Showing posts with label title deeds. Show all posts
Showing posts with label title deeds. Show all posts

Saturday, 24 June 2023

Whether the bank can accept a final decree in a partition suit as a document of title?

 The second difficulty that the Asset Reconstruction Company has, is that six different companies created an equitable mortgage by deposit of title deeds. As per the averment contained in Para 2 of I.A. No. 110290 of 2022, the deposit of title deeds happened on 25.03.2009. What is said to have been deposited are the certified copies of the final decree in Application No. 517 of 1998 in CS No. 14 of 1958 dated 24.04.1998. {Para 218}

 219. We do not know how a final decree in a partition suit and that too in a notorious suit like CS No. 14 of 1958 could have been taken to be a document of title which can be accepted by way of equitable mortgage. In any case, the deposit of title deeds is said to have taken place on 25.03.2009. By this time, the order of the learned Single Judge (L. Narasimha Reddy, J.) dated 26.10.2004 allowing the claims of the obstructionists had come into existence. Though the said order of the learned Single Judge dated 26.10.2004 was set aside by the Division Bench by an order dated 23.06.2006, the said order of the Division Bench had become the subject matter of the civil appeals even at that time. These civil appeals were eventually allowed by this Court by an order dated 05.03.2014. We do not know how during this interregnum period, the Banks could have accepted this property as security, despite the same being the subject matter of a serious long drawn litigation.

In the Supreme Court of India

(Before V. Ramasubramanian and Pankaj Mithal, JJ.)

Civil Appeal Nos. of 2023


Trinity Infraventures Ltd. and Others Vs M.S. Murthy and Others.

Citation: 2023 SCC OnLine SC 738.

Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2019

What right a party acquires if a person who is directed to produce his title deed fails to produce it?

 In so far as the first reason is concerned it is not disputed that the plaintiff had caused summonses to be served upon the witness who had custody of the original and was called upon to produce it. The witness, however, did not comply with the order of the Court. The plaintiff subsequently applied for the issue of a warrant against the witness but no process-fee was paid for service of the writ. This does not, in our opinion, amount to default on the part of the plaintiff. As was pointed out by this Court in the case of Bhagabat Prasad Singh v. King Emperor 14 C.L.J. 120 : 11 Ind. Cas. 794 under Section 130of the Indian Evidence Act, no witness who is not a party to a suit can be compelled to produce his title-deed to any property, or any document in virtue of which he holds any property as pledgee or mortgagee or any document the production of which might tend to incriminate him, unless he has agreed in writing to produce them with the person seeking the production of such deed or some person through whom he claims. It cannot be disputed that the lessee under the perpetual lease of the 21st December 1874 was entitled to urge that the document was his title-deed, and that he was not bound to produce the original except in the event contemplated by Section 130 of the Indian Evidence Act. It is not alleged that the lessee had agreed with the plaintiff in writing to produce the original in Court. Consequently, if, after service of summons upon him, he did not pro duce the original, the plaintiff became entitled to use the certified copy as secondary evidence. The first reason assigned by the Subordinate Judge in support of his order of rejection of the document cannot, therefore be supported.

Calcutta High Court
Imrit Chamar vs Sridhar Panday And Ors. on 29 August, 1911
Equivalent citations: 13 Ind Cas 120
Bench: Mookerjee, Carnduff
Print Page

Saturday, 13 January 2018

Whether subsequent purchaser can be treated as bonafide purchaser if he fails to make inquiry about original title deeds prior to purchase of property?

