Showing posts with label second application. Show all posts
Showing posts with label second application. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 March 2023

Under which circumstances second application U/S 97 of CRPC is maintainable?


If the Court ultimately holds that keeping of

the child in the manner alleged in the subsequent

application, in fact amounts to illegal confinement, then

the same cannot be restricted to any particular date.

Therefore, in particular, looking at the statutory intent

behind enactment of Section 97 of Cr.P.C. it can be safely

held that in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the

present case, the filing of the subsequent application

cannot be treated as barred by law. Moreover, as has been

argued by Mr. Pattanayak, there is no concept of res

judicata in criminal jurisprudence. From the facts

narrated hereinbefore, it is evident that there is dispute

between the petitioner and her husband and that their 2

and ½ years child (at the relevant time) was alleged taken

away forcibly by opposite party no.3 and the petitioner

was not allowed to meet her child. Further, the child is

said to be kept confined to a room and there is also some

danger to its life. Now, whether the allegation as above is

correct and/or whether this would amount to wrongful

confinement of the child would depend on the facts and

circumstances of the case but it would suffice to say that

if the allegations leveled by the petitioner are accepted on

their face value, the possibility of such offence having

been/being committed cannot entirely be ruled out.

Reference to Section 340 of IPC would be apposite at this

stage which reads as follows:

“340. Wrongful confinement.—Whoever

wrongfully restrains any person in such a

manner as to prevent that person from

proceedings beyond certain circumscribing

limits, is said “wrongfully to confine” that

person.”

It all depends on the facts and circumstances of the case.

To such extent therefore, this Court is of the considered

view that the second application filed under Section 97 of

Cr.P.C. by the petitioner was maintainable. {Para 5}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

CRLREV No. 196 of 2022

Amrita Ray  Vs State of Odisha and Others

CORAM:

JUSTICE SASHIKANTA MISHRA

Dated: 7th February, 2023

Print Page

Wednesday, 1 March 2017

When second application for rejection of plaint is maintainable?

By the impugned order the learned Court below rejected the second application of the defendant petitioner for rejection of the plaint filed in the suit on the ground that on rejection of the earlier application under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code no such second application lies under the same provision. The learned Court below held that the aforementioned order dated March 31, 2015 passed by this Court in C.O. 1093 of 2015 not having been assailed by the defendant anywhere is binding on it. It was contended on behalf of the plaintiff opposite party that the said finding of the learned Court below is the correct exposition of law. However, no decision or authority was cited before me to support the said finding of the learned Court below. However, it is to be noted the reasoned decision by which this Court held the earlier application of the defendant petitioner under Order VII Rule 11 to be not maintainable was passed in C.O. 1092 of 2015 and not in C.O. 1093 of 2015 as recorded in the impugned order. In the facts of the present case already discussed above, it is evident that the grounds urged by the defendant petitioner in the second application for rejection of plaint and the ground urged in his said earlier application decided by this Court in the aforementioned earlier revisional application are completely different. Therefore, the dismissal of the earlier application of the defendant petitioner for rejection of the plaint by this Court could not render the second application of the defendant petitioner under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code to be not maintainable. 
Calcutta High Court (Appellete Side)
Ashwin Desai vs Bijay Kumar Manish Kumar Huf on 15 November, 2016
Ashis Kumar Chakraborty, J.  
Print Page

Thursday, 5 January 2017

Whether second application on different cause of action is maintainable?

 A submission had been made on behalf of the
Appellant that the second application filed under Section 17
of the Act was not maintainable and therefore, it ought not
to have been entertained by the Tribunal. We are not in
agreement with the said submission for the reason that
when another application was filed under Section 17(1) of
the Act, the cause of action was different. At an earlier
point of time, the issuance of notice as well as notice for sale
of the flat had been challenged, whereas the subsequent
application had been filed after the auction had been held.
The cause of action in respect of both the applications was
not same and therefore, in our opinion, the second
application for a different cause of action was maintainable.
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL Nos.10676-10677 OF 2016
(@ SLP (C) No. 32638-32639 of 2011)
M/s Oasis Dealcom Pvt. Ltd. 

 VERSUS
Khazana Dealcomm Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
Citation:(2016) 10 SCC214
Dated:NOVEMBER 8, 2016.

Print Page

Saturday, 29 October 2016

Whether second application for maintenance U/S 125 of crpc is maintainable if first application is dismissed for want of prosecution?

 The learned Advocate for the petitioner has not been able
to point out any bar which disables the party from moving subsequent
application under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure after
the earlier proceedings are dismissed for want of prosecution.   The
incorporation of Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is
beneficial to the persons who are claiming maintenance from those
who   are   liable   to   maintain   them.     Looking   to   the   nature   of
proceedings, the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner cannot
be accepted and it cannot be held that the subsequent proceedings
under  Section  125 of   the  Code  of  Criminal   Procedure   will  not  be
maintainable   if   the   earlier   proceedings   are   dismissed   for   want   of
prosecution.
  IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
    CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.158 OF 2015
Shri Raymond Lancy Rodrigues, 

V
 Smt. Yogita w/o Raymond Rodrigues,
   
  CORAM : Z.A. HAQ, J.
   DATED  : 25th FEBRUARY, 2016.
Citation:2016 ALLMR(CRI)4173
Print Page