Showing posts with label ad valorem court fees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ad valorem court fees. Show all posts

Wednesday, 22 March 2023

Whether plaintiff must pay ad valorem court fees if he is challenging demand notice issued by municipal corporation for specific amount?

 Suit R.C.S. No. 26 of 2021 has been filed challenging the

notice dated 21.06.2021. By this notice a demand has been

raised by the Municipal Corporation for a sum of Rs. 7,57,203/-

seeking reimbursement of expenses incurred in cleaning the

nallah on the basis that it was obligation of the petitioner to

clean the nala, and as the obligation was not complied by the

petitioner, the said work was undertaken by the Municipal

Corporation.{Para 6}

7. It is clear that although one of grounds of challenge is to

the obligation of the Municipal Corporation by relying upon the

provisions of the Corporation Act, what has been challenged in

effect is a demand notice which has been issued by the Municipal

Corporation seeking to recover the amount. In my view, the

submissions raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner as

regards the authority of the corporation and on the lease deed

are in fact grounds in support of the challenge to the demand

notice. The subject matter of the suit has been valued at Rs.

1,000/- on the ground that the petitioner is claiming declaration

and the notice is not susceptible to the monetary valuation and

as such has been valued under Section 6(iv)(a) of the

Maharashtra Court Fees Act. In my view since the demand

notice which is under challenge seeks to recover a monetary

component, it cannot be said that notice is not susceptible to

monetary valuation as submitted.

10. In my view, the Petitioner seeks adjudication of demand

notice seeking to recover a sum of Rs. 7,57,203/ which is capable

of monetary valuation and hence the impugned order directing

to value the suit as per the provisions of Section 6(iv)(a) of the

Maharashtra Court Fees Act is proper and deserves no

interference at the hands of this Court.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

WRIT PETITION NO. 3692 OF 2022

The Aurangabad Jilha Chemists and Druggists Association Vs

The Municipal Corporation, Aurangabad

CORAM : SHARMILA U. DESHMUKH, J.

DATE : 16TH JANUARY, 2023.

Citation: 2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 13.

Print Page

Saturday, 10 September 2022

Questions and answers on law(Part 51)

 

Q 1:-Whether arbitration proceeding can be treated as legal proceeding for the purpose of limitation Act?

Ans:- Limitation Act is applicable to arbitration proceeding.

Section 43.   Limitations.

(1) The Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), shall apply to arbitrations as it applies to proceedings in court. 

Q 2:-Whether proceedings under Sec 154 of Electricity Act before special court for fixing civil liability needs payment of court fee as a civil case?


Ans: Ad valorem court fee is not payable on the complaints filed by the petitioner before the Special Courts in proceedings under Sec 154 of Electricity Act for fixing civil liability.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print Page

Whether proceedings under Sec 154 of Electricity Act before special court for fixing civil liability needs payment of court fee as a civil case?

In any case, the complaint filed by the petitioner before the Special Court cannot be construed as a 'plaint' by any logical construction of the document. A bare perusal of this document, styled as a complaint Under Section 135 r/w Section 151 of Electricity Act would show that the main prayer made by the complainant/petitioner was to summon, try and punish the respondents/accused persons on the ground that they had committed theft of electricity and had thereby committed offences punishable Under Section 135(1) of Electricity Act, 2003. The complaint also contains an additional prayer to the court to determine the civil liability as provided in Section 154(5) of the Act. In my view, merely because this complaint also contains a prayer for determination of civil liability that by itself does not convert it into a 'plaint'. A document cannot be said to be a criminal complaint as well as a plaint at the same time. A criminal plaint lies before a criminal court whereas the plaint lies before a civil court. The procedure prescribed in Code of Criminal Procedure for trial of a case instituted on a complaint is altogether different from the procedure prescribed in the Code of Civil Procedure, for trial of a suit instituted by filing a plaint. Therefore, this document cannot be termed as a plaint within the meaning of Article 1 of Schedule 1 of Court Fee Act.{Para 24}

31. For the reasons given in the preceding paragraphs, I am of the considered view that ad valorem court fee is not payable on the complaints filed by the petitioner before the Special Courts.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Crl. M.C. 3284, 3453, 3454, 3455, 3456/2008

Decided On: 25.11.2009

BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. Vs. State N.C.T. of Delhi and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.K. Jain, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/3143/2009

Print Page

Friday, 18 March 2022

Whether a party must pay Ad Valorem Court-Fees in Suit For recovery of Compensation And Damages?

