Showing posts with label setting aside abatement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label setting aside abatement. Show all posts

Saturday, 11 November 2017

Whether order of abatement can be altered at subsequent point of time?

Needless to mention that the order of abatement is not so sacrosanct or inviolable that the same cannot be altered at a subsequent point of time inspite of sufficient cause being shown by the plaintiffs or any other party to the suit. If the party to the suit is able to satisfy the Court that the requirements of Rule 4A or Rule 4(4) are attracted in a given case then the Court may in its inherent powers pass appropriate orders including an order of setting aside abatement on such ground. If the aforesaid rules permit prosecution of the suit in absence of legal representatives of the deceased party, and yet the judgment passed would bind the estate of such deceased party, then surely it would be preposterous to contend that suit against such a person would abate in law. Both these situations would be antithesis to each other. In my view it would defeat the legislative intent behind the Amendment Act of 1976.

11. Understood thus, the Court below ought to examine the subject application in wider perspective. In such a situation, to do substantial justice to the parties the Court ought to exercise inherent powers under section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure and pass appropriate orders. Incase defendants 2 to 5 are justified in contending and there is material on record to support the contention that they were the heirs of deceased Pragji and could represent the estate of the defendant No. 1 the Court could suitably modify the abatement order and permit the defendants 2 to 5 to represent the estate of defendant No. 1. All questions are left open to be decided by the Trial Court. The Court may re-examine the application in the wake of observations made hereinbefore and decide the same in accordance with law.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 6294 of 1995

Decided On: 28.06.2001

Gulabben wd/o Chimanlal Maniar and Ors. Vs. Narendra Balchandra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.M. Khanwilkar, J.
Citation: 2001 Vol 103(4) BOM L R 540
Print Page

Whether date of knowledge of death of party is relevant for deciding delay condonation application?

We are of the view that the order passed by the learned Single Judge is unsustainable in law. The delay in taking out the application has to be computed from the date of knowledge of the death of a party. It is the case of the appellants that they had no knowledge and as soon as they acquired knowledge, they took out application for bringing legal heirs on record. This aspect as regards knowledge is not seriously disputed by the respondent. Secondly, it is now well settled that the provisions of Order 22, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code are not penal in nature. It is a rule of procedure and substantial rights of the parties cannot be defeated by pedantic approach by observing strict adherence to the procedural aspect of law. In the aforesaid circumstances, we are of the view that the learned Single Judge was in error in refusing to use discretion vested in him for condoning delay in taking out application for bringing legal heirs on record. Even if proceeding abates, the Court has ample powers to set aside the abatement, and condone the delay to bring legal heirs on record.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

L.P.A. No. 81 of 1993 in W.P. No. 2571 of 1991

Decided On: 28.10.2004

 Keshao s/o Kawadu Maral and Anr. Vs.State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
V.C. Daga and S.U. Kamdar, JJ.
Print Page

Supreme Court: Whether the court can permit setting aside of abatement of suit or appeal even in absence of specific application in that regard?

