Showing posts with label Servant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Servant. Show all posts

Friday, 24 September 2021

Should the court reject the plaint if the caretaker of the property claims an interest in the property against the owner of the property?

 The respondent no.1-plaintiff filed a suit with the

following prayer:

a) for a declaration that the plaintiff is a

lawful occupier as caretaker/servant of the sole

owner of the A schedule property and occupier and

adverse possessor of the B Schedule property.

After the notice was served. The application under

Order VII Rule 11, CPC came to be filed at the behest of

the present appellant-defendant with an objection that the

suit proceedings at the instance of the respondent no.1-

plaintiff who had pleaded himself to be a

caretaker/servant, acquires no interest in the subject

property irrespective of his long possession, is not

maintainable under the law and as regards the plea of

adverse possession is concerned, it lacks material

particulars.

The Trial Judge dismissed the application on the

premise that these are the subject matter of disputes which

can be examined only after the written statement being

filed at the behest of the present appellant-defendant and

is not within the scope of Order VII Rule 11, CPC and order

of Trial Judge came to be confirmed by the High Court by

the impugned order assailed in the present proceedings.

After we heard counsel for the parties and taking into

consideration the material on record, in our considered

view, the Trail Court has committed a manifest error in

appreciating the pleadings on record from the plaint filed

at the instance of respondent no.1-plaintiff who as a

caretaker/servant can never acquire interest in the

property irrespective of his long possession and the

caretaker/servant has to give possession forthwith on

demand and so far as the plea of adverse possession is

concerned as it lacks material particulars and the plaint

does not discloses the cause of action for institution of

the suit.


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 5779 OF 2021


HIMALAYA VINTRADE PVT. LTD. Vs MD. ZAHID & ANR. 

Dated: SEPTEMBER 16, 2021

Print Page

Tuesday, 19 February 2019

Whether servant working with tenant can become tenant?

The facts on record indicate that the defendant herein along with said Nusli Randelia had filed a suit for declaration of their status as the tenants of the suit flat. That suit is pending before the Small Causes Court. Though it was urged on behalf of the defendant that adjudication of the question as to the status of the defendant in the present appeal would prejudice the rights of the defendant in that suit, suffice it to clarify that this Court has merely answered the question whether the defendant was a trespasser or not. Once it is found on the basis of the pleadings of the parties and evidence led by them that the defendant was merely a servant of Nusli Randelia as admitted by her coupled with the fact that there was no blood relationship between said Nusli Randelia and the defendant, it becomes obvious that on the death of said Nusli Randelia the status of the defendant becomes that of a trespasser. This Court has not gone into the question as to entitlement of the defendant as regards her claim of being a tenant under provisions of Section 7(15) of the said Act which question falls within the domain of the Small Causes Court. Suffice it to say that in the light of the admitted fact that the defendant was a servant of Nusli Randelia, her continuation in the suit flat after the death of Nusli Randelia becomes unauthorised thus leading to her eviction. The plaintiffs are thus found entitled to the relief of declaration and eviction as prayed for. Point No. (ii) stands answered accordingly.

18. As a result of it being held that the defendant was a trespasser in the suit after the death of Nusli Randelia.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

First Appeal No. 2307 of 2008

Decided On: 03.12.2018

 Pilloo D. Broacha Vs.  Meena Ramesh Dewadiga

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.S. Chandurkar, J.

Citation: 2019(1) MHLJ 924
Print Page

Sunday, 28 January 2018

Supreme Court: Caretaker, watchman or servant can not claim possession of property against its owner


Principles of law which emerge in this case are crystallized as under:

1. No one acquires title to the property if he or she was allowed to stay in the premises gratuitously. Even by long possession of years or decades such person would not acquire any right or interest in the said property.

2. Caretaker, watchman or servant can never acquire interest in the property irrespective of his long possession. The caretaker or servant has to give possession forthwith on demand.

3. The Courts are not justified in protecting the possession of a caretaker, servant or any person who was allowed to live in the premises for some time either as a friend, relative, caretaker or as a servant.

4. The protection of the Court can only be granted or extended to the person who has valid, subsisting rent agreement, lease agreement or license agreement in his favour.

5. The caretaker or agent holds property of the principal only on behalf of the principal. He acquires no right or interest whatsoever for himself in such property irrespective of his long stay or possession.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Appeal No. 2968 of 2012 (Arising out of SLP (C) No. 15382 of 2009)

Decided On: 21.03.2012

Maria Margarida Sequeria Fernandes and Ors. Vs. Erasmo Jack de Sequeria (Dead) through L. Rs.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dalveer Bhandari, H.L. Dattu and Deepak Verma, JJ.
Citation: (2012) 5 SCC 370,

Print Page

Sunday, 5 March 2017

Whether a person can be held guilty for breach of injunction order even if he was not party to suit?

The respondent set up a case that the owner of the disputed premises is Smt. Savita Singh and the respondent No. 3 has denied to be present at the site during the period when the outlets in question were closed by filling earth. The architect who was working at the instance of respondent No. 3 had filed his affidavit and stated that he had filled the strip of land with earth at the instance of respondent No. 3. The respondent No. 3 stated that he had been away from Dehradun at the relevant time and also said that the petitioner has no right of easement. Now, after the judgment of the civil court decreeing the petitioners' suit for injunction accepting the easementary right, it is no more open to the respondent to plead otherwise and deny that there is no easementary right of flowing rain and flood water through the disputed outlets. The technical plea raised is that owner of the premises is Smt. Savita Singh and the respondent is not the owner and he has no concern with the same. The judgment of the learned Civil Judge shows that he mainly proceeded on placing reliance on 1962 ALJ 201 (supra) and has not noticed the relevant amendments made in the Code otherwise he would have invoked the inherent jurisdiction under O. 39, R. 2A. The question whether an agent of the defendant can be proceeded against in a proceeding under 0. 39, R. 2A of the Code as amended by 1976 Act, the Patna High Court in MANU/BH/0067/1983 Ram Pd. Singh v. Subodh Pd. Singh has held that a person is liable to be proceeded against under O. 39, R. 2A of the Code even if he was not presently party to the suit provided he is shown to be the agent or servant of the defendant and to have violated the orders of the Court in spite of knowledge that there was such an order. The respondent No. 3 is the husband of the owner of the premises. The architect stated on affidavit that the apertures were closed at the instance of the respondent No. 3. It is wholly immaterial whether the respondent was personally present at the time of actual closing of the outlets or not and whether he was a party in the suit or not.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 19415 of 1988
Decided On: 13.07.1992

 K.L. Virmani  Vs.  IIIrd Additional Dist. Judge, and others

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.L. Ganguly, J.

 Citation : AIR 1992 All 326
Print Page

Tuesday, 28 February 2012

Whether Asset Details Of Govt. Servant Can Be Assessed Under RTI Act?

 For all the above discussions, we reject the contention that the assets details are held by the Government and cannot be made available to the appellant as untenable. Hence, the relief sought for in this writ appeal must be considered. Though the appellant would be entitled to the inspection of the assets details of the I.A.S. Officers furnished by them in sealed cover to the State Government, the application requesting the information with reference to the office cannot be ordered, as such information should be made with reference to the individual officer with specific request by naming him/her. In the event such request is made, the appellant would be entitled to the furnishing of such information, which includes the inspection of the assets details of the concerned officer.Madras High Court
V.Madhav vs The Tamil Nadu Information Commission ... on 12 July, 2011
DATED: 12.07.2011
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE D.MURUGESAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K.K.SASIDHARAN
W.A.No.551 of 2010

Print Page