each dying declaration is trustworthy by itself, then compare them with each other, and finally check which one fits the medical and surrounding evidence. If they are consistent, they can be relied on; if they materially contradict each other, the court should look for corroboration and may prefer a trustworthy Magistrate-recorded declaration.

Print Page

Sunday, 15 March 2026

Supreme Court: Recovery Of A Weapon From An Open Place Accessible To All Not Reliable U/ S of 27 Evidence Act

27.1. This Court has, in various judgments, clarified this position. Illustratively, in Jaikam Khan v. State of U.P. MANU/SC/1259/2021 : (2021) 13 SCC 716 it was observed:

One of the alleged recoveries is from the room where deceased Asgari used to sleep. The other two recoveries are from open field, just behind the house of deceased Shaukeen Khan i.e. the place of incident. It could thus be seen that the recoveries were made from the places, which were accessible to one and all and as such, no reliance could be placed on such recoveries.

(Emphasis supplied)

 27.2. Also, in Nikhil Chandra Mondal v. State of W.B. MANU/SC/0211/2023 : (2023) 6 SCC 605 the Court held:


20. The trial court disbelieved the recovery of clothes and weapon on two grounds. Firstly, that there was no memorandum statement of the Accused as required Under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, 1872 and secondly, the recovery of the knife was from an open place accessible to one and all. We find that the approach adopted by the trial court was in accordance with law. However, this circumstance which, in our view, could not have been used, has been employed by the High Court to seek corroboration to the extra- judicial confession.


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 866 of 2011

Decided On: 06.11.2023

Manjunath and Ors. Vs. State of Karnataka

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1212/2023.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Tuesday, 10 February 2026

The Person Who Wrote It Matters: Why “Who Recorded the Dying Declaration” Can Make or Break a Case

 Proper Identification of the Recording Officer in Dying Declaration Cases

Proper identification of the recording officer is a critical procedural requirement in dying declaration cases that ensures the authenticity, reliability, and admissibility of such statements. This principle, established through various Supreme Court judgments and procedural guidelines, encompasses several key aspects that must be meticulously followed.

Hierarchy of Authority for Recording Officers

The Supreme Court has established a clear hierarchy of preferred authorities for recording dying declarations, with specific identification requirements for each level:

Print Page

Sunday, 3 August 2025

When Love Turns Lethal: The Legal Tightrope of Abetment to Suicide in Marital Disputes


 The Case That Reveals Complex Legal Realities

In the tragic intersection of domestic conflict and criminal law, a deeply disturbing case unfolds that challenges our understanding of legal culpability and human nature. A wife, overwhelmed by marital discord and harassment over giving birth to three daughters, threatens suicide. Her husband's chilling response: "If you commit suicide, I will be free to perform a second marriage." When she tragically follows through, burning herself alive, the question becomes not just moral but legal—can the husband be held criminally liable for abetment of suicide?

Print Page

Sunday, 6 July 2025

Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

 Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

The Supreme Court of India has established comprehensive principles for evaluating multiple dying declarations in criminal cases, recognizing that these statements, while powerful evidence, require careful judicial scrutiny to ensure justice.

Legal Foundation and Admissibility

Print Page

Wednesday, 2 July 2025

Supreme Court: Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

 When dealing with multiple dying declarations, courts in India follow certain well-established principles to ensure that justice is served and that the declarations are reliable and admissible as evidence. The  Supreme Court judgment (Abhishek Sharma v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), 2023 INSC 924) provides a comprehensive discussion of these principles, which can be summarized and explained as follows:

Principles to Be Followed in Case of Multiple Dying Declarations

1. Voluntariness, Reliability, and Mental Fitness

·       Every dying declaration must be voluntary, reliable, and made when the declarant was in a fit mental condition to make such a statement.

Print Page

Sunday, 19 November 2023

Landmark Supreme Court Judgment on Dying Declaration

PRINCIPLES IN REGARD TO DYING DECLARATIONS


11. Section 32 the Indian Evidence Act, 18723 relates to statements, written or verbal of relevant fact made by a person who is dead or who cannot be found, in other words, dying declaration. The various principles laid down by pronouncements of this Court in respect of dying declarations can be summarised as under:



11.3 The Privy Council in Pakala Narayana Swamy v. Emperor MANU/PR/0001/1939 : AIR 1939 PC 47 [5 Judge Bench] explained the phrase "circumstances of the transaction" as under:


The circumstances must be circumstances of the transaction: general expressions indicating fear or suspicion whether of a particular individual or otherwise and not directly related to the occasion of the death will not be admissible. But statements made by the deceased that he was proceeding to the spot where he was in fact killed, or as to his reasons for so proceeding, or that he was going to meet a particular person, or that he had been invited by such person to meet him would each of them be circumstances of the transaction, and would be so whether the person was unknown, or was not the person Accused. Such a statement might indeed be exculpatory of the person Accused. 'Circumstances of the transaction' is a phrase no doubt that conveys some limitations. It is not as broad as the analogous use in 'circumstantial evidence' which includes evidence of all relevant facts. It is on the other hand narrower than 'res gestae'. Circumstances must have some proximate relation to the actual occurrence: though, as for instance, in a case of prolonged poisoning they may be related to dates at a considerable distance from the date of the actual fatal dose. It will be observed that 'the circumstances' are of the transaction which resulted in the death of the declarant. It is not necessary that there should be a known transaction other than that the death of the declarant has ultimately been caused, for the condition of the admissibility of the evidence is that 'the cause of (the declarant's) death comes into question'.



