Showing posts with label addition of parties. Show all posts
Showing posts with label addition of parties. Show all posts

Saturday, 21 November 2026

Supreme Court : Section 92 of CPC Suit Doesn't Give Every Devotee An Automatic Right To Be Impleaded

  Coming to the applications for impleadment, Order I Rule

10(2) of the CPC requires the Court to determine whether

the presence of a proposed party is necessary or proper for

the effective and complete adjudication of the questions

involved in the suit. Although a suit instituted under

Section 92 of the CPC is representative in nature and

concerns the interests of persons associated with the

institution, this does not confer an automatic right of

impleadment upon every devotee or member of the Sangha.

The applicants must demonstrate sufficient grounds for

their separate participation and explain how their presence

is necessary or proper for the adjudication of the

controversy. In the present case, the Trial Court, by its

reasoned order dated 09.09.2025, found that the

applicants had failed to establish such grounds. Their

general allegations of collusion and mismanagement,

without sufficient particulars demonstrating the necessity

of their presence, were found inadequate to justify

impleadment.  {Para 9}

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOS.841-842 OF 2023

SUBHASINDU DAS & ORS. V  BACCHU RANJAN DAS & ORS. 

Author: VIKRAM NATH, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 1250.

Dated: NOVEMBER 19, 2026

Print Page

Sunday, 23 November 2025

Supreme Court: Whether applicant in domestic violence Act proceeding can add any person as party to the petition if they are not residing with her in shared household?

The High Court has rightly found in effect that the ingredients of domestic violence are wholly absent in this case. The Petitioner and the Respondents are not persons living together in a shared household. There is a vague allegation that the Respondents are family members. There is not a whisper of the Respondents with the Petitioner. They appear to be neighbours.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Special Leave Petition (Criminal)... Diary No. 34053/2019

Date of Order: 04.10.2019

Kamlesh Devi Vs. Jaipal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Indira Banerjee and M.R. Shah, JJ.

Citation:  MANU/SCOR/36609/2019.

Print Page

Sunday, 1 June 2025

Should the Second Wife Be Impleaded in Domestic Violence Cases? A Legal Analysis

 The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 has been a crucial legislation in safeguarding women's rights. However, questions often arise regarding the scope of parties who can be impleaded in proceedings under this Act, particularly when allegations involve a second marriage. This article examines the legal position on whether a second wife should be made a party to domestic violence proceedings initiated by the first wife.

Print Page

Wednesday, 16 April 2025

Jharkhand HC: Whether motor accident claim petition can be rejected on the ground that some of legal heirs of deceased are not added as party to the petition?

 Matter for consideration is whether all the heirs are a necessary party in a claim case. Compensation is assessed on the basis of dependency and not on heirship. Only those who are the dependents shall be entitled to compensation. The entire concept of computation of compensation arising out of the death is based on calculation of the amount on dependency. In Sarla Verma v. DTC, MANU/SC/0606/2009 : (2009) 6 SCC 12 it is held that if the deceased is survived by parents and siblings, only the mother would be considered to be a dependant. The learned Tribunal thus committed a gross error to dismiss the claim application merely on the ground that the all the children of the deceased had not been impleaded. In any case any of the party or parties could have been impleaded as dependants and ordered accordingly. {Para 8}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI

M.A. No. 223 of 2012

Decided On: 13.04.2022

Ugni Bibi Vs. Gobind Ram Hathampuria and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Gautam Kumar Choudhary, J.

Citation: 2024(3) TAC (Jhar), MANU/JH/0275/2022.

Print Page

Sunday, 3 September 2023

Whether a person can seek that he be added as party to a suit if there is any dispute between him and defendant?

 Point No. (i):- The interveners mainly contended that the property has wrongly been sold by Mahabir Singh his uncle even including the share of the intervener in favour of the defendant 1st party. In fact the intervener are the real owner and in possession of the property of their share. The sale deed is illegal sale deed. So far these allegations are concerned, there is nothing on record in support of these facts. According to the defendants, the properties were sold by Mahabir Singh who was one of the settlee. Now, therefore, this dispute raised by the intervener is dispute between defendants because if the intervener will be added, they will be defendant in the suit. In my opinion, therefore, the inter se dispute between the defendants cannot be decided in a suit filed by the plaintiff appellant. Order 1 Rule 10 CPC speaks about the jurisdiction of the Court and not the right of a party for being added as defendant. If the intervener are not necessary party and in absence of the interveners, if the dispute raised between the parties can be effectively decided by the Court, the Court should not add a person whose presence is not required for just decision of the case. Here, as stated above, the plaintiff approached the Court with a particular case which was denied by the defendants. This dispute is to be decided and the trial Court has dealt with the controversy between the plaintiff and the contesting defendants. Now, these interveners are raising another controversy against the contesting defendants for which neither there is any pleading nor there is any evidence. In such circumstances, for the purpose of setting aside the Judgment and Decree, the intervener cannot be added as a party after such a long period. The suit is of the year 1976 and the application has been filed in this First Appeal in the year 2015, i.e., after 39 years. Further the dispute as to whether the plaintiff has got title or not can very well be decided in absence of these interveners because they are not saying anything against the plaintiff but are making allegation against the contesting defendant. In my opinion, therefore the interveners are not at all necessary party and accordingly, this intervention application, i.e., I.A. No. 3490 of 2015 is hereby rejected. {Para 15}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA

First Appeal No. 530 of 1982

Decided On: 07.07.2015

Sahood Alam and Ors.  Vs. Nayyer and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Mungeshwar Sahoo, J.

