Showing posts with label remission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label remission. Show all posts

Sunday, 27 September 2026

Bombay HC explains the concept of family feud for the purpose of grant of remission to convict

The term “family feud” as understood in common parlance and as per the meaning given in various dictionaries, essentially means a long-standing dispute between members of a family or between two families. The expression “family” has a broad meaning. It includes not just blood relatives but also relatives by affinity and those connected by law, extending up to various generations. Thus, a feud can arise even within the extended family. A family feud does not necessarily mean a dispute that has been going on for generations. When a prior dispute between family members of the same generation becomes the reason for a subsequent offence, the resulting conflict certainly amounts to a family feud.

{Para 16}

Considering the facts of the case and the above noted meaning of the word "family feud", the case of the petitioner will fall in category 3(b) which deals with "Murders arising out of Land Dispute, Family Feuds, Family Prestige, and Superstition, committed with premeditation" and not in 2(c), which deals with "offences relating to crime against women and minor, committed with exceptional violence and or with brutality".

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Writ Petition No. 364 of 2026

Decided On: 09.09.2026

Devidas Vs. State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sandip Kumar Chandrabhan More and Vaishali Patil Jadhav, JJ.

Author: Vaishali Patil Jadhav, J.

Citation: 2026:BHC-AUG:41949-DB,MANU/MH/5860/2026

Print Page

Saturday, 8 November 2025

The Judicial Appraisal Imperative: When Prison Authorities Must Answer to the Courts for Punishing Parole Violators

 A Comprehensive Guide to Section 48A of the Prisons Act and Rule 23-A of the Remission Rules Under Maharashtra Law

Introduction

When a prisoner fails to return from parole or furlough on the stipulated date, prison authorities often move quickly to impose punishment—cutting remission, forfeiting privileges, or reducing grade. But do they have unfettered discretion? The answer, established through landmark judicial pronouncements, is an emphatic no.

The doctrine of Judicial Appraisal stands as the sentinel guarding prisoners’ rights against arbitrary administrative action. Under this regime, no punishment for breach of parole or furlough conditions can be imposed without the prior review and blessing of the Sessions Judge. This article dissects the legal position, procedural requirements, and judicial philosophy that animate Section 48A of the Prisons Act, 1894 and Rule 23-A of the Maharashtra Prisons (Remission System) Rules, 1962 (as amended in 2011), with particular emphasis on the seminal judgment in Vishal Baban Vanne v. The State of Maharashtra (Bombay High Court, 30 January 2019).
Print Page

Bombay HC: What is the role of Judicial appraisal by the Session Judge in cases involving the punishment to prisoners by prison authorities?

 We, therefore, direct the respondents to punctually place before the District and Sessions Judge the case papers in matters of imposition of punishment for appraisal. In case the District and Sessions Judge finds any error of law in the order of punishment or notices any serious infirmity then the same shall be immediately brought to the notice of the concerned authorities so that the purpose of placing the relevant papers before the District and Sessions Judge is served. The respondents - prison authorities shall maintain appropriate record of the same. The matters in which punishments are imposed shall be dealt with diligently and the papers thereof shall be placed for appraisal and sanction without much loss of time. {Para 20}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY(AURANGABAD BENCH)

Sanjay S/O. Madhukar Kini Vs. State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

Criminal Writ Petition No. 637 of 2007

14th March, 2008

Coram: NARESH H. PATIL AND P.R. BORKAR, JJ.

Citation: 2008 ALL MR (Cri) 994.

Print Page

Friday, 14 March 2025

LLM Notes: Life Imprisonment in Indian Law: Statutory Provisions and Landmark Judgments

 Introduction

Life imprisonment in India is a significant form of punishment under the criminal justice system, often imposed for heinous crimes such as murder, terrorism, and kidnapping. While it is considered less severe than the death penalty, life imprisonment entails prolonged incarceration, often for the convict's entire natural life. This article explores the statutory provisions governing life imprisonment in India and examines landmark judgments that have shaped its interpretation.

  1. : This section categorizes punishments under the IPC, including "imprisonment for life." Life imprisonment is defined as incarceration until the convict's death unless commuted by the appropriate government.