  The moot question for consideration is whether the suit in question as framed was a money suit for compensation/damages falling under Clause (i) of Section 7 or was a suit falling in any of the categories specified in clause (iv) of Section 7 of the Act. A reading of the relief clause would make it abundantly clear that this was a money suit for compensation/damages and not falling under any of the categories mentioned in clause (iv) of Section 7 of the Act. Therefore, there would be no question at all for the applicability of Section 7(iv) of the Act. It would be a simple case of applicability of Section 7(i) of the Act and ad valorem Court-fees would have to be paid as per Schedule 1 entry 1.{Para 20}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION 

CIVIL APPEAL NO(s). 2064 OF 2022 

 STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS Vs DEV BRAT SHARMA

Coram: DINESH MAHESHWARI; VIKRAM NATH, JJ. 

Author: VIKRAM NATH, J.

Dated: MARCH 16, 2022 

Print Page

Sunday, 1 September 2019

Whether it is necessary to pay ad valorem Court-fee on application for restitution?

In my considered view, law is quite clear that the application for restitution under Section 144, C.P.C. is an application for execution of decree within the purview of Section 2(2), C.P.C. read with Order 21 , C.P.C.

6. This Court also in a case between Sri Tapan Sarkar v. Smt. Sukhila Boro reported in 1990 (2) GLR 29 held that the application for restitution under Section 144, C.P.C. is an application for execution of the decree. In view of the above well principle of law, I am of the view that the First Appellate Court has jurisdiction to hear the appeal arising from the order passed under Section 144, C.P.C. I am also of the view that as the application for restitution under Section 144, C.P.C. is an application for execution of the decree, no ad valorem Court-fee is required on the value of the suit land or mesne profit except the required Court-fees for the purpose of execution of decree or order.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GAUHATI (AGARTALA BENCH)

Second Appeal No. 30 of 1984

Decided On: 13.06.1996

Ramesh Ch. Deb Vs.  Barindra Kr. Chakraborty

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N. Surjamani Singh, J.

Citation : AIR 1997 Gau 24

Print Page

Saturday, 2 December 2017

What are essential ingredient necessary in order to constitute consequential relief?

Third question is in respect of consequential relief. In the Act, section 7(iv)(c) provides for payment of Ad Valorem Court Fee for a suit claiming a declaratory decree/order where consequential relief has prayed for. Full Bench of Allahabad High Court in the case of Murlidhar v. Banshidhar and others, MANU/UP/0029/1963 : AIR 1963 Allahabad 86 has laid down the meaning of expression "Consequential Relief as used in this section. It is as under:--

"In our opinion, the expression consequential relief "in section 7(iv)(c) means some relief which would follow directly from the declaration given, the valuation of which is not capable of being definitely ascertained and which is not specifically provided for anywhere in the Act and cannot be claimed independently of the declaration as a substantive relief. A consideration of all the Cls. (1) to (f), sub-section (4) Court-Fees Act leads to the same conclusion".

This definition of the expression "consequential relief was followed by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Sri Krishna Chandraji v. Shyam Behari Lal, (s) MANU/UP/0060/1955 : AIR 1955 All 177 where an analysis of the definition the learned Judges found four essential ingredients to be necessary in order to constitute a consequential relief. Those ingredients were:

(I) That the relief should follow directly from the declaration given;

(II) that the valuation of the relief be not capable of being definitely ascertained;

(III) that the relief is not specifically provided for anywhere in the Act; and

(IV) that the relief cannot be claimed independently of a declaration as a substantial relief."

