Showing posts with label attornment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label attornment. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 March 2019

When it is permissible for tenant to deny title of landlord?

The rule of estoppel embodied under Section 116 of the Evidence Act is that, a tenant who has been let into possession cannot deny his landlord's title, however defective it may be, so long as he has not openly restored possession by surrender to his landlord. During the continuance of the tenancy, the tenant cannot acquire by prescription a permanent right of occupancy in derogation of the landlord's title by mere assertion of such a right to the knowledge of the landlord. See: Bilas Kunwar v. Desraj Ranjit Singh ILR (1915) 37 All. 557 (PC) and Atyam Veerraju and Ors. v. Pechetti Venkanna and Ors. MANU/SC/0349/1965 : [1966]1SCR831 . The general rule is, however, subject to certain exceptions. Thus

a tenant is not precluded from denying the derivative title of the persons claiming through the landlord.
See: Kumar Krishna Prosad Lal Singha Deo v. Baraboni Coal Concern Limited and Ors. MANU/PR/0072/1937. Similarly, the estoppel under Section 116 of the Evidence Act is restricted to the denial of the title at the commencement of the tenancy. From this, the exception follows, that
it is open to the tenant even without surrendering possession to show that since the date of the tenancy, the title of the landlord came to an end or that he was evicted by a paramount title holder or that even though there was no actual eviction or dispossession from the property, under a threat of eviction he had attorned to the paramount title-holder.
In order to constitute eviction by title paramount, it has been established by decisions in England and in India, that it is not necessary that the tenant should be dispossessed or even that there should be a suit in ejectment against him. It will be sufficient if there was threat of eviction and if the tenant as a result of such threat attars to the real owner, he can set up such eviction by way of defence either to an action for rent or to a suit in ejectment. If the tenant, however, gives up possession voluntarily to the title-holder, he cannot claim the benefit of this rule. When the tenancy has been determined by eviction by title paramount, no question of estoppel arises under Section 116 of the Evidence Act. See : Adyanath Ghatak v. Krishna Prasad Singh and Anr. MANU/PR/0056/1948. The principle must equally apply when the tenant has attorned under a threat of eviction by the title paramount and there comes into existence a new jural relationship of landlord and tenant as between them. The law is stated in 27 Halsbury's Laws of England, 4th edn., para 238:
238. Eviction under title paramount. In order to constitute an eviction by a person claiming under title paramount, it is not necessary that the tenant should be put out of possession, or that proceedings should be brought. A threat of eviction is sufficient, and if the tenant, in consequence of that threat, attars to the claimant, he may set this up as an eviction by way of defence to an action for rent, subject to his proving the evictor's title. There is no eviction, however, if the tenant gives up possession voluntarily.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 2223 of 1987

Decided On: 15.09.1987

 D. Satyanarayana Vs.  P. Jagadish

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.P. Sen and B.C. Ray, JJ.

Citation : AIR 1987 SC 2192

Print Page

Saturday, 2 May 2015

Whether Attornment by tenant is necessary to confer validity of transfer of landlord’s rights?

 From perusal of the aforesaid Section, it is manifest
that after the transfer of lessor’s right in favour of the
transferee, the latter gets all rights and liabilities of the
lessor in respect of subsisting tenancy. The Section does not
insist that transfer will take effect only when the tenant
attorns. It is well settled that a transferee of the landlord’s
rights steps into the shoes of the landlord with all the rights
and liabilities of the transferor landlord in respect of the
subsisting tenancy. The section does not require that the
transfer of the right of the landlord can take effect only if the
tenant attorns to him. Attornment by the tenant is not
necessary to confer validity of the transfer of the landlord’s
rights. Since attornment by the tenant is not required, a
notice under Section 106 in terms of the old terms of lease
by the transferor landlord would be proper and so also the
suit for ejectment.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.3391 OF 2015
(arising out of S.L.P.(C) NO.19487 of 2014)

Dr. Ambica Prasad  Vs Md. Alam and another

Dated:April 08, 2015


Print Page

Friday, 20 March 2015

Whether attornment of tenancy is necessary in case property is transferred by Landlord?

So far as the issue of attornment raised by learned counsel
for the petitioner is concerned, Section 109 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 ('the T.P. Act') dealing with attornment reads
as under:-
“109. Rights of lessor's transferee. - If the lessor
transfers the property leased, or any part thereof, or any
part of his interest therein, the transferee, in the absence of
a contract to the contrary, shall possess all the rights, and,
if the lessee so elects, be subject to all the liabilities of the
lessor as to the property or part transferred so long as he is
the owner of it; but the lessor shall not, by reason only of
such transfer cease to be subject to any of the liabilities
imposed upon him by the lease, unless the lease elects to
treat the transferee as the person liable to him;
Provided that the transferee is not entitled to arrears
of rent due before the transfer, and that, if the lessee, not
having reason to believe that such transfer has been made,
prays rent to the lessor, the lessee shall not be liable to pay
such rent over again to the transferee.
The lessor, the transferee and the lessee may
determine what proportion of the premium or rent reserved
by the lease is payable in respect of the part so transferred,
and, in case they disagree, such determination may be
made by any Court having jurisdiction to entertain a suit for
the possession of the property leased.”
The above provision provides that on account of transfer of
ownership of the premises to the respondent by the previous
lessor, the respondent becomes the lessor and becomes entitled
to receive the rent in terms of the lease by operation of Section
109 of the T.P. Act. No attornment of tenancy is necessary in
law as the above Section creates a statutory attornment and the
Section does not insist that the transfer of the lessor's right can
take effect only if the tenant attorns as attornment by tenant is
unnecessary to confer validity to the transfer of lessor's right.
However, the Section protects payment of rent by the tenant to
the transferor without notice of the transfer. The transfer of
ownership of the premises to the respondent by the previous
lessor results in statutory attornment by the tenant in favour of
the lessor's transferee and consequently jural relationship of
landlord and tenant, the said right of transferee under Section
109 is not curtailed or modified by the T.P. Act.
This Court in the case of Ram Saran Sharma v. Smt.
Kamla Acharya : 2001 (2) RLR 136 held and observed as under:-
“17. As regards the law of attornment, envisaged under
Section 109 of the Act of 1882, it is held that Section 109 of
the said Act does not require service of notice on the tenant,
on alienation of property, to create relationship of landlord
and tenant between the transferee landlord and the existing
tenant. The transferee of the lessor steps into the shoes
and possess all the rights, which the transferor has and the
attornment is not a condition precedent, to give validity to
the transfer made in favour of the transferee. Section 8 of
the Act of 1882 specifically provides that a transfer of
property passes forthwith, to the transferee, all the
interests, which the transferor is capable of passing in the
property, including the legal incidents thereof and such
incidents include the rents and profits thereof. Once the title
of the assignee is complete, the attornment is automatic not
dependent on the tenant's attorning or agreeing to the
attornment. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JODHPUR
: O R D E R :
S.B. CIVIL WRIT PETITION NO.2721/2014

Laxmi Narayan vs. Ram Kishan & Ors.

Date of Order :: 10th December, 2014
PRESENT
 MR. JUSTICE ARUN BHANSALI
Citation;AIR 2015 Raj 46

Print Page