In as much as the abatement results in denial of hearing on the merits of the case, the provision of abatement has to be construed strictly. On the other hand, the prayer for setting aside an abatement and the dismissal consequent upon an abatement, have to be considered liberally. A simple prayer for bringing the legal representatives on record without specifically praying for setting aside of an abatement may in substance be construed as a prayer for setting aside abatement. So also a prayer for setting aside abatement as regard one of the plaintiffs can be construed as a prayer for setting aside the abatement of the suit in its entirety. Abatement of suit for failure to move an application for bringing the legal representatives on record within the prescribed period of limitation is automatic and a specific order dismissing the suit as abated is not called for. Once the suit has abated as a matter of law, though there may not have been passed on record a specific order dismissing the suit as abateed, yet the legal representatives proposing to be brought on record or any other applicant proposing to bring the legal representatives of the deceased party on record would seek the setting aside of an abatement. A prayer for bringing the legal representatives on record, if allowed, would have the effect of setting aside the abatement as the relief of setting aside abatement though not asked for in so many words is in effect being actually asked for and is necessarily implied. Too technical or pedantic an approach in such cases is not called for.
The courts have to adopt a justice oriented approach dictated by the upper most consideration that ordinarily a litigant ought not to be denied an opportunity of having a lis determined on merits unless he has, by gross negligence, deliberate inaction or something akin to misconduct, disentitled himself from seeking the indulgence of the court. The opinion of the trial Judge allowing a prayer for setting aside abatement and his finding on the question of availability of 'sufficient cause' within the meaning of sub-rule(l) of Rule (9) of Order 22 and of Section 5 of the Indian Limitation Act, 1963 deserves to be given weight, and once arrived at would not normally be interfered with by superior jurisdiction.
In the present case, the learned trial judge found sufficient cause for consideration of delay in moving the application and such finding having been reasonably arrived at and based on the material available, was not open for interference by the Division Bench. 
In Maria Flaviana Almeida & Ors. 's case (supra), Chief Justice Beaumont speaking for the Division Bench observed that an order setting aside an abatement is really one in procedure. The party originally had a cause of action which through no fault of their own came to an end by the death of their opponent and the effect of setting aside the abatement is merely to excuse delay in restoring the suit to an actionable condition. The Division Bench held that the order setting aside an abatement does not effect the merits of the dispute between the parties though it certainly determines a right and, therefore, does not amount to a 'judgment'.
Supreme Court of India
Mithailal Dalsangar Singh And Ors vs Annabai Devram Kini And Ors on 16 September, 2003
Bench: R.C. Lahoti, Ashok Bhan
Citation: 2003 Supp(3) SCR 822 
Print Page

Tuesday, 25 April 2017

Whether court can direct other defendant to furnish names and addresses of legal heirs of deceased defendant?

 Though on a strict construction of rule 10 A of order XXII of the Code, the obligation imposed on the pleader stands discharged on his informing the court about the death of the party but in my view in exceptional circumstances particularly when the litigants are not two private individuals but a public sector undertaking or a public body, which has no sure or prompt means to know the existence and particulars of legal representatives of the defendant, the court would have been within its jurisdiction to exercise its inherent power under section 151 of the Code and issue directions to the other defendants, who, in the present case, happened to be son and daughter-in-law of the deceased defendant, to furnish the names and addresses of the remaining legal representatives or heirs. 
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 - Section 151--Impleadment of legal representative--Powers of Court--In appropriate case, the Court may direct a party to furnish the names and addresses of legal representatives or heirs of the deceased.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI
IA No. 297/96, 2628/96 & 2629/96 in Suit No. 145/82
Decided On: 09.07.1998
State Bank of India Vs. Gobbs Kay India & Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

D.K. Jain, J.





Print Page

Sunday, 11 December 2016

What are basic principles for setting aside of abatement of proceeding?

Since no steps were taken to bring on record the
legal representatives of late Banwari Lal either in the first
appeal or in the second appeal, the appellants have filed CM
No. 1998/2012 (under Order I Rule 10 CPC read with Section
151 CPC) to implead (i) Shakuntala (ii) Gaurav (iii) Rachna and
(iv) Manju. Civil Procedure Code Order XXII stipulates the
manner in which the legal representatives of plaintiffs or
defendants ought to be brought on record. The prescribed
procedure cannot be circumvented by filing application under
Order I Rule 10 CPC read with Section 151 CPC. However, in
our view, it would be unjust to non-suit the appellants on the
ground of technicalities.
10 Provisions of Order XXII CPC are not penal in
nature. It is a rule of procedure and substantial rights of the
parties cannot be defeated by pedantic approach by observing
strict adherence to the procedural aspects of law. In Sardar
Amarjit Singh Kalra v. Pramod Gupta, (2003) 3 SCC 272, a Five
Judge Bench of this Court held as under:-
“26. Laws of procedure are meant to regulate effectively, assist
and aid the object of doing substantial and real justice and not
to foreclose even an adjudication on merits of substantial rights
of citizen under personal, property and other laws. Procedure
has always been viewed as the handmaid of justice and not
meant to hamper the cause of justice or sanctify miscarriage of
justice. A careful reading of the provisions contained in Order
22 CPC as well as the subsequent amendments thereto would
lend credit and support to the view that they were devised to
ensure their continuation and culmination in an effective
adjudication and not to retard the further progress of the
proceedings and thereby non-suit the others similarly placed as
long as their distinct and independent rights to property or any
claim remain intact and not lost forever due to the death of one
or the other in the proceedings. The provisions contained in
Order 22 are not to be construed as a rigid matter of principle
but must ever be viewed as a flexible tool of convenience in the
administration of justice. 
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6567 OF 2015
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 22468/2013)
BANWARI LAL (D) BY LRS. & ANR. 
V
BALBIR SINGH .
Citation: 2016(6) MHLJ 1

