Showing posts with label separate trial. Show all posts
Showing posts with label separate trial. Show all posts

Thursday, 5 February 2026

Questions and answers on law (Part 76)

Q 1:- If five accused are charged for the offence and two are absconded how judge will decide the case?

 Ans:- In cases with five accused where two are absconding, the judge typically proceeds with the trial against the three present accused by splitting the trial, ensuring speedy justice for those in custody.

This approach avoids stalling the entire case due to absconders, as affirmed in Supreme Court rulings and procedural norms under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, which replaced the CrPC.

Standard Procedure

Print Page

Wednesday, 29 December 2021

Whether Appellate court should direct joint trial of accused even if the accused has not shown any prejudice due to separate trial?

 Even if it is conceded that the alleged offences committed in FIR 96 and FIR 197 were committed in the course of the same transaction, within the meaning of the phrase in Section 223(d), in view of the interpretation in Cheemalapati Ganeswara Rao (supra), it does not warrant the exercise of discretion to direct a retrial followed by a joint trial. It was imperative for the accused-respondents to prove that the separate trials caused a miscarriage of justice. The respondents have not been able to demonstrate before the Court that separate trials led to a miscarriage of justice. No explanation has been rendered on the aspect of a miscarriage of justice. Though the High Court has in the impugned judgment observed that the separate trials in FIR 96 and FIR 187 led to a miscarriage of justice, no analysis has been undertaken to explain the finding. Moreover, the High Court has only observed that there ‘may’ be a miscarriage of justice. Therefore, quite apart from the individual prejudice to the appellant which has been brought out before the Court, we are clearly of the view that the holding of separate trials was not contrary to law and that there was no resultant failure of justice demonstrated to the satisfaction of the High Court. {Para 47}

48. We are conscious of the fact that the State of Punjab is not in appeal before this Court against the retrial which has been ordered by the High Court. But as a matter of first principle, it is evident that even the appellant has been able to establish that a retrial would be a matter of serious prejudice since vital evidence which has been recorded during the course of the trial would be obliterated as a result of the death of the witnesses from the investigating team lead by the appellant. That apart, a retrial will not serve the ends of ensuring that justice is done in a heinous crime alleged to have been perpetrated on the prosecutrix resulting in her suicide.

Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Criminal Appeal Nos. 1051-1054 of 2021

Nasib Singh Vs The State of Punjab 

Author: Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, J

Dated: October 08, 2021.

Print Page

Thursday, 16 July 2020

Whether the court can separate trial of accused in dishonour of cheque case?

But the next important question for consideration would be what should happen to the criminal proceeding initiated against the accused if the accused did not turn up even after such service of notice on him and the same having been declared to be sufficient service by the Court. It is needless to point out that the presence of accused in a criminal trial is a must. No criminal trial could proceed in the absence of an accused for the obvious reasons that the plea of the accused has to be recorded and if he pleads not guilty, the trial has to be held in his presence and the statement of the accused if any has to be recorded and that further in case if the accused is to be convicted his presence will be very much required before the Court, more so, when the sentence to be imposed against the accused is the substantive sentence of imprisonment. In this context, a reference may be made to Section 273 of Cr.P.C which prescribes that except as otherwise expressly provided, all evidence taken in the course of the trial or other proceeding shall be taken in the presence of the accused, or, when his personal attendance is dispensed with in the presence of his pleader. That means the evidence in a criminal trial cannot be taken in the absence of an accused except as otherwise provided under law. In other words, a criminal trial cannot be held in the absence of an accused or his counsel when the personal presence of the accused is dispensed with in the manner as recognized under the provisions of Cr.P.C. The only exception to this procedure appears to be the one prescribed under Section 126 of Cr.P.C. But no such exception is made in cases where the plea of the accused has to be recorded, the evidence has to be taken at the trial, the statement of the accused has to be recorded and in the event of the accused being found guilty, his presence will be required for passing an order of conviction and if he is to be sentenced with imprisonment, his presence is required. This being the position in a criminal trial, if the accused did not respond even after the service of notice to him by the other mode of service prescribed under Section 65 or under Section 144 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the presence of the accused will have to be secured by resorting to the coercive methods like issue of warrants and proclamation in the manner as contemplated under the provisions of the Cr.P.C. This is very much necessary because in the absence of an accused, a criminal trial cannot be proceeded with effectively and the accused cannot be convicted and sentenced to custodial sentence without his personal presence being secured before the Court. There may be cases where even by resorting to such coercive measures, the presence of the accused could not be secured within a reasonable time, then the provisions as contemplated under Chapter IV of the Karnataka Criminal Rules of Practice will have to be resorted to and the case against such accused will have to be split up and it is only for the purpose of invoking the provisions contained in Chapter IV of the Karnataka Criminal Rules of Practice, the Court can resort to the procedure as prescribed under Section 299 of Cr.P.C. of recording the evidence of witnesses in the absence of the accused. Such a procedure is permissible only for the purpose of invoking the provisions contained under Chapter IV of the Karnataka Criminal Rules of Practice and not for the purpose of holding a trial when the presence of the accused could not be secured. Therefore in a criminal trial where the presence of the accused is a must and where the presence of the accused could not he secured in the manner known to law within a reasonable time, the case against such accused will have to be split up in the manner as provided under Chapter IV of the Karnataka Criminal Rules of Practice and the case against the remaining accused who are present before the Court could be proceeded with further in accordance with law. The same will be the procedure applicable even in cases instituted for the alleged offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

