Showing posts with label S 53A of TP Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S 53A of TP Act. Show all posts

Saturday, 4 April 2026

Bombay HC: Whether third party has locus standi to plead on behalf of the real owner that it is he (real owner), who was to be benefited by the Benami transaction?

 It is, therefore, necessary to understand whether the evidence is sufficient to prove that the appellant was holding property Benami. The appellant's husband is not party to the suit and, therefore, he has not claimed himself to be the real owner of the property. To my mind and in terms of Section 4 of the Benami Transactions Act, the question, whether the property held Benami was for the benefit of real owner, can only be answered when the real owner either files a suit or raises a defence on this count. It is so because the intention behind the Benami transaction is known to the person in whose name the property has been purchased or the person who has purchased the property in the name of other. A third party has no locus to plead on behalf of the real owner that it is he (real owner), who was to be benefited by the Benami transaction, unless third party otherwise proves. {Para 12}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 616/2007

Decided On: 26.04.2024

Badrunisa Vs. Sabdar Khan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Anil L. Pansare, J.

Citation: 2024:BHC-NAG:4870, MANU/MH/2715/2024.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Bombay HC: Whether agreement executed by husband of original owner will be concluded contract and will bind his wife?

 The respondents have placed on record a document Exh.-78, allegedly signed by the plaintiff's husband stating therein that the suit property is agreed to be sold to the respondent No. 1. As such, the husband has denied execution of document and even if the document is presumed to be signed by the appellant's husband, it does not satisfy the ingredients of the concluded contract, at least, not against the appellant and, therefore, the question of granting protection under Section 53-A of the Act does not arise at all. {Para 17}


18. Both the Courts below have thus committed serious error of law in holding that the transaction under question was Benami and secondly that there was valid contract between the appellant and the respondents.


19. Put all together, it cannot be said that agreement dated 07.07.1995 is binding upon the appellant-plaintiff inasmuch as the document is the unilateral document, signed by the appellant's husband. The respondents failed to establish a concluded contract with the plaintiff. The substantial question of law is answered accordingly.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 616/2007

Decided On: 26.04.2024

Badrunisa Vs. Sabdar Khan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Anil L. Pansare, J.

Citation: 2024:BHC-NAG:4870, MANU/MH/2715/2024

Print Page

Sunday, 15 February 2026

Supreme Court: Transferee cannot claim protection U/S 53-A of TPA if he fails to prove the execution of a sale agreement based on which possession was claimed.

 In terms of this provision, if the above preconditions stand

complied with, the transferor or any person claiming under him

shall be debarred from enforcing against the transferee and

person(s) claiming under him, any right in respect of the property

of which the transferee has taken or continue in possession, other

than a right expressly provided by the terms of the contract,

notwithstanding the fact, that the transfer, as contemplated, had

not been completed in the manner prescribed therefor by the law for

the time being in force. Noticeably, an exception to this restraint

is carved out qua a transferee for consideration, who has no notice

of the contract or of the part-performance thereof. {Para 12}

13. Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act was inserted

partly to set at rest the conflict of views in this country, but

principally for the protection of ignorant transferees who take

possession or spend money in improvements relying on documents

which are ineffective as transfers or on contracts which cannot be

proved for want of registration. The effect of this section, is to

relax the strict provisions of the Transfer of Property Act and the

Registration Act in favour of transferees in order to allow the

defence of part performance to be established.

14. Section 53-A is an exception to the provisions which require a

contract to be in writing and registered and which bar proof of

such contract by any other evidence. Consequently, the exception must be strictly construed.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

EXTRAORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION

SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No.30804 of 2024

[Diary No(s). 56304/2024]

GIRIYAPPA & ANR. Vs KAMALAMMA & ORS. 

Citation: 2024 INSC 1043

Dated: 20th DECEMBER, 2024.

Print Page

Monday, 24 March 2025

Supreme Court: S.53A Transfer Of Property Act Protection Not Available If Person Entered Into Agreement Knowing About Pending Litigation

The High Court also dealt with the submissions raised by the learned Counsel for the Appellant qua the applicability of Section 53A of the TP Act. It is the admitted fact that the Revision Petitioner having the knowledge of the pendency of the suit, had entered into agreement with the father of the Respondent Nos. 1 to 8 and he could not have better and valid right over the rights of the original transferer and in that situation, no recourse could have been taken. {Para 8}


9. The High Court rightly observed that the Courts have uniformly held that the limited rights of the transferee pendent lite on the principle of lis pendens. Such limited rights cannot be stretched to obstruct and resist the full claim of the decree holders to execute the decree in their favour. In fact, the Courts have deprecated such obstruction.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3616/2024

Decided On: 19.03.2025

Raju Naidu Vs. Chenmouga Sundra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sudhanshu Dhulia and P.B. Varale, JJ.

