Showing posts with label confidentiality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label confidentiality. Show all posts

Friday, 23 August 2024

What is the duty of the parties who wish to cite in court any identifying particulars of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor of sexual offences?

 34.2.9. If the parties wish to cite in court any identifying particulars of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor, including photographs or social media communications etc., such party may bring the same to court in 'sealed cover'; or file the same in 'sealed cover' or in a 'pass-code locked' electronic folder and share the pass-code only with the concerned Court Master.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Bail Appln. 3635/2022

Decided On: 19.04.2023

Saleem Vs. The State of NCT of Delhi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Anup Jairam Bhambhani, J.

Citation: 2023:DHC:2622,MANU/DE/2515/2023.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Under which circumstances, names of accused should not be mentioned in court filings?

 34.2.3. The name, parentage and address of family members of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor - through whom the prosecutrix/victim/survivor could be identified - must not be disclosed in the filings, including in the memo of parties, even if they are accused in the case, since this may indirectly lead to the identification of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor;

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Bail Appln. 3635/2022

Decided On: 19.04.2023

Saleem Vs. The State of NCT of Delhi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Anup Jairam Bhambhani, J.

Citation: 2023:DHC:2622,MANU/DE/2515/2023.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.


Print Page

Delhi high court guidelines to ensure that the anonymity and confidentiality of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor of sexual offences

 34. Furthermore, as a sequitur to the above, this court issues the following directions:


34.1. It is directed that the Registry must carefully scrutinise all filings relating to sexual offences, to ensure that the anonymity and confidentiality of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor is strictly maintained;


34.2. To be more specific, in order to maintain confidentiality as aforesaid, the following must be done :


34.2.1. The name, parentage, address, social media credentials and photographs of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor must not be disclosed in the filings made in court, including in the memo of parties;


34.2.2. Though, if the foregoing direction is scrupulously followed, the identifying particulars would not appear in the cause-list, by way of abundant caution, the Registry must ensure that such particulars do not get reflected in the cause-list of the court in any manner;


34.2.3. The name, parentage and address of family members of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor - through whom the prosecutrix/victim/survivor could be identified - must not be disclosed in the filings, including in the memo of parties, even if they are accused in the case, since this may indirectly lead to the identification of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor;


34.2.4. Since redaction of the identifying particulars of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor from the FIR, chargesheet, proceedings before the trial court and other similar records, is the duty and obligation of the authorities/court that prepare such documents; and insofar as the proceedings before this court are concerned, making complete redaction in each of those documents may not be feasible, it is also directed that the files/paper-books/e-portfolio of matters relating to sexual offences filed in this court must not be provided to any person other than the parties to the litigation, to the prosecutrix/victim/survivor and their respective counsel, after due verification of the identity credentials of such persons;


34.2.5. At the stage of scrutiny of the filings, in the event the Registry finds that the identity credentials of a prosecutrix/victim/survivor are disclosed in the memo of parties or anywhere else in the filings, such filings must be returned to counsel who have filed the same, to undertake requisite redactions, before the filings are accepted;


34.2.6. To obviate the dissemination of identifying particulars to any other person or agency even within the High Court, it is further directed that all service to be effected upon the prosecutrix/victim/survivor shall only be through the Investigating Officer in accordance with Practice Directions dated 24.09.2019 and not through the process serving agency, though a copy of the petition or application must be served upon the prosecutrix/victim/survivor;


34.2.7. In effecting service as aforesaid, the Investigating Officer must remain in 'plain clothes' so as to avoid any unwarranted attention;


34.2.8. Furthermore, the Investigating Officer must also inform the prosecutrix/victim/survivor that they have the right to free legal-aid/representation in accordance with the mandate of the Supreme Court in Delhi Domestic Working Women's Forum vs. Union of India & Ors; MANU/SC/0519/1995 : (1995) 1 SCC 14 cf. para 15


34.2.9. If the parties wish to cite in court any identifying particulars of the prosecutrix/victim/survivor, including photographs or social media communications etc., such party may bring the same to court in 'sealed cover'; or file the same in 'sealed cover' or in a 'pass-code locked' electronic folder and share the pass-code only with the concerned Court Master.


34.3. The foregoing directions are not intended to be exhaustive; and at the stage of scrutiny, the Registry is expected to apply its mind to any peculiarities of a given case, with the aim and intent of scrupulously applying the directions of the Supreme Court in Nipun Saxena (supra).

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Bail Appln. 3635/2022

Decided On: 19.04.2023

Saleem Vs. The State of NCT of Delhi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Anup Jairam Bhambhani, J.

Citation: 2023:DHC:2622,MANU/DE/2515/2023.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.