Print Page

Saturday, 1 February 2025

Supreme Court: The power to impose a modified punishment providing for any specific term of incarceration or till the end of the convict's life as an alternate to death penalty, can be exercised only by the High Court and the Supreme Court.

 This Court, while exercising its appellate jurisdiction

under Article 136 of the Constitution of India,

possesses the authority to scrutinize not only the

conviction of an accused but also the

appropriateness of the sentence imposed. As

articulated in the principles laid down in Swamy

Shraddananda 1, the power to impose or modify a

sentence within the prescribed framework of the

Penal Code is exclusively vested in the High Court

and this Court. The alternate punishment for

offences punishable by death, such as imprisonment

for a specific term exceeding 14 years or until the

natural life of the convict, remains within the judicial

conscience of this Court and the High Court. This

ensures that the gravity of the offence, the mitigating

and aggravating circumstances, and the possibility of

reformation are thoroughly assessed before

irrevocable sentences such as capital punishment

are affirmed. Therefore, the commutation of a death

sentence to imprisonment for the remainder of the

convict’s natural life, as an alternative to death, is

well within the judicial prerogative of this Court and

adheres to the constitutional mandate of ensuring

justice. 

105. We, therefore, reiterate that the power

derived from the Penal Code for any modified

punishment within the punishment provided for

in the Penal Code for such specified offences can

only be exercised by the High Court and in the

event of further appeal only by the Supreme

Court and not by any other court in this

country. To put it differently, the power to

impose a modified punishment providing for any

specific term of incarceration or till the end of

the convict's life as an alternate to death

penalty, can be exercised only by the High Court

and the Supreme Court and not by any other

inferior court.

 106. Viewed in that respect, we state that the

ratio laid down in Swamy Shraddananda (2)

[Swamy Shraddananda (2) v. State of

Karnataka, (2008) 13 SCC 767 : (2009) 3 SCC

(Cri) 113] that a special category of sentence;

instead of death; for a term exceeding 14 years

and put that category beyond application of

remission is well founded and we answer the

said question in the affirmative. We are,

therefore, not in agreement with the opinion

expressed by this Court in Sangeet v. State of

Haryana [Sangeet v. State of Haryana, (2013) 2

SCC 452 : (2013) 2 SCC (Cri) 611] that the

deprival of remission power of the appropriate

Government by awarding sentences of 20 or 25

years or without any remission as not

permissible is not in consonance with the law

and we specifically overrule the same.”

NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS.2220-2221 OF 2022

DEEN DAYAL TIWARI  Vs STATE OF

UTTAR PRADESH 

Citation: 2025 INSC 111.

Dated: JANUARY 16, 2025.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Monday, 26 August 2024

Bombay HC: Special remission due to birth anniversary of Dr. Ambedkar is not available to convict who were not in jail as on 14.04.2016 or whose appeals were not pending

We are in agreement with the decisions in Akash S/o

Devanand Tempe (supra) and Rameshwar s/o Chunnilal Hardule

(supra). The said GR was issued with a particular purpose as a

special remission scheme and it was made available to those

convicts, who were in jail as on 14.04.2016 or whose appeals are

pending but they are released on bail on suspension of sentence. It was the special occasion i.e. 125th Birth Anniversary of late Dr.

Babasaheb Ambedkar. Whether to grant a special remission or in

other words granting remission under special scheme is within the prerogative of the State Government. Even otherwise also the

wording of the GR dated 03.06.2017 was sufficient to infer that it

was applicable to those category of persons only, but now the

clarification has been given on 20.02.2024, it has to be considered. {Para 7}

8. As the conviction awarded to the present petitioner is in the

case that came to be registered in 2019 and the judgment is

pronounced on 07.02.2020, the scheme is not applicable to him.

