Showing posts with label counter cases. Show all posts
Showing posts with label counter cases. Show all posts

Thursday, 14 May 2026

The "Sickle vs. Soil" Defense: A Judicial Guide to Adjudicating Agricultural Injury Cases

In the vast landscape of rural litigation, few scenarios are as common—or as contentious—as the "agricultural brawl." A fight breaks out in a field, a sickle is wielded, and a serious injury occurs. But in the courtroom, the narrative often shifts. The defense argues: "The accused never struck the blow; the complainant fell on the crops and sustained the injury accidentally."

For a Sessions Judge, distinguishing between a deliberate sickle attack and an accidental fall is not a matter of guesswork—it is a matter of forensic science and strict legal principles.

Print Page

Sunday, 29 July 2018

When second FIR in relation to same offence and against same accused is maintainable?

From the aforesaid decisions, it is quite luminous that the lodgment of two FIRs is not permissible in respect of one and the same incident. The concept of sameness has been given a restricted meaning. It does not encompass filing of a counter-FIR relating to the same or connected cognizable offence. What is prohibited is any further complaint by the same complainant and others against the same Accused subsequent to the registration of the case under the Code, for an investigation in that regard would have already commenced and allowing registration of further complaint would amount to an improvement of the facts mentioned in the original complaint. As is further made clear by the three-Judge Bench in Upkar Singh, the prohibition does not cover the allegations made by the Accused in the first FIR alleging a different version of the same incident. Thus, rival versions in respect of the same incident do take different shapes and in that event, lodgment of two FIRs is permissible.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 408 of 2018 (Arising out of S.L.P. (Crl.) No. 7970 of 2014)

Decided On: 19.03.2018

 P. Sreekumar Vs.  State of Kerala and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Agrawal and Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.

Citation: (2018) 4 SCC 579
Print Page

Monday, 7 May 2018

Whether second FIR can be registered in respect of same incident?

Be that as it may, if the law laid down by this Court in T.T. Antony case 1 is to be accepted as holding that a second complaint in regard to the same incident filed as a counter-complaint is prohibited under the Code then, in our opinion, such conclusion would lead to serious consequences. This will be clear from the hypothetical example given hereinbelow i.e. if in regard to a crime committed by the real Accused he takes the first opportunity to lodge a false complaint and the same is registered by the jurisdictional police then the aggrieved victim of such crime will be precluded from lodging a complaint giving his version of the incident in question, consequently he will be deprived of his legitimated right to bring the real Accused to book. This cannot be the purport of the Code.


24. From the aforesaid decisions, it is quite luminous that the lodgment of two FIRs is not permissible in respect of one and the same incident. The concept of sameness has been given a restricted meaning. It does not encompass filing of a counter-FIR relating to the same or connected cognizable offence. What is prohibited is any further complaint by the same complainant and others against the same Accused subsequent to the registration of the case under the Code, for an investigation in that regard would have already commenced and allowing registration of further complaint would amount to an improvement of the facts mentioned in the original complaint. As is further made clear by the three-Judge Bench in Upkar Singh, the prohibition does not cover the allegations made by the Accused in the first FIR alleging a different version of the same incident. Thus, rival versions in respect of the same incident do take different shapes and in that event, lodgment of two FIRs is permissible.

31. Keeping the aforesaid principle of law in mind when we examine the facts of the case at hand, we find that the second FIR filed by the Appellant against Respondent No. 3 though related to the same incident for which the first FIR was filed by Respondent No. 2 against the Appellant, Respondent No. 3 and three Bank officials, yet the second FIR being in the nature of a counter-complaint against Respondent No. 3 was legally maintainable and could be entertained for being tried on its merits.

32. In other words, there is no prohibition in law to file the second FIR and once it is filed, such FIR is capable of being taken note of and tried on merits in accordance with law.

