Showing posts with label bribe. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bribe. Show all posts

Monday, 16 September 2019

Whether demand of bribe without acceptance amounts to offence under Prevention of Corruption Act?

Section 7 on the other hand, is wider and uses the words "accepts" or "obtains" or "agrees to accept" or "attempts to obtain". All these four words or phrases are used for specific purposes, thus Section 7 envisages that acceptance of bribe money is covered under the words "accepts" or "obtains". However, the use of the phrases "agrees to accept" or "attempts to obtain" would clearly cover the case of demand. In these eventualities, there may or may not be acceptance and yet the offence is complete as per Section 7. Thus there is no manner of doubt to hold that the demand is covered under Section 7. Similar phrases are used in Section 13 (1)(a) and 13 (1)(b), thus under both these clauses, mere demand without acceptance is envisaged for which punishment is provided. Therefore, it cannot be said that mere demand is not an offence.

18. A Division Bench of this Court in the case of Ashok S/o. Ganapati Kolte & Anr. v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors., reported MANU/MH/3045/2016 : (2016) ALL MR (Cri.) page 4317 has already dealt with this issue and has squarely held that for constituting offence under Section 7, there was no need to show the acceptance of bribe and mere agreeing to accept or attempting to accept the bribe from any person is sufficient. In the said case, the applicant therein had prayed for quashing of the F.I.R. on the similar set of facts. In that case, demand was made but suspecting the proposed trap, the accused decided not to accept the bribe amount. This case is very similar to the case before us and we are in agreement with the ratio laid down in the said judgment.

19. Even the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that each demand constituted a separate offence by itself. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Application No. 1077 of 2017

Decided On: 13.03.2018

Rajendra Shinde Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M. Savant and Sarang V. Kotwal, JJ.


Print Page

Thursday, 18 October 2018

Whether a person can be convicted under prevention of corruption Act if demand and acceptance of bribe by him is not proved?

In such circumstances, there is no evidence to
prove that the appellant directly accepted the money
from the Complainant. Since the plea of conspiracy
against the appellant and Rajinder Kumar failed, it
cannot be held that money (Rs.4000/)
recovered
from the possession of Rajinder Kumar was as a
fact the bribe money meant for the appellant for
holding him guilty for the offences punishable
under Sections 7, 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the PC
Act. It is more so when the benefit of such acquittal
from the charge of conspiracy was given to Rajinder
Kumar but was not given to the appellant.

31) In our view, the prosecution, therefore, failed
to prove the factum of acceptance of bribe money of
Rs.4000/by
the appellant from the Complainant
on 29.03.1995 as per the charges framed against
him.
32) Since in order to attract the rigors of Sections
7, 13(2) read 13(1)(d) of PC Act, the prosecution was
under a legal obligation to prove the twin
requirements of “demand and acceptance of bribe
money by the accused”, the proving of one alone
but not the other was not sufficient. The appellant
is, therefore, entitled for acquittal from the charges
framed against him under the PC Act too. (See para
8 of M.K. Harshan vs. State of Kerala, (1996) 11
SCC 720)
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1276 OF 2010

Dashrath Singh Chauhan Vs Central Bureau of Investigation 

Dated:October 09, 2018
Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.
Print Page

Sunday, 30 October 2016

How to appreciate evidence if there is allegation that superior officer demanded bribe through subordinate officer?