After considering the communication dated 04.07.2023 given by the learned Principal District and Sessions Judge, Gondia, it can be seen that the offence took place on 01.06.2019, that means on the day when the GR was issued i.e. on 03.06.2017, the offence was not even committed and therefore, it cannot be said that the said GR is applicable to the present petitioner. The present petition is devoid of merits and therefore, deserves to be dismissed and accordingly, it is dismissed.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.865 OF 2023

 Sonu alias Ashwin S/o Vitthal Meshram Vs  State of Maharashtra, 

CORAM : SMT. VIBHA KANKANWADI

 & MRS. VRUSHALI V. JOSHI, JJ.

 PRONOUNCED ON : 01.08.2024

JUDGMENT : (PER : SMT. VIBHA KANKANWADI, J )
Print Page

Tuesday, 2 July 2024

Important Supreme Court and Bombay HC judgments on Remission of convict

 

1) Supreme court guidelines for releasing convict prematurely on remission


This Court also issued certain guidelines as to the basis on which a convict can be released prematurely and they are as under:

1. Whether the offence is an individual act of crime without affecting the society at large.

2. Whether there is any fruitful purpose of confining of this convict anymore.

3. Whether there is any chance of future recurrence of committing crime.

4. Whether the convict has lost his potentiality in committing crime.

5. Socio-economic condition of the convict's family. {Para 6}.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 110 of 2000

Decided On: 01.09.2000

Life Convict Laxman Laskar Vs. State of West Bengal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S. Rajendra Babu and Shivaraj V. Patil, JJ.

Author: S. Rajendra Babu, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/3130/2000,(2000)7 SCC 626.

https://www.lawweb.in/2024/06/supreme-court-guidelines-for-releasing.html

Print Page

Wednesday, 26 June 2024

Supreme court guidelines for releasing convict prematurely on remission

This Court also issued certain guidelines as to the basis on which a convict can be released prematurely and they are as under:

1. Whether the offence is an individual act of crime without affecting the society at large.

2. Whether there is any fruitful purpose of confining of this convict anymore.

3. Whether there is any chance of future recurrence of committing crime.

4. Whether the convict has lost his potentiality in committing crime.

5. Socio-economic condition of the convict's family. {Para 6}

 If we look at the reasons given by the Government, we are afraid that the same are palpably irrelevant or devoid of substance. Firstly, the views of the witnesses who had been examined in the case or the persons in the locality cannot determine whether the Petitioner would be a danger if prematurely released because the persons in the locality and the witnesses may still live in the past and their memories are being relied upon without reference to the present and the report of the jail authorities to the effect that the Petitioner has reformed himself to a large extent. Secondly, by reason of one's age, one cannot say whether the convict has still potentiality of committing the crime or not, but it depends on his attitude to matters, which is not being taken note of by the Government. Lastly, the suggestion that the incident is not an individual act of crime but a sequel of the political feud affecting society at large, whether his political views have been changed or still carries the same so as to commit crime has not been examined by the Government. {Para 8}

9. On the basis of the grounds stated above, the Government could not have rejected the claim made by the Petitioner.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 110 of 2000

Decided On: 01.09.2000

Life Convict Laxman Laskar Vs. State of West Bengal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S. Rajendra Babu and Shivaraj V. Patil, JJ.

Author: S. Rajendra Babu, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/3130/2000,(2000)7 SCC 626.

Print Page

Supreme Court: What factors are to be considered while deciding application for remission of convict?

 To consider the prayer for premature release of the "life convicts" , police report was called for on the following points:

(i) Whether the offence is an individual act of crime without affecting the society at large;

(ii) Whether there is any chance of future recurrence of committing crime;

(iii) Whether the convict has lost his potentiality in committing crime;

(iv) Whether there is any fruitful purpose of confining this convict any more;

(v) Socio-economic condition of the convict's family.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Writ Petition (Criminal) Nos. 64, 120, 121, 122, 123 and 181 of 1999

Decided On: 15.02.2000

Laxman Naskar Vs. Union of India (UOI) and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.T. Nanavati and S.N. Phukan, JJ.

Author: S.N. Phukan, J.