(4) It may be important to note that Section 32 does not speak of homicide alone but includes suicide also, hence all the circumstances which may be relevant to prove a case of homicide would be equally relevant to prove a case of suicide.


(5) Where the main evidence consists of statements and letters written by the deceased which are directly connected with or related to her death and which reveal a tell-tale story, the said statement would clearly fall within the four corners of Section 32 and, therefore, admissible. The distance of time alone in such cases would not make the statement irrelevant.

11.5.3.1. In Paniben v. State of Gujarat MANU/SC/0346/1992 : (1992) 2 SCC 474 [2 Judge Bench] it was observed-


The Court has to be on guard that the statement of deceased was not as a result of either tutoring, prompting or a product of imagination.


A reference may also be made to K. Ramachandra Reddy v. Public Prosecutor MANU/SC/0127/1976 : (1976) 3 SCC 618 [2 Judge Bench]


11.6. The Court must be satisfied that at the time of making such a statement, the deceased was in a "fit state of mind". In Shama v. State of Haryana MANU/SC/1654/2016 : (2017) 11 SCC 535 [2 Judge Bench], a fit state of mind has been held to be a prerequisite, alongside the ability to recollect the situation and the state of affairs at that point in time in relation to the incident, to the satisfaction of the court.


11.6.1. In Uttam v. State of Maharashtra MANU/SC/0787/2022 : (2022) 8 SCC 576 [2 Judge Bench], it was discussed that it is for the court to determine, from the evidence available on record, the state of mind being fit or not.


11.6.2. In order to make a determination of the state of mind of the person making the dying declaration, the court ordinarily relies on medical evidence.4 However, equally, it has been held that if witnesses present, while the statement is being made, state that the deceased while making the statement was in a fit state of mind, such statement would prevail over the medical evidence.5 The statement of witnesses present prevailing over the opinion of the doctor has been reiterated in Uttam (supra).


11.6.3. It has also, however, been held in Laxman (supra) that the mere absence of a doctor's certificate in regard to the "fit state of mind" of the dying declarant, will not ipso facto render such declaration unacceptable. This position had been once again recognised in Surendra Bangali @ Surendra Singh Routele v. State of Jharkhand6.


11.7. In case of a plurality of such statements, it has been observed that it is not the plurality but the reliability of such declaration determines its evidentiary value. The principle as held in Amol Singh v. State of M.P. MANU/SC/7724/2008 : (2008) 5 SCC 468 [2 Judge Bench] was:


13. ... it is not the plurality of the dying declarations but the reliability thereof that adds weight to the prosecution case. If a dying declaration is found to be voluntary, reliable and made in fit mental condition, it can be relied upon without any corroboration [but] the statement should be consistent throughout. ... However, if some inconsistencies are noticed between one dying declaration and the other, the court has to examine the nature of the inconsistencies, namely, whether they are material or not [and] while scrutinising the contents of various dying declarations, in such a situation, the court has to examine the same in the light of the various surrounding facts and circumstances.


11.7.1. Faced with multiple dying declarations, this Court in Lakhan v. State of M.P. MANU/SC/0577/2010 : (2010) 8 SCC 514 [2 Judge Bench] observed-


21. .... In such an eventuality no corroboration is required. In case there are multiple dying declarations and there are inconsistencies between them, generally, the dying declaration recorded by the higher officer like a Magistrate can be relied upon, provided that there is no circumstance giving rise to any suspicion about its truthfulness. In case there are circumstances wherein the declaration had been made, not voluntarily and even otherwise, it is not supported by the other evidence, the court has to scrutinise the facts of an individual case very carefully and take a decision as to which of the declarations is worth reliance.


11.7.2. This Court, in Jagbir Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi) MANU/SC/1200/2019 : (2019) 8 SCC 779 [2 Judge Bench], in this respect, concluded as under:


32. We would think that on a conspectus of the law as laid down by this Court, when there are more than one dying declaration, and in the earlier dying declaration, the Accused is not sought to be roped in but in the later dying declaration, a somersault is made by the deceased, the case must be decided on the facts of each case. The court will not be relieved of its duty to carefully examine the entirety of materials as also the circumstances surrounding the making of the different dying declarations. If the court finds that the incriminatory dying declaration brings out the truthful position particularly in conjunction with the capacity of the deceased to make such declaration, the voluntariness with which it was made which involves, no doubt, ruling out tutoring and prompting and also the other evidence which support the contents of the incriminatory dying declaration, it can be acted upon. Equally, the circumstances which render the earlier dying declaration, worthy or unworthy of acceptance, can be considered.