33. It is for the reasons that firstly, the second FIR was not filed by the same person, who had filed the first FIR. Had it been so, then the situation would have been somewhat different. Such was not the case here; Second, it was filed by the Appellant as a counter-complaint against Respondent No. 3; Third, the first FIR was against five persons based on one set of allegations whereas the second FIR was based on the allegations different from the allegations made in the first FIR.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 408 of 2018 (Arising out of S.L.P. (Crl.) No. 7970 of 2014)

Decided On: 19.03.2018

 P. Sreekumar Vs. State of Kerala and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.K. Agrawal and Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2018 SC 1482
Print Page

Thursday, 29 December 2016

Whether session court can try magistrate triable case if it is counter case to session triable case?

Thus, it has become abundantly clear that by series of 
judicial pronouncement as detailed above,
availed by the Court of Magistrate to co it has conclusively been
held that trial of case and counter-case irrespective of its nature is to
be conducted by the same Court and further, even the cases having
triable by the Court of Magistrate could be fairly tried by the Court of
Sessions in terms of power being entertained by the Court of Sessions
according to Section 26 of the Criminal Procedure Code and for that,
irrespective of nature of evidence, Section 323 of the Cr.P.C. could bemmit the case for that
purpose, which could not be questioned over its proprietary much less
with regard to absence of sufficient materials. That being so, the
learned lower Court rightly committed the case to the Court of
Sessions. Because of the fact that even the Magisterial trial is to be
proceeded with by the Court of Sessions on account thereof, there is
no question of applicability of Section 228(1)(a) of the Cr.P.C.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Criminal Miscellaneous No.24629 of 2016

Sanjay Kumar, V  The State of Bihar


CORAM:  MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR TRIVEDI

Date: 19-08-2016
Citation: 2016 CRLJ 4540
Print Page

Friday, 2 December 2016

Whether magistrate can commit counter case to session court even though it is not triable by session court?

To sum up the legal issues involved in the case:-
        (i) No Court of Sessions shall take cognizance of any offence unless
the case has been committed to it by the jurisdictional Magistrate.
        (ii) The Court of Sessions has no power to direct a Magistrate to
commit any case to his file nor can a Court of Sessions withdraw a case from
a Magistrate to his file.
        (iii) If any of the offences in a given case is exclusively triable by
a Court of Sessions then, the legal duty of the Magistrate is to commit the
case to the Court of Sessions for trial as provided inSection 209 of Cr.P.C.
        (iv) In cross cases, where one of the cases involves offences
exclusively triable by a Court of Sessions and in the other case none of the
offence is exclusively triable by a Court of Sessions, then, as provided
in Section 323 of Cr.P.C. the jurisdictional Magistrate should commit both
the cases for trial to the Court of Sessions.
        (v) On such committal of cross cases arising out of the same
occurrence, the Sessions Court shall scrupulously follow the procedure laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nathi Lal v. State of U.P., 1990 Supp.
SCC 145. 
        (vi) In any other case involving offences which are not exclusively
triable by a Court of Sessions and if it appears to the jurisdictional
Magistrate that for any of the grounds enumerated underSection 407 (1)
of Cr.P.C. that the case needs to be tried by a Court of Sessions, the
learned Magistrate shall submit a report to the High Court and on such report
the High Court may order for committal of such case to the Court of Sessions
for trial and thereupon on committal, the Sessions Court shall try the same
as per Chapter XVIII of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
        (vii) In any event, the trial court shall not record common evidence or
substitute the evidence recorded in one case as evidence in the other case
and shall not consider the evidence recorded in one case in the other case.
        (viii) In no case, the trial court shall deliver a common judgement in
two or more cases [vide Nathi Lal's case cited supra].
        (ix) In respect of the cases where trial has not already commenced
before the Court of Sessions without the case being committed, the accused
shall be at liberty to raise objection at the earliest opportunity or else,
the court shall follow the dictum laid down in State of Madhya Pradesh v.
Bhooraji and others, 2001 Cri.L.J. 4228 (1).
     (x) In respect of cross cases, for each case there has to be a separate
public prosecutor to conduct the prosecution.
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED : 08.01.2015
CORAM
 MR.JUSTICE A.SELVAM
and
 MR.JUSTICE T.MATHIVANAN

CRIMINAL APPEAL(MD)Nos.16 OF 2012
and 87 of 2012


R.Velladurai Vs.State 
Citation:2016 CRLJ3985 Madras

Print Page

Procedure to followed by investigating officer and court in counter cases

From the above Judgments, the law now remains well settled that it
is not an illegality to file final report in both the case  and the counter
case. What is to be tested is only the question of prejudice for the accused.