Citation: MANU/BH/0423/2015.

Print Page

Whether addition of the intervenor as party will create his interest in the suit property?

Having heard the learned senior counsel for the parties and on considering the material on record, it appears that learned Court below has considered the impleadment application and submissions made on behalf of the parties and passed the detailed and reasoned order exercising his jurisdiction in the facts and circumstances of the case. The learned Court below observed that plaintiff has also sought alternative relief of declaration of title and recovery of possession. The defendants denied relationship of landlord and tenant and asserted their independent title over the suit land. The Court framed issues on 28.05.2013 which includes issue of title as well. The petitioner challenged the deed of partition dated 19.12.1988 as fraudulent and illegal. So, the suit does not seems to be one of tenancy rather complex issue of title is involved here. The intervenor has no right to birth in the suit property is a matter of investigation. Mere addition the intervenor as party will not create an interest in the suit property. So, the learned Court below found the presence of the intervenor is necessary for efficacious adjudication of this case and the addition is also necessary for avoidance of multiplicity of suits. {Para 16}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PATNA

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 1428 of 2016

Decided On: 08.08.2023

 Ratan Kumar Sarawgi  Vs. Vishwanath Sarawgi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sunil Dutta Mishra, J.

Citation:  MANU/BH/0947/2023.

Print Page

Wednesday, 26 October 2022

Can the court permit the plaintiff to add any party to suit even if that party is neither necessary nor proper?

 9.0. From the impugned order passed by the High Court, it appears that what has weighed with the High Court is that plaintiffs, is the dominus litus and heavy reliance is placed in the case of Kasturi (supra). However, the principle that the plaintiffs is the dominus litus shall be applicable only in a case where parties sought to be added as defendants are necessary and / or proper parties. Plaintiffs cannot be permitted to join any party as a defendant who may not be necessary and / or proper parties at all on the ground that the plaintiffs is the dominus litus.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 3703-3750 OF 2022;

ASIAN HOTELS (NORTH) LTD. Vs ALOK KUMAR LODHA & ORS.

Coram:  M.R. SHAH; J., B.V. NAGARATHNA, J. 

Author: M.R. SHAH, J.

Dated:  JULY 12, 2022 

Print Page

Saturday, 23 July 2022

Can a person claim to be added as a party in a partition suit if he has entered into an agreement of sale with one defendant?

 The well entrenched principle is that the plaintiff is dominus litis which latin expression means that the plaintiff is the master of the suit. The plaintiff cannot be compelled to wage a legal battle against a person, against the plaintiff’s Will. The exception would be if the compulsion of law would necessitate the presence of third party, either as necessary party or proper party. A distinction between the plaintiff seeking addition of third party, and either, third party of the defendant invoking the provisions of Order I Rule 10 (2) of the Code, will also have to be borne in mind. {Para10}

11. In the present case, the plaintiff is opposing the impleadment. Respondent 15 and 16-third parties preferred an application seeking impleadment on the premise that the Agreement of Sale clothes them with the status of necessary and at any rate, proper parties. The

plaintiff, who is the dominus litis, is opposing the impleadment. The

short question which is required to be answered, is whether the third

parties are necessary or proper parties.

12. I have already held that the third parties do not have any

share or interest in the subject matter of the suit. The Agreement of Sale does not create any interest in the property. A necessary party would be a party, in whose absence, no effective decree can be passed. A proper party, would be a party, in whose absence, an effective order can be passed but whose presence is necessary for complete and final decision on the questions involved in the proceedings.

13. In the factual matrix, the suit is brought for partition and

possession. The third parties, who claim to hold an Agreement of Sale executed qua the suit property by defendant 1 are neither necessary parties nor a proper parties considering the question involved. 

14. The third parties claim to have an Agreement of Sale executed in their favour by defendant 1. The right of third parties to enforce the agreement is restricted to defendant 1 and the property which may fall to his share in view of the final adjudication in the partition suit. The third party may, if permissible in law, proceed on the basis of the Agreement of Sale, against the portion of the suit property which may be allotted to the defendant 1, in the partition suit.

16. The said decision and the other decisions which consider

similar situation do not take the case of third parties any further since third parties have no interest in the property and merely hold an Agreement of Sale and not Conveyance Deed as would transfer title and create share and interest in the property in favour of third parties.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.6355 OF 2019

 Jagannath Khanderao Kedar Vs  Gopinath Bhimaji Kedar 

CORAM : ROHIT B. DEO, J.