11.8. The presence of a Magistrate in recording of a dying declaration, is not a necessity but only a Rule of Prudence. To this effect in Jayamma (supra), this Court observed:


...law does not compulsorily require the presence of a judicial or executive Magistrate to record a dying declaration or that a dying declaration cannot be relied upon as the solitary piece of evidence unless recorded by judicial or executive Magistrate. It is only a Rule of prudence, and if so permitted by the facts and circumstances, the dying declaration may preferably be recorded by a judicial or executive Magistrate so as to muster additional strength to the prosecution case.


Referring to the Constitution bench in Laxman (supra) the principle of a dying declaration not necessarily to be recorded by a Magistrate stands reiterated in Rajaram v. State of Madhya Pradesh MANU/SC/1635/2022 [2 Judge Bench]


11.9. Dying Declaration is not to be discarded by reason of its brevity is what is held in Surajdeo Ojha v. State of Bihar MANU/SC/0269/1979 : 1980 Supp SCC 769 [2 Judge Bench].


11.9.1. It was observed in the State of Maharashtra v. Krishnamurti Laxmipati Naidu 1980 Supp SCC 455 [2 Judge Bench] that if the dying declaration, while being brief, contains essential information, the courts would not be justified in ignoring the same.


11.9.2. In fact, the Constitution bench in Laxman reiterated this principle, stating:


Marely because a dying declaration does not contain the details of the occurrence, it cannot be rejected and in case there is merely a brief statement, it is more reliable for the reason that the shortness of the statement is itself a guarantee of its veracity.


11.10. Examination of the person who reduced into writing, the dying declaration, is essential. Particularly, in the absence of any explanation forthcoming for the production of evidence is what stands observed in Govind Narain v. State of Rajasthan MANU/SC/0374/1993 : 1993 Supp (3) SCC 343 [2 Judge Bench].


11.10.1. In fact, in Kans Raj v. State of Punjab MANU/SC/0296/2000 : (2000) 5 SCC 207 [3 Judge Bench] it was held:


11. ...To make such statement as substantive evidence, the person or the agency relying upon it is under a legal obligation to prove the making of such statement as a fact. If it is in writing, the scribe must be produced in the Court and if it is verbal, it should be proved by examining the person who heard the deceased making the statement." and;


In Sudhakar v. State of Maharashtra MANU/SC/0431/2000 : (2000) 6 SCC 671 [3 Judge Bench], this Court categorically observed:


5. If it is in writing, the scribe must be produced in the court and if it is verbal, it should be proved by examining the person who heard the deceased making the statement. However, in cases where the original recorded dying declaration is proved to have been lost and not available, the prosecution is entitled to give secondary evidence thereof.


11.11. The questions that a court must ask when dealing with a case concerning a dying declaration, as listed out by this Court in Irfan@Naka v. State of U.P. MANU/SC/0925/2023 [3-Judge Bench] along with the principles culled out hereinabove form the complete gamut of consideration required on part of a court when deciding the weightage to be awarded to a dying declaration.

Ratio of This case:

  • A dying declaration must relate to the circumstances of the transaction that resulted in the death of the declarant. General expressions unrelated to the death are not admissible.
  • The statement does not need to be made to a magistrate - that is only a rule of prudence. An unsigned or verbal statement can also be admitted.
  • The court must ensure the declarant was in a fit state of mind and able to recall events when making the statement. Medical evidence can confirm this but witness testimony may prevail.
  • Multiple statements can be relied on if consistent. Inconsistencies require careful examination of their nature and surrounding context.
  • Brevity alone is not a reason to discard a statement if it provides essential information. Details are not required.
  • Those who recorded the statement, whether verbally or in writing, must be produced in court for examination.
  • The court must consider voluntariness, absence of tutoring/prompting, capacity to recall events, and consistency with other evidence when evaluating the reliability and evidentiary value of a dying declaration.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 866 of 2011

Decided On: 06.11.2023

Manjunath and Ors. Vs. State of Karnataka

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1212/2023.

Print Page

Tuesday, 24 October 2023

Supreme court : Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

 Having considered various pronouncements of this Court, the following principles emerge, for a Court to consider when dealing with a case involving multiple dying declarations:


9.1 The primary requirement for all dying declarations is that they should be voluntary and reliable and that such statements should be in a fit state of mind;


9.2 All dying declarations should be consistent. In other words, inconsistencies between such statements should be 'material' for its credibility to be shaken;


9.3 When inconsistencies are found between various dying declarations, other evidence available on record may be considered for the purposes of corroboration of the contents of dying declarations.


