It is no doubt true that a code of procedure “is
designed to facilitate justice and further its ends and it is
not a penal enactment for punishment and penalty and
not a thing designed to trip people up”. Procedural laws
are no doubt devised and enacted for the purposes of
advancing justice. Procedural laws, however, are also
laws and are enacted to be obeyed and
implemented. The laws of procedure by themselves
do not create any impediment or obstruction in the
matter of doing justice to the parties. On the other
hand, the main purpose and object of enacting
procedural laws is to see that justice is done to the
parties. In the absence of procedural laws regulating
procedure as to dealing with any dispute between
the parties, the cause of justice suffers and justice
will be in a state of confusion and quandary.
Difficulties arise when parties are at default in
complying with the laws of procedure. As procedure
is aptly described to be the hand-maid of justice, the
court may in appropriate cases ignore or excuse a
mere irregularity in the observance of the procedural
law in the larger interest of justice. It is, however,
always to be borne in mind that procedural laws are
as valid as any other law and are enacted to be
observed and have not been enacted merely to be
brushed aside by the Court. Justice means justice to
the parties in any particular case and justice
according to law. If procedural laws are properly
observed, as they should be observed, no problem
arises for the court for considering whether any lapse in
the observance of the procedural law needs to be
excused or overlooked. As I have already observed
depending on the facts and circumstances of a
particular case in the larger interests of administration of
justice the Court may and the Court in fact does,
excuse or overlook a mere irregularity or a trivial breach
in the observance of any procedural law for doing real
and substantial justice to the parties and the Court
passes proper orders which will serve the interests of
justice best.
13. Excuse of lapses in compliance with the laws
of procedure, as a matter of course, with the avowed
object of doing substantial justice to the parties may
in many cases lead to miscarriage of justice.
14. Civil Procedure Code requires that in the event of
death of a particular party, heirs and legal
representatives of the deceased have to be brought on
record within a particular period, provided the cause of
action survives. If the legal representatives are not
brought on record within the stipulated period,
certain consequences follow and the action abates
either wholly or partially depending on the facts and
circumstances of a particular case. The Code further
provides that an application may be made for setting
aside the abatement within a stipulated period. It is now
well settled that an abatement can be set aside at
any time even beyond the period prescribed for
making an application for setting aside the
abatement, if sufficient cause is shown explaining
the delay in the making of the application. If,
irrespective of the provisions of the Code and the
merits of the case, abatements are to be set aside as
a matter of course merely on the ground that
abatement is only a consequence of noncompliance
of law of procedure and substantial
justice is denied to the parties, the result may really
amount to a denial of justice and in an indefinite
prolongation of a litigation.
(Emphasis supplied)
12. I believe this powerfully articulated passage to be squarely
applicable to this case. I cannot in law turn a blind eye to the law
relating to abatement. What is it that is expected of the Applicants?
At a minimum, I believe the law requires the Applicants to explain
the delay. It is not just any explanation that will do. The explanation
must be one that is cogent, persuasive and tenable. As we have
seen, the statements in the Affidavit in Support of the Chamber
Summons provide no sort of explanation at all, apart from stating in
the most general terms that the Applicants were ‘unaware’ of the
proceedings in this Court. That they were aware of the proceedings
between the same parties in other courts is accepted. The so-called
explanation seems to me to be most unlikely in the normal course of
conduct; it postulates that the Petitioner kept the Applicants
abreast of the litigations in other courts but for some reason
completely shut them out of all knowledge of the present
proceedings. Why and how that might have been is left to our
speculation. On so diaphanous a thread am I asked to allow this
application. In short, what the Applicants say is that it matters not a
whit what the law says; it matters perhaps even less that their
affidavit contains no explanation as required by law; I must, for the
mere asking, allow their application. I cannot.
13. Would an order putting the Applicants to terms suffice?
After all, in several cases, our courts, including the Supreme Court,
have condoned delayed and set aside abatement by putting parties
to terms. I do not believe there is any rigid formula in such cases. It
also cannot be that in every single case, irrespective of conduct or
the want of any explanation, a party can simply agree to pay costs
and thus evade the consequences of his own negligence or
indolence, or both. Costs are imposed to compensate the other side
for the trouble and expense they have suffered.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
TESTAMENTARY AND INTESTATE JURISDICTION
CHAMBER SUMMONS NO. 50 OF 2015
IN
TESTAMENTARY SUIT NO. 17 OF 2011
IN
TESTAMENTARY PETITION NO. 402 OF 2004
Smt. Hema Achyut Shah & Ors
V
Princess Ujawala Raje
CORAM: G.S. PATEL, J
DATED: 12th June 2015
Citation:2016(6) ALLMR403
Print Page