Showing posts with label title dispute. Show all posts
Showing posts with label title dispute. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 April 2026

Supreme Court: Ex Parte Suit Cannot Be Dismissed on Ground of No Title in Absence of Pleading Contesting Title

As laid down in Man Kaur (dead) by LRs v.

Hartar Singh Sangha (2010) 10 SCC 512, there must be a valid

contract; that defendant committed breach of

and readiness and willingness of the plaintiff to

perform his part of contract. {Para 30}

31. In present case, all the three essentials are

present. However, the suit was dismissed for

lack of title in favour of the Respondent. No

issues or points for determination were framed

for the same. Appellant at no point was given an

opportunity to lead evidence on the same. In the

absence of any issues, and especially in the

absence of any pleading contesting title of the

Respondent, the Appellant could not be

expected to prove such title in a suit for specific

performance of Agreement to sell. Therefore,

omission to frame issues has caused prejudice

to the Appellant.

32. Hence, the judgment and decree passed by the

trial court does not fulfil the requirements of a

judgment as provided for under the Code of Civil

Procedure, 1908. The judgments and decree of

both the courts below are, therefore, not in

accordance with law and thus, set-aside. 

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

PRAMOD SHROFF  Vs MOHAN SINGH CHOPRA 

AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 378

Print Page

Sunday, 3 April 2022

Whether plaintiff can claim permanent injunction against defendant if the court has rejected her prayer for declaration and cancellation of sale deed?

In the present case the plaintiff, who has failed to get any declaratory relief and the defendant No.1 is held to be a true and absolute owner on the basis of the registered sale deed on payment of full sale consideration thereafter the plaintiff’s possession cannot be said to be “lawful possession”. Therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled to any permanent injunction against the true owner in the instant case.

11. From the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court, it appears that the High Court has not properly appreciated the distinction between a substantive relief and a consequential relief. The High Court has observed that in the instant case the relief of permanent injunction can be said to be a substantive relief, which is clearly an erroneous view. It is to be noted that the main reliefs sought by the plaintiff in the suit were cancellation of the sale deed and declaration and the prayer of permanent injunction restraining defendant No.1 from disturbing her possession can be said to be a consequential relief. Therefore, the title to the property was the basis of the relief of possession. If that be so, in the present case, the relief for permanent injunction can be said to be a consequential relief and not a substantive relief as observed and held by the High Court. Therefore, once the plaintiff has failed to get any substantive relief of cancellation of the sale deed and failed to get any declaratory relief, and as observed hereinabove, relief of injunction can be said to be a consequential relief. Therefore, the prayer for permanent injunction must fail. In the instant case as the plaintiff cannot be said to be in lawful possession of the suit land, i.e., the possession of the plaintiff is “not legal or authorised by the law”, the plaintiff shall not be entitled to any permanent injunction.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION 

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1382 OF 2022;


Padhiyar Prahladji Chenaji (Deceased) Through L.R.s Vs Maniben Jagmalbhai (Deceased) Through L.R.s and Ors.

Coram: M.R. SHAH; B.V. NAGARATHNA, JJ. 

Dated:  MARCH 03, 2022

Author: M.R. SHAH, J.

Print Page

Monday, 23 December 2019

Whether it is permissible to convert small cause suit in to regular suit if issue of title is not involved?

 Under Section 33 of the Provincial Small Causes Court Act, a Court invested with the jurisdiction of the Court of Small Causes with respect to exercise of that jurisdiction, and the same Court with respect to exercise of its jurisdiction in Suit of a civil nature which are not cognizable by a Court of Small Causes, shall, for the purposes of the Act and the Code of Civil Procedure Code be deemed to be different Courts. Thus, Judge Small Causes Court though may also be the Court of Civil Judge (Junior Division) it could not have converted the SCC Suit into a regular Civil Suit. The Judge Small Causes Court could have only returned the plaint under Section 23 of the Provincial Small Causes Court Act if there was a dispute regarding the title of the property in question. In this case, there was no such dispute raised by the tenant. He had admitted the relationship of landlord and tenant, but had alleged that he was not in default and the rent had not fallen into arrears.

42. The order passed by the Judge Small Causes Court impugned in this writ petition could not have been passed converting the Suit by exercising inherent power under Section 151 CPC.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD

Matters Under Article 227 No. 3634 of 2018

Decided On: 10.01.2019

 Shafiuddin  Vs. Mashur Alam

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sangeeta Chandra, J.

Citation: AIR 2019(ALL) 155
Print Page

Wednesday, 20 November 2019

Supreme Court: Tenant can not seek enquiry of title of landlord

Whether the share given by Shri Dwarka Prasad to
the appellant who is his son is justified or as to whether the
nature of the document under which the settlement was
recorded was as per requirement of law and valid are all
issues which can only be raised by any other member of
the family who would feel deprived and could have claimed
right over the such property. But in a circumstance where
Shri Dwarka Prasad who admittedly was the owner of the

property had made a settlement in favour of the appellant
who is his son, the title thus acquired, in any event, cannot
be called in question by the person who is in occupation of
the premises as a tenant when Shri Dwarka Prasad who
admittedly was his landlord did not continue to claim to be
the landlord. If that be the position as rightly noticed by
the Appellate Authority, in view of the provision as
contained in Section 8 and Section 109 of Transfer of
Property Act, on transfer of the property by the owner the
tenant would automatically become the tenant of the
transferee. 
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6572 OF 2010

Santosh Chaturvedi  Vs Kailash Chandra 

Dated:November 15, 2019

A.S. Bopanna,J.
Citation: AIR 2020 SC 270 : 2020(1) APEX COURT JUDGMENTS 405 (S.C.)
Print Page

Thursday, 27 June 2019

Whether rent court should decide title dispute of tenanted premises?

 The major question arising for consideration is whether the findings entered into by the Rent Control Appellate Authority that the denial of title was bona fide is legal and proper and is supported by evidence and law. The other question as to whether landlords established the grounds of eviction could arise only if the first question is answered in favour of the revision petitioner.

18. The authorities under the Act are not supposed to decide the title in dispute between the parties since law does not extend its jurisdiction to adjudging the title of parties to the alleged tenanted premises. Such a function to decide title is exclusively confined by law to civil courts. The authority of the functionaries under the Act is only to ascertain whether denial of title in the proceedings is bona fide or not. If the finding entered as required by 2nd proviso to Section 11(1) of the Act accepts denial as a bona fide contention, the eviction of the occupant then could be pursued only in a civil court. Pursuit of eviction proceedings in the Rent Control Court after the finding under the 2nd proviso to Section 11(1) of the Act could be justified only if the said finding ended up in holding that the denial was without bona fides. In testing the bona fides of the contention denying title, the function of the authorities under the Act is only to check up whether such a plea was raised in good faith and with honesty and proceed accordingly. In that process, we however, do not think, it is necessary for the Rent Control Court to make sure that the plea denying title is one which should essentially be upheld by the civil court in the proceedings instituted before it.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

R.C. Rev. No. 234 of 2015

Decided On: 04.06.2019

 Baby Vs.   Babu P. Pappachan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A. Hariprasad and T.V. Anilkumar, JJ.

Print Page