DATED : 6th JUNE 2022

Print Page

Monday, 23 August 2021

Whether Session court can permit the addition of complainant in criminal revision as per 401(2) Cr.P.C?

It is the grievance of the learned senior counsel for the petitionersvide the impugned order the learned Revisional Court had directed the petitioner herein to file an amended memo of parties by impleading the complainant defacto as respondent No.2, whereas the complainant has no role to play before learned Revisional Court and its only the learned Public Prosecutor for the State, who has to take realm of the case before learned Session’s Court. It is argued per sub-section 2 to Section 401 Cr P C no order shall be passed to the prejudice of the accused or other person unless he has an liberty of being heard either personally or through pleader. It is argued the words other person refers to person akin to the accused and it does not include the complainant and hence the learned Revisional Court erred to make the complainant defacto as respondent No.2.

 Section 401(2) and 403 CrP C are as under:-

“401. High Court' s Powers of revisions.

(1) xxxx

(2) No order under this section shall be made to the

prejudice of the accused or other person unless he has had

an opportunity of being heard either personally or by

pleader in his own defence.

(3) to (5) xxxx

403. Option of Court to hear parties. Save as otherwise

expressly provided by this Code, no party has any right to

be heard either personally or by pleader before any Court

exercising its powers of revision; but the Court may, if it

thinks fit, when exercising such powers, hear any party

either personally or by pleader.

8. A bare perusal of Section 401(2) Cr P C would show other personmust be akin to an accused who can participate in the proceedings. The phrase in his own defence in clause 2 of Section 401 Cr P C strengthens this belief. The complainant is never heard in his defence and hence the word „other person‟ referred to in Section 401 Cr P C is a person akin or  similarly placed to an accused. Section 403 Cr P C is also to be read in consonance with Section 401 Cr P C as it starts with the word „otherwise expressly provided by this Code‟.

Thus as is seen above „other person‟ does not include a

complainant in revision. This is a State prosecution and at the highest the complainant can be a witness to the proceedings and can participate through learned APP for the Sate but cannot be a party to the revision petition. The judgments relied upon by the respondents did not consider A.K.Subhaiah‟s (supra). I agree with the petitioner if we allow the complainant to participate before the Session’s it shall change the entire nature of the proceedings from criminal to civil and hence shall hamper independence of prosecution. The complainant can at best assist the prosecution, though prosecution in such a case has to make an independent call.

15. The law laid down in A.K.Subbaiah & Ors (supra) hold good even for today. The judgments referred to by the respondent No.2 are mostly under Section 482 Cr.P.C. wherein the High Court may even implead the complainant in revision. The power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is quite different than the one under Section 401 Cr.P.C. as nothing limits such power of the Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and it is far wider than under Section 401(2) Cr.P.C. but Session’s Court does not have such parallel power and it cannot implead anyone, except those mentioned under Section 401(2) Cr.P.C.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

Decided on : 06th August, 2021

+ CRL.M.C. 1163/2021 & CRL.M.A.5948/2021

VIPUL GUPTA; and S. P.GUPTA  Vs STATE 

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YOGESH KHANNA

YOGESH KHANNA, J. (Through Video Conferencing)

Print Page

Thursday, 15 July 2021

Whether the court should allow the addition of a party if the said party has a commercial interest in the suit?

 In the backdrop of the aforesaid facts, pointing out the

distinction in the matter of impleadment of a party in a suit relating to property and a matter involving a declaration as regards the status or legal character, the Supreme Court observed that, in a suit relating to property in order that a person may be added as a party, he should have a direct interest as distinguished from a commercial interest in the subjectmatter  of the litigation. It was further observed what makes a person a necessary party is not merely that he has relevant evidence to give on some of the questions involved in the suit. The observations of the Supreme Court in paragraph 13 and 14 are instructive and, thus,

extracted below :“

13 A clear distinction has been drawn between suits relating

to property and those in which the subject matter of litigation is

a declaration as regards status or legal character. In the

former category, the rule of present interest as distinguished

from the Commercial interest is required to be shown before

a person may be added as a party.

14 It cannot be said that the main object of the rule is to

prevent multiplicity of actions though it may incidentally

have that effect. But that appears to be a desirable

consequence of the rule rather than its main objective. The

person to be joined must be one whose presence is necessary

as a party. What makes a person a necessary party is not

merely that he has relevant evidence to give on some of the

questions involved that would only make him a necessary

witness and not merely that he has an interest in the correct

solution of some question involved and has thought of relevant

arguments to advance. The only reason which makes it

necessary to make a person a party to an action is that he

should be bound by the result of the action and the question to

be settled therefore, must be a question in the action which

cannot be effectually and completely settled unless he is a

party. The line has been drawn on a wider construction of the

rule between the direct interest or the legal interest and

commercial interest. It is, therefore, necessary that person

must be directly or legally interested in the action in the

answer, i.e., he can say that the litigation may lead to a result

which will affect him legally, that is, by curtailing his legal

rights. It is difficult to say that the rule contemplates joining as

a defendant a person whose only object is to prosecute his own

cause of action." (Emphasis supplied)

In the case at hand, the petitioners do not claim any proprietary interest in the land on which the unauthorized constructions are allegedly erected. The petitioners, on the contrary, desire to ensure a favourable outcome of C.S. No. 94 of 2017 so as to advance their commercial interest. This pure commercial interest separates the petitioners from the class litigants who have an abiding interest in the orderly and planned development and thus approach the Court to compel the planning authority to perform its duty.

