Showing posts with label stray sentences. Show all posts
Showing posts with label stray sentences. Show all posts

Saturday, 14 April 2018

Whether stray sentence in a judgment without focused argument can be considered as ratio of judgment?

It is clear that a stray sentence in a judgment without a focused argument cannot be considered as the ratio of such a judgment. Also, on a careful reading of the second sentence in paragraph 19, it is clear that all that is stated by this Court is that, while exercising its power Under Section 26A of the Drugs Act, the basis of the Central Government's decision must be "expert advice". The sentence then goes on to add that the Drugs Act makes provision for obtaining such advice through the Board and the DCC. According to us, there was no focused argument on whether such advice is or is not mandatory before powers Under Section 26A of the Drugs Act can be exercised, and merely reading a stray sentence in this judgment does not lead to such a conclusion. Equally, the single Judge's reliance upon a Division Bench judgment contained in E. Merck (supra), where, in holding Section 26A to be constitutional, the Court stated:

Before the Government records its satisfaction to prohibit the manufacture, sale, distribution etc. of a particular drug, opinion of the DTAB and/or Drugs Consultative Committee is obtained.

This is an equally stray sentence and what has been stated with respect to Systopic Laboratories (supra), applies equally to this sentence.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 22972 of 2017 

Decided On: 15.12.2017

 Union of India (UOI) and Ors. Vs. Pfizer Limited and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Rohinton Fali Nariman and Sanjay Kishan Kaul, JJ.

Citation:(2018) 2 SCC 39


Print Page

Saturday, 18 April 2015

Whether stray sentences elicited in cross-examination can be construed as admission?


Thus, it is clear that these stray sentences elicited in the cross-examination could hardlv be construed as admission. The Supreme Court of India, in the case of Chikkam Koteswara Rao v. Chikkam Subbarao, speaking through Justice Hegde, as he then was, has observed in this behalf thus:
"This admission must be read along with the evidence given by him in his chief examination ............
If we read these statements along with his other evidence and in a harmonious manner, it is clear that what the appellant admitted was that the acquisition in question was made by his father on his behalf and the consideration for the same was paid by his father from out of the appellant's private funds that were in the hands of his father...........
Thus, the Supreme Court has pointed out that before the right of a party can be considered to have been defeated on the- basis of an alleged admission by him, the implication of the statement made by him must be clear and conclusive. There should not be any doubt or ambiguity about the alleged admission and to examine whether there is ambiguity in the admission, it would be necessary for the Court to read the other parts of the evidence and the stand taken by him in the pleadings. 
Karnataka High Court

Parameshwari Bai vs Muthojirao Scindia on 29 July, 1980
Equivalent citations: AIR 1981 Kant 40, ILR 1981 KAR 78

Bench: G Sabhahit, D V Rao


Print Page