        19. In view of the above well settled position of law in the instant
case at no stretch of imagination it could be held that filing of final
report in both the instant cases would amount to illegality. We hold that the
investigating officer, who was unable to find as to who was the aggressor,
was right in placing all the materials before the Trial Court by way of two
final reports and therefore, it was for the trial court to appreciate the
evidence let in both the cases and to punish the guilty.

        20. Now, we have to examine the proper procedure to be followed while
conducting the trial of both the cases. In this regard, we may also refer to
a judgement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nathi Lal v. State of UP, 1990
(Supp) SCC 145 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has in para 2 has held as 
follows:-       
        2.We think that the fair procedure to adopt in a matter like the
present where there are cross cases, is to direct that the same learned Judge
must try both the cross case one after the other. After the recording of
evidence in one case is completed, he must hear the arguments but he must 
reserve the judgment. Thereafter he must proceed to hear the cross case and
after recording all the evidence he must hear the arguments but reserve the
judgment is that case. The same learned Judge must thereafter dispose of the
matters by two separate judgments. In deciding each of the case, he can rely
only on the evidence recorded in that particular case. The evidence recorded
in the cross case cannot be looked into. Nor can the judge be influenced by
whatever is argued in the cross case. Each case must be decided on the basis
of the evidence which has been placed on record in the particular case
without being influenced in any manner by the evidence or arguments urged in
the cross case. But both the judgments must be pronounced by the same learned  
Judge one after the other.?

        21. One of us (JUSTICE S.NAGAMUTHU), while sitting single in Ganesan   
and others v. State  and another, 2011 (5) CTC 747 had occasion to  consider
the similar issue wherein the legal issues have been summed up as follows:-

        ?58. To sum up the legal issues involved in the case:-
        (i) No Court of Sessions shall take cognizance of any offence unless
the case has been committed to it by the jurisdictional Magistrate.
        (ii) The Court of Sessions has no power to direct a Magistrate to
commit any case to his file nor can a Court of Sessions withdraw a case from
a Magistrate to his file.
        (iii) If any of the offences in a given case is exclusively triable by
a Court of Sessions then, the legal duty of the Magistrate is to commit the
case to the Court of Sessions for trial as provided inSection 209 of Cr.P.C.
        (iv) In cross cases, where one of the cases involves offences
exclusively triable by a Court of Sessions and in the other case none of the
offence is exclusively triable by a Court of Sessions, then, as provided
in Section 323 of Cr.P.C. the jurisdictional Magistrate should commit both
the cases for trial to the Court of Sessions.
        (v) On such committal of cross cases arising out of the same
occurrence, the Sessions Court shall scrupulously follow the procedure laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nathi Lal v. State of U.P., 1990 Supp.
SCC 145. 
        (vi) In any other case involving offences which are not exclusively
triable by a Court of Sessions and if it appears to the jurisdictional
Magistrate that for any of the grounds enumerated underSection 407 (1)
of Cr.P.C. that the case needs to be tried by a Court of Sessions, the
learned Magistrate shall submit a report to the High Court and on such report
the High Court may order for committal of such case to the Court of Sessions
for trial and thereupon on committal, the Sessions Court shall try the same
as per Chapter XVIII of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
        (vii) In any event, the trial court shall not record common evidence or
substitute the evidence recorded in one case as evidence in the other case
and shall not consider the evidence recorded in one case in the other case.
        (viii) In no case, the trial court shall deliver a common judgement in
two or more cases [vide Nathi Lal's case cited supra].
        (ix) In respect of the cases where trial has not already commenced
before the Court of Sessions without the case being committed, the accused
shall be at liberty to raise objection at the earliest opportunity or else,
the court shall follow the dictum laid down in State of Madhya Pradesh v.
Bhooraji and others, 2001 Cri.L.J. 4228 (1).
     (x) In respect of cross cases, for each case there has to be a separate 
public prosecutor to conduct the prosecution.?
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED : 08.01.2015
CORAM
 MR.JUSTICE A.SELVAM
and
 MR.JUSTICE T.MATHIVANAN