Print Page

Monday, 14 September 2020

Kerala high court guidelines for Maintaining Rape Victim Anonymity In Cases Filed Before It

It is observed that in several matters instituted before
this court where victim anonymity is to be maintained, the identity of
the victim is disclosed directly or indirectly. In some matters, identity is
disclosed in the pleadings and in some others, identity is disclosed in
the documents produced along with the pleadings. It is also observed
that though documents revealing the identity of the victim are
produced in sealed covers in the light of the decision of the Apex Court
in Nipun Saxena and another v. Union of India and others, (2019)
2 SCC 703, there is no system in place to maintain victim anonymity,
once the sealed covers are opened by the court. In the case on hand, it
is observed that the opened cover containing the documents were sent
back to the section and brought back from the section to the court on
the subsequent hearing dates. It is also observed that there is no
system in place for disposal of the documents produced in sealed
covers, after the final disposal of the case. Similarly, it is observed that
the registry is insisting copies of the documents revealing the identity
of the victims to be given to the opposite parties in the matter. There is

no system in place to maintain victim anonymity in such situations.
Needless to say, the procedure in place to maintain victim anonymity is
against the spirit of Section 228A of the Indian Penal Code, Sections
24(5), 33(7) and 37 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences
Act, 2012, and the decision of the Apex Court in Nipun Saxena. In the
circumstances, the following directions are issued for future guidelines
for maintaining victim anonymity in the matters instituted before this
court:
1. The criteria for deciding the identity of the victim shall
include the identity of the family of the victim, the school/college of the
victim, the place of work of the victim, the relatives of the victim, the
neighbourhood of the victim and all other information from which the
identity of the victim would be revealed.
2. In all proceedings instituted by or on behalf of the
victim and against them, documents in which the identity of the victim
is disclosed, either required in terms of the rules of the court or
produced by the parties concerned to substantiate their case, shall be
insisted to be filed in a sealed cover.
3. The registry shall designate an officer for the proper
custody of documents produced in sealed covers in cases where victim
anonymity is to be maintained and shall provide to that officer
necessary infrastructure for keeping custody of the documents. Such
officer shall be bound by the highest standards of confidentiality.
4. After the matter is numbered, registry shall forward
the documents received in sealed covers in a self-sealing bag/envelope

of appropriate size, preferably one having a provision for tamper proof
seal as well, or in other similar tamper proof bag/envelope, after
affixing on it a label indicating the particulars of the case under the
signature of the Filing Scrutiny Officer concerned to the designated
officer for custody and that officer shall ensure that the documents are
made available to the court as and when the matters are listed for
hearing.
5. If the self-sealing bag/envelope in which the
documents are kept is opened by the court for perusal of the
documents, after the purposes of the court, the same shall be kept in a
fresh self-sealing bag/envelope and returned to the designated officer,
after affixing on the same a new label indicating the particulars of the
case under the signature of the Court Officer concerned. If the selfsealing
bag/envelope is opened subsequently by the court, the same
procedure directed herein-above shall be repeated.
6. The parties producing documents disclosing the
identity of the victims need not have to keep or give copies of the same to the opposite parties and they need only refer to such documents in their pleadings.
7. If the lawyers appearing against the victims
require/need to peruse the documents in the sealed covers, they shall peruse the same with the permission of the court and if they are permitted by the court to peruse the documents, the documents shall be preserved in the same manner indicated in the preceding directions.
8. These directions shall be in force until replaced by the

Honourable the Chief Justice by appropriate practice instructions.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT

Crl.MC.No.3463 OF 2020(C)


X  Vs  STATE OF KERALA


Coram: P.B.SURESH KUMAR, J.

Dated this the 9th day of September, 2020
Print Page

Sunday, 13 January 2019

When court should strike off mediation report?

Going by Rule 23 of the Rules, a mediator is not entitled to communicate to the court except in respect of the matters mentioned in the Rule. Sub clauses (i) and (ii) of Clause (a) of Rule 23 do not cause any difficulty for interpretation. What is the meaning of the words "getting advice on procedural matters with the consent of the parties" occurring in Sub clause (iii) of Clause (a) of Rule 23 is the question which arises for decision. Sri Joby Jacob Pulickekudy, the learned counsel appearing for the fourth respondent, submitted that the mediator has only sought the advice on procedural matters and therefore, the mediation report is legal and proper. A mediator can get advice on procedural matters only with the consent of parties. If the parties do not give consent, the mediator has no right to get advice on procedural matters. In the present case, the petitioner was not present at all before the mediator. She expressed her view that she was not participating in the mediation. The mediator, therefore, could communicate to the court only in the manner provided under sub-clause (i) of Clause (a) of Rule 23 and submit a failure report. In the absence of parties, the mediator had no jurisdiction to seek the advice on procedural matters. One of the parties having expressed her reluctance to appear before the mediator, the mediator was not justified in arriving at "findings and conclusions" and thereafter seeking directions from the court. Even the directions sought for are not on procedural matters or to enable the mediator to carry on the mediation proceedings in a particular manner, but the directions are sought to be issued to the parties. The mediator was not justified in undertaking a video conferencing with some of the parties in the absence of commencement of mediation in accordance with law. No mediation at all took place. On the refusal of a party to appear before the mediator, there was no justification for the mediator to undertake an expedition with respect to the disputes between the parties. Conducting a video conferencing, in the absence of one of the parties, was also quite illegal. Smt. Rekha Vasudevan, the learned counsel appearing for the 5th respondent, submitted that the prayer made by the petitioner is not maintainable in view of Rule 22 of the Rules. Rule 22 provides that no mediator shall be held liable for anything bona fide done or omitted to be done by him during the mediation proceedings. The prayer made in the application is not to take any action against the mediator. No action is sought to be taken against the mediator. Immunity contemplated under Rule 22 does not take away the power of the court to say that the mediation report is not liable to be accepted or to strike off the mediation report or to hold that the mediator acted without jurisdiction. The very appointment of mediator by the court carries with it the power to cancel it also. If the mediator has misconducted himself or if the mediation report is otherwise illegal being contrary to the Rules, the court in which the proceedings are pending would have jurisdiction to pass appropriate orders with regard to the acceptability or otherwise of the mediation report. Immunity under Rule 22 does not deter the court from doing so.

