Showing posts with label registration of FIR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label registration of FIR. Show all posts

Sunday, 23 July 2023

Whether Magistrate can direct police to register an offence against Organizer Of Public Meeting if A Participant of said meeting has delivered a Hate Speech?

 (i) The respondent no. 1 had not levelled any allegation against the petitioner in the complaint which he had lodged with the concerned police officials.

(ii) The single line averred by respondent no. 1 against the petitioner in his complaint and application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. filed before the learned Magistrate, on the face of it, does not constitute any offence or make out any case against the petitioner. (iii) Even if the entire allegations made in the complaint lodged with the police or before the learned Magistrate as well as the inquiry conducted by the police in that regard are accepted in their entirety, the same do not disclose commission of any offence by the present petitioner. (iv) The records of the case reveal that the present case is not a case of lack of sufficient evidence against the petitioner, but rather a case with no incriminating material whatsoever against him. (v) Given that the allegations levelled by respondent no. 1 primarily pertain to an alleged hate speech delivered by proposed accused no. 2, and considering that there is no concept of vicarious liability in criminal law regarding such alleged offences, initiating criminal proceedings against the present petitioner would undoubtedly constitute an abuse of the legal process. (vi) The learned Magistrate overlooked the crucial distinction between the duty imposed on the police under Section 154 Cr.P.C. to register an FIR when a complaint reveals a cognizable offence, and the powers vested in Magistrates under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. which necessitates the application of judicial mind and scrutiny of the material on record.

(vii) The impugned order passed by the learned Magistrate reflects lack of application of judicial mind, for the reasons that (a) it fails to record any reasons whatsoever for directing registration of FIR; (b) it does not record as to commission of which cognizable offences was disclosed from the perusal of complaint and application filed before it, against the proposed accused persons; and (c) it fails to acknowledge or refer to the contents of preliminary inquiry conducted by the police and submitted before the concerned Magistrate by way of Action Taken Report, even for the purposes of disagreeing with the same and ordering registration of FIR, even though the learned Magistrate had himself called for the same.

122. The recognized purpose of criminal adjudicatory process is that an accused or a proposed accused, if essentially connected to incriminating evidence in a complaint, should be brought within the ambit of law. However, an unmeritorious complaint containing no incriminating material against an accused should not result in orders of registration of FIRs as such proceedings will certainly amount to abuse of process of criminal law.

123. The duty that a Court of law owes to its citizens who approach them as litigants is protected when the material placed on record which reveals commission of a cognizable offence is acted upon. While doing so, the Courts have to be cautious in identifying cases where such material is absent and protecting an accused or proposed accused by way of a reasoned order to avoid abuse of process of law. Absence of reasons brings into question the propriety of an order being not based on judicial precedents, material on record or reasons for its conclusion. The Courts should embrace the method of passing a reasoned order based on judicial precedents and law as well as the material placed before it, which is reflected in its order or judgments. Through such reasoned orders, the Courts can order for registration of FIR against persons who cross criminal boundaries without lawful justification, or conversely, reject such applications where it seems that the accused or proposed accused can be a possible victim of abuse of process of law by initiation of criminal proceedings.


127. However, it is also to be kept in mind that a person against whom FIR is being ordered to be registered for no reason will have his reputation at stake. In cases as the present one, against this backdrop, this Court finds merit in the present petition since the complaint filed before the learned Magistrate did not fulfil the criteria of presence of incriminating material disclosing any connection of the petitioner with the alleged act of organising the speech delivered by one Swami ji, whose identity also remains unknown.

130. It is to be noted at the cost of repetition that the complaint qua the present petitioner was not a case of insufficient material but of no material at all. The Court also takes note of the fact that though the Magistrate mentions that from perusal of the complaint, commission of cognizable offence is revealed there is no allegation in the entire complaint itself or in the Action Taken Report about any act of commission or omission on part of the present petitioner.

131. This Court is, therefore, constrained to observe that the Magisterial power may be unlimited but it is not unfettered and should be used not only with utmost caution and vigilance, but also with circumspection after carefully going through the contents of the complaint and the Action Taken Report, if any, filed by the police.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI 

CRL.M.C. 1463/2020 & CRL.M.A. 5732/2020

 ALOK KUMAR Vs HARSH MANDER & ANR.

 CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA J

 Pronounced on: 21.07.2023 

Index to the Judgment

FACTUAL BACKDROP ...................................................................................... 3

ARGUMENTS OF THE PETITIONER ........................................................... 10

ARGUMENTS OF THE RESPONDENTS ....................................................... 13

WHEN CAN A MAGISTRATE DIRECT REGISTRATION OF FIR .......... 15

I. Law of Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. ....................................................................... 15

II. Essential Pre-conditions While Directing Registration of FIR under Section 156(3) ..................................................................................................................... 21

(i) Disclosure of Cognizable Offence .......................................................... 21

(ii) Application of Judicial Mind ................................................................... 23

(iii) Necessity to pass Speaking Order ........................................................... 28

EXAMINING THE PRESENT CASE ON THE TOUCHSTONE OF ABOVE INGREDIENTS .................................................................................................... 29