Reference in Criminal Petition No. 778/2005

Decided On: 30.06.2005

 Mac Charles (I) Ltd.  Vs.  Chandrashekar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B. Padmaraj and C.R. Kumaraswamy, JJ.

Citations: 2006 (1) ALD Cri 44, III (2006) BC 143, 2005 CriLJ 3700, ILR 2005 KAR 3648, 2006 (2) KarLJ 570, MANU/KA/0272/2005
Print Page

Saturday, 11 November 2017

What are limits of joint trial of criminal cases?

 This Court in Natwar Lal Sakar Lal Mody v. The State of Bombay 26 (1984) DLT 64 considered the question of joint trial of persons and offences for conspiracy as per provisions contained in Section 239(d) of the old Code of Criminal Procedure. This Court has laid down that separate trial is the Rule and joint trial is an exception. Joint trial would be an irregular exercise of discretion if a court allows innumerable offences spread over a long period of time and committed by a large number of persons to be under the protecting wings of an all-embracing conspiracy, and if each or some of the offences can be separately tried, it would be appropriate and lawful. Joint trial prolongs the trial and causes waste of judicial time and complicates the matter which might otherwise be simple, and it would confuse the Accused and cause prejudice to them. Court should not be overzealous to provide a cover of conspiracy for a number of offences unless it is satisfied that the persons who committed separate offences were parties to the conspiracy and committed the separate acts pursuant to conspiracy. This Court has laid down thus:

11. This discussion leads us to the following legal position. Separate trial is the Rule and joint trial is an exception. While Section 239 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows a joint trial of person and offences within defined limits, it is within the discretion of the Court to permit such a joint trial or not, having regard to the circumstances of each case. It would certainly be an irregular exercise of discretion if a Court allows an innumerable number of offences spread over a long period of time and committed by a large number of persons under the protecting wing of all-embracing conspiracy, if each or some of the offences can legitimately and properly form the subject-matter of a separate trial; such a joint trial would undoubtedly prolong the trial and would be a cause of unnecessary waste of judicial time. It would complicate matters which might otherwise be simple; it would confuse Accused and cause prejudice to them, for more often than not Accused who have taken part in one of the minor offences might have not only to undergo the long strain of protracted trial, but there might also be the likelihood of the impact of the evidence adduced in respect of other Accused on the evidence adduced against him working to his detriment. Nor can it be said that such an omnibus charge or charges would always be in favour of the prosecution for the confusion introduced in the charges and consequently in the evidence may ultimately benefit some of the accused, as a clear case against one or other of the Accused may be complicated or confused by the attempt to put it in a proper place in a larger setting. A Court should not be overzealous to provide a cover of conspiracy for a number of offences unless it is clearly satisfied on the material placed before it that there is evidence to prove prima facie that the persons who committed separate offences were parties to the conspiracy and they committed the separate acts attributed to them pursuant to the object of the said conspiracy.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 394, 393 and 395 of 2017

Decided On: 08.05.2017

State of Jharkhand through S.P., CBI Vs. Lalu Prasad and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Arun Mishra and Amitava Roy, JJ.
Citation:(2017) 8 SCC1
Print Page

Friday, 31 July 2015

Whether evidence recorded in separate trial arising out of same FIR can be considered while deciding application for discharge of accused?

 Shri Singh was submitting that the informant of the case had made a turn round as regards the First Information Report and had stated that he had filed a case under some misunderstanding and misinformation and the information was not correctly projecting the facts. This Court does not have any business to make any comment on the quality of that evidence of the informant except that which has just been pointed out by this Court, that is to say, that the evidence being an evidence in an appropriately conducted trial under Chapter-XVIII of the Cr.P.C. could not be the part of the case record or documents submitted therewith, that is, the police report and, as such, was completely outside the consideration of the Court. It has its own value and the value is to confront the maker of the statement, if he was to contest the trial on which the petitioners should be put on, to draw his attention to show the falsity of his evidence which might be coming during that trial. Except that particular use which could be made in the light of the provision ofSection 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, that recorded evidence of the informant does not have any value as regards a judge proceeding under Section 227 or 228 Cr.P.C.
Patna High Court
Subidha Devi & Ors vs State Of Bihar & Anr on 16 April, 2015
Citation; 2015 CRLJ2906 Patna
Print Page