Showing posts with label concurrent jurisdiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label concurrent jurisdiction. Show all posts

Tuesday, 19 December 2017

Whether parties can exclude jurisdiction of any court by arbitration agreement?

Supreme Court in the case of Indus Mobile has indeed laid down as a matter of law that any agreement between the parties as to the seat of arbitration is in the nature of an exclusive jurisdiction clause. This exclusive jurisdiction cause would then oust the jurisdiction of any other court having concurrent jurisdiction. Further, such exclusive jurisdiction clause would forbid Section 42 having any play for the purpose of determination of jurisdiction of the Court. As held by the Supreme Court in the case of State of West Bengal Vs. Associated Contractors MANU/SC/0793/2014 : (2015) 1 Supreme Court Cases 32, where the agreement between the parties restricted jurisdiction to only one particular court out of courts having concurrent jurisdiction, that court alone would have jurisdiction, since neither Section 31(4) nor Section 42 contains a non obstante clause wiping out a contrary agreement between the parties. In other words, if there is a contrary agreement between the parties conferring exclusive jurisdiction on one particular court, it is that court and that court alone which will entertain any challenge to an arbitral award. There is no difficulty thus far. The difficulty arises when we come to consider whether or not there is indeed a seat of arbitration fixed or agreed between the parties in the present case. It is important to note that a seat of arbitration, as observed by the Supreme Court in case of Indus Mobile, is a place chosen by or on behalf of the parties; it is designated either in the arbitration agreement or in the terms of the reference or reflected in the minutes of proceedings or in some other way as "place or seat of arbitration". As far as the agreement between the parties in the present case is concerned, there is indeed no place of arbitration chosen. If at all, the agreement points to a seat outside Mumbai inasmuch as the jurisdiction to arbitrate, under the agreement, is conferred on the Commissioner of Municipal Corporation for the cities of Kalyan & Dombivli, whose seat is indisputably beyond the city of Mumbai. Mr. Chinoy, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Petitioner, however, submits that in the face of this agreement, when this Court was approached under Section 11 of the Act, an independent arbitrator was chosen. It is submitted that this Arbitrator held the proceedings of the reference in Mumbai, with the concurrence of the parties and also declared his award in Mumbai. Learned Counsel submits that there being nothing contrary either in the agreement or in the minutes of proceedings or otherwise, the very fact that the meetings in the arbitration reference were held, and the award was made, in Mumbai, fixes the seat of arbitration in Mumbai. I am afraid that is not a correct way of ascertaining the seat of arbitration. The seat of arbitration, in the context of fixation of jurisdiction of the curial Court, is not the same as the venue where the arbitral forum held its sittings or the place where it made its award. In fact, there is a well known distinction between the venue of arbitration and seat of arbitration. Even if the parties by their contract designate any place as the seat of arbitration, the arbitral forum is free to hold sittings at any place other than the seat of arbitration. For that matter, all sittings can be held and even an award can be made, at a location outside the place of seat of arbitration. In the face of this distinction, the simple fact of conduct of arbitration reference or making of an award at a particular place, in this case, Mumbai, is neither here nor there. In the present case, the seat of arbitration having not been designated either in the contract between the parties or in the terms of the reference or in the minutes of proceedings or otherwise, the city of Mumbai cannot be termed as the seat of arbitration, going by the sheer conduct of meetings in the reference there. Even there, as a matter of fact, it is not disputed that some of the meetings in the arbitration references were actually held in Thane, within the jurisdiction of the District Court at Thane, though even that fact, on the reasoning discussed above, is hardly relevant.

5. In the premises, the combined effect of the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the cases of Indus Mobile and Associated Contractors (supra), does not imply ouster of jurisdiction of the District Court at Thane. As noted above, it is not in dispute that the cause of action did arise in Thane and application/s under Part-I was/were infact made before the Court at Thane prior to the present arbitration petitions. The District Court at Thane, accordingly, has curial jurisdiction over the award within the meaning of Section 42 read with Section 2(1)(e) of the Act. It is the only Court to exercise jurisdiction in any challenge to the arbitral award, and not this Court.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Arbitration Petition No. 372 of 2016, Notice of Motion (L) No. 1302 of 2016, Miscellaneous Application No. 193 of 2016 and Arbitration Petition No. 373 of 2016

Decided On: 05.07.2017

 Municipal Corporation for the city of Kalyan & Dombivli
Vs. Rudranee Infrastructure Ltd.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.C. Gupte, J.
Citation: 2017(6) MHLJ 753
Print Page

Sunday, 21 August 2016

Whether CJM can tender pardon to accused after commitment of case to session court?