Print Page

Sunday, 27 November 2016

When court should not allow application for setting aside of abatement of suit?

 It is no doubt true that a code of procedure “is
designed to facilitate justice and further its ends and it is
not a penal enactment for punishment and penalty and
not a thing designed to trip people up”. Procedural laws
are no doubt devised and enacted for the purposes of
advancing justice. Procedural laws, however, are also
laws and are enacted to be obeyed and
implemented. The laws of procedure by themselves
do not create any impediment or obstruction in the
matter of doing justice to the parties. On the other
hand, the main purpose and object of enacting
procedural laws is to see that justice is done to the
parties. In the absence of procedural laws regulating
procedure as to dealing with any dispute between
the parties, the cause of justice suffers and justice
will be in a state of confusion and quandary.
Difficulties arise when parties are at default in
complying with the laws of procedure. As procedure
is aptly described to be the hand-maid of justice, the
court may in appropriate cases ignore or excuse a
 mere irregularity in the observance of the procedural
law in the larger interest of justice. It is, however,
always to be borne in mind that procedural laws are
as valid as any other law and are enacted to be
observed and have not been enacted merely to be
brushed aside by the Court. Justice means justice to
the parties in any particular case and justice
according to law. If procedural laws are properly

observed, as they should be observed, no problem
arises for the court for considering whether any lapse in
the observance of the procedural law needs to be
excused or overlooked. As I have already observed
depending on the facts and circumstances of a
particular case in the larger interests of administration of
justice the Court may and the Court in fact does,
excuse or overlook a mere irregularity or a trivial breach
in the observance of any procedural law for doing real
and substantial justice to the parties and the Court
passes proper orders which will serve the interests of
justice best.
13. Excuse of lapses in compliance with the laws
of procedure, as a matter of course, with the avowed
object of doing substantial justice to the parties may
in many cases lead to miscarriage of justice.
14. Civil Procedure Code requires that in the event of
death of a particular party, heirs and legal
representatives of the deceased have to be brought on
record within a particular period, provided the cause of
action survives. If the legal representatives are not
brought on record within the stipulated period,
certain consequences follow and the action abates
either wholly or partially depending on the facts and
circumstances of a particular case. The Code further
provides that an application may be made for setting
aside the abatement within a stipulated period. It is now
well settled that an abatement can be set aside at
any time even beyond the period prescribed for
making an application for setting aside the
 abatement, if sufficient cause is shown explaining
 the delay in the making of the application. If,
irrespective of the provisions of the Code and the
merits of the case, abatements are to be set aside as
a matter of course merely on the ground that

abatement is only a consequence of noncompliance
of law of procedure and substantial
justice is denied to the parties, the result may really
amount to a denial of justice and in an indefinite
prolongation of a litigation.
(Emphasis supplied)
12. I believe this powerfully articulated passage to be squarely
applicable to this case. I cannot in law turn a blind eye to the law
relating to abatement. What is it that is expected of the Applicants?
At a minimum, I believe the law requires the Applicants to explain
the delay. It is not just any explanation that will do. The explanation
must be one that is cogent, persuasive and tenable. As we have
seen, the statements in the Affidavit in Support of the Chamber
Summons provide no sort of explanation at all, apart from stating in
the most general terms that the Applicants were ‘unaware’ of the
proceedings in this Court. That they were aware of the proceedings
between the same parties in other courts is accepted. The so-called
explanation seems to me to be most unlikely in the normal course of
conduct; it postulates that the Petitioner kept the Applicants
abreast of the litigations in other courts but for some reason
completely shut them out of all knowledge of the present
proceedings. Why and how that might have been is left to our
speculation. On so diaphanous a thread am I asked to allow this
application. In short, what the Applicants say is that it matters not a
whit what the law says; it matters perhaps even less that their
affidavit contains no explanation as required by law; I must, for the
mere asking, allow their application. I cannot.

