Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 — Section 163-A — Second Schedule — Notification dated 22.05.2018 substituting the Second Schedule — Whether the substituted (enhanced) Schedule can be applied to compute compensation where the accident occurred prior to the date of the notification but the claim/appeal was still pending on that date — Held, yes.
The claimant's daughter, aged 22 years, died in a motor accident on 11.12.2004. A claim under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 was filed before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Sealdah, which computed compensation under the structured formula then prevailing in the Second Schedule and awarded ₹1,14,500 by judgment dated 17.12.2008. The claimant preferred a first appeal seeking enhancement. During the pendency of the appeal, the Central Government, by notification dated 22.05.2018, substituted the Second Schedule to Section 163-A, replacing the age-and-income-linked formula with fixed lump-sum compensation, prescribing ₹5,00,000 for death.
Held: The right to claim compensation under Section 163-A accrues on the date of the accident and is not disturbed by a subsequent amendment to the Second Schedule. However, the Second Schedule prescribes only the mode and modality of computing the quantum of an already-existing statutory liability; it does not itself create or extinguish liability. Since the appeal remained pending and undecided as on the date the substituted Schedule came into force, the enhanced/substituted Schedule — and not the Schedule as it stood on the date of the accident — governs computation of compensation. The claimant was accordingly held entitled to the fixed sum of ₹5,00,000 prescribed under the substituted Schedule, notwithstanding that the accident had occurred nearly fourteen years earlier, and the insurer was directed to pay the balance amount (₹5,00,000 minus the sum already awarded) within two months.
Ratio: A beneficial amendment to the Second Schedule under Section 163-A, altering only the computational formula for an existing no-fault liability, applies to all claims/appeals pending adjudication on the date the amendment comes into force, irrespective of the date of the accident, since the amendment does not create a new cause of action but merely revises the yardstick for quantifying a liability that already exists.
Subsequent history: The insurer's appeal against this judgment was dismissed by the Supreme Court in The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Urmila Halder (Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 6260 of 2019, decided on 8.02.2024), which affirmed the above reasoning and upheld the award of ₹5,00,000.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA
F.M.A. No. 446 of 2010 and F.M.A.T. No. 278 of 2009
Decided On: 09.08.2018
Urmila Halder Vs. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dipankar Datta and Shampa Sarkar, JJ.
Author: Dipankar Datta, J.
Citation: MANU/WB/1123/2018.
Print Page