I. Preliminary Inquiry in Present Case: Examining Action Taken Report ........ 30

II. Whether commission of cognizable offences are disclosed against the petitioner? .............................................................................................................. 33

(i) Function of Pleadings .......................................................................... 39

III. Whether impugned order reflects application of judicial mind? ................... 40

(i) Importance of Reasoned Order ............................................................ 45

LAW ON VICARIOUS LIABILITY IN CRIMINAL CASES ........................ 50

UNLIMITED MAGISTERIAL POWER DOES NOT MEAN UNFETTERED POWER .................................................................................... 56

POWERS OF THE HIGH COURT UNDER SECTION 482 CR.P.C. ........... 57

I. Judicial Precedents in a Nutshell ..................................................................... 58

II. What is Abuse of Process of Law ................................................................... 63

III. Sufficiency or Insufficiency of Incriminating material viz. Abuse of Process of Law… ................................................................................................................ 64

IV. Striking balance between interest of the complainant and reputational injury to the unheard proposed accused ........................................................................... 65

THE CONCLUSION OF THE COURT ............................................................ 66

BEFORE PARTING WITH THIS CASE… ..................................................... 69

Print Page

Thursday, 20 June 2019

Whether Magistrate should follow principles laid down by Supreme Court for registration of FIR against doctors under S. 156(3) CrPC?

The principle of law laid down by the Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew(supra) and Martin F. D'Souza (supra) for registration of criminal case against a doctor before registering an FIR under Section 154(1) of the CrPC by getting an expert opinion from a qualified doctor would apply with equal force while registering/directing for registration of offence under Section 156(3) of the CrPC, because it is also another mode of getting the FIR registered for which the person concerned has failed to get the FIR registered under Sections 154(1) & 154(3) of the CrPC, as by virtue of Section 156(1) of the CrPC, it is the power and jurisdiction of the police officer to investigate any cognizable offence without the order of the Magistrate and by virtue of Section 156(3) of the CrPC, the Magistrate is empowered under Section 190 to order such an investigation as mentioned in Section 156(3) of the CrPC. Therefore, before directing investigation and registration of FIR under Section 156(3) of the CrPC, the principle of law laid down by the Supreme Court in Jacob Mathew (para-52) (supra) and Martin F. D'Souza(para-106) (supra) is mandatory and has to be followed before directing investigation against medical professionals by obtaining medical opinion from experts is sine qua non for direction of registration and investigation of offence against medical practitioners. Thus, the course open to the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate is to call for the medical opinion of experts in line with and as per the direction in Jacob Mathew (supra) and Martin F. D'Souza (supra) before entertaining an application under Section 156(3) of the CrPC and directing registration of FIR and investigation against medical professional, which was not followed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate while granting the application under Section 156(3) of the CrPC making the order vulnerable.

In the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur
(Before Sanjay K. Agrawal, J.)

Dr. Smt. Krishna Dixit  v. State of Chhattisgarh,

Writ Petition (Cr.) No. 146 of 2016
Decided on May 14, 2019
Citation: 2019 SCC OnLine Chh 47
Print Page

Wednesday, 6 July 2016

Whether police can register FIR even if it is not specifically directed by Magistrate?

In view of the aforesaid broad consensus amongst
the counsel for the various parties, it is not
necessary for us to go deeper into the relevant issue
of law as to whether the earlier order of this Court
dated April 12,2010 warranted registering of F.I.R.
by the police before commencing investigation. But
we would like to only indicate in brief the law on

this subject expressly stated by this Court in the
case of Mohd. Yousuf versus Afaq Jahan (Smt.) and
another, (2006) 1 SCC 627. This Court explained that
registration of an F.I.R. involves only the process
of recording the substance of information relating to
commission of any cognizable offence in a book kept
by the officer incharge of the concerned police
station. In paragraph 11 of the aforementioned case,
the law was further elucidated by pointing out that
to enable the police to start investigation, it is
open to the Magistrate to direct the police to
register an F.I.R. and even where a Magistrate does
not do so in explicit words but directs for
investigation under Section 156(3) of the Code, the
police should register an F.I.R. Because Section 156
falls within chapter XII of the Code which deals with
powers of the police officers to investigate
cognizable offences, the police officer concerned
would always be in a better position to take further
steps contemplated in Chapter XII once F.I.R. is
registered in respect of the concerned cognizable
offence.
REPORTABLE
 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
 CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 110 OF 2016

HAMANT YASHWANT DHAGE
 V
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 
Dated:February 10, 2016
Citation:(2016) 6 SCC273

SHIVA KIRTI SINGH, J.
Print Page

Saturday, 30 June 2012

Whether Police Officer Can Refuse To Register Complaint On The Ground Of Territorial Jurisdiction?

Police officer cannot refuse to register complaint on ground that concerned police station had not territorial jurisdiction over place of crime. He has to record information and forward same to police station having jurisdiction. Non- registration of FIR by police officer is dereliction of statutory duty enjoined upon him. Endorsement by police officer directing petitioner to file complaint in appropriate police station being erroneous and unsustainable in law and liable to be quashed.

High Court of Karnataka
B. S. Sundaresh Vs. State of Karnataka
Print Page