It has been held by a two Judge bench of this Court in
the case of Bismillah Be(Dead) by Legal
Representatives Vs. Majeed Shah 2017 2 SCC 274:-
“24. Law relating to derivative title of the landlord (Lessor)
and challenge, if made, to such title by the tenant (Lessee)
during subsistence of tenancy in relation to demised
property is fairly well settled. Though by virtue of Section
116 of the Evidence Act, 1872, the tenant is estopped from
challenging the title of his landlord during continuance of
the tenancy, yet the tenant/lessee is entitled to challenge
the derivative title of an Assignee/Vendee of the original
landlord (Lessor) of the demised property in an action
brought by the Assignee/Vendee against the tenant for his
eviction from the demised property under the Rent laws.
This right of a tenant is, however, subject to one caveat that
the tenant/lessee has not attorned to the Assignee/Vendee.
In other words, if the tenant/lessee pays rent to the
Assignee/Vendee of the tenanted property then it results in
creation of an attornment between the parties which, in
turn, deprives the tenant/lessee to challenge the derivative
title of an Assignee/Vendee in the proceedings.”
This authority has been followed in a later case,
Company Limited [(2018) 6 SCC 744]. It has been held
in this case:-
“42... Similarly, the law relating to derivative title to the
landlord and when the tenant challenges it during
subsistence of his tenancy in relation to the demised
property is also fairly well settled. Though by virtue of
Section 116 of the Evidence Act, the tenant is estopped
from challenging the title of his landlord, yet the tenant is
entitled to challenge the derivative title of an assignee of
the original landlord of the demised property in an action
brought by the assignee against the tenant for his eviction
under the rent laws. However, this right of a tenant is
subject to one caveat that the tenant has not attorned to
the assignee. If the tenant pays rent to the assignee or
otherwise accepts the assignee’s title over the demised
property, then it results in creation of the attornment which,
in turn, deprives the tenant to challenge the derivative title
of the landlord.”
NON REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4726 OF 2010
VINAY EKNATH LAD Vs CHIU MAO CHEN
ANIRUDDHA BOSE, J.
Dated: December 18, 2019