9.4 The statement treated as a dying declaration must be interpreted in light of surrounding facts and circumstances.


9.5 Each declaration must be scrutinized on its own merits. The court has to examine upon which of the statements reliance can be placed in order for the case to proceed further.


9.6 When there are inconsistencies, the statement that has been recorded by a Magistrate or like higher officer can be relied on, subject to the indispensable qualities of truthfulness and being free of suspicion.


9.7 In the presence of inconsistencies, the medical fitness of the person making such declaration, at the relevant time, assumes importance along with other factors such as the possibility of tutoring by relatives, etc.{Para 9}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1473 of 2011

Decided On: 18.10.2023

Abhishek Sharma Vs. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1159/2023.

Print Page

Sunday, 22 October 2023

Under which circumstance the court can convict accused for offences U/S 498A and S 306 of IPC even though accused were not charged under those sections?

 Omission to frame charge does not disable the court from convicting the Accused for the offence which is found to have been proved on the evidence on record. The code has ample provisions to meet a situation like the one before us. From the statement of charge framed Under Section 304B and in the alternative Section 306, it is clear that all the facts and ingredients for framing the charge for offence Under Section 306 existed. The mere omission on the part of the trial judge to mention Section 306 Indian Penal Code with 498A would not preclude this Court from convicting the Accused for the said offence when found proved. In the charge framed Under Section 304B of Indian Penal Code, it has been clearly mentioned that the Accused has subjected the deceased to such cruelty and harassment as to drive her to commit suicide by self-immolation and as such non-framing of the specific charge would not be fatal in the instant case as no injustice is being caused to the Accused. {Para 28}


29. This Court in K. Prema S. Rao and Anr. v. Yadla Srinivasa Rao and Ors. MANU/SC/0890/2002 : (2003) 1 SCC 217 has held that mere omission or defect in framing of charge would not be fatal if from the statement of charge Under Section 304B and in the alternative Section 498A, it is clear that all facts and ingredients for framing of charge Under Section 306 existed in the case, same would suffice. It was further held that:


22. Mere omission or defect in framing charge does not disable the criminal court from convicting the Accused for the offence which is found to have been proved on the evidence on record. The Code of Criminal Procedure has ample provisions to meet a situation like the one before us. From the statement of charge framed Under Section 304-B and in the alternative Section 498-A Indian Penal Code (as quoted above) it is clear that all facts and ingredients for framing charge for offence Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code existed in the case. The mere omission on the part of the trial Judge to mention Section 306 Indian Penal Code with Section 498-A Indian Penal Code does not preclude the court from convicting the Accused for the said offence when found proved. In the alternate charge framed Under Section 498-A Indian Penal Code, it has been clearly mentioned that the Accused subjected the deceased to such cruelty and harassment as to drive her to commit suicide. The provisions of Section 221 Code of Criminal Procedure take care of such a situation and safeguard the powers of the criminal court to convict an Accused for an offence with which he is not charged although on facts found in evidence, he could have been charged for such offence. Section 221 Code of Criminal Procedure needs reproduction:


221. Where it is doubtful what offence has been committed.-(1) If a single act or series of acts is of such a nature that it is doubtful which of several offences the facts which can be proved will constitute, the Accused may be charged with having committed all or any of such offences, and any number of such charges may be tried at once; or he may be charged in the alternative with having committed some one of the said offences.


(2) If in such a case the Accused is charged with one offence, and it appears in evidence that he committed a different offence for which he might have been charged under the provisions of Sub-section (1), he may be convicted of the offence which he is shown to have committed, although he was not charged with it.


23. The provision of Sub-section (2) of Section 221 read with Sub-section (1) of the said Section can be taken aid of in convicting and sentencing Accused 1 of offence of abetment of suicide Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code along with or instead of Section 498-A Indian Penal Code.


24. Section 215 allows the criminal court to ignore any error in stating either the offence or the particulars required to be stated in the charge, if the Accused was not, in fact, misled by such error or omission in framing the charge and it has not occasioned a failure of justice. See Section 215 Code of Criminal Procedure which reads:


215. Effect of errors.-No error in stating either the offence or the particulars required to be stated in the charge, and no omission to state the offence or those particulars, shall be regarded at any stage of the case as material, unless the Accused was in fact misled by such error or omission, and it has occasioned a failure of justice.


25. As provided in Section 215 Code of Criminal Procedure omission to frame charge Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code has not resulted in any failure of justice. We find no necessity to remit the matter to the trial court for framing charge Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code and direct a retrial for that charge. The Accused cannot legitimately complain of any want of opportunity to defend the charge Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code and a consequent failure of justice. The same facts found in evidence, which justify conviction of the Appellant Under Section 498-A for cruel treatment of his wife, make out a case against him Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code of having abetted commission of suicide by the wife. The Appellant was charged for an offence of higher degree causing "dowry death" Under Section 304-B which is punishable with minimum sentence of seven years' rigorous imprisonment and maximum for life. Presumption Under Section 113-A of the Evidence Act could also be raised against him on same facts constituting offence of cruelty Under Section 498-A Indian Penal Code. No further opportunity of defence is required to be granted to the Appellant when he had ample opportunity to meet the charge Under Section 498-A Indian Penal Code.