29. The learned Judge was justified in observing that the

impleadment of the petitioners would change the nature of adjudication. If the petitioners are impleaded as party defendants, inevitably, the questions as to whether the building permission was lawfully granted, whether access as per norms was available at the time of grant of building permission and whether the Corporation can now withheld the permission for want of access as per norms would be urged for consideration and adjudication. These aspects are not germane for the adjudication of the dispute between the respondent Nos. 2 to 10 and respondent No.11. There is a clear and present danger of the trial of the suit taking the turn of a distinct trial between the petitioners and Planning Authority.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO. 6563 OF 2017

Mr.Ashok Bansidhar Agarwal Vs The State of Maharashtra

CORAM : N.J. JAMADAR, J.

Dated: 22nd July 2019

Print Page

Monday, 12 July 2021

Whether the appeal is maintainable U/S 37 of Arbitration Act against the order passed by the arbitrator in the application for party addition?

Hindustan Prefab Ltd. (hereinafter ‘HPL’) has filed the present

appeal under Section 37(2)(b) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter the ‘A&C Act’) impugning an order dated

09.04.2021 (hereinafter ‘the impugned order’) passed by the learned Arbitral Tribunal. By the impugned order, the Arbitral Tribunal rejected the appellant’s application to implead National Law University, Orissa (hereinafter ‘NLUO’) in the arbitral proceedings pending between HPL and the respondent (hereafter ‘NCC’).

5. First of all, this Court has serious reservations as to whether the present appeal is maintainable. Impleadment of a party is not an “interim measure”, which as the expression suggests would be

operative till conclusion of the arbitral proceedings. The application for seeking impleadment of NLUO before the Arbitral Tribunal cannot be considered as an application for an interim measure of protection. Thus, such a relief would not fall within the scope of an application under Section 17 of the A&C Act. Consequently, it is doubtful whether any order of the Arbitral Tribunal for refusing to join any other party in the arbitral proceedings can be made a subject matter of an appeal under Section 37 of the A&C Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 Date of Judgment : 3rd June, 2021

ARB. A. (COMM.) 26/2021 and IA Nos. 7261/2021

& 7262/2021

HINDUSTANT PREFAB LTD.  Vs M/S. NCC LIMITED 

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIBHU BAKHRU

Dated:  03.06.2021

Print Page

Wednesday, 9 June 2021

Whether the court can refuse to take counterclaim on record if it leads to the addition of parties?

 As regards addition of the parties i.e. the parties who are not arrayed as the parties to the suit by the plaintiffs, the Rule 15 clearly permits addition of such parties in the course of filing of the counter claim. {Para 5}

 6. For the reasons stated above, therefore, exclusion of the counter claim merely on the ground of addition of new parties or disclosure of a new cause of action is not permissible. In the circumstances, the impugned order apparently discloses failure of exercise of power under Rule 6-C of Order VIII by the trial Court, as also failure on the part of the trial Court to ascertain the occasion for exercise of such power vis-a-vis after taking into consideration the pleadings in the counter claim. The Court below without applying its mind to the provisions of law relating to the rights of the parties pertaining to the counter claim and ignoring the provisions of Order VIII, Rule 15 onwards has ordered the exclusion of the counter claim and, therefore, has clearly acted illegally rendering the impugned order to be bad in law.

 Bombay High Court

(Panaji Bench)

(Before Khandeparkar R.M.S., J.)


Oberlino Cirilo Sanches Vs Momenta Vaz 

Citation:
2006 SCC OnLine Bom 94 : (2006) 5 Bom CR 383 : (2006) 3 AIR Kant R (NOC 316) 17 : (2006) 3 All LJ (NOC 590) 52 : 2006 AIHC (NOC 176) 59

Writ Petition No. 359 of 2005

Decided on January 27, 2006

Print Page

Sunday, 18 October 2020

Whether the husband is a necessary party to suit filed by father-in-law against daughter-in-law for her eviction from his house?

 Question No.7

118. Learned counsel for the appellant challenging the

direction issued by the High Court that the husband of

respondent be impleaded by the Trial Court by invoking

suo moto powers under Order I Rule 10 CPC, submits that

no relief having been claimed against the son of the

appellant, he (son) was neither necessary nor proper

party. Learned counsel for the appellant has relied on

the judgments of this Court in Razia Begum Vs.