Citation:  2000 INSC 69, MANU/SC/0084/2000,(2000) 2 SCC 595

Print Page

Bombay HC: It is the duty of prison authorities who seek opinion of Session judge for deciding remission application of convict to place before him all necessary documents

 The presiding officers, when such opinion is called from them, should be armed with all the necessary documents and it would be then the job of the prison authorities, who call their opinion to place before them the necessary documents including the behaviour of the convict while undergoing imprisonment. We take this opportunity to give directions to the respondents as well as to the presiding officers/the judges from whom the opinion is sought under Section 432(2) of the Cr.P.C.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.950 OF 2022

Bharat s/o Fakira Dhivar Vs  The State of Maharashtra,

WITH

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.1001 OF 2022

Bhagwan s/o Ranoji Patole Vs State of Maharashtra,

CORAM : SMT. VIBHA KANKANWADI AND

ABHAY S. WAGHWASE, JJ.

DATE : NOVEMBER 22, 2022.

ORDER :- [Per Smt. Vibha Kankanwadi, J.]

Print Page

Wednesday, 29 May 2024

Bombay HC: Factors which Session Judge should consider while giving his opinion regarding remission of convict

It is thus apparent that except the

prisoners of these categories the rest of the

prisoners are entitled to the benefit of

remission under this Government Resolution

dated 3rd June, 2017.

4] Ex facie, the petitioner, who is a

prisoner undergoing a sentence of 23 years

imprisonment, does not fall into any of these

categories. Still, the learned Additional

Sessions Judge in his opinion dated 17th July,

2017, has overlooked these aspects and for

the reasons de hors the Government Resolution

has opined that the petitioner is not

entitled to any remission. He seems to have

misdirected himself in considering the

gravity of the crime when the Government

Resolution does not admit of any such

parameter for extending the benefit. Even a

life convict is entitled to remission to the

extent of three months. It is also apparent

that the learned Additional Sessions Judge

for the reasons best known to him has not at

all referred to the Government Resolution

dated 3rd June, 2017. Had his attention been

brought to it, we are sure the learned Judge

would not have given a negative opinion. Be

that as it may, the opinion expressed by the

learned Additional Sessions Judge in

ignorance of or by overlooking the Government

Resolution is clearly faulty.

5] In the light of discussion herein

above, the Petition is partly allowed. The

matter is remitted back to the Additional

Sessions Judge, Ahmednagar, for reconsideration.

The Additional Sessions Judge, Ahmednagar, to

 reconsider the entire issue,

keeping in view the Government Resolution

dated 3rd June, 2017, and take decision as

expeditiously as possible, however, within

eight weeks from the date of receipt of this

order.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.1710 OF 2018

Santosh s/o. Suryabhan Kale Vs  The State of Maharashtra,

CORAM: S.S.SHINDE & R.G.AVACHAT,JJ.

Pronounced on : 08.02.2019

JUDGMENT: [Per S.S.Shinde, J.]:

Print Page

Tuesday, 28 May 2024

What is the duty of Session Judge after receipt of application of convict for remission through Superintendent of Prison?

 Similarly, it was incumbent upon the learned

Addition Sessions Judge, Akot either to call for required

information in the context of the facts stated in the application

from the Superintendent of Central Prison, Amravati or give his

opinion immediately on receipt of the application. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 83 OF 2020

Akshay Kailasrao Purohit (In Jail) Vs  State of Maharashtra,

CORAM : A. S. CHANDURKAR AND G. A. SANAP, JJ.

DATED : 27.08.2021

O R A L J U D G M E N T (Per : G. A. Sanap, J.)
Print Page

Whether Govt GR regarding special remission on account of 125th Birth Anniversary of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar is applicable to person convicted of offence of rape or POCSO Act?

  The GR dated 03.06.2017 carves out six categories which have been excluded from the applicability of GR. Apparently, the offence of rape or POCSO Act does not fall in the exceptional category. The learned Trial Court has misread the said GR while opining that due to seriousness of offence, the petitioner is not eligible. Apparently, the reason accorded by the Sessions Judge is not in consonance with the said GR and thus, the denial is unjust and arbitrary.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY :

NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR.

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 579/2023

Nitin s/o Shamraoji Pawnikar,  Vs State of Maharashtra,

CORAM : VINAY JOSHI AND

MRS. VRUSHALI V. JOSHI , JJ .