30. In the aforesaid background and the evidence on record as already noticed by us hereinabove, it can be safely noted that High Court ought to have examined as to whether Accused could have been convicted for an offence for which no charge was framed and not undertaking of such an exercise would result in failure of justice? Thus, it will have to be seen from the facts unfolded in the present case as to whether the Accused was aware of the basic ingredients of the offence for which they are being tried and whether the main facts sought to be established against them were explained to them clearly and whether they got a fair chance to defend themselves. If the answer is in the affirmative, then necessarily this Court will have to proceed further and examine as to whether Accused can be convicted for the offence not charged and if the answer is in the negative it would result in acquittal of the Accused for said offence. In the instant case the dying declaration of the deceased would clearly indicate that deceased was mentally traumatized and she was unable to tolerate the torture and harassment meted out by the Accused person on account of which she committed suicide. It is this taunting or mental torture which she could not withstand and forced her to commit suicide by self- immolation. In that view of the matter, we are of the considered opinion that Accused persons are liable to be convicted for the offence punishable Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code though charge was not framed. 

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 3274 of 2023 

Decided On: 19.10.2023

Paranagouda and Ors. Vs. The State of Karnataka and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S. Ravindra Bhat and Aravind Kumar, JJ.

Author: Aravind Kumar, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1171/2023.

Print Page

Sunday, 27 August 2023

Supreme Court lays down principles for appreciation of Dying declaration evidence

There is no hard and fast rule for determining when a dying

declaration should be accepted; the duty of the Court is to decide this

question in the facts and surrounding circumstances of the case and be fully convinced of the truthfulness of the same. Certain factors below reproduced can be considered to determine the same, however, they will only affect the weight of the dying declaration and not its admissibility: -

(i) Whether the person making the statement was in expectation

of death?

(ii) Whether the dying declaration was made at the earliest

opportunity? “Rule of First Opportunity”

(iii) Whether there is any reasonable suspicion to believe the dying

declaration was put in the mouth of the dying person?

(iv) Whether the dying declaration was a product of prompting,

tutoring or leading at the instance of police or any interested

party?

(v) Whether the statement was not recorded properly?

(vi) Whether, the dying declarant had opportunity to clearly

observe the incident?

(vii) Whether, the dying declaration has been consistent

throughout?

(viii) Whether, the dying declaration in itself is a manifestation /

fiction of the dying person’s imagination of what he thinks

transpired?

(ix) Whether, the dying declaration was itself voluntary?

(x) In case of multiple dying declarations, whether, the first one

inspires truth and consistent with the other dying declaration?

(xi) Whether, as per the injuries, it would have been impossible for

the deceased to make a dying declaration? {Para 62}

63. It is the duty of the prosecution to establish the charge against theaccused beyond the reasonable doubt. The benefit of doubt must always go in favour of the accused. It is true that dying declaration is a substantive piece of evidence to be relied on provided it is proved that the same was voluntary and truthful and the victim was in a fit state of mind. It is just not enough for the court to say that the dying declaration is reliable as the accused is named in the dying declaration as the assailant.

64. It is unsafe to record the conviction on the basis of a dying

declaration alone in the cases where suspicion, like the case on hand is raised, as regards the correctness of the dying declaration. In such cases, the Court may have to look for some corroborative evidence by treating the dying declaration only as a piece of evidence. The evidence and material available on record must be properly weighed in each case to arrive at an appropriate conclusion. The reason why we say so is that in the case on hand, although the appellant-convict has been named in the two dying declarations as a person who set the room on fire yet the surrounding circumstances render such statement of the declarants very doubtful.

 2023INSC758

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 825-826 of 2022

IRFAN @ NAKA  Vs  THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH 

Author: J. B. Pardiwala, J.:

Dated: AUGUST 23, 2023.

Print Page

Thursday, 26 January 2023

Can the court acquit the accused by relying on ocular evidence and discarding the dying declaration if the Deceased Was Adversely Motivated?

 Considering the facts and the law discussed above, it emerges that where it is proved that the mental condition of the deceased was motivated adversely due to the immediate past events, the circumstances do not support the dying declaration, and the evidence of ocular witnesses inspires the confidence, the ocular evidence would prevail over the statement of the deceased as to the cause of his death. Considering the circumstances and the evidence produced in the case, the Court comes to the conclusion that the events that happened in her marital life motivated her intellect, and her mental condition became vindictive. Therefore, she did not give the correct statement as to her cause of death.