Sahebzadi Anwar Begum and others, AIR 1958 SC 886 and

Ramesh Hirachand Kundanmal Vs. Municipal Corporation of

Greater Bombay and others, (1992) 2 SCC 524. Latter

judgment of this Court discussing judgment of Razia

Begum has laid down following in paragraphs 10 and 12:

“10. The power of the Court to add parties

under Order I Rule 10, CPC, came up for

consideration before this Court in Razia Begum

(supra). In that case it was pointed out that

the Courts in India have not treated the matter

of addition of parties as raising any question

of the initial jurisdiction of the Court and

that it is firmly established as a result of

judicial decisions that in order that a person

may be added as a party to a suit, he should

have a direct interest in the subject-matter of

the litigation whether it be the questions

relating to moveable or Immovable property.

12. Sinha, J. speaking for the majority

said that a declaratory judgment in respect of

a disputed status will be binding not only upon

parties actually before the Court but also upon

persons claiming through them respectively. The

Court laid down the law that in a suit relating

to property in order that a person may be added

as a party, he should have a direct interest as

distinguished from a commercial interest in the

subject-matter of the litigation. Where the

subject-matter of a litigation is a declaration

as regards status or a legal character, the

rule of presence of direct interest may be

relaxed in a suitable case where the Court is

of the opinion that by adding that party it

would be in a better position effectually and

completely to adjudicate upon the controversy.

…………”

119. There can be no dispute with the preposition of

law as laid down by this Court in the above two cases.

In the present case, although plaintiff has not claimed

any relief against his son, Raveen Ahuja, the husband

of the respondent, hence, he was not a necessary party

but in view of the fact that respondent has pleaded her

right of residence in shared household relying on

Sections 17 and 19 of the Act, 2005 and one of the

rights which can be granted under Section 19 is right

of alternate accommodation, the husband is a proper

party. The right of maintenance as per the provisions

of Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956 is that of

the husband, hence he may be a proper party in cases

when the Court is to consider the claim of respondent

under Sections 17 and 19 read with Section 26 of the

Act, 2005.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO.2483 of 2020


SATISH CHANDER AHUJA Vs  SNEHA AHUJA 
Print Page

Thursday, 23 July 2020

Whether it is necessary to hear the proposed defendant before adding him as a party to suit?

This Court is not even remotely suggesting as to what order learned Court below should have had passed. All that this Court is observing is that had the notices been issued to the petitioners of the application filed under Order 1, Rule 10 of the Code, then they would have got an opportunity to respond to the same, take all pleas available opposing the said application and the Court would have had then passed a reasoned order whether to implead them or not after taking note of the respective pleas of the parties. Learned Court below having failed to do so has indeed caused grave prejudice to the petitioner.

26. Before parting with the case, this Court would like to observe that though it is not in dispute that Order 1, Rule 10 of the Code expressly does not provides that a proposed party has to be heard before being impleaded but then the said provision can also not be read so as to mean that under no circumstance/situation, notice need not be issued to a proposed party. In my considered view, a harmonious construction of the said provision is that whether or not before impleading a party in a lis, notice to the proposed party should be issued or not, will depend upon facts of the lis itself. In a suit like the present one, where contentious issues are involved, prudence and fair play demands that before order is passed on the application, proposed party should be given an opportunity of being heard. By doing so, while the Court shall be causing no prejudice to the applicant who seeks the impleadment of a new person as a party, justice will also be done to the proposed party as it shall have the satisfaction of having been heard before any order on such an application is passed by the Court. Not only this, because the Court will have the benefit of the view of the applicant as also the proposed party, it will be in a position to pass a speaking order containing reasons explaining its decision.

27. In view of discussion held herein-above, the impugned order impleading petitioners as party defendants to the suit without giving them an opportunity of responding to/opposing the application filed for their impleadment is not sustainable in law and is liable to be quashed and set aside. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA

CMPMO No. 311 of 2018

Decided On: 16.03.2019

Ashwani Kumar  Vs.  Sanjay Kumar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ajay Mohan Goel, J.
 Citations: MANU/HP/0194/2019
Print Page

Sunday, 23 February 2020

Precaution to be taken by court while allowing application for addition of parties in eviction suit against tenant

