In the present case, the controversy has arisen in an
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. Whether the matter
comes within the purview of Section 4(3) of the Act is an
aspect which must be gone into on the strength of the evidence
on record. Going by the averments in the plaint, the question
whether the plea raised by the appellant is barred under
Section 4 of the Act or not could not have been the subjectmatter
of assessment at the stage when application under
Order 7 Rule 11 CPC was taken up for consideration. The
matter required fuller and final consideration after the
evidence was led by the parties. It cannot be said that the plea
of the appellant as raised on the face of it, was barred under
the Act. The approach must be to proceed on a demurrer and
see whether accepting the averments in the plaint the suit is
barred by any law or not. We may quote the following
observations of this Court in Popat and Kotecha
Property v. SBI Staff Assn. [Popat and Kotecha
Property v. SBI Staff Assn., (2005) 7 SCC 510] : (SCC p. 515,
para 10)
10. Clause (d) of Order 7 Rule 7 speaks of suit, as appears
from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any law.
Disputed questions cannot be decided at the time of
considering an application filed under Order 7 Rule 11
CPC. Clause (d) of Rule 11 of Order 7 applies in those cases
only where the statement made by the plaintiff in the plaint,
without any doubt or dispute shows that the suit is barred by
(emphasis added)
23. If we go strictly by the averments made in the plaint and the
documents filed by the appellant/plaintiffs, we are of the opinion that the
suit ought not to have been rejected outright under Order VII Rule 11 CPC
on the ground that the pleas taken by the appellants/plaintiffs are barred
under Section 4(3) of the unamended Benami Act. In our view, the matter
would require a more comprehensive consideration after permitting the
parties to lead evidence in the case. Order VII Rule 11 CPC was not the
appropriate stage for testing the veracity of the pleas taken in the plaint and
return any finding on the merits of the said plea taken by the
appellants/plaintiffs in the plaint or to extensively examine the underlying
intent of the parties on a perusal of the documents filed by the appellants. On
a bare reading of the averments made in the plaint read in conjunction with
the documents placed on record, we are of the opinion that sufficient
material facts have been disclosed requiring determination only after a
proper trial. At the stage of deciding an application moved by the
respondents under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, there was no occasion for the
court to have taken pains to interpret and analyse the documents filed by the
appellants/plaintiffs to hold in favour of the respondents.
24. In the instant case where it has been asserted that the suit premises
was purchased in the name of the respondent No.1, but from the exclusive
contributions made by late Shri R.P. Dhir and therefore in reality, was meant
for the benefit of all the family members, the real test would be the source
from which the purchase money came from, the nature and status of
possession of the property after its purchase, the motive if any for giving the
transaction a Benami colour, the position of the parties and their inter se
relationship, between the appellants/plaintiffs and the respondent No.1, the
overall conduct of the parties in dealing with the suit premises after it was
acquired, etc. [Refer: Jaydayal Poddar (Deceased) through LRs and Anr. vs.
Mst. Bibi Hazra and Ors. reported as (1974) 1 SCC 3] It would therefore be
imperative to weigh the evidence in the instant case for the court to
conclusively decide as to whether the appellants/plaintiffs can succeed in
their claim that the respondent No.1 is holding the suit premises in a
fiduciary capacity, for the benefit of all the family members.