In the decision rendered in Union of India vs. Master Construction
Co.(2011) 12 SCC 349
this court observed as under:
“18. In our opinion, there is no rule of the absolute
kind. In a case where the claimant contends that a
discharge voucher or no-claim certificate has been
obtained by fraud, coercion, duress or undue influence
and the other side contests the correctness thereof, the
Chief Justice/his designate must look into this aspect to
find out at least, prima facie, whether or not the dispute
is bona fide and genuine. Where the dispute raised by the
claimant with regard to validity of the discharge voucher
or no-claim certificate or settlement agreement, prima
facie, appears to be lacking in credibility, there may not
be a necessity to refer the dispute for arbitration at all.
19. It cannot be overlooked that the cost of arbitration
is quite huge—most of the time, it runs into six and seven
figures. It may not be proper to burden a party, who
contends that the dispute is not arbitrable on account of
discharge of contract, with huge cost of arbitration
merely because plea of fraud, coercion, duress or undue
influence has been taken by the claimant. A bald plea of
fraud, coercion, duress or undue influence is not enough
and the party who sets up such a plea must prima facie
establish the same by placing material before the Chief
Justice/his designate. If the Chief Justice/his designate
finds some merit in the allegation of fraud, coercion,
duress or undue influence, he may decide the same or
leave it to be decided by the Arbitral Tribunal. On the
other hand, if such plea is found to be an afterthought,
make-believe or lacking in credibility, the matter must be
set at rest then and there.
In our considered view, the plea raised by the respondent is bereft of
any details and particulars, and cannot be anything but a bald assertion.
Given the fact that there was no protest or demur raised around the time or
soon after the letter of subrogation was signed, that the notice dated
31.03.2011 itself was nearly after three weeks and that the financial
condition of the respondent was not so precarious that it was left with no
alternative but to accept the terms as suggested, we are of the firm view that
the discharge in the present case and signing of letter of subrogation were
not because of exercise of any undue influence. Such discharge and signing
of letter of subrogation was voluntary and free from any coercion or undue
influence. In the circumstances, we hold that upon execution of the letter of
subrogation, there was full and final settlement of the claim. Since our
answer to the question, whether there was really accord and satisfaction, is
in the affirmative, in our view no arbitrable dispute existed so as to exercise
power under section 11 of the Act. The High Court was not therefore
justified in exercising power under Section 11 of the Act.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10784 OF 2014 @
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO.24652 OF 2013
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LTD …. Appellant
Versus
GENUS POWER INFRASTRUCTURE LTD. …. Respondent
Uday U. Lalit, J.
Dated:December 04, 2014
Citation:AIR 2015 SC (SUPP)136