Order 1, Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure empowers the Court to strike out or add parties whose presence before the Court may be necessary in order to enable the Court to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit effectively and completely. However in doing so the Court must keep in mind that the scope of the suit is not enlarged and also the nature of the suit is not changed. It should also not cause any prejudice to either of the parties. !t is also imperative that the party sought to be added under the provisions should have a direct interest in the subject-matter of litigation. In every case the Court has got a discretion but it should be exercised in accordance with the settled principles of law. In the instant case it is clear that the plaintiff Peer Azhar Hussain has filed a suit with the allegation that he is the landlord and he let out the suit shop to defendant No. I and the latter in contravention of the terms of the contract let out the defendant No. 1 and thereafter defendants Nos. 1 and 2 sublet the same is defendant No. 3. The fact in issue in the case will be whether the plaintiff let out the shop to defendant No. 1 and whether defendant No. 1 sublet the same to defendant No. 2 and then defendants Nos. 1 and 2 sublet the suit shop to defendant No. 3. For adjudication of the above issues, the plaintiff will be called upon to prove the relationship of landlord and tenant existing between him and defendant No. 1 . In such a case the Court cannot embark upon the inquiry or rival claim of the plaintiff and petitioner regarding the title of the suit shop. The question of title cannot be investigated in such a case. The plaintiff will succeed or fail on his proving or disproving the above relationship. If the petitioner is arrayed a party there will be a rival claim regarding the ownership of me suit shop between the plaintiff and the petitioner. Without deciding the same the relevancy of arraying the petitioner as party will not be justified. In a suit for eviction the investigation of title is not warranted by law. Even if the petitioner is not made a party nothing is going to prejudice his case. The judgment delivered in this case will not be binding on him because that judgment will be a judgment in personam.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN

Civil Revn. Petn. No. 99 of 1998

Decided On: 04.02.1998

Talib Hussain Vs. Peer Azhar Hussain and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.C. Jain, J.

Citation: 1998 DGL (Raj) 73
Print Page

Thursday, 28 November 2019

Whether court can allow party to be impleaded as co-plaintiff if there is conflict of interest between original plaintiff and that party?

There is a serious dispute as to whether the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 have assigned their entire rights in the suit premises in favour of GITCPL as contended by Mr. Ankhad who represents plaintiff Nos. 4 to 6 in the suit or whether the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 have only assigned 75% of their rights to the suit premises as contended by both Mr. Godbole and Mr. Dhakephalkar. GITCPL relying upon the deeds of assignment, has applied for impleadment and relied upon the provisions in Order XXII Rule 10 of CPC. At the stage of deciding whether leave is to be granted under Order XXII Rule 10 of CPC, a detailed enquiry is really not contemplated. Only a prima facie satisfaction would normally suffice. From this perspective, it will be only appropriate that both GITCPL as well as plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 continue as parties in the suit. The question really is about capacity in which they ought to continue in this suit.


16. There is also no warrant for the proposition that a party to the suit who may have assigned its interest in favour of a third party, is required to be necessarily struck out from the array of parties. The party to the suit who may have assigned its interest is entitled to continue as a party in the suit, because, in a given case, the covenant to supply a good title to the assignee and to assign property free from any encumbrances or litigations may continue upon such party. In the present case, there is a serious dispute as to whether the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 have assigned their 100% rights or the assignment is restricted to only 75% of the rights which they claim to have in the suit premises. In these circumstances, there was no justification to order deletion of the plaintiff Nos. 2, 7 to 10 and 12 from the array of parties in the suit.

17. Although, GITCPL is entitled to become a party, the learned trial Judge, was not at all justified in impleading the GITCPL as 'co plaintiff' particularly when there is a serious conflict of interest between plaintiff Nos. 4 to 6 on one hand and GITCPL on the other. Although, the exercise of power under Order I Rule 10 of CPC is discretionary, the discretion in such matters, cannot be exercised in unreasonable manner. In fact, this is what is held in Mumbai International Airport Pvt. Ltd. (supra) upon which reliance was placed by Mr. Godbole. In Bayajabai Patil (supra) Chief Justice M.C. Chagla, in the context of exercise of power under Order I Rule 10 of CPC has held that a party may be added as a co-plaintiff, when the plaintiff does not dispute the right of the co-plaintiff to the decree which might be passed; but where his right to property in suit is disputed by the plaintiff, the proper procedure is to join him as a defendant and not as a co-plaintiff. The principle in such matters appears to be that the original plaintiff, who is even otherwise dominus litis, cannot be compelled to proceed with the suit with a co-plaintiff, with whom, such original plaintiff may have a conflict of interest.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition Nos. 5917 of 2017 and 13794 of 2016

Decided On: 20.09.2017

Daksha Keshrichand Jhaveri  Vs.  Nikhilesh Keshrichand Jhaveri and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
M.S. Sonak, J.

Citation: Manu/MH/2165/2017:2017 SCC Online Bom 8448

Print Page

Sunday, 13 October 2019

What is duty of court if application is made for addition of parties in Representative Suit?

 Having given our considered thought to the point under reference, we are of the view that what was opined by the learned single Judge in Chintamani's case merits acceptance, because of which a person seeking to invoke the power of the court under Sub-rule (3), which power has been accepted by the learned Judge making the present reference also as discretionary, has to satisfy the court that the person on record is acting prejudicially to the applicant because of which he ought to be brought on record to protect his interest. As the power under Sub-rule (3) is discretionary, we would however like to observe that the circumstance under which the discretionary power can be exercised cannot be put in a strait-jacket, and so, if in a given case the court were to be satisfied that even without proving that the person on record is acting prejudicially to the applicant his prayer to be impleaded deserves to be allowed, it would be open for it to do so, but the court shall have to be satisfied that a reason akin to prejudicial acting by the person on record exists. To put it differently, the prayer would not be allowed merely on asking. We further state that merely because the application is not mala fide or does not tend to abuse the process of law, the same would not be required to be allowed unless the aforesaid requirement exists.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA

Civil Revision No. 89 of 1990

Decided On: 04.08.1993

Balaram Palai Vs.   Collector, Puri

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.L. Hansaria, C.J. and R.K. Patra, J.