Is it uncommon or even un-natural, in our
society, for a senior government functionary to direct a person,
who has, suddenly, come to his residence and sought some
favour, to go and meet the subordinates? The answer has to be
an emphatic “No”. The subordinate staff, ordinarily, available at
the residential quarter is the driver. The conduct of the Subdivisional
Magistrate, in such circumstance, in asking the 
informant (truck driver) to talk to the co-accused (driver of the
official vehicle), who was, at that time, at the residence of the
petitioner, was the natural thing that many other officers
similarly situated would do. The co-accused, then, demands
money for releasing the truck from the informant (truck driver).
The demand is, admittedly, not made in the presence of the
petitioner. The informant does not cross check with the
petitioner about the demand of money; instead, he goes and
pays the money to the co-accused and, then, tries to rope in
the petitioner in the offence. Nobody, in fact, made any
attempt, even a feeble attempt, to ascertain from the petitioner
if he had really demanded money, which Sanjay had claimed
from the driver of the truck in question.
16. Two possibilities, thus, arise: Firstly, the
demand is made at the behest of the petitioner. Secondly, the
driver made the demand on his own without any prodding from
the Sub-divisional Magistrate. If two possibilities exist, the one
that favours the accused has to be adopted.
17. The conduct of a Sub-divisional Magistrate in
directing the informant, who has, suddenly, entered his official
residence to consult the co-accused, a government employee,
albeit a driver, in the circumstance of this case, cannot be said
to be unnatural. Had the informant come to the office of the
Sub-divisional Magistrate and if Sub-divisional Magistrate asked 
him to meet the dealing assistant and if, then, the dealing
assistant would have demanded the money and said that the
money was asked for by the petitioner, could we, by any
stretch of imagination, fasten penal liability upon the petitioner?
The answer has to be once again an emphatic „no‟.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Criminal Writ Jurisdiction Case No.1000 of 2016

Dr. Jitendra Gupta, 
V
 State of Bihar 
CORAM: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE

Date: 28-10-2016
Print Page

Sunday, 17 January 2016

Whether offence of taking of bribe is made out if work for which money is given to accused is not within his jurisdiction?

 The   evidence   of   P.W.   3­   Gunderao   Anmole,   the
then   Deputy   Engineer   of   the   Zilla   Parishad   would   show
that he was the sanctioning authority of the T.A. bills.
He   himself   was   on   earned   leave   for   the   period   from
17/5/1995 to 16/6/1995.   The bills could not have been
sanctioned without log book and the said log book was
with the Senior Clerk Mr. Kadam.   Even the said Senior
Clerk   Mr.   Kadam   was   on   leave   during   the   said   period.

Besides this, this witness, thereafter, was on training
from 12/6/1995 to 16/6/1995.  Further, the bills of the
complainant were already prepared by the accused and he
(P.W.3)  had  signed   the  said  T.A.   bills   on  10th  or  11th
June, 1995.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 295 OF 2002
The State of Maharashtra,

   Vs.
Maroti Putaji Tagadpalle,

­­­­
CORAM : M.T. JOSHI, J.
   
    PRONOUNCED ON  : 30/04/2015
Citation; 2015 ALLMR(CRI)4292
Print Page

Monday, 21 December 2015

Whether a person can be prosecuted for taking bribe in the capacity of a private citizen?

The official act or official function referred to in the
relevant provisions obviously mean  acts or functions which the
concerned public servant can perform in his official capacity and not
in the capacity of a private citizen.  The appellant, admittedly, was
working   as   a   Tax   Recovery   Clerk   in   the   Thane   Municipal
Corporation and had nothing to do with the demolition of the
illegal   constructions.    The   not   reporting   of   the   matter   to   the
Encroachment Department, which was said to be the act for which
bribe was being demanded, cannot be said to be an official act of
the appellant in his capacity as a public servant. The favour which
the appellant was to show to the complainant in return for the
bribe,   viz.,   'of   not   reporting   the   matter   to   the   Encroachment
Department', had nothing to do with the official duties of the
appellant.  Not reporting of the matter would be an act performed
by the appellant in his private capacity and not in his official
capacity.  When the complainant had made illegal construction, it
could be reported to the Encroachment Department by any person.
The   appellant   had   nothing   to   do   with   the   work   of   the