14. The true test to ascertain whether the consequential relief infact flows from the declaratory relief is as to whether the said consequential relief can be claimed independently of the declaration as a substantial relief or not. Every injunction in a suit for injunction would not flow from the declaration in a case where the plaintiff is in possession of the property in his own rights; comes before this Court and seeks declaration that the property belongs to him and the other party cannot interfere with his possession then it cannot be said that the plaintiff is required Ad Valorem Court Fees because the relief of injunction is a consequential relief. As observed above the relief of injunction if can independently be claimed then in every case it would not be a consequential relief. It is settled law that if a person is in settled possession he cannot be evicted except in accordance with law. Such a person if claims a declaration of his title and injunction that the defendants be restrained from interfering with his possession then the relief of injunction is not a consequence of the declaration because even if the Court is of the opinion that the declaration cannot be made in favour of the plaintiff then too the Court will grant an injunction in favour of the person who is in settled possession. Such a person would be called upon to value both the reliefs separately and each of the relief would be independent of the other. In a suit of this nature the plaintiff is not seeking the relief of injunction as consequential relief but is entitled to claim the same because of his settled possession. In such a case section 7(iv)(d) of the Court Fees Act would be applicable for valuing the relief of injunction and Article 17 of Schedule II of the Act would provide the Court fees for the said declaration. In the matter of Sanik Nagar durga G.H. Samiti v. Indore City Improvement Trust, 1983 M.P. Weekly Note, Note No. 56, in almost similar situation where the plaintiff sought for the relief of declaration and injunction to restrain the defendant from starting the construction over the suit land, this Court observed that in fact the plaintiff was claiming two distinct reliefs, one for declaration of the title and the other for preventive injunction. The relief of injunction in fact was not consequential to the relief of declaration because even without claiming the declaration relief, plaintiff could have brought the suit on the same pleadings seeking the relief for injunction only. These were two distinct and separate reliefs. The High Court further observed that the relief of injunction though related to question of plaintiff's title, was not consequential to the declaration.

15. In the instant case also the plaintiff has sought declaration of her title and has prayed for injunction. Each of the relief can be claimed separately. If it is found that the reliefs can be claimed separately then the relief of injunction would not be consequential reliefs to the relief of declaration. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH (GWALIOR BENCH)

W.P. No. 4467 of 2014

Decided On: 20.03.2017

Gomatiprasad and Ors. Vs. Mahesh Singh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Anand Pathak, J.

Citation: AIR 2017 Madhya pradesh 125
Print Page

Saturday, 14 October 2017

How to ascertain court fees if suit is for declaration that sale deed is not binding on plaintiff?

Obviously clause (ha) of Section 6(iv) of the Act applies only when the suit seeks declaration that any sale or contract for sale or termination of contract for sale of any moveable or immoveable property is void and as such, it would have no application to declarations sought in this case which do not seek any sale or contract for sale or termination of contract for sale of any immovable or movable property to be void. One must understand that there is a sea difference between a declaration that any sale or contract for sale is null and void and the declaration that the sale or contract for sale has no binding effect. In the former case, the very existence of the sale transaction or contract for sale is sought to be razed whereas in the latter case, such existence is not sought to be denied but its effect is only sought to be not applicable to the person seeking declaration. This would mean that when the declaration that a sale or contract for sale insofar its effect is concerned, does not affect in any manner the claimant or is not binding upon the claimant, its existence is not sought to be denied and it may still be binding upon all others but the claimant. It would then follow that the declarations as sought by the applicant in this case were such as were not covered by clause (ha) of Section 6(iv) of the Act and that would be covered by some different clause.

3. At this juncture, learned counsel for the applicant has invited my attention to clause (j) of Section 6(iv) of the Act which is reproduced as under:

"(j) for other declarations

In suits where declaration is sought, with or without injunction or other consequential relief and the subject-matter in dispute is not susceptible of monetary evaluation and which are not otherwise provided for by this Act, ad valorem fee payable, as if the amount or value of the subject matter was one thousand rupees.

In all suits under clauses (a) to (I) the plaintiff shall state the amount at which the values the relief sought, with the reasons for the valuation."

4. Even a cursory glance at the above clause would be enough to clear the air of doubt pervading the issue involved in this case. The nature of prayers made in the plaint in the present case is already discussed in detail. These declarations would be squarely covered by above referred clause contained in clause (j) of Section 6(iv) of the Act.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Civil Revision Application No. 3 of 2017

Decided On: 14.06.2017

 Common Pipu Caudhari Vs. Berubai Chendu Redhiwale and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.B. Shukre, J.


Citation: 2017(5) MHLJ388 BOM

Print Page

Tuesday, 19 July 2016

Whether plaintiff is required to pay ad valorem court fees for getting set aside subsequent sale deed?