We are satisfied that the mediator travelled beyond his powers and the mediation report is liable to be struck off, except to the extent of communication that the mediation failed. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA

W.P. (Crl.) No. 278 of 2012

Decided On: 06.07.2012

 Prabhavathy, K. Vs. Director General of Police and Others

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Mr. Justice K.T. Sankaran and Mr. Justice M.L. Joseph Francis

Citation: ILR 2012(3) Kerala 922
Print Page

Guidelines of Supreme court regarding confidentiality in Mediation

 In this connection, we would like to state that mediation proceedings are totally confidential proceedings. This is unlike proceedings in Court which are conducted openly in the public gaze. If the mediation succeeds, then the mediator should send the agreement signed by both the parties to the Court without mentioning what transpired during the mediation proceedings. If the mediation is unsuccessful, then the mediator should only write one sentence in his report and send it to the Court stating that the 'Mediation has been unsuccessful'. Beyond that, the mediator should not write anything which was discussed, proposed or done during the mediation proceedings. This is because in mediation, very often, offers, counter offers and proposals are made by the parties but until and unless the parties reach to an agreement signed by them, it will not amount to any concluded contract. If the happenings in the mediation proceedings are disclosed, it will destroy the confidentiality of the mediation process.

3. We are compelled to observe this because the mediators should know what kind of reports they should send to the Courts. The report sent in this core should not have mentioned the proposals made by the parties, but should only have stated that the mediation was unsuccessful.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

C.A. No. 1095 of 2008

Decided On: 07.12.2010

 Moti Ram  Vs.  Ashok Kumar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram: 
Markandey Katju and Gyan Sudha Misra, JJ.


Citation: (2011)1 SCC 466
Print Page

Friday, 2 June 2017

Whether parties can unilaterally withdraw from agreement entered before mediator?

The mediator


appointed will have to report to the court as to whether the matter is

settled or not settled. In case, the mediation has not taken place; he

will have to report, 'not mediated'. He has no duty other than the

above. The mediator cannot forward any agreement to the court to

the effect as to what course of procedure to be followed by the court

for passing a decree.

      8.    However, when the parties settled the disputes by signing

an agreement, detailing the procedures to be followed to work out

such settlement, certainly, that agreement is having all the

characteristics of compromise in terms of Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC.

Once a compromise is arrived at between the parties, it is a

settlement of dispute referred to in the mediation pending before the

court. When the parties to the dispute sign the compromise, this

settlement comes to the public domain.           Confidentiality of the

mediation covers the matters only upto the stage of reaching at a

settlement or till the termination of the mediation. The parties when

put their signature by accepting the terms and conditions in writing,

the agreement is having all the characteristics of the compromise as

referred to under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC and no party can withdraw

from it unilaterally. The moment it reaches the court, the court will


have to act upon the compromise and to pass a decree in terms of

the compromise.       No doubt, the court concerned will have to be

satisfied with the legality of the compromise as well as jurisdiction to

pass a decree based on such compromise. Once a settlement has

been arrived at between the parties in relation to the matter in the

suit, that concludes as far as the court concerned in relation to the

dispute resolved in the settlement. It is to be noted that the court

recording the compromise is entering into a satisfaction in terms or

Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC and the court is not merely acting upon

agreement. If one party wants to withdraw from the agreement, the

court has every power to decide whether the agreement was effected

lawfully or not. If it is proved to the satisfaction of the court that the

dispute has been settled wholly or in part by a compromise, the court

shall pass a decree in accordance with the agreement. The proviso

to Order XXIII Rule 3 has a significant guidance in this regard.

Therefore, if in the case of denial of an agreement or in the case of

unilateral withdrawal, the court will have to enter a satisfaction

whether there was a compromise of the subject matter of the suit or

not. In fact, in the case of denial or withdrawal of the agreement, the


court is bound to frame a question in this regard and decide the

matter as contemplated under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

                                                      PRESENT:

                   MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE

            15TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2017

                                          OP(C).No. 3131 of 2016 (O)
                                                
         MOHANAN P.K.,
         V
          SUDAKSHINA RAMAKRISHNAN,
           


Print Page