DATE : 19.01.2024.

ORAL JUDGMENT (PER VINAY JOSHI, J.) :
Print Page

When the convict is not entitled to get benefit of Govt GR regarding special remission on account of 125th Birth Anniversary of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar?

 The petitioner has applied for special remission on account of 125th Birth Anniversary of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar which fell on 14.04.2016. The special remission has been claimed in pursuance of related Government Resolution dated 03.06.2017. 

6. The facts are quite clear that on the cutoff date i.e. on 14.04.2016, the petitioner was not in jail and thus, he is not eligible for the special remission in terms of Government Resolution dated 03.06.2017.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 857 OF 2023

Akash S/o. Devanand Tempe Vs  State of Maharashtra

CORAM : VINAY JOSHI AND

MRS. VRUSHALI V. JOSHI, JJ.

DATE : 21.02.2024

ORAL JUDGMENT (PER : VINAY JOSHI , J.) :-

Print Page

Wednesday, 24 January 2024

Basic concept of remission and commutation of sentence of convict and distinction between them

 In the context of the Criminal Procedure Code (CRPC) in India, the concepts of remission and commutation of a sentence pertain to the modification of a convict's punishment. Here are the basic concepts and distinctions between remission and commutation:

Basic Concepts:

  1. Remission of Sentence:

    • Definition: Remission refers to the reduction or mitigation of the term of imprisonment without changing the nature of the sentence.
    • Authority: The power to remit a sentence is typically vested in the executive branch of the government, often exercised by the Governor or the President, depending on the nature of the offense.
    • Purpose: Remission is usually granted based on factors such as good conduct during imprisonment, completion of a certain percentage of the sentence, or humanitarian considerations.
    • Outcome: The primary outcome of remission is a reduction in the actual duration of imprisonment, allowing the convict to be released earlier than initially sentenced.
  2. Commutation of Sentence:

    • Definition: Commutation involves the substitution of a milder form of punishment for a more severe one, changing the nature of the sentence.
Print Page

Friday, 28 October 2022

Can the state seek enhancement of the accused's sentence if it is granting remission to the accused?

  Learned counsel for respondent/accused has

vehemently contended that the State has compelled the

accused to withdraw the appeal in order to get remission

under the provisions of the Karnataka Prisons Rules, 1974.

But in these Rules, there is no provision to show that

remission cannot be granted in case of any pendency of the

appeal. It is argued by the learned counsel for

respondent/accused that there is a practice for refusing the

remission in case of pendency of the appeal but no evidence

is placed to show that any such practice is being followed.

Further, the remission is under statute and pendency of

appeal has no relevancy and in any event accused is going to

get the benefit of remission if he is entitled under law. Under

such circumstances, the said arguments do not have any

relevancy and cannot be accepted. When the remission is

granted under the statute, it cannot lie in the mouth of the

accused that the State is taking dual stand regarding granting

remission and also seeking enhancement of the sentence. It

is to be noted here that remission is granted under the

statute. The enhancement of sentence is also sought only

under the statute wherein minimum sentence is prescribed.

Hence, there is no inconsistency with each other. The

arguments advanced by the learned counsel regarding

doctrine of legitimate expectation cannot be made applicable

to the facts and circumstances of the case in hand. In this

context, learned counsel for respondent has placed reliance

on a decision of the Delhi High Court in W.P.(C)

No.4760/2010 dated 12.11.2010 but the facts and

circumstances of the said case are entirely different and it was

pertaining to educational qualification and seat matrix. It has

nothing to do with the present case and as such, the doctrine

of legitimate expectation cannot be applied in the instant case

as the remission was granted under the statute and

enhancement of sentence is also being sought only under the

statute. Even if the sentence is enhanced, the remission will

not be taken away and the accused will get the remission and

Rule 36(8) of Karnataka Prisons Rules 1974 which deals with

re-admission and earning remission thereunder. Under such

circumstances, these rules are not contradictory to each

other.{Para 23}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

DHARWAD BENCH

CRL.A. NO.100242/2018

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA Vs SHANKAR URF SHANKRAPPA S/O RAMPPA HUBBALLI,

PRESENT

 MR. JUSTICE H.T.NARENDRA PRASAD

AND

 MR. JUSTICE RAJENDRA BADAMIKAR

Author: RAJENDRA BADAMIKAR, J. 

