Showing posts with label S 228A of IPC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S 228A of IPC. Show all posts

Saturday, 5 August 2023

Bombay HC Directs Police To file Photos of victim in sealed cover alongwith chargesheet to avoid disclosure of identity of Victim of Sexual assault

We would like to specifically mention here that Section 228-A was inserted in Indian Penal Code with effect from 25.12.1983, which prohibits disclosure of identity of the victim of certain offences. By S. 4 of Act 13 of 2013, words "offence under Sections 376, 376A, 376B, 376C or section 376D" were substituted/inserted with effect from 03.02.2013. Thereafter, by Act 22 of 2018 further amendment in respect of other Sections has been made with effect from 21.04.2018. Thus, the identity of the victim cannot be disclosed by any of the authorities in the charge-sheet. Nowadays, we are finding that photographs are taken i.e. either the old photographs are collected or even victim showing the spot of occurrence are taken and those photographs are produced in the charge-sheet. We do not say that such photographs should not be collected or should not be taken, but we expect that those photographs should not be openly added as part of charge-sheet. A charge-sheet travels from the office of the investigating agency (may be handled by many persons), then it comes to either the Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class or directly presented before the learned Special Judge where also it is handled by many persons. Under such circumstance, the identity of the victim is disclosed. The investigating agency has to be sensitive in the matter. If they want to produce such documents, then it should be put in a sealed envelope including in the copies of the charge-sheet also, so that the identity of the victim is not disclosed in any manner. In the catena of judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court as well as this Court, it has been stressed that the identity of the victim in such cases, i.e. under Section 376 and other Sections of Indian Penal Code, POCSO Act, should not be disclosed. We are constrained to make these observations, as we are coming across such incidences time and again. We may also observe that when it was found that the accused facing charge under these Sections want to rely on certain photographs in which victim is seen then those photographs are openly placed/annexed in the petition. Coordinate Bench at Principal Seat has given directions that they should be filed under sealed envelope. We take those directions further and direct all the concerned agencies, who are dealing with the investigation of such crime that henceforth the photographs of such victims should be filed in sealed envelope before the concerned Courts. We may also say that failure to follow the directions may invite the action for the offence under Section 228-A of the Indian Penal Code. These directions are also to the concerned Courts where the charge-sheet is accepted. They should also see that such photographs are produced in sealed envelope before them and the identity of the victim is not disclosed in any manner.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Appeal No. 869 of 2022

Decided On: 08.02.2023

Sajjan  Vs.  The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vibha Kankanwadi and Abhay S. Waghwase, JJ.

Citation: MANU/MH/0509/2023.

Print Page

Monday, 14 September 2020

Kerala high court guidelines for Maintaining Rape Victim Anonymity In Cases Filed Before It

It is observed that in several matters instituted before
this court where victim anonymity is to be maintained, the identity of
the victim is disclosed directly or indirectly. In some matters, identity is
disclosed in the pleadings and in some others, identity is disclosed in
the documents produced along with the pleadings. It is also observed
that though documents revealing the identity of the victim are
produced in sealed covers in the light of the decision of the Apex Court
in Nipun Saxena and another v. Union of India and others, (2019)
2 SCC 703, there is no system in place to maintain victim anonymity,
once the sealed covers are opened by the court. In the case on hand, it
is observed that the opened cover containing the documents were sent
back to the section and brought back from the section to the court on
the subsequent hearing dates. It is also observed that there is no
system in place for disposal of the documents produced in sealed
covers, after the final disposal of the case. Similarly, it is observed that
the registry is insisting copies of the documents revealing the identity
of the victims to be given to the opposite parties in the matter. There is

no system in place to maintain victim anonymity in such situations.
Needless to say, the procedure in place to maintain victim anonymity is
against the spirit of Section 228A of the Indian Penal Code, Sections
24(5), 33(7) and 37 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences
Act, 2012, and the decision of the Apex Court in Nipun Saxena. In the
circumstances, the following directions are issued for future guidelines
for maintaining victim anonymity in the matters instituted before this
court:
1. The criteria for deciding the identity of the victim shall
include the identity of the family of the victim, the school/college of the
victim, the place of work of the victim, the relatives of the victim, the
neighbourhood of the victim and all other information from which the
identity of the victim would be revealed.
2. In all proceedings instituted by or on behalf of the
victim and against them, documents in which the identity of the victim
is disclosed, either required in terms of the rules of the court or
produced by the parties concerned to substantiate their case, shall be
insisted to be filed in a sealed cover.
3. The registry shall designate an officer for the proper
custody of documents produced in sealed covers in cases where victim
anonymity is to be maintained and shall provide to that officer
necessary infrastructure for keeping custody of the documents. Such
officer shall be bound by the highest standards of confidentiality.
4. After the matter is numbered, registry shall forward
the documents received in sealed covers in a self-sealing bag/envelope