Now, this takes the Court to decide whether one of the subsequent purchasers i.e. the appellant herein is a bona fide purchaser of the subject land or not. In order to examine this aspect, it is necessary to consider the conduct of the subsequent purchasers before execution of sale deed dated 03.09.2014. It is settled principle of law under Section 19(b) of the Specific Relief Act that specific performance of contract may be enforced against any other person claiming under him by a title arising subsequently to the contract. If a person, as an owner of the property, has entered into an agreement to sale, he cannot, thereafter, convey the same property to any other person, as after prior agreement to sale, he cannot be said to be free owner of the property. If the owner alienates the property, he can alienate it only subject to the rights created under the prior agreement to sale. It is the case of the appellant i.e. subsequent purchaser that he has no knowledge about execution of sale agreement inter se between plaintiff and defendant No. 1 and, therefore, they have bona fidely entered into the registered sale deed dated 03.09.2014 without notice of prior sale agreements and paid full value in good faith. Upon re-appreciation of the events, which occurred before and after registered sale deed dated 03.09.2014, it shows that the defendants with unusual haste, carried out the sale deed. The obvious reason is such that the sale deed executed and registered on 03.09.2014 discloses that the appellant was aware of pending proceedings being Special Civil Suit No. 405 of 2008 between defendant No. 1 and his predecessor in title. Admittedly, the dispute came to be resolved between the parties to the said suit on 12.09.2014 and prior to it, the sale deed was executed and registered. The said sale deed indicates that the appellant and respondent No. 3 herein have paid amount of consideration by way of various cheques of the date 01.09.2014 to 04.09.2014. Admittedly, the amounts of cheques were withdrawn by defendant No. 1 on 16.09.2014 and 17.09.2014 as per the statement of account annexed with the affidavit produced before this Court during the course of hearing. It is a matter of fact that though the dispute has been resolved on 12.09.2014, the suit was disposed of only on 02.10.2014. Normally, there is no reason to consider about withdrawal of the amounts on the part of the original owner - defendant No. 1 but, in view of the peculiar facts of this case, conduct of the defendants goes to suggest that before the issue is resolved in a pending suit between defendant No. 1 and his predecessor in title, the sale deed was executed and registered and meanwhile, the amounts of consideration were withdrawn in cash by the original owner i.e. defendant No. 1 and thereafter, the Court has passed the order of disposal of the suit on 02.10.2014. This speaks a lot about conduct of the defendants, who in collusion, joined hands to frustrate the sale agreements in question. It requires to be considered here that the defendants with unusual haste, carried out the sale deed, where such transactions, as a rule, are carried out with appropriate inquiry and, more particularly, after obtaining title clearance certificate and also by publishing notice in newspaper before purchase. Admittedly, no such steps have been taken by the subsequent purchasers i.e. the appellant and respondent No. 3 herein. Not only that, they have not bothered to inquire about the whereabouts of the original title deeds. One more significant aspect of the case required to be considered is such that defendant No. 1 agreed to sale the subject land to the plaintiff for consideration of Rs. 51 lacs which was fixed in the year 2008 whereas, the defendants inter se fixed the sale price of the subject land of Rs. 17,50,000/- in the year 2014. Meaning thereby, from 2008 to 2014, price of the subject land has been reduced to about 66% which can never be believed by any prudent man dealing in the transaction of the immovable property and further, the Court cannot overlook or ignore the existing scenario in the market about the prices of the land during the period in question.

15. The plain language of Sub-Section (b) of Section 19 of the Specific Relief Act shows that subsequent transferee can retain the benefit of transfer by purchase, which prima facie, he had right to get, only after satisfying two conditions i.e. (1) he must have paid the full value for which, he purchased the property and; (2) he must have paid it in good faith and without notice of prior contract. The burden of proof is upon the subsequent purchaser to establish existence of these two conditions in order to see that his right prevails over the prior agreement of sale. In the case on hand, the conduct of the defendants themselves indicates that the appellant herein is not a bona fide purchaser because, the sale deed came to be executed and registered with unusual rapidity. Normal procedure for sale/purchase of immovable property as a rule is not such which is adopted in the present case. Hence, required ingredients of Section 19(b) of the Specific Relief Act are missing in this case and hence, protection of Section 19(b) is not available to the subsequent purchaser i.e. appellant herein.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

Appeal From Order No. 457 of 2016 and Civil Application No. 12575 of 2016 in Appeal From Order No. 457 of 2016

Decided On: 10.01.2017

Ghnshyambhai Dhirubhai Barvaliya Vs. Rasikbhai Dhirubhai Ambaliya and Ors.
Print Page

Sunday, 18 June 2017

When it is necessary to see title deeds for determining possession?