The learned counsel for the Petitioner Shri Jamdar submitted that
there   is  no requirement  to  value  the   suit  as  per   Section   6(iv)(ha)  of  the
Bombay Court Fees Act, 1959 as the main substantive relief sought is by way of
prayer clause (A) to the effect that a declaration is sought that the sale deed
dated 31/10/2008 has been got executed from the Plaintiff by fraud, misrepresentation
and by breach of trust taking dis­advantage of the old age and
illness of the Plaintiff and without consideration, and for a declaration that the
said so called sale deed is illegal and suffers from fraud is ab­initio illegal and
not binding on the Plaintiff. The learned counsel would contend that the 2nd
prayer introduced by way of amendment is a consequential as if the 1st prayer
is granted, the said 2nd prayer has to necessarily follow. The learned counsel
would contend that the Bombay Court Fees Act is a fiscal statute and would
have   to   be   strictly   construed,   and   unless   requisites   for   the   application   of
Section   6(iv)(ha)   are   available,   the   said   provision   would   not   apply.     
 It   would   also   apposite   to   reproduce   the   relevant   statutory
provisions of Section 6(iv)(ha) and Section 6(iv)(j) reproduced thus :­
“(ha) for avoidance of sale, contract for sale, etc.
In suits for declaration that any sale, or contract for sale
or termination of contract for sale, of any moveable or
immoveable property is void one half of ad­valorem fee
leviable on the value of the property”
(j) for other declarations
In suits where declaration is sought, with or without
injunction or other consequential relief and the subject
matter   in   dispute   is   not   susceptible   of   monetary
evaluation and which are not otherwise provided for by
this Act ad valorem fee payable, as if the amount or
value of the subject matter was one thousand rupees.
In all suits under clauses (a) to (j) the Plaintiff shall
state the amount at which the values the relief sought,
with the reasons for the valuation.”

As   can   be   seen,   Section   6(iv)(ha)   reveals   that   in   suits   for
declaration that any sale, or contract for sale or termination of contract for
sale, of any moveable or immoveable property is void and stipulates the court
fees payable under the said provision.
Section 6(iv)(j) covers the suits where declaration is sought, with
or without injunction or other consequential relief and the subject matter in
dispute is not susceptible of monetary evaluation and which are not otherwise
provided for by the said Act.  
The submission of the learned counsel for the Petitioner that in the
said suit what was sought was the declaration of the agreement in question as
void which relief is covered by Section 6(iv)(ha) of the said Act. However, in
the instant case, the Petitioner is not seeking any such relief in the suit but only
claiming a declaration that the sale deed dated 15/12/2008 is not binding
upon him.  In my view, the same would not make any difference as what in
effect the Plaintiff is seeking by way of prayer clause A(1) is the avoidance of
the said agreement dated 15/12/2008, and therefore, Section 6(iv)(ha) would
be attracted.   As observed herein above, even if prayer clause A were to be
granted to the Plaintiff, nevertheless the agreement in question in favour of the
Defendant Nos.3 to 5 would have to be set aside, and therefore, the relief

sought by way of prayer clause A(1) would have to be valued in terms of
Section 6(iv)(ha).
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.401 OF 2011

Shri Abdulsattar Gulabbhai Bagwan Vs  Shri Vaibhav Lxmangiri Gosawi, 

CORAM : R M SAVANT, J.

Pronounced on : 01st December 2011
Citation: 2012 (1) Bom C R 1
Print Page

Monday, 23 December 2013

Suit seeking declaration from immunity to pay amount under Bank Guarantee-liable to pay ad-valorem court fees

 The trial Court and the first Appellate Court, however, committed patent error while entertaining the suit without payment of ad-volaram court fees. The suit merely seeking declaration from immunity to pay the amount under the Bank Guarantee cannot be treated as a mere suit for declaration. The suit is susceptible to monetary evaluation. Obviously, the respondent No. 1 (plaintiff) was required to pay the entire court fees on ad-volaram basis and the valuation of the suit is defective. So also, it would be in the interest of justice to secure payment of interest amount/compensation in case the suit fails because the dispute arose out of commercial transaction.


Bombay High Court
M/S Great Eastern Energy vs M/S Jain Irrigation Systems Ltd on 17 February, 2010
Bench: Shri V.R. Kingaonkar

Citation;2010 (4) MHLJ759

Print Page