In view of the rival submissions, the first question that arises for consideration is whether the approver's evidence can at all be relied upon to bring home the charge against the accused persons? It is no doubt true that the very object of granting pardon to an accused is to unfold the truth in grave offence so that other accused persons involved in the offence could be brought home with the aid of the evidence of the approver. But all the same the legislative mandate as well as the safeguards enshrined in the provisions of the Code for the accused cannot be given a go by merely because of gravity of the offence. With this background in mind it would be necessary to examine the provisions of the Code for testing the correctness of the rival submissions. Coming now to the question as to whether the Chief Judicial Magistrate could have at all granted pardon to the accused even after the committal of the proceedings to the Court of Sessions, the same would depend upon the interpretation of Sections 306 and 307 of the Code. A combined reading of the aforesaid two provisions would indicate that under Section 306 power has been conferred upon the Chief Judicial Magistrate or a Metropolitan Magistrate as well as the Magistrate of the First Class to tender pardon to a person on condition of his making a full and true disclosure of whole of the circumstances within his knowledge relating to the offence. The only distinction between the two sets of Magistrates for exercise of their power lies at the stage when the power can be exercised. While a Magistrate of the First Class can exercise the power while enquiring into or trying the offence in question, the Chief Judicial Magistrate or a Metropolitan Magistrate can exercise the power at any stage of investigation or enquiry into or trial of the offence which they themselves may not be trying. But under Section 307 the power has been conferred upon the Court to which the commitment is made to grant pardon. In other words once a proceeding is committed to a Court of Sessions then only the said Court can exercise power to tender pardon to an accused. Section 307 of the Code corresponds to Section 338 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1898, If the two provisions are examined in juxtaposition it would be clear that while under Section 338 of the old Code after commitment is made the Court to which the commitment was made could himself tender pardon to an accused or could order the committing Magistrate or the District Magistrate to tender pardon, but under Section 307 of the Code of 1973 the Court to whom commitment is made, no longer retains the power to order the committing Magistrate or the District Magistrate to tender pardon. In other words underSection 307 of the present Code after commitment of a case the only Court which can tender pardon is the Court to which the commitment has been made. It would be appropriate at this stage to extract Section 338 of the old Code and the corresponding provisions of Section 307 of the new Code:
338. Power to direct tender of pardon. - At any time after commitment, but before judgment is passed the Court to which the commitment is made may, with the view of obtaining on the trial the evidence of any person supposed to have been directly or indirectly concerned in, or privy, to any, any such offence, tender, or order the committing Magistrate or the District Magistrate to tender, a pardon on the same condition to such person.
307. Power to direct tender of pardon.- At any time after commitment of a case but before judgment is passed, the Court to which the commitment is made may, with a view to obtaining at the trial the evidence of any person supposed to have been directly or indirectly concerned in, or privy to, any such offence, tender a pardon on the same condition to such person.
7. In view of the aforesaid change in the provisions it is difficult for us to accept the contention of the learned Counsel appearing for the State that even under Section 307 after commitment of a case a Chief Judicial Magistrate retains the power to grant pardon. It may not be out of place to notice the recommendations of the Law Commission in its 41st Report in paragraph 24.23;
24.23. Under Section 338, the Court of Session may at any time after commitment of the case, but before passing judgment, either tender pardon itself, or may "order the committing Magistrate or the District Magistrate" to tender pardon. Though this power is rarely resorted to by a Court of Session, it will be useful to retain the Section. But in view of the abolition of the commitment proceedings the Court of Session need not be authorised to direct "the committing Magistrate" or any other Magistrate to tender pardon. The section may be revised to read as follows:
338. At any time after commitment of a case but before judgment is passed, the Court of Session may, with the view to obtaining at the trial the evidence of any person supposed to have been directly or indirectly concerned in or privy to, any such offence, tender a pardon on the same condition to such person.
8. The aforesaid Section has now taken the place of Section 307 in the new Code. This indicates that in the changed circumstances the legislature thought it necessary to delete the expression "or order the committing Magistrate or the District Magistrate to tender a Pardon" from Section 307 of the present Code which was there in Section 338 of the previous Code. On a plain reading of the provisions contained in Sections 306 and 307 of the Code and on examining the changes that have been brought about by the legislature from the corresponding provisions of the old Code, the conclusion is irresistible that under the new Procedure Code of 1973 once a case is committed to the Court of Sessions then it is only that Court to which the proceedings have been committed can tender pardon to a person and the Chief Judicial Magistrate cannot be said to have concurrent jurisdiction for tendering pardon.
Supreme Court of India
A. Deivendran vs State Of T.N. on 21 October, 1997
Print Page