In the present case, the suit property was taken on rent by the
father-in-law of deceased tenant-Lalita that is Hem Ram Sharma and
after his death, his son Baldev (husband of Lalita) became tenant of the
suit property. Upon his death, Lalita became the tenant of the suit
property. Upon death of Lalita, in terms of Section 15(2)(b) of the Hindu
Succession Act, in the absence of any son or daughter of deceased
Lalita, the tenancy would devolve upon the heirs of her husband. Since
the appellant does not fall under the category of ‘heir’ of Lalita’s
husband, the tenancy of the suit property will not devolve on him nor
can he be called as an ‘heir’ under Section 3(a) of the U.P. Act XIII of
1972.
13. Section 3(g) defines ‘family’, in relation to landlord which includes
the spouse that is husband or wife of a person, male lineal descendants
which means his or her son, son’s son, son’s son’s son and so on,
parents, grandparents, unmarried, widowed, divorced daughter or
granddaughter, etc. The definition given in the clause is an inclusive
one and is supposed to be construed in its technical meaning which
implies what is not given has to be excluded as not forming part of the
family of landlord or tenant. Therefore, sisters and brothers of landlord
and tenant are excluded from his/her family. In the facts of present
case, the appellant being brother of deceased tenant cannot be held to
be the ‘family’ as the inclusive list given under the Act clearly omits
“brother and sister” and the same cannot be read therein as the list has
to be read and interpreted strictly.
14. Assuming, for the sake of arguments that the appellant is an heir
of Lalita, for devolution of tenancy, on the death of Lalita, the appellant
has to be a ‘tenant’ within the meaning of Section 3(a) of the U.P. Act
XIII of 1972. As per Section 3(a)(1), in the case of residential building,
in the event of death of a tenant, for heirs to be treated as tenant, the
statute requires them to prove that they have been normally residing
with the deceased tenant at the time of his/her death. The term used in
the section is ‘heir’ which implies that not any of the family member
residing with the tenant would succeed to the tenancy, but only the heirs
of tenant normally residing with him/her. The words “normally residing
with him” suggests that only those heirs would inherit the tenancy rights
of deceased tenant who resided with him ordinarily in normal course
and not temporarily. The legislative intent appears to be that only those
heirs would inherit tenancy who normally resided with the tenant and not
occasionally. In the present case, the appellant claims that he has been
carrying on business in the property along with his deceased sister
Lalita and had been ordinarily living with her because of the medical
business they were running. The appellant being the brother of
deceased-Lalita had no reason to normally reside with his married
sister. Be it noted, in her written statement filed in the release
application, Lalita has not averred that her brother-appellant Durga
Prasad was living with her and that he was taking care of her.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS.1305-06 OF 2017
DURGA PRASAD V NARAYAN RAMCHANDAANI (D) THR. LRS.
Citation: AIR 2017 SC 915,(2017) 5 SCC69,2017(5) All MR 468(SC)
Print Page