DATED:  22ND DAY OF APRIL 2022.

Read full Judgment here: Click here

Print Page

Karnataka HC: POCSO Act has an overriding Effect in Case Of Inconsistency and is not in Derogation of Any Other Law

  Section 376(2) (i) of IPC is pertaining to rape of a

woman when she is under sixteen years of age. Even under

Section 376(2)(i) of IPC, the minimum sentence imposed is

10 years. {Para 14}

15. Section 42 of POCSO Act deals with alternative

sentence which reads as under:

“42. Alternate punishment

Where an act or omission constitutes an

offence punishable under this Act and also under

sections 166A, 354A, 354B, 354C, 354D, 370,

370A, 375, 376, 376A, 376AB,376B, 376C, 376D,

376DA, 376DB, 376E or section 509 of the Indian

Penal Code, then, notwithstanding anything

contained in any law for the time being in force, the

offender found guilty of such offence shall be liable

to punishment under this Act or under the Indian

Penal Code as provides for punishment which is

greater in degree.”

16. Further, Section 42A makes it clear that act is not

in derogation of any other law and if there is any

inconsistency with any other law for the time being in force,

the provisions of POCSO Act shall have overriding effect. In

the instant case, there is no inconsistency as the offence

under Section 376(2)(i) as well as Section 6 of POCSO Act are

punishable with minimum imprisonment of ten years. But the

judgment discloses that though the Trial Court has considered

Section 42 of POCSO Act, it has proceeded to impose

sentence of 7 years with fine of Rs.30,000/- with default

clause of RI for two years. This is against the statute and the

State is harping on this point.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

DHARWAD BENCH

CRL.A. NO.100242/2018

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA Vs SHANKAR URF SHANKRAPPA S/O RAMPPA HUBBALLI,

PRESENT

 MR. JUSTICE H.T.NARENDRA PRASAD

AND

 MR. JUSTICE RAJENDRA BADAMIKAR

Author: RAJENDRA BADAMIKAR, J. 

DATED:  22ND DAY OF APRIL 2022

Print Page

Saturday, 23 April 2022

Supreme Court: Factors which Judge should consider while giving Opinion for Remission of sentence of convict U/Sec 433(2) CrPC

 In Laxman Naskar v. Union of India (2000) 2 SCC 595, this Court laid down that the following factors must be reported by the police in respect of the grant of pre-mature release:

(a) Whether the offence is an individual act of crime that does not affect the society;

(b) Whether there is a chance of the crime being repeated in future;

(c) Whether the convict has lost the potentiality to commit crime;

(d) Whether any purpose is being served in keeping the convict in prison; and

(e) Socio-economic conditions of the convict’s family.

21. However, this is not to say that the appropriate government should mechanically follow the opinion of the presiding judge. If the opinion of the presiding judge does not comply with the requirements of Section 432 (2) or if the judge does not consider the relevant factors for grant of remission that have been laid down in Laxman Naskar v. Union of India (supra), the government may request the presiding judge to consider the matter afresh.

22. In the present case, there is nothing to indicate that the presiding judge took into account the factors which have been laid down in Laxman Naskar v. Union of India (supra). These factors include assessing (i) whether the offence affects the society at large; (ii) the probability of the crime being repeated; (iii) the potential of the convict to commit crimes in future; (iv) if any fruitful purpose is being served by keeping the convict in prison; and (v) the socio-economic condition of the convict’s family. In Laxman Naskar v. State of West Bengal (supra) and State of Haryana v. Jagdish17, this Court has reiterated that these factors will be considered while deciding the application of a convict for premature release.

25. In view of the above discussion, we hold that the petitioner’s application for remission should be re-considered. We direct the Special Judge, Durg to provide an opinion on the application afresh accompanied by adequate reasoning that takes into consideration all the relevant factors that govern the grant of remission as laid down in Laxman Naskar v. Union of India (supra). The Special Judge, Durg must provide his opinion within a month of the date of the receipt of this order. 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD; ANIRUDDHA BOSE, JJ.

