Showing posts with label vague. Show all posts
Showing posts with label vague. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 March 2017

Precaution to be taken by court while passing order for attachment of property for disobedience of injunction order

The penalty imposed by the trial Court reads as hereunder:
"The opp. Parties are hereby found guilty of disobedience of status quo order of this Court. The properties of the O.Ps. be attached and they also be detained in Civil prison for seven days."
It is clearly readable from the above quoted law and underlined portion from the impugned order that the order of attachment of the property as one of the penalties is not in accordance with the provision of law. Extent of property and duration for which it should remain under attachment and extent of restriction for using or dealing with such properties by the person guilty of breach of order of injunction must be made clearly specific and no ambiguity or vagueness should be there. Apart from that, such penalty should be proportionate to the gravity of the act complained. Applying judicial discretion in that respect is the salutary principle.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA
Civil Revision No. 71 of 2002
Decided On: 09.05.2002
Jaigun Nisa Bibi and 2 Ors.
Vs.
 Sk. Badiruddin Zahed
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P.K. Tripathy, J.
Citation:2002(3) Civil court cases 513 Orissa
Print Page

Sunday, 25 September 2016

When notice for amendment of assessment list for recovery of property tax is liable to be quashed?

 On a reading of the afore-quoted provisions, it is clear that
while vesting the power in the Committee to amend an
assessment list, the Legislature has taken care to specify
the circumstances in and the grounds on which such amendment
may be made; it has also laid down the manner in which such
amendment or revision of the assessment list is to be made.
Care has also been taken to comply with the principle of
natural justice by making the provision for giving notice to
the person who is likely to be affected by the proposed
amendment giving him not less than a month’s time to tender
objection, if any, to the Committee and allowing him an
opportunity of being heard in support of the objections
raised. Notice to the affected person mandated in the
section is not an empty formality; it is meant for a
purpose. A vague and unspecific notice will not provide
reasonable opportunity to the noticee to file objection
meeting the reasons/grounds on which the amendment of the
assessment list is proposed to be made. Such a notice
cannot be taken to be complying with the statutory
requirement. On perusal of the notice issued to the
Corporation, which is on record, it is evident that the
notice is vague and lacks particulars. It neither states
the reason for/or the ground on which the amendment is
proposed to be made nor does it indicate any material on the
basis of which the revision as stated in the notice is
proposed to be made. It is stated in the notice: "Whereas
your above-mentioned property has wrongly been left out from
the assessment list, whereas it should have/should have been
in the same. Whereas the assessment of this property of
yours was assessed less due to inadvertent mistake/fraud or
intention, which needs amendment thereby".
 It is apparent that the Committee is not sure on which
ground it proposes to proceed for amending the assessment
list. Such a notice not only does not comply with the
statutory requirements, it also defeats the very purpose of
the statutory provisions. Coming to the question of
increase of the capacity of the godown in question and the
rate of rent, neither the discussions in the orders under
challenge indicate any basis for increasing the capacity of
the godown from 1,84,000 to 2,06,656 bags, nor has our
attention been drawn to any primary material in support of
the order. In the circumstances the contentions raised by
the learned counsel for Corporation that notice is vague and
it has been issued without due application of mind and the
grounds stated in the order are based on no material, have
to be accepted. 
 SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 
CASE NO.: Appeal (civil) 7423 1996
PETITIONER:
FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA
 Vs.
RESPONDENT:
STATE OF PUNJAB & OTHERS
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 01/12/2000
BENCH:
D.P.Mohapatro, Y.K.Sabharwal

Citation:(2001) 1 SCC 291
Print Page

Wednesday, 18 March 2015

Whether court can permit party to adduce evidence when pleading is vague?


There is a glaring omission to mention the names of the workers said to have been employed by the respondent or his agents who have allegedly painted the slogans. So also no material particulars are given as regards the vehicles on which the said slogans have been said to have been painted. There are no material particulars or facts. We are of the view that inasmuch as the material facts and particulars in regard to this alleged practice were not mentioned and the High Court was justified in taking the view that it had taken. The averments contained in regard to this charge also do not satisfy the test laid down by the various decisions of this Court adverted hereinabove. A Division Bench of this Court in Nihal Singh v. Rao Birendra Singh, [1970] 3 S.C.C. 239, speaking through Bhargava, J. has observed :-
"...The pleading was so vague that it left a wide scope to the appellant to adduce evidence in respect of a meeting at any place on any date that he found convenient or for which he could procure witnesses. The pleading, in fact, was so vague and was wanting in essential particulars that no evidence should have been permitted by the High Court on this point...... "
(see para 8) The principle laid down is that the pleading in regard to matters where there is scope for ascribing an alleged corrupt practice to a returned candidate in the context of a meeting of which dates and particulars are not given would tantamount to failure to incorporate the essential particulars and that inasmuch as there was a possibility that witnesses could be procured in the context of a meeting at a place or date convenient for adducing evidence, the High Court should not even have permitted evidence on that point. In other words, no amount of evidence could cure the basic defect in the pleading and the pleading as it stood must be construed as one disclosing no cause of action. In the light of the aforesaid principle laid down by the Supreme Court which has held the field for more than 15 years, the High Court was perfectly Justified in reaching the conclusion called into question by the appellant.
Supreme Court of India

Azhar Hussain vs Rajiv Gandhi on 25 April, 1986
Equivalent citations: 1986 AIR 1253, 1986 SCR (2) 782

Bench: Thakkar, M.P. (J)
    
Print Page