Showing posts with label confessional FIR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label confessional FIR. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 August 2025

Supreme court: Confessional FIR cannot be used against Accused and a co-accused

 In Faddi (supra), this Court stated that:

"If the FIR given by the Accused contains any admission as defined in Section 17 of the Evidence Act there is no bar in using such an admission against the maker thereof as permitted Under Section 21 of the Act, provided such admission is not inculpatory in character. In the judgment their Lordships distinguished Nisar Ali case [  MANU/SC/0032/1957 : 1957:INSC:17 : AIR 1957 SC 366] in the following lines:

But it appears to us that in the context in which the observation is made and in the circumstances, which we have verified from the record of that case, that the Sessions Judge had definitely held the first information report lodged by the co-accused who was acquitted to be inadmissible against Nisar Ali, and that the High Court did not refer to it at all in its judgment, this observation really refers to a first information report which is in the nature of a confession by the maker thereof. Of course, a confessional first information report cannot be used against the maker when he be an Accused and necessarily cannot be used against a co-accused. {Para 19}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 3343 of 2025

Decided On: 05.08.2025

Narayan Yadav Vs. State of Chhattisgarh

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.

Author: J.B. Pardiwala, J.

Citation:2025 INSC 927, MANU/SC/1018/2025

Print Page

Saturday, 23 November 2013

Leading Supreme Court judgment on evidentiary value of Confessional F.I.R. by accused


A confession may consist of severd parts and may reveal not only the actual commission of the crime but also the motive, the preparation, the provocation etc. If the confession is tainted the taint attaches to the whole statement of the accused. [140 B-C]
If a statement contains an admission of an offence, not only that admission but also every other admission of an incriminating fact contained in the statement is part of he confession. Little substance and content would be left in ss. 24, 25 and 26 if proof of admissions of incriminating facts in confessional statement is permitted. [140 D-E, F] The appellant's first information report was a confessional statement to a police officer and as such no part of it could be admitted into evidence on account of the ban in s. 25 except in so far as the ban was lifted by s. 27 and except in so far as it identified the appellant is the maker of the report. 
Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure provides for the recording of the first information. The information report as such is not substantive evidence. It may be used to corroborate the informant under s. 157 of the Evidence Act or to contradict him under s. 145 of the Act, if the informant is called a,,; a witness. If the first information is given by the accused himself, the fact of his giving the information is admissible against him as evidence of his conduct under s. 8 of the Evidence Art. If the information is a non-confessional statement, it is admissible against the accused as an admission under s. 21 of the Evidence

Act and is relevant,1

Supreme Court of India
Aghnoo Nagesia vs State Of Bihar on 4 May, 1965
Equivalent citations: 1966 AIR 119, 1966 SCR (1) 134
Bench: Bachawat, R.S.

BENCH:
BACHAWAT, R.S.
SUBBARAO, K.
DAYAL, RAGHUBAR
Print Page

Thursday, 21 March 2013

Where the accused himself lodges the first information report, the fact of his giving the information to the police is admissible against him as evidence of his conduct under Section 8 of the Evidence Act to the extent it is non-confessional in nature


The Apex Court in Bheru Singh v. State of Rajasthan, (supra) has laid down :--
"17. Where the first information report is given by an accused himself to a police officer and amounts to a confessional statement, proof of the confession is prohibited by Section 25 of the Evidence Act. No part of the confessional statement can be proved or received in evidence, except to the extent it is permitted by Section 27 of the Evidence Act. The first information report recorded under Section 154 of the Criminal Procedure Code is not a substantive piece of evidence. It may be used to corroborate the informant under Section 157 of the Evidence Act or to contradict him under Section 145 of the Evidence Act in case the informant appears as a witness at the trial. Where the accused himself lodges the first information report, the fact of his giving the information to the police is admissible against him as evidence of his conduct under Section 8 of the Evidence Act to the extent it is non-confessional in nature. It would also be relevant under Section 21 of the Evidence Act but the confessional part of the first information report by the accused to the Police Officer cannot be used at all against him in view of the ban of Section 25 of the Evidence Act."

Bombay High Court
Bandu Yedu Metkari vs State Of Maharashtra on 22 February, 2002
Equivalent citations: 2002 BomCR Cri, (2002) 2 BOMLR 492, 2002 (2) MhLj 867

Bench: R Batta, F Rebello

Print Page