CRIMINAL APPEAL(MD)Nos.16 OF 2012
and 87 of 2012


R.Velladurai Vs.State 
Citation:2016 CRLJ3985 Madras
Print Page

Monday, 16 November 2015

When Session Judge can try offences which are not exclusively triable by Court of Sessions?

 In this context, we may point out that a Sessions Judge has the power to try any offence under the Indian Penal Code. It is not necessary for the Sessions Court that the offence should be one exclusively triable by a Court of Sessions. This power of the Sessions Court can be discerned from a reading of Section 26 of the Code. When it is realised that the Sessions Judge has the power to try any offence under the Indian Penal code and when a case involving offence not exclusively triable by such court is committed to the Court of Sessions, the Sessions Judge has to exercise a discretion regarding the case which he has to continue for trial in his court and the case which he has to transfer to the Chief Judicial Magistrate. For this purpose we have to read and understand the scope of Section 228(1) in the light of the above legal position. The sub-section is extracted below:
"If, after such consideration and hearing as aforesaid, the Judge is of opinion that there is ground for presuming that the accused has committed an offence which -
(a) is not exclusively triable by the Court of session, he may, frame a charge against the accused and, by order, transfer the case for trial to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, and thereupon the Chief Judicial Magistrate shall try the offence in accordance with the procedure for the trial of warrant- cases instituted on a police report;
(b) is exclusively triable by the Court, he shall frame in writing a charge against the accused."
 The employment of the word "may" at one place and the word "shall" at another place in the same sub-section unmistakably indicates that when the offence is not triable exclusively by the Sessions Court it is not mandatory that he should order transfer of the case to the Chief Judicial Magistrate after framing a charge. In situations where it is advisable for him to try such offence in his court there is no legal obligation to transfer the case to the Chief Judicial Magistrate. One of the instances for not making the transfer is when a case and counter case have been committed to the Sessions Court and one of those cases involves an offence exclusively triable by the Sessions Court and the other does not involve any such offence.
Supreme Court of India
Sudhir & Ors. Etc. vs State Of M.P. Etc. on 2 February, 2001
Equivalent citations: 2001 (2) ALT Cri 79, 2001 CriLJ 1072, JT 2001 (2) SC 274, 2001 (1) KLT 682 SC, 2001 (2) MPHT 359, 2001 (1) SCALE 600, (2001) 2 SCC 688, 2001 1 SCR 813

Bench: K Thomas, R Sethi
Print Page

Good legal article on trial of counter cases

Print Page

Procedure to be followed by Magistrate when one case is triable by session court and counter case is trable by Magistrate