Authored By : B.L. Hansaria, R.K. Patra

B.L. Hansaria, C.J.
Citation: Citation : AIR 1994 Ori 21

Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2019

Whether legal heirs of deceased vendor can be added as party to suit for specific performance of contract under O.1 R 10 of CPC?

"9. Learned counsel for the respondent relied on a three-Judge Bench decision of this Court in Kasturi vs. Iyyamperumal and others - MANU/SC/0319/2005 : (2005) 6 SCC 733. He has submitted that in this case it has been held that in a suit for specific performance of a contract for sale of property a stranger or a third party to the contract cannot be added as defendant in the suit. In our opinion, the aforesaid decision is clearly distinguishable. In our opinion, the aforesaid decision can only be understood to mean that a third party cannot be impleaded in a suit for specific performance if he has no semblance of title in the property in dispute. Obviously, a busybody or interloper with no semblance of title cannot be impleaded in such a suit. That would unnecessarily protract or obstruct the proceedings in the suit. However, the aforesaid decision will have no application where a third party shows some semblance of title or interest in the property in dispute. In the present case, the registered sale deed dated 12.8.1960 by which the property was purchased shows that the shop in dispute was sold in favour of not only Kapoor Chand, but also his sons. Thus prima facie it appears that the purchaser of the property in dispute was not only Kapoor Chand but also his sons. Hence, it cannot be said that the sons of Kapoor Chand have no semblance of title and are mere busybodies or interlopers.

14. In view of the aforesaid decisions we are of the opinion that Kasturi is case (supra) is clearly distinguishable. In our opinion it cannot be laid down as an absolute proposition that whenever a suit for specific performance is filed by A against B, a third party C can never be impleaded in that suit. In our opinion, if C can show a fair semblance of title or interest he can certainly file an application for impleadment. To take a contrary view would lead to multiplicity of proceedings because then C will have to wait until a decree is passed against B, and then file a suit for cancellation of the decree on the ground that A had no title in the property in dispute. Clearly, such a view cannot be countenanced."

12. A reference to relevant portion of judgment in the case of Vidyawati (supra), relied upon by the learned Counsel for respondent nos. 1 [a] to 1 [f], is also necessary. The relevant portion of the said judgment reads as follows:-

"4. This Court in Bal Kishan vs. Om Parkash & Anr. MANU/SC/0528/1986 : AIR 1986 SC 1952 has said thus:

"The sub-rule (2) of Rule of Order 22 authorised the legal representative of a deceased defendant to file an additional written statement or statement of objections raising all pleas which the deceased-defendant had or could have raised except those which were personal to the deceased-defendant or respondent."

5. The same view was expressed in Jagdish Chander Chatterjee & Ors. vs. Sri Kishan & Anr., MANU/SC/0616/1972 : 1973 (1) SCR 850 wherein this Court said:

"The legal representative of the deceased respondent was entitled to make any defence appropriate to his character as legal representative of the deceased respondent. In other words, the heirs and the legal representatives could urge all contentions which the deceased could have urged except only those which were personal to the deceased. Indeed this does not prevent the legal representative from setting up also their own independent title, in which case there could be no objection to the court impleading them not merely as the Lrs. of the deceased but also in their personal capacity avoiding thereby a separate suit for a decision on the title."

13. Applying the said position of law to the facts of the present case, it becomes evident that the trial Court has not committed an error in passing the impugned order and allowing the application of respondent nos. 1 [a] to 1 [f] by directing them to be added as defendants in their private capacity and granting them an opportunity to file their written statement. It is relevant that in the written statement filed on behalf of the deceased defendant no. 1, it was stated that the suit property was ancestral property, which came to the share of the said defendant and that his children i.e. respondent nos. 1 [a] to 1 [f] had rights therein. Therefore, there was already material before the trial Court indicating that the respondent nos. 1 [a] to 1 [f] did have a fair semblance of right and interest in the suit property. Merely because the said respondents had filed a Pursis before the trial Court adopting the written statement of deceased defendant no. 1 would not have the effect of prohibiting them from seeking their addition as party defendants in their own right in the suit and to file written statement to place on record their defence. It would be inappropriate to restrict respondent nos. 1 [a] to 1 [f] only to the written statement and the stand taken by the deceased defendant no. 1, particularly when they could be said to have interest in the suit property.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 848 of 2017

Decided On: 04.12.2018

 Vishweshwar Vs. Uttam and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Manish Pitale, J.

Citation: 2019(4) MHLJ 361
Print Page

Saturday, 13 July 2019

Whether owner of tenanted property is necessary party to eviction suit against tenant?