The learned counsel for the appellant has invited

the attention of this Court to the decision in State of Andhra

Pradesh and Others v. Star Bone Mill and Fertiliser

Company [(2013) 9 SCC 319], wherein it was held in

paragraph 21 that:

                         "The maxim "possession follows

                 title" is applicable in cases where proof

                 of      actual      possession    cannot

                 reasonably be expected, for instance,

                 in the case of wastelands, or where

                 nothing is known about possession one

                 way or another. Presumption of title as

                 a result of possession, can arise only

                 where facts disclose that no title vests

                 in any party. Possession of the plaintiff

                 is not prima facie wrongful, and title of

                 the plaintiff is not proved. It certainly

                 does not mean that because a man

                 has title over some land, he is

                 necessarily in possession of it.       It in

                 fact means, that if at any time a man

                 with title was in possession of the said

                 property,     the      law   allows     the

                 presumption that such possession was

                 in continuation of the title vested in

                 him. A person must establish that he

                 was continued possession of the suit

                 property, while the other side claiming

                 title, must    make out a case of

                 trespass/encroachment, etc.        Where

                 the apparent title is with the plaintiffs, it

                 is incumbent upon the defendant, that

                 in order to displace this claim of

                 apparent     title    and   to   establish

                 beneficial title in himself, he must


                 establish   by    way   of satisfactory

                 evidence, circumstances that favour

                 his version. Even, a revenue record is

                 not a document of title.     It merely

                 raises a presumption in regard to

                 possession" . (Emphasis supplied).

       29. In order to grant a decree of perpetual injunction

what has to be considered is as to who is in actual physical

possession of the property. When the property is a baron

land, vacant land or lying as a road etc., title deed should be

there to ascertain the possession over such property. The

principle is that in such case, possession follows title.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                             PRESENT:
 MR. JUSTICE B.KEMAL PASHA

     30TH DAY OF MARCH 2017.

                      RSA.No. 85 of 2011 

   
            P.M.MATHEW, 
V

          ANTONY MATHEW, 
Print Page

Wednesday, 13 January 2016

Whether valid equitable mortgage can be made if original title deeds are lost?

 The submission that a valid equitable mortgage can never be made without delivering the original title deed has to be rejected. Such original documents of title may, at times, be lost or destroyed due to natural causes like cyclones and fire-accidents. They may also be lost either by thefts or due to want of proper care and sometimes they would have been filed in courts and not taken return of in time. The owners of property who have so lost their documents of title will, therefore, be not in a position to deliver such original documents with intent to create an equitable mortgage. It will be rather anomalous if such persons can validly execute registered documents of sale, lease and mortgage, but will not be entitled to raise any monies by creating an equitable mortgage. If the original title deeds are lost, we do not see why the owner of the property should not be in a position to an equitable mortgage. The mortgagee in such cases has only to be vigilant in accepting such representation made to him and should make the necessary enquiries before agreeing to advance any monies on the basis of registration extracts of documents of title or copies of documents. That seems to be the underlying principle behind S. 78 of the T. P. Act which provided that if the conduct of a prior mortgagee amounted to gross neglect, the mortgage in his favour will be postponed to the subsequent mortgagee.Andhra High Court
Kanigalla Prakasa Rao vs Nanduri Ramakrishna Rao And Ors. on 18 November, 1981
Equivalent citations: AIR 1982 AP 272

Bench: Punnayya, P R Raju
Print Page

Monday, 23 December 2013

Whether title deed is of no value if owner is not in possession of immovable property?

In Kusum Chandra Debbarma v. Sunil Chandra Debnath & ors. AIR 
2012 Gauhati 88, it was held by Justice S. C. Das that—“The plaintiff 
has brought on record Ext. 1, a title deed, executed by defendant no.-2, 
transferring the suit land and that is legally proved. It is the settled 
principle of law that title follows possession. If a person claims title to an 
immovable property, he has to prove his possession thereof as 
otherwise such title has got no value at all. However, that does not 
mean that title thereof has been extinguished because of the person 
not being in possession. The decision of the first Appellate court on this 
point was, therefore, wrong that since the plaintiff could not prove his 
possession his title also should go and the registered title deed has no 
value at all.”
GAUHATI HIGH COURT
Judge : S.C. DAS
Decided On : Mar-21-2012
Case Number : RSA No.10 of 2002
Appellant : Kusum Chandra Deb Barma
Respondent : Sunil Chandra Debnath and Others
Print Page