{Para 38}

39. For the reasons stated above, the Court discards the statement of the deceased as to her cause of death, believes the ocular witnesses, and agrees with the findings of the learned Sessions Judge.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Revision Application No. 169 of 2007

Shivkaran Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.G. Mehare, J.

Decided On: 20.01.2023.

Citation: MANU/MH/0181/2023,2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 4.

Print Page

Thursday, 15 December 2022

Whether injured person can be contradicted with his dying declaration treating it as his previous statement?

 The Executive Magistrate had purportedly recorded a statement of P.W.1 Jagannath in the form of a dying declaration. In view of Section 157 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 the so-called dying declaration can be treated as a former statement made by P.W.1 and, therefore, the same can be used for contradicting the witness. When P.W.1 Jagannath was confronted with a portion of hisstatement at Ex.D-2, he accepted that the statement does not refer to the presence of accused nos.1, 3, 7, 8 and 9. {Para 7}

 NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.162 of 2010

Ramcharan (Dead) & Anr. Vs State of Madhya Pradesh 

Author: Abhay S. Oka, J.

Dated: December 07, 2022.

Print Page

Sunday, 11 September 2022

Questions and answers on law (Part 53)

 Q 1 :- What is Dying declaration?

Ans:- A dying declaration is a statement made by a dying person as to cause of his death or as to any of the circumstances of the transaction which resulted in his death when the cause of his death is in question.

https://www.lawweb.in/2018/08/notes-on-dying-declaration.html

Q 2 :- What are conditions for conviction on circumstantial evidence?

Ans:- A close analysis of this decision would show that the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be said to be fully established:

(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established. It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances concerned 'must or should' and not 'may be' established. 
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty.
Print Page

Sunday, 15 May 2022

Whether the court can rely on dying declaration of wife for convicting husband for an offence U/S 498A of IPC?

  A reading of the above pronouncements makes it clear that, in some circumstances, the evidence of a deceased wife with respect to cruelty could be admissible in a trial for a charge under Section 498 A of the IPC under Section 32(1) of the Evidence Act. There are, however, certain necessary preconditions that must be met before the evidence is admitted. {Para 20}

21. The first condition is that her cause of death must come into question in the matter. This would include, for instance, matters where along with the charge under Section 498A of the IPC, the prosecution has also charged the accused under Sections 302, 306 or 304B of the IPC. It must be noted however that as long as the cause of her death has come into question, whether the charge relating to death is proved or not is immaterial with respect to admissibility.

22. The second condition is that the prosecution will have to show that the evidence that is sought to be admitted with respect to Section 498A of the IPC must also relate to the circumstances of the transaction of the death. How far back the evidence can be, and how connected the evidence is to the cause of death of the deceased would necessarily depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. No specific straitjacket formula or rule can be given with respect to this.

23. To the above extent therefore, the judgments of this Court in Gananath Pattnaik (supra), Inderpal (supra), Bhairon Singh (supra) and Kantilal Martaji Pandor (supra), wherein it has been held that the evidence of the deceased cannot be admitted under Section 32(1) of the Evidence Act to prove the charge under Section 498 A of the IPC only because the accused stands acquitted of the charge relating to the death of the deceased, may not be correct. These judgments stand overruled to that limited extent.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1080 of 2019; 

Dated: MAY 13, 2022 

SURENDRAN Vs STATE OF KERALA

Print Page

Sunday, 10 April 2022

Can the court refuse to rely on a dying declaration if there was no extreme emergency when it was recorded?

 The submission on behalf of the accused relying upon the decision of this Court in the case of Laxman (supra) that the day on which the dying declaration was recorded, there was no extreme emergency and/or his condition was not so serious or there was any danger to his life and therefore there was no reason and/or cause to record the dying declaration and therefore the dying declaration is not believable, has no substance. In the case of Laxman (supra), which has been relied upon by learned counsel appearing on behalf of the accused there is no absolute proposition of law laid down by this Court that, in a case when at the time when the dying declaration was recorded, there was no emergency and/or any danger to the life, the dying declaration should be discarded as a whole. In the present case, as the deceased was having a stab injury by a knife, there was a possibility of danger to his life and therefore, by way of prudence, if the dying declaration was recorded on 05.12.1980, there is no reason to doubt the dying declaration, which was recorded by Assistant Divisional Transport Officer. Therefore, in our view the Trial Court has rightly relied upon and/or believed the dying declaration recorded by Assistant Divisional Transport Officer on 05.12.1980.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

 CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 436 OF 2022; 


The State of Uttar Pradesh Vs Subhash @ Pappu
Print Page

Saturday, 19 February 2022

Can the court convict the accused if the common thread runs through multiple dying declarations?