Encroachment Department and there is not even an assertion to
that effect.  The work carried out by the complainant was obvious
and could be noticed by anyone. For reporting or not reporting
such matter, anybody could similarly demand gratification from
the complainant.  The appellant's position as a Tax Recovery Clerk
in the Thane Municipal Corporation, in no manner gave the status
of   an   official   act   to   his   not   reporting   the   matter   to   the
Encroachment Department.   Thus, what the appellant allegedly
agreed to do in return for a bribe was not his official act and was
an act purely in his personal capacity, to which the provisions of
the P.C.Act do not apply.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1152 OF 2004
RAVINDRA MAHADEO KOTHAMKAR )...APPELLANT
V/s.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA  )...RESPONDENT

CORAM : ABHAY M. THIPSAY, J.
DATE : 9th OCTOBER 2015.
Citation; 2015(4) Crimes 222 Bombay
Print Page

Friday, 13 November 2015

Whether accused can be held guilty for corruption if there is no demand for bribe?

The prosecution examined the other fair price shop dealers in Kurnool as PWs 3, 4 and 6 to prove that the accused was receiving monthly mamools from them. PWs 4 and 6 did not state so and they were declared hostile. PW-3 though in the examination-in-chief stated so, in the cross-examination turned round and stated that the accused never asked any monthly mamool and he did not pay Rs.50/- at any time. The prosecution has not examined any other witness present at the time when the money was demanded by the accused and also when the money was allegedly handed-over to the accused by the complainant. The complainant himself had disowned his complaint and has turned hostile and there is no other evidence to prove that the accused had made any demand. In short there is no proof of the demand allegedly made by the accused. The only other material available is the recovery of the tainted currency notes from the possession of the accused. The possession is also admitted by the accused. It is settled law that mere possession and recovery of the currency notes from the accused without proof of demand will not bring home the offence under Section 7, since demand of illegal gratification is sine-qua-non to constitute the said offence. The above also will be conclusive insofar as the offence underSection 13(1)(d) is concerned as in the absence of any proof of demand for illegal gratification the use of corrupt or illegal means or abuse of position as a public servant to obtain any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage cannot be held to be established. It is only on proof of acceptance of illegal gratification that presumption can be drawn under Section 20 of the Act that such gratification was received for doing or forbearing to do any official act. Unless there is proof of demand of illegal gratification proof of acceptance will not follow. 
Supreme Court of India
N.Sunkanna vs State Of A.P on 14 October, 2015

Bench: M.Y. Eqbal, C. Nagappan
REPORTABLE
Print Page

Sunday, 27 September 2015

Whether court can take lenient view in corruption case on the ground that less amount of bribe taken?

 In Niranjan Hemchandra Sashittal v. State of
Maharashtra (2013) 4 SCC 642, it has been observed that:-
“... corruption mothers disorder, destroys societal
will to progress, accelerates undeserved
ambitions, kills the conscience, jettisons the glory
of the institutions, paralyses the economic health
of a country, corrodes the sense of civility and
mars the marrows of governance. It is worth
noting that immoral acquisition of wealth
destroys the energy of the people believing in
honesty, and history records with agony how they
have suffered. The only redeeming fact is that
collective sensibility respects such suffering as it
is in consonance with the constitutional
morality.”
In the said case, it has also been observed that the
degree of corruption is immaterial. In the case at hand, as
we perceive, the delinquent employee has harboured the
notion that when the cancerous growth has affected the
system, he can further allow it to grow by covering it like an
octopus, with its tentacles disallowing any kind of surgical
operation or treatment so that the lesion continues. The
whole act is reprehensible and such a situation does not
even remotely commend any lenience.
 Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.2038 OF 2012
U.P. State Road Transport Corp. & Anr.
 V
Gopal Shukla & Anr.
Dated;September 1, 2015.
Dipak Misra, J.
Citation: 2015(9)SCALE567
Print Page

Sunday, 24 May 2015

Whether accused can be convicted for corruption if prosecution fails to prove that he demanded bribe?