Writ Petition (Crl) No 49 of 2022

Ram Chander Vs The State of Chhattisgarh & Anr.

Author: Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, J

Dated:  April 22, 2022.

Citation: (2022) 12 SCC 52.

Print Page

Thursday, 20 August 2020

P& H HC: Trial court can not award life imprisonment with the rider that it shall continue for rest of his natural life or rule out remission

 The legal position with regard to the power of the trial Courts to award
sentences with riders has been made explicit in the Constitution Bench
judgment of the Supreme Court in V. Sriharan (supra) in paras 103 to 105,
in the following words:
“103. That apart, in most of such cases where death
penalty or life imprisonment is the punishment imposed
by the trial Court and confirmed by the Division Bench of
the High Court, the concerned convict will get an
opportunity to get such verdict tested by filing further
appeal by way of Special Leave to this Court. By way of
abundant caution and as per the prescribed law of the
Code and the criminal jurisprudence, we can assert that
after the initial finding of guilt of such specified grave
offences and the imposition of penalty either death or life

imprisonment when comes under the scrutiny of the
Division Bench of the High Court, it is only the High
Court which derives the power under the Penal Code,
which prescribes the capital and alternate
punishment, to alter the said punishment with one
either for the entirety of the convict's life or for any
specific period of more than 14 years, say 20, 30 or so
on depending upon the gravity of the crime committed
and the exercise of judicial conscience befitting such
offence found proved to have been committed.
104. We, therefore, reiterate that, the power derived from
the Penal Code for any modified punishment within the
punishment provided for in the Penal Code for such
specified offences can only be exercised by the High
Court and in the event of further appeal only by the
Supreme Court and not by any other Court in this
country. To put it differently, the power to impose a
modified punishment providing for any specific term
of incarceration or till the end of the convict's life as
an alternate to death penalty, can be exercised only by
the High Court and the Supreme Court and not by
any other inferior Court.

11. Thus, after the judgment of the Constitution Bench of the Supreme
Court in V. Sriharan (supra), it is not open to a court inferior to the High
Court and Supreme Court, while awarding a sentence of life imprisonment
under the Indian Penal Code to further provide for any specific term of
incarceration, or till the end of a convict’s life, or to direct that there shall
be no remission, as an alternate to the death penalty. That power is

available only with the High Courts and the Supreme Court. Consequently,
the trial Court, in the instant case, while awarding the Petitioner the
sentence of rigorous imprisonment for life could not have added the riders
that it should be for the rest of her natural life or that she would not be
entitled to any remission.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
CRWP-5238-2020 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 19th August, 2020

SAVITRI Vs  STATE OF HARYANA 

CORAM: JUSTICE S. MURALIDHAR
JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
Author:  Dr. S. Muralidhar, J.
Print Page

Sunday, 14 April 2019

What is object of judicial appraisal by Judge while grant remission to prisoner?

 As observed earlier, in the case of State of Haryana Vs.
Mohinder Singh & Ors (supra), the decision to grant remission has to be
reasonable and fair to all the concerned and that the grant of remission is
statutory. The object of providing for judicial appraisal is to ensure that the
Order or the Policy or the Rules of the State Government for grant of
remissions are applied and implemented reasonably and fairly. When a
Judicial Officer makes a judicial appraisal of the entitlement of the prisoner
for grant of the State remission under the said Government Circular, the
scope of judicial appraisal is to examine whether the case of the prisoner is
covered by the Order contained in the said Government
Resolution/Circular.
11] In the present case, we find that the learned Additional Sessions
Judge has not even adverted to the said Government Circular with a view
to ascertain whether the petitioner is entitled to the benefit of remission.
He has merely observed that considering the nature of the offence
committed by the petitioner, he should be denied remission.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.1414 OF 2018

Satish Dada Londhe Vs The State of Maharashtra 


CORAM : A.S. OKA & A.S.GADKARI, J.J.
DATE : 1st February 2019.
(Per A.S. Oka, J.)
Print Page