 10.2 Kushal Rao V. State of Bombay, AIR 1958 SC 22:1958 SCR 552 is a watershed judgment on the law on the evidentiary value of dying declarations. This Court laid down the following principles as to the circumstances under which a dying declaration may be accepted, without corroboration: ­

“16. On a review of the relevant provisions of the Evidence Act and of the decided cases in the different High Courts in India and in this Court, we have come to the conclusion, in agreement with the opinion of the Full Bench of the Madras High Court, aforesaid, (1) that it cannot be laid down as an absolute rule of law that a dying declaration cannot form the sole basis of conviction unless it is corroborated; (2) that each case must be determined on its own facts keeping in view the circumstances in which the dying declaration was made; (3) that it cannot be laid down as a general proposition that a dying declaration is a weaker kind of evidence than other pieces of evidence; (4) that a dying declaration stands on the same footing as another piece of evidence and has to be judged in the light of surrounding circumstances and with reference to the principles governing the weighing of evidence; (5) that a dying declaration which has been recorded by a competent Magistrate in the proper manner, that is to say, in the form of questions and answers, and, as far as practicable, in the words of the maker of the declaration, stands on a much higher footing than a dying declaration which depends upon oral testimony which may suffer from all the infirmities of human memory and human character, and (6) that in order to test the reliability of a dying declaration, the court has to keep in view, the circumstances like the opportunity of the dying man for observation, for example, whether there was sufficient light if the crime was committed at night; whether the capacity of the man to remember the facts stated, had not been impaired at the time he was making the statement, by circumstances beyond his control; that the statement has been consistent throughout if he had several opportunities of making a dying declaration apart from the official record of it; and that the statement had been made at the earliest opportunity and was not the result of tutoring by interested parties.”
The relevant facts of the said case are that the deceased therein had given three successive dying declarations within a span of two hours, which were, to a certain degree contradictory to each other. However, one of the aspects that remained common and was narrated by the deceased in all three dying declarations was that he was attacked by two persons, namely Kushal Rao and Tukaram with swords and spears. This Court, relying on the common thread running through all dying declarations, which was consistent with medical evidence revealing punctured and incised wounds on various parts of the body, held that the said declarations could be relied upon in convicting the accused who had been named in all three dying declarations.

Supreme Court

JUSTICE M. R. SHAH JUSTICE B. V. NAGARATHNA

State of U.P. Vs. Veerpal & Anr.

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 34 OF 2022

1st February 2022

Author: M. R. Shah, J.

Citation: 2022 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 112

Print Page

Saturday, 11 September 2021

How to appreciate evidence if there are Oral and written multiple dying declarations?

Following are the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Purushottam Chopra and another Vs. State (Government of NCT of Delhi) (supra), which are summed up as under :

“(1) A dying declaration could be the sole basis of

conviction even without corroboration, if it inspires

confidence of the Court.

(2) The Court should be satisfied that the declarant was

in a fit state of mind at the time of making the

statement; and that it was a voluntary statement,

which was not the result of tutoring, prompting or

imagination.

(3) Where a dying declaration is suspicious or is

suffering from any infirmity such as want of fit state

of mind of the declarant or of like nature, it should

not be acted upon without corroborative evidence.

(4) When the eyewitnesses affirm that the deceased

was not in a fit and conscious state to make the

statement, the medical opinion cannot prevail.

(5) The law does not provide as to who could record

dying declaration nor there is any prescribed format

or procedure for the same but the person recording

dying declaration must be satisfied that the maker is

in a fit state of mind and is capable of making the

statement

(6) Although presence of a Magistrate is not absolutely

necessary for recording of a dying declaration but to

ensure authenticity and credibility, it is expected

that a Magistrate be requested to record such dying

declaration and/or attestation be obtained from

other persons present at the time of recording the

dying declaration.

(7) As regards a burns case, the percentage and degree

of burns would not, by itself, be decisive of the

credibility of dying declaration; and the decisive

factor would be the quality of evidence about the fit

and conscious state of the declarant to make the

statement.

(8) If after careful scrutiny, the Court finds the

statement placed as dying declaration to be

voluntary and also finds it coherent and consistent,

there is no legal impediment in recording conviction

on its basis even without corroboration”.

19. Having regard to the parameters laid down by the Hon’ble

Supreme Court in case of Laxman (supra) and in case of Purushottam Copra (supra), it is absolutely necessary to examine dying declarations in the form of written as well as oral. In case of Laxman (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has made it clear that oral dying declaration is admissible in evidence and there is no legal bar. There is no requirement of law that a dying declaration must necessarily be made to a Magistrate with certification of doctor about the mental fitness of the patient. What is essentially required is that the person who records a dying declaration must be satisfied that the deceased was in a fit state of mind. A certification by the doctor is essentially a rule of caution and therefore the voluntary and truthful nature of the declaration can be established otherwise.