 It is 
settled   legal   position   that   unless   the   evidence   of   the   demand   is 
satisfactory, the evidence obtained by laying a trap is required to be 
viewed cautiously.   It would be necessary for the prosecution in such 
cases to prove that it was as a result of 'demand' that the money was 
passed on.  In this case, the evidence of the acceptance of the money by 
itself, is not sufficient to raise the inference about there  having had a 
previous demand of illegal gratification.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.346 OF 2005
Shri Balkrishna Bhau Desai

Versus
The State of Maharashtra

  
­­­
CORAM :   ABHAY M. THIPSAY, J.
DATED  :    23rd APRIL, 2015
­­­

Print Page

Sunday, 22 February 2015

What are essential condition for proving offence under prevention of corruption Act?


 It is a settled principle in law laid down by this Court in a number of decisions that once the demand and voluntary acceptance of illegal gratification knowing it to be the bribe are proved by evidence then conviction must follow Under Section 7 ibid against the accused. Indeed, these twin requirements are sine qua non for proving the offence Under Section 7 ibid. (See-C.M. Sharma v. State of Andhra Pradesh [MANU/SC/0981/2010(2010) 15 SCC 1].
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.593 OF 2012
L. Laxmikanta V State by Superintendent of Police,

Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.
Dated;February 5, 2015.
Print Page

Friday, 9 November 2012

Bribe offered by subordinate officer

SUBORDINATE OFFICER OFFERING BRIBE TO SUPERIOR OFFICER,IT AMOUNT TO MISCONDUCT ON THE PART OF SUBORDINATE.DEPARTMENTAL ENQUIRY BE INITIATED AGAINST SUBORDINATE OFFICER

Sir, I beg to submit that the facts and circumstances narrated above bear very grave implications and consequences. For one, in as much as the offer was made to me by my own immediate subordinate officer, it leaves me in little doubt that henceforth he will be collecting money/bribes on my name. There already exists a great amount of cynicism in the district, vis-a-vis corruption. The situation described above will do little to alleviate it. In essence, district administration is more than certainly likely to receive a severe set back.
Apart from these general consequences, the implications are rather serious on a personal level. The consequences it will have on my reputation may well be appreciated. Needless to say, it strikes against the very fundamentals of the principles and value structure that have sustained me so far.
Sir, I therefore beg for your kind consideration in the matter. In do understand that in as much as the conversation that took place in the privacy of my chambers, the veracity of my narrative cannot be relied upon any more than may be made in any counter by him. However, I do assure your Sir, that I have no personal motives against the individual. I write this not so much in my personal capacity, but as the Collector (and administrative head) of Chengalpattu District. In this I must assume that I am a repository of Govt. trust and faith. And should I be found wanting, and where sufficient confidence is not placed upon me, then from that point I case to be effective, and will therefore be poor in the delivery of administrative objectives. It is with this sense of belief that I seek your trust in my statements above. It is with a sense of duty that I submit the above facts to enable suitable action being initiated in the matter. And, I sincerely hope that I do retain your kind confidence in me. I assure you Sir, of my highest considerations, and remain humbly, and
Yours sincerely
Sd. Sameer Vyas".

Madras High Court
D. Uthirakumaran vs Government Of Tamil Nadu And Anr. on 29 July, 1988
Equivalent citations: (1990) ILLJ 205 Mad
Print Page

Saturday, 21 April 2012

Supreme Court: Mere recovery of tainted money does not amount to bribe

Anti- corruption act mere recovery of tainted money by itself cannot prove the charge of corruption against the accused in the absence any evidence to prove payment of bribe or to show that accused had voluntarily accepted money knowing it to be bribe.
Supreme Court of India
Suraj Mal vs State (Delhi Administration) on 13 February, 1979
Equivalent citations: AIR 1979 SC 1408, 1979 CriLJ 1087, (1979) 4 SCC 725
Author: S M Ali
Bench: A Koshal, S M Ali
Print Page