Author: P.B. Varale, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 368,MANU/SC/0366/2025.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme Court: The merger of a decree takes place irrespective of the fact as to whether the Appellate Court affirms, modifies or reverses the decree passed by the trial court

The doctrine of merger is based on the principles of propriety in the hierarchy of justice delivery system. The doctrine of merger does not make a distinction between an order of reversal, modification or an order of confirmation passed by the appellate authority. The said doctrine postulates that there cannot be more than one operative decree governing the same subject matter at a given point of time. It is trite that when an Appellate Court passes a decree, the decree of the trial court merges with the decree of the Appellate Court and even if and subject to any modification that may be made in the appellate decree, the decree of the Appellate Court supersedes the decree of the trial court. In other words, merger of a decree takes place irrespective of the fact as to whether the Appellate Court affirms, modifies or reverses the decree passed by the trial court.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3616/2024

Decided On: 19.03.2025

Raju Naidu Vs. Chenmouga Sundra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sudhanshu Dhulia and P.B. Varale, JJ.

Author: P.B. Varale, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 368,MANU/SC/0366/2025.
Print Page

Sunday, 4 April 2021

Whether tenant can acquire possessory right in tenanted premises under the oral agreement of sale?

 I have perused the judgment of the Trial Court. Trial Court has

decreed the suit on the ground that in the written statement the Appellant admitted payment of rental amount from time to time and did not claim that the status of the Appellant was severed as a tenant completely. Even assuming that the Appellant had entered into an agreement to sell for purchasing the suit property from the Respondent and had paid part consideration, at best, the Appellant could rely on the agreement for two purposes i.e. (i) file a suit for specific performance seeking execution of

the sale deed; and (ii) claim protection under Section 53A of the Act. It was also an admitted case that there was no written Agreement to Sell ever executed between the parties and the defence of the Appellant was based on an oral agreement. Based on the amendment to Section 17 of the Registration Act, whereby the Registration of an Agreement to Sell has been made compulsory as well as amendment to Section 53A of the Act

and the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, the Trial Court concluded that in the absence of a registered Agreement to Sell the Appellant could not claim protection under Section 53A of the Act. Based on the proposition of law laid down in Sudhir Sabharwal vs. Rajesh Pruthi 2014 AIR CC 2850 by this Court that mere Agreement to Sell of immovable property will not terminate the landlord-tenant relationship, the Trial Court was of the view

that no purpose would be served to put the matter to trial and passed the judgment, noting that while there was no admission, however, if thedefendant has no legal defence, then under Order XIV Rule 1(6) CPC, judgment can be straightaway passed.{Para 12}

14. Appellant in the written statement admitted that he was inducted as a tenant in the year 2013 vide a registered lease deed dated 09.09.2013 and also admitted the renewal of the lease till 2015. Appellant, however, set up an oral agreement to sell and also pleaded payment of Rs.30 Lakhs towards part consideration of the sale price.

15. The issue that arises before this Court is as to whether the

Appellant could claim retention of the suit property on the plea of an oral Agreement to Sell.

16. The answer to the above question in my view can only be against the Appellant. The legal position on this aspect is no longer res integra. Section 17 of the Registration Act was amended by the Registration and Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2001, Act No.48 of 2001, by insertion of Section 1(A) therein and by virtue of the Amendment, registration of an Agreement to Sell has been made compulsory with effect from 24.09.2001. Section 17(1-A) reads as follows:-

“Section (1A). The documents containing contracts

to transfer for consideration, any immovable

property for the purpose of Section 53A of the

Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (4 of 1882) shall be

registered if they have been executed on or after the

commencement of the Registration and other

Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2001 and if such

documents are not registered on or after such

commencement (i.e. w.e.f. 24.09.2001), then, they

shall have no effect for the purposes of the said

Section 53A.”

17. Therefore, a buyer cannot avail the benefit of Section 53A of the Act if the agreement to sell is not registered. When a tenant enters into an agreement to sell for buying the tenanted premises but the agreement to sell is not in conformity with law, the relationship continues as landlord tenant and while the tenant can seek specific performance, but he acquires no right to retain possession, till a sale deed is registered in his favour.


In view of the legal position that “mere agreement

to sell of immovable property does not create any

right in the property save the right to enforce the

said agreement” and in view of the preceding

discussion that “mere agreement of sale will not

terminate landlord- tenant relationship unless there

is specification to that effect in agreement itself”,

this Court is of the view defendant has not right to

occupy the said property.”

18. In Shiv Kumar vs. Sumit Gulati, RSA No.417/2015, decided on 04.12.2015, the Court held that when the defendant claims possession on the basis of an oral agreement to sell, the same cannot be recognized in view of the amended Section 53A of the Act. 

19. Significantly in the present case the relationship between the

parties as landlord-tenant is an admitted position. It is also admitted that the rent of the premises was over Rs.3,500/- as also that the Respondent terminated the lease by sending a notice under Section 106 of the Act. In view of the said position and in the absence of the alleged oral agreement being registered, the Trial Court has rightly passed a decree for recovery of the suit property and no infirmity can be found. The suit is pending on

other reliefs and shall be continued and adjudicated in accordance with law.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI


 RFA 272/2020 and CM 28819/2020, 28820/2020 and 28818/2020

PRASHANT GOYAL Vs INDRANIL WADHWA .

CORAM:

HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH

Date of decision: 11.11.2020

Print Page