of appropriate size, preferably one having a provision for tamper proof
seal as well, or in other similar tamper proof bag/envelope, after
affixing on it a label indicating the particulars of the case under the
signature of the Filing Scrutiny Officer concerned to the designated
officer for custody and that officer shall ensure that the documents are
made available to the court as and when the matters are listed for
hearing.
5. If the self-sealing bag/envelope in which the
documents are kept is opened by the court for perusal of the
documents, after the purposes of the court, the same shall be kept in a
fresh self-sealing bag/envelope and returned to the designated officer,
after affixing on the same a new label indicating the particulars of the
case under the signature of the Court Officer concerned. If the selfsealing
bag/envelope is opened subsequently by the court, the same
procedure directed herein-above shall be repeated.
6. The parties producing documents disclosing the
identity of the victims need not have to keep or give copies of the same to the opposite parties and they need only refer to such documents in their pleadings.
7. If the lawyers appearing against the victims
require/need to peruse the documents in the sealed covers, they shall peruse the same with the permission of the court and if they are permitted by the court to peruse the documents, the documents shall be preserved in the same manner indicated in the preceding directions.
8. These directions shall be in force until replaced by the

Honourable the Chief Justice by appropriate practice instructions.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT

Crl.MC.No.3463 OF 2020(C)


X  Vs  STATE OF KERALA


Coram: P.B.SURESH KUMAR, J.

Dated this the 9th day of September, 2020
Print Page

Tuesday, 2 October 2018

Whether identity of family members of Rape victim is to be protected?

Before parting, we have noticed that in the
order passed by the learned trial Court, the name of the
victim girl is disclosed. We have also noticed in some
other cases tried by the learned trial Court under Section
376 of IPC or under POCSO Act that the names of the victim
girls or the names of parents of victim girls are
mentioned in the Judgment. Section 228A
of the Indian
Penal Code makes disclosure of the identity of a victim of
certain offences punishable. Printing or publishing name
or any matter which may make known the identity of any
person against whom offence under Sections 376, 376A,
376B,
376C
or 376D,
IPC is alleged or found to have
been committed can be punished. The Apex Court in State of
Karnataka v/s. Puttaraja [ Appeal (crl.) 506 of 199 7
Decided on 27112003]
, has held that, “Though Section
228A
IPC does not put any restriction to print or
publish the name of victim of such offences in the
judgment by the High Court or the Supreme Court, but

keeping in view the social object of preventing social
victimisation or ostracism of the victim of a sexual
offence for which Section 228A
IPC has been enacted it
would be appropriate that in the judgment, be they of
Supreme Court, High Court or the lower Court, the name of
the victim should not be indicated”. Further in State of
H. P. v/s. Shree Kant Shekari (2004 Cri LJ 4232), the
Apex Court has reiterated that position. The relevant
portion of the judgment in Puttaraja case is quoted
below :
" We do not propose to mention the name of the victim.
Section 228A
of the Indian Penal Code 1860 (in short
"IPC") makes disclosure of identity of victim of certain
offences punishable. Printing or publishing name or any
matter which may make known the identity of any person
against whom an offence under Section 376, 376A,
376B,
376C
or 376D
is alleged or found to have been committed
can be punished. True it is, the restriction does not
relate to printing or publication of the judgment by the
High Court or the Supreme Court. But keeping in view the
social object of preventing social victimization or
ostracism of the victim of a sexual offence for which
Section 228A
has been connected, it would be appropriate
that in the judgments, be it of this Court the High Court

or the Lower Court the name of the victim should not be
indicated. We have chosen to describe her as the victim
in the judgment."
09. In view of the aforesaid legal position, we
direct that the learned trial Court shall not in future
indicate the name (either full or even first name) of the
victim of the offences under Section 376, 376A,
376B,
376C
or 376D
of IPC in the judgment and orders. The said
protection can also be extended to the family of the
victim. The identity of parents/ brother/ sister of the
victim is also required to be protected. This Protection
is also required to be given to the victims and their
parents, etc. in cases under Protection of Children from
Sexual Offences Act. It is unfortunate that such
directions are required to be given even after the
pronouncement of decision in Puttaraja in 2003.
10. Another fact that is required to be noted that
all the orders and judgments of all the Courts are
required to be uploaded on the website.
In view of
Section 15A of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, the victim or first
informant has a right to be heard. Therefore, in
applications for bail or appeals, many times (when above:::

said IPC sections or under Protection of Children from
Sexual Offences Act are also invoked), the victim or her
parent is made party. After uploading of order in such
matters, the identity of the victim would be disclosed and
therefore, directions are required to be given to all the
concerned Courts that precautions should be taken, while
uploading the order or judgment in such bail applications
or any application, so that the identity of the victim or
his / her parents is not disclosed from the same.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 501 OF 2018

Parmeshwar Dnyanoba Nagargoje, Vs  The State of Maharashtra,


CORAM : T. V. NALAWADE &
SMT. VIBHA KANKANWADI, JJ.
DATE : 20-08-2018.
ORAL ORDER : (Per Smt. Vibha Kankanwadi, J)
Print Page