13. Would an order putting the Applicants to terms suffice?
After all, in several cases, our courts, including the Supreme Court,
have condoned delayed and set aside abatement by putting parties
to terms. I do not believe there is any rigid formula in such cases. It
also cannot be that in every single case, irrespective of conduct or
the want of any explanation, a party can simply agree to pay costs
and thus evade the consequences of his own negligence or
indolence, or both. Costs are imposed to compensate the other side
for the trouble and expense they have suffered. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
TESTAMENTARY AND INTESTATE JURISDICTION
CHAMBER SUMMONS NO. 50 OF 2015
IN
TESTAMENTARY SUIT NO. 17 OF 2011
IN
TESTAMENTARY PETITION NO. 402 OF 2004
Smt. Hema Achyut Shah & Ors
V
Princess Ujawala Raje 
CORAM: G.S. PATEL, J
DATED: 12th June 2015
Citation:2016(6) ALLMR403
Print Page

Friday, 28 October 2016

When court should not condone delay for bringing legal heirs on record when parties were living in immediate vicinity?

The learned Judge had brought about a clear distinction between a case where the parties had been living in immediate vicinity or were related to the Court or had issued notice on him informing the death of the respondent and in other cases.
It is not in dispute that the appellants were neighbours. They were co-sharers. The respective dates of death of the respondent Nos.2 and 3, thus, were known to them. It is difficult to conceive that the petitioners were not in touch with their learned advocates from 1999 to December 2006. If not every week, they are expected to contact their lawyers once in a year. Ignorance of legal consequence without something more would, in our opinion, be not sufficient to condone such a huge delay. Appellants are literates. They have been fighting their cases for a long time. The High Court in its impugned judgment has categorically arrived at a finding that no sufficient cause has been shown for the purpose of condonation of delay in bringing on record the names of the heirs or legal representatives of the deceased respondent Nos.2 and 3.
Reportable
Supreme Court of India
Katari Suryanarayana & Ors vs Koppisetti Subba Rao & Ors on 8 April, 2009

Bench: S.B. Sinha, Mukundakam Sharma
Citation:AIR 2009 SC 2907
Print Page

When court should not condone delay in bringing legal heirs of deceased party on record?

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Order 22, rules 3 and
9; s. 151 read with s.5 of Limitation Act, 1963 – Death of
appellant during pendency of appeal before Supreme Court
– Application filed after long delay of 778 days for bringing
the legal representatives of deceased appellant on record
accompanied by application for condonation of delay – Held:
Such applications cannot be allowed as a matter of right and
even in a routine manner – They should be rejected unless
sufficient cause is shown for condonation of delay – On facts,
except for a vague averment that the legal representatives
were not aware of the pendency of the appeal, no other
justifiable reason was stated by the applicants – The
applications also did not contain correct and true facts, thus,
want of bona fides is imputable to the applicants – No reason
nor sufficient cause was shown as to why immediate steps
were not taken by the applicants, even after they admittedly
came to know of the pendency of the appeal – The conduct
of the applicants was abnormal – They acted irresponsibly
and even with negligence, and miserably failed in showing any
‘sufficient cause’ for condonation of the long delay of 778 days
– Applications accordingly dismissed – Resultantly, the
appeal, having already abated, also dismissed.
Limitation – The law of limitation is a substantive law and
has definite consequences on the right and obligation of a
party – Once a valuable right is accrued in favour of one party
as a result of the failure of the other party to explain the delay
by showing sufficient cause and its own conduct, it will be
unreasonable to take away that right on the mere asking of
the applicant, particularly, when the delay is directly a result
of negligence, default or inaction of that party.
Supreme Court of India
Balwant Singh (Dead) vs Jagdish Singh & Ors on 8 July, 2010

Bench: B.S. Chauhan, Swatanter Kumar
Citation:AIR 2010 SC 3043
Print Page