There can be no dispute about the proposition that the counter cases arising out of the same incident have to be tried together. If two persons have lodged report in respect of the same incident giving different versions and two separate criminal cases are registered on the basis of these complaints it is necessary to ensure that both the criminal cases are tried by the same learned judge to ensure that conflicting decisions are not rendered in respect of the same incident. In a situation where one of the criminal cases involves an offence exclusively triable by the Court of Session whereas the other pertains to the offence triable by the Magistrate the Magistrate is obliged to commit the counter case to the Court of Session for being tried along with the sessions case arising out of the same incident by resorting to the provisions of section 323 of the Criminal Procedure Code 1973 (for short cr. P. C. )- If due to inadvertence the counter case is not committed for trial by the concerned magistrate the power of calling for the said case can be exercised by the Court of session. This dictum is no longer res integra. In Nathi Lal vs. State of U. P. 1990 Supp SCC 145 = 1990 SCC (Cri) 638 the Apex Court enunciated the principle that both the counter cases should be tried by the same Judge one after the other and judgments in both the criminal cases should be pronounced on the same day. However the judge has to take precautions to ensure that he is not influenced by the evidence or the arguments advanced in the counter case. These principles governing the procedure for deciding the counter cases are approved by the Supreme Court in the matter of Sudhir vs. State of M. P. (2001)2 SCC 688 at page 692. In that case it is laid down that section 323 of the Criminal procedure Code is enacted for meeting such contingencies and can be resorted to by the Magistrate for committing a counter case to the Court of Session although the trial is not for the offences exclusively triable by the Court of session. It is further clarified that in such a situation the Sessions Judge has jurisdiction to try the counter case not involving offences exclusively triable by the Sessions Court.
 Citation; 2007 (1) MAH.L.J(Cri) 344 2007 ALL MR (CRI) 897 2007 (2) AIR (Bom) R 513
BOMBAY HIGH COURT
Mukinda Rama Kamble 

v 

state of maharashtra
Dated; 20 -12 -2006

Print Page

Whether counter cases are to be decided by same Judge?

It is expected that when there are
counter cases the same Judge should try both the cases and decide
both one after the other.
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATUTRE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH NAGPUR.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.86 OF 1991.
 The State of Maharashtra, V  Govinda s/o Sampatrao Ghogare,


 CORAM: K.J.ROHEE & C.L.PANGARKAR,JJ.

DATE OF PRONOUNCMENT OF THE JUDGMENT: 20/12/2006.
Citation; 2006 BCI525
Print Page

Monday, 27 May 2013

Whether second FIR by different person in respect of same incident is permissible?

If the involvement of the number of accused persons and the nature of the allegations are scrutinized, it becomes crystal clear that every FIR has a different spectrum. The allegations made are distinct and separate. It may be regarded as a counter complaint and cannot be stated that an effort has been made to improve the allegations that find place in the first FIR. It is well-nigh impossible to say that the principle of sameness gets attracted. We are inclined to think so, for if the said principle is made applicable to the case at hand and the investigation is scuttled by quashing the FIRs, the complainants in the other two FIRs would be deprived of justice. The appellants have lodged the FIR making the allegations against certain persons, but that does not debar the other aggrieved persons to move the court for direction of registration of an FIR as there have been other accused persons including the complainant in the first FIR involved in the forgery and fabrication of documents and getting benefits from the statutory authority. In the ultimate eventuate, how the trial would commence and be concluded is up to the concerned court. The appellants or any of the other complainants or the accused persons may move the appropriate court for a trial in one court. That is another aspect altogether. But to say that it is a second FIR relating to the same cause of action and the same incident and there is sameness of occurrence and an attempt has been made to improvise the case is not correct. Hence, we conclude and hold that the submission that the FIR lodged by the fourth respondent is a second FIR and is, therefore, liable to be quashed, does not merit acceptance.

Supreme Court of India
Surnder Kaushik & Ors. vs State Of U.P & Ors. on 14 February, 2013
Print Page

Thursday, 2 August 2012

Whether session judge should decide case and counter case even if counter case is triable by magistrate?

The employment of the word "may" at one place and the word "shall" at another place in the same sub-section unmistakably indicates that when the offence is not triable exclusively by the Sessions Court it is not mandatory that he should order transfer of the case to the Chief Judicial Magistrate after framing a charge. In situations where it is advisable for him to try such offence in his court there is no legal obligation to transfer the case to the Chief Judicial Magistrate. One of the instances for not making the transfer is when a case and counter case have been committed to the Sessions Court and one of those cases involves an offence exclusively triable by the Sessions Court and the other does not involve any such offence.
Supreme Court of India
Sudhir & Ors. Etc. vs State Of M.P. Etc. on 2 February, 2001
Equivalent citations: 2001 (2) ALT Cri 79, 2001 CriLJ 1072, JT 2001 (2) SC 274

Bench: K T Sethi
Print Page