 Mr. Dani, however, submitted that the petitioners, who
according to him, are admittedly the owners of the suit
property, are at least a proper parties to R.A.E. Suit No. 1148
of 2013 and therefore, were required to be impleaded as

parties to the suit. He submits that the petitioners in this case,
are entitled to contend that they do not want a decree of
eviction against their tenants on the ground of default in
payment of rent. In the alternate, the petitioners are entitled
to contend that the vacant possession of the suit premises be
restored to the petitioners than to plaintiff, who has per his
own pleadings in the plaint, claims to be only a rent collector.
15] Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
(CPC) entitles the Court, at any stage of the proceedings,
either upon or without the application of either party, and on
such terms as may appear to the Court to be just, order that
the name of any party improperly joined, whether as plaintiff
or defendant, be struck out, and that the name of any person
who ought to have been joined, whether as plaintiff or
defendant, or whose presence before the Court may be
necessary in order to enable the Court effectually and
completely to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions
involved in the suit, be added. The object of the rule is not to
change the scope or character of the suit by adding new
parties and to enable them to litigate their own independent
suit but simply to hold them to avoid unnecessary litigation

which might otherwise become necessary. The main object of
this rule is also not to prevent multiplicity of actions, even
though it may, incidentally, have that effect. The person to be
joined must be one, whose presence is necessary as a party.
When a right is claimed against him and when it is not
possible to pass an effective decree in his absence, he
becomes a necessary party. Similarly, if an adjudication is
likely to affect a party, then, ordinarily, joinder of such party is
necessary so as to effectually and completely settle the issue
between the parties and grant comprehensive relief.
16] In this case, as noted earlier, considering the nature of
the suit and the relief claimed, it cannot be said that the
petitioners were necessary parties to R.A.E. Suit No. 1148 of
2013. Mr. Dani, however, submits that the petitioners are atleast
proper parties and therefore, discretion exercised by the
Small Causes Court in ordering the petitioners' joinder was
incorrectly interfered with by the Revisional Authority.
17] Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the CPC confers a wide discretion
to the Court to meet the every case of joinder or nonjoinder
of parties. However, discretion is required to be exercised not

arbitrarily, but on judicial principles. Ordinarily, the plaintiff is
the dominus litus. However, joinder can be ordered even
against the wishes of the plaintiff, if the situation, so
demands. The power to order joinder is normally confined in
two cases:
(i) When a party ought to have been joined, but is
not joined (necessary party); and
(ii) When, without presence of such party, the
question involved in the case cannot be effectively
decided (proper party).
18] The petitioners in this case, has failed to make out a
case that they are necessary parties to R.A.E. Suit No. 1148 of
2013. The reliefs applied for in the suit are perfectly capable
of being granted or refused without presence of the
petitioners. Any relief granted or finding recorded in R.A.E.
Suit No. 1148 of 2013 cannot, affect the rights, if any, of the
petitioners to suit property, regards which, there are already
several litigations pending between the parties. In fact, the
joinder of the petitioners in R.A.E. Suit No. 1148 of 2013,
might have the effect of altering the very character of such
suit and introducing a litigative front between the plaintiff

and the petitioners in the context of their respective rights
qua the agreement dated 8th January 1984 and the irrevocable
POA. Such disputes are quite alien to proceedings in R.A.E.
Suit No. 1148 of 2013.
19] In the absence of the petitioners, it is not as if R.A.E.
Suit No. 1148 of 2013 cannot be completely or effectively
decided. The presence of the petitioners is not necessary for
determination of real matter in dispute. The presence of the
petitioners is not necessary for effectual and complete
adjudication of all the questions involved in R.A.E. Suit No.
1148 of 2013. Thus construed, it cannot be said that the
petitioners are either necessary or proper parties insofar as
R.A.E. Suit No. 1148 of 2013 is concerned.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 5624 OF 2017

Mr. Peter Cajetan Travasso vs. Shri. Lal Bherumal Laungani 
CORAM : M. S. SONAK, J.

Dated : 10th October 2017.

Print Page

Wednesday, 27 June 2018

Basic principles to be followed by court while deciding application for addition of parties

 A party seeking to be impleaded as a party to a suit must demonstrate that it has a direct and substantial interest in the subject-matter of the suit and that such interest would be affected directly by the decree that may be passed in the suit or that its presence as a party to the suit must be necessary for answering the issues arising in the suit. These factors must demonstrably exist before the party applying can be allowed to be impleaded as a party to the suit. These are factors which must be taken into account while considering whether the presence of a party is necessary before an effective order is made or is proper for a complete and final adjudication of the suit. In the present case, the applicant does not answer any of the descriptions above.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Chamber Summons No. 326 of 2000 in Suit No. 2792 of 2000

Decided On: 27.03.2002

 P.M.A. Hakeem, Vs. U.P. Co-operative Spinning Mills Federation Limited and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.A. Bobde, J.
Citation: 2002(3) ALLMR 389
Print Page