33. In case of Suresh Arjun Dodorkar (Sonar) Vs. State of

Maharashtra (supra), the Division Bench of this Court, bench at

Aurangabad has observed that, “where there are multiple dying

declarations and acceptance of one dying declaration falsifies the

other, the dying declarations have to be necessarily rejected. The

dying declaration has to pass all the tests of reliability as the declarant is not available for cross examination”.

In the case in hand, there are three oral dying declarations and two written dying declarations. All of them are found to be consistent about the role of the accused in setting his wife ablaze after pouring kerosene from a can in the house when both of them were alone. We are unable to accept the argument advanced by Mr. Chatterji, learned counsel for the appellant/accused in this regard.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 295 OF 2014

Sanjay Maruti Doule Vs  The State of Maharashtra

CORAM : V. K. JADHAV AND

SHRIKANT D. KULKARNI, JJ.

Pronounced on : 08.09.2021

JUDGMENT (PER SHRIKANT D. KULKARNI, J.) :-

Print Page

Saturday, 6 March 2021

Whether the court should disbelieve the dying declaration if the deceased's relatives were present in the hospital when her dying declaration was recorded?

Further, merely

because the parents and other relatives of the deceased

were present in the Hospital, when the statement of the

deceased was recorded, it cannot be said that the said

statement was a tutored one. It is quite natural that

when such an incident happens, the parents and other

relatives try to reach the hospital immediately. Merely

because they were in the hospital, the same is no

ground to disbelieve the dying declaration, recorded by

the Magistrate, who was examined as PW-16.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.261 OF 2021


Satpal  vs.  State of Haryana 


Author: R.SUBHASH REDDY,J.

Dated: March 03, 2021

Print Page

Tuesday, 10 November 2020

Whether court can treat Suicide Note as Dying Declaration?

Whether Suicide Note can be treated as Dying Declaration:


29. Nilesh (P.W.-7), brother of the victim has also produced the suicide note (Ex. P-6) written by the deceased, taken in possession vide memo Ex. P-7 on 23.10.1998 at about 7.30 am. Her dead body was taken in possession on 23.10.1998 vide Memo Ex. P-10. The time of death is mentioned as 22/23.10.1998 before 3.00 am. In the suicide note (Ex. P-6) dated 22.10.1998, she has written that she does not want to live the life of disgrace nor the police will permit her to live gracefully. She has stated that to avoid disgrace to her and her parents, she is taking this step. She stated that it was her fault that she sat in their vehicle. They were drunk and that she sat in their vehicle by mistake and they thought that she is the girl of loose-character. In the suicide note she is categorical that she will not be able to live a life of disgrace. She stated that it will be better if she dies rather than to live a life of disgrace to her and her family members. She has stated that both of the accused had liquor and that whatever has happened to her has disrupted and ruined the life and that she does not want to ruin the life of the boys by punishing them. She was violated on 17.10.1998. She committed suicide after four days. From her suicide note, it is clear that she was violated and that she does not want to live life of disgrace. She has tried to convey that the accused were hungry (for sex) and that she became their food (victim). The entire reading of the dying declaration does not absolve the accused though she said that they be not punished.


30. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant in Lalji Dusadh (supra), was a case of trial for an offence under Sections 392 and 397 of the IPC wherein the dying declaration was found to be admissible. It was held that the words of Section 32 of the Act are very wide and it is not necessary that the charge should be one of homicide. The evidence as to the cause of death was relevant to the charge of robbery and consequently the cause of death i.e. the assault committed by the appellant came in question in the trial. 

36. The suicide note which is a dying declaration and just on the day of writing of such letter and five days of the occurrence, the dead body was taken in possession at about 9.30 a.m. on 23.10.1998 vide memo Ex. P-10 and the time of death is mentioned as 22/23.10.1998 before 3.00 am in the intervening night of 22nd and 23rd October, 1998. However, the suicide note is corroborated by the other evidence on record, which we discuss hereinafter.


37. In view of the evidence on record, the statement Ex. P-6 in the handwriting of the victim proved by Nilesh (P.W.-7) is a dying declaration, as she died on the same day, which fact is evident from the memo Ex. P-10 having been prepared around 9.30 a.m. on 23.10.1998, wherein the time of death is mentioned as "before 3.00 a.m. on 23.10.1998". The argument that the suicide note does not name the accused, is of no consequence, as the presence of the victim with the accused at the place of occurrence is proved from the statement of Kashi Singh (P.W.-1), Kishan Singh (P.W.-4) and also Manoj Sharma (P.W.-14), who recorded the first information report. The suicide note has to be read as a whole and not a line can be picked up from out of context.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH (JABALPUR BENCH)

Criminal Appeal No. 541/2000

Decided On: 01.11.2018

State of Madhya Pradesh Vs.  Mohammad Shahid and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Hemant Gupta, C.J. and Atul Sreedharan, J.

Author:Hemant Gupta, C.J.

Citation